5 ms·
YouTube Blocks Game Videos, Industry Offers Help
- schwap 13y agoWow, managing to piss off both ends of the issue (rights holders and video creators) is pretty impressive on YouTube's part.
- Pxtl 13y agoSeems like they need to improve their tools to allow rightsholders to conveniently white-list their content as youtubable.
- Ygg2 13y agoHow did they manage that? Note: RPS is down atm.
- snogglethorpe 13y agoBecause in this particular case, the producers (game developers) are actually pretty much OK with people using their "content" in Youtube videos, and indeed, probably benefit from it. Unfortunately the Youtube system is structured mainly to handle the opposite case, where the producers are insane jealous spawns of evil who will scream shrilly at the top of their lungs at even the merest hint of faint resemblance (if you look with your eyes blurred while drunk) between a video and their "content." So basically Youtube's automatic system is being over-eager in tagging a bunch of stuff as potential copyright violations, when it's probably OK to not do so for much of it.... As somebody else said, there's likely a technical solution to this by improving the ability to whitelist content from consenting producers.
- smtddr 13y ago>>If you’re dependent on YouTube for making money from video content, that’s disastrous, as even a single strike against your YouTube account can limit the account’s functionality within the site and impact anything from the length of videos you’re able to upload to your ability to monetise those videos with advertising. Always be very careful when your business depends on the free(AFAIK, uploading to youtube is free) services & regulations of some other company. I can't help but think of the stories on Facebook-platform/API dependency. That said, I still think it's bad how Google isn't a bit more careful when considering that, intentional or not, they now hold several people's livelihood in their hands. Semi-arbitrarily dropping sites' page-rank, marking sites as phishing attempts or messing with youtube-accounts' abilities to continue their business by some automation-script is kinda harsh. It's kinda like a guilty-until-proven-innocent thing where you just wake up one day and find your youtube-channel crippled. You're losing money while trying to contact Google and get everything straightened out. The fact that Google isn't exactly known for amazing customer service adds to the problem. I certainly don't expect Google to manually check all that content, but how about instead of immediate penalty... they send an email with a warning that action will be taken in 20 business days if alleged-offending content isn't removed. At least give the uploaders a chance to fix the issue or plan for an "outage" of sorts. Perhaps even for websites & youtube channels that are well known high-traffic & monetizing, Google makes sure to white-list them so they can never be auto-penalized without a human confirming. Instead, it just triggers an alert to all parties involved so people can look at it.
- judk 13y agoPaying for the service won't protect you. Visa or whoever will happily cancel a paid merchant account.
- A_Non_eMouse 13y agoExcept that The DMCA requires immediate removal upon complaint. Granted, the automated youtube-internal identification isn't exactly subject to that, but it was created in response to a lawsuit from the media companies about how hard it was for them to find and report infringing content.
- noct 13y agoAt least the DMCA requires the submitter swear under penalty of perjury that the notice is accurate. The current YouTube system has no penalty for false claims.
- chii 13y agoi say for monetized accounts, there needs to be more accountability from google's end to prevent loss of monetization. A rogue DMCA takedown is detrimental to a youtuber's livelihood. If you haven't, check out these following opinion pieces : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QfgoDDh4kE0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QfgoDDh4kE0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=en5hWeodMws http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=en5hWeodMws I highly respect content producers on youtube - they deserve as much protection from rogue elements who intend to exploit them as possible. Unfortunately, there isn't any competition for youtube, and so the problem will only get worse.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoWhat stands out most about this issue is the open-mindedness of the Video Games Industry. The fact that they've stood up for someone's ability to not only record their gameplay, but on top of that, make money from it just shows how understanding they are (unlike neighboring industries that take down amateur remixes from Soundcloud and YouTube). They're one of the few industries that generally: ● Don't Sue Pirates ● Don't claim copyright infringement on uploaded video game soundtracks to YouTube or gh.ffshrine.org (except Square Enix because their Final Fantasy OST still sells big) ● Don't send DMCA notices to people who remix their content (make mods) ● Allow unofficial communities to sprout up using their IP's name in the domain name url I'd say they're going above and beyond to support fair use & infringement in order to please customers, grow communities, and grow their fan base through crowdsourced content infringement. Genius I'd say.
- zwily 13y agoThe industry does have some of the nastiest DRM we've ever seen though.
- ekianjo 13y agoDon't claim copyright infringement on uploaded video game soundtracks to YouTube (except Square Enix because their Final Fantasy OST still sells big) Because most video game music is crap, really. Of course, there are exceptions, but nothing that would really sell anyway if they were marketing it. Don't send DMCA notices to people who remix their content (make mods) Huh... you haven't heard about Nintendo I guess? They just closed the site of someone who made a Mario clone (a 20+ years old game) in the browser, and they also sued Great Giana Sisters in the 80s because it was too similar to Mario. Allow unofficial communities to sprout up using their IP's name in the domain name url I can't remember which site right now, but I clearly remember Sony or other big players making it difficult to use some of their brands as domain names. It's clearly not as nice an industry as you seem to be considering it.
- ChrisNorstrom 13y ago1) Are you really going to make a hot-air blanket statement like "Most video game music is crap"? You do realize that even mid-budget games like Resident Evil 5 & Remember Me (both with really good soundtracks) record using Hollywood sized orchestras. 2) A "CLONE" of a game is different. Especially when you clone an iconic game that Nintendo still sells. It's clearly not as evil an industry as you seem to be considering it.
- Daishiman 13y agoI don't understand, can video game companies really claim copyright over gameplay videos? Or is this just a Youtube-specific thing?
- cdash 13y agoI am not sure on the answer to this question or if there is even an answer yet but what is happening on YouTube is all a YouTube specific thing.
- leeskye 13y agoPublishers who own the IP to titles can claim copyright to the gameplays. Since it is basically free promotion for their games, it's against their best interest. Hence, you see them offering their blessing and support to YouTubers.
- yaeger 13y agoIsn't this the same as with product placement in TV shows? Sometimes you see the characters using a Mac complete with logo visible and sometimes the logo gets covered. The reasons for this may also come from both ends. Either Apple can say "We did not authorize the use of our trademark" or they could just enjoy the free exposure on TV. On the other hand, the TV shows producers could say "What we would do with displaying the logo in that way would be advertising, therefore Apple would have to pay us to show their logo. Otherwise we just cover it up"
- uchi 13y agoThe problem is that a lot of videos are being taken down because of copyright claims on press materials and game footage from trailers, not gameplays. This material is classified under fair use. They're also attempting to claim copyright on game reviews. Which in short, puts reviewers in a bad position where someone is trying to monetize their opinion and are easily silenced if that opinion is unpopular. For reviewers its grossly unfair for publishers to make money off their reviews, because while they will reference their game, the opinions expressed are entirely the reviewer's, and writing a critique is certainly nothing at all like showing a dry gameplay video with no commentary or editing.
- yeukhon 13y agoAs a matter of fact, I would spend some of my lunch time just watching game play when no other videos interest me.
- username223 13y agoIt's just standard "we (Google) have more money and lawyers than you do" stuff. Nothing to see here.
- tshadwell 13y agoWhy is it that video games are not filmable? I cannot imagine Grand Illusions' (https://www.youtube.com/user/henders007 https://www.youtube.com/user/henders007) videos being flagged for not owning the copyright for the toys he does "let's plays" of.
- thetinguy 13y agocached version: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2013/12/11/youtube-blocks-game-videos-industry-offers-help/ http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- booop 13y agoIs Google deliberately trying to kill off Youtube?
- archgoon 13y agoI'm pretty sure that Twitch will happily fill the gap here.
- nmc 13y agoSince the Twitch player feels like it was written by monkeys in the 90s (while YT is finishing to roll-out its neat HTML5 player), I believe this is clearly not for the best. Although, maybe the Twitch guys will compensate their awful technological lateness by showing some humanity (which Google seems less and less able to do).
- hendrik-xdest 13y agoI don't think that will last. It shouldn't take too long for rights holders to figure out that there are videos and live streams on Twitch that contain music and cut scenes, as well. Might be that Twitch is not receiving as much take-down notices, just yet. Imho that's not going to last. Since there is already people on their making money with their "property".
- simfoo 13y agoNot until Twitch manages to fix their downlink connection problems. I haven't been able to watch a single HD cast without major lags and stuttering in months even though I'm on a very fast connection (granted, not by a major provider so no direct peering). Twitch has promised to build new data centers here in Europe but I have only noticed it becoming worse. I'm not the only one too, I'm part of the Team Fortress 2 competitive community and get to talk to a lot of other Twitch viewers. Also, don't get me started on VODs on Twitch, they're even worse.
- saraid216 13y agoHave they fixed the issue where the same ad will repeatedly play back-to-back over the free version? It's been a while since I've tried to watch a Twitch stream because of that.
- petriw 13y agoWhile VODs may start slow I find the playback much more reliable than streams here in Europe.
- werid 13y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bt1ubSVMwaw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bt1ubSVMwaw In this video, they go in-depth about the different youtube issues going on at the moment, both the recent content-ID massacre, and the new status for network/partners that's coming. Worth spending time on if you are at all interested in these issues. (Description has shortcuts to the different parts discussed as well, but I recommend watching the entire thing.)
- TazeTSchnitzel 13y agoI agree with this guy's thoughts on it: http://youtube.com/watch?v=2e5pheJJvno http://youtube.com/watch?v=2e5pheJJvno It's definitely not fair use to film the gameplay of the entire game, just add commentary, and then make money off it. That being said, if the publishers give permission, it's fine.
- bcRIPster 13y agoActually, it is fair use. It's a derivative work. This is no different than taking a car and doing a video showing everything about it along with a running commentary. Anyways, what's happening is these guys are getting nailed for using unlicensed music as part of their videos. That's a copyright infringement unless it has been paid for YouTube distribution.
- thenomad 13y agoAnd this sort of crap is why I've just decided to make my most major video release in 5 years Vimeo-centric, not YouTube. * I'm about to release a significant Machinima movie - significant in that it's doing a bunch of things that haven't been done before. (I'm the guy who came up with the term "Machinima" originally.) I've been strongly considering putting it on YT, but the extreme lack of customer support and the automated, often error-prone takedown systems mean that it really doesn't seem like a great platform for anything important. This could actually become a serious problem for YouTube. They've got some real competitors in the video space, notably Vimeo but also Blip and others. If working with YouTube starts to become overly risky or onerous for creators, the others could start to catch up fast. * Also, to be fair, I'm going for Vimeo because they support 2.35:1 aspect ratio video. But that's not the most major reason.
- Kronopath 13y agoFrom what I've heard, Vimeo is even worse, disallowing all video game content unless it's a game you developed yourself: http://blog.wolfire.com/2009/01/vimeowned/ http://blog.wolfire.com/2009/01/vimeowned/