12 ms·
Simulations back up theory that Universe is a hologram
- herbig 13y agoBut not in the Matrix sense, as I was lead to believe from the title.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoI had the same reaction. So they did some calculations on a black hole with and without gravity and their calculations match and now the entire universe is a hologram?
- dllthomas 13y ago"Hologram" in the sense of "it looks like it has a different number of dimensions than it does", not in the sense of "rendering of something that isn't real".
- a3voices 13y agoIt's a hologram in the sense that its max information density is based on the surface area of the observable universe, not its volume.
- tlarkworthy 13y agoI have lead loads of these physics theory of universe things and I am none the wiser about anything in the field. Might as well say "Physics have shown we are an electronc's imagination in 7.5D space like a windy coral on an orange Tuesday"
- jmpe 13y agoThis is pretty much one of the Ultima Thules of Mathematics. Reading about it won't make you understand it, the metaphors used in popular science are just that: simple analogies that fool the reader. If you want to understand it I'd suggest allocating 6 years of your life to be thought the foundations and move on from there. Edited to remove a shitty snark re fractional dimensions, hence the replies.
- jaibot 13y agoFractional dimensions are a thing (for certain values of "dimension"). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Long_Is_the_Coast_of_Britain%3F_Statistical_Self-Similarity_and_Fractional_Dimension http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Long_Is_the_Coast_of_Britai...
- bad_alloc 13y agoSee also this list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fractals_by_Hausdorff_dimension http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fractals_by_Hausdorff_d...
- diminoten 13y agoWait, I don't understand. So there's the "flatland" where strings "live" and interact without gravity, and when these strings interact in this flatland the side-effects of those interactions are the 10-dimensional space we observe?
- easy_rider 13y agoI swear I've read this somewhere else before.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle
- jasonlfunk 13y agoWhat would it even mean that the universe is a hologram? Wouldn't it imply some sort of holographic projector?
- DanBC 13y agoStrings are the projector. Except, uh, ...
- ck2 13y agoSo basically they are saying we are a 3D projection (extrapolation) of a 2D source? Can we do anything useful with that like FTL space folding?
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoBasically, but the numbers are higher than 2 and 3. String theory represents the universe (the projection) as 10-dimensional, for instance.
- X4 13y agoYes, but this theory is simpler compared to the 10+ dimensions of string theory and m-theory.
- damon_c 13y agoI have found this Leonard Susskind lecture to come closest to answering the question of "why would anyone even suggest such a thing?" about this subject: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DIl3Hfh9tY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DIl3Hfh9tY
- Kronopath 13y agoThat's an excellent lecture, and explains a lot of these things in understandable terms. Thanks.
- richardjordan 13y agoOf course this isn't helpful to the layman who thinks of holograms as things they get on a card in a cereal box.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Demiurge 13y agoI wonder if I would age faster or slower in the universe rewritten in Go?
- optymizer 13y agoYour cells would age concurrently, depending on the value of GOMAXPROCS.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 13y agoThe garbage collector seemed like a great idea, until now.
- derefr 13y agoSo, the naive way I'm reading this might reduce to this lie-to-children analogy: "You have a 2D layout of memory cells on a RAM chip (strings), which store the representation of a 3D universe. From within our 3D universe, we can tell that we're actually stored on a 2D medium by the way we see the effects of interactions between things in our 3D world that are distant in 3D, but stored on 'neighboring' memory-cells." Anyone who knows enough about this to tell me how far off-base I am?
- astrodust 13y agoIt's going to be a real downer when we find out the universe is actually one gigantic one-dimensional Turing machine.
- redthrowaway 13y agoWhy? It'd prove Hard AI. That'd be nifty.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoThe universe already contains human-level intelligent agents. They're called humans.
- ngoldbaum 13y agoBut humans aren't necessarily Turing machines.
- astrodust 13y agoIf we're all in a Turing machine, Q.E.D.
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoIt's still possible, technically, that humans are very high level simulations computed by a Turing machine.
- davidbielen 13y agothere are much simpler theories that unite gravity and quantum physics, without going into 'matrix-mode': http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/12/131205142218.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/12/131205142218.ht...
- apalmer 13y agoSo basically they are showing that a simple model exists that gives the same results as a more complex model? I mean the article seems clear that neither universes they modeled was actually the same as ours... so i dont get the significance.
- aaren 13y agoIf it turns out that the universe that we observe is just a projection from a lower dimensional space then this could radically alter the way in which we interact with that universe. Things that seem to be coherent in our space (the things we observe - electrons, people, solar systems) may not look at all coherent in the source. Similarly, coherent structures in the source may not be at all coherent in our space. It might be that, by fiddling around with this theory, we could work out the mapping from the source to our space. If we could do this we could conceivably interact with this space in completely unimaginable ways. Imagine superconducting levitation as perceived by someone from the stone age and then go up another few levels... n.b. by 'our space' I mean the higher dimensional universe, the hologram. By 'the source' I mean the lower dimensional space that the hologram is projected from.
- crazygringo 13y ago1) What the heck do they mean by a hologram? The analogy here baffles me. Is this just a layman's analogy, or does this actually mean something scientific? 2) Anybody have any suggestions on a high-quality layman's explanation? I finished reading Feynman's QED the other week, and loved it, and was wondering what the closest might be for string theory.
- devindotcom 13y agoYeah, this is trouble, because the common understanding of "hologram" is very different from the actual definition. As far as I understand it (and another person has explained it better below), the indication is that the way we perceive the universe indicates that the "data" producing those perceptions is not stored in the same structures we see or detect - instead, those structures (space, mass) are sort of "implied" by a more fundamental way of "storing" that data, which we interpret secondhand because we can't perceive the original. Not sure if this is clear or accurate, but that's what I've taken away from previous articles on a holographic universe.
- bitops 13y agoEven if it's not completely technically accurate, I think your explanation makes the most intuitive sense to me out of all the responses I read.
- jonnathanson 13y agoSo basically, Plato was correct. (Sort of.)
- X4 13y agoIf I get this right, then the irony here is, that everybody is correct and wrong at the same time. Just draw some dots, circles etc. on paper and it could be that one day that non-local representation of the holographic universe holds true.
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoWhat's interesting is that your description would also be appropriate for a computer model, or simulation.
- anentropic 13y agoI don't see explained anywhere what causes them to make the leap that, because the math of holographic theory works, the universe 'is' a hologram. Doesn't it just mean that they've found a way to convert between two abstractions?
- tinco 13y agoWell the important thing is that they found a way to abstract it with less dimensions than they previously did. This means that the previous theory had unnecessary redundancy, so the new theory has less cruft. The hologram is their way of describing how they changed their way of thinking to land on this new theory. So they looked at the problem with the idea that the interactions in our universe could be a projection of the interactions in some other universe. The breakthrough is that they found such a universe ours could be a projection of, and that universe can be described with less parameters than the previous leading theory. The smaller a theory is, the more clear its foundational relationships will be, so the closer we are to actually understanding why things are like they are. So previously we had a big question, why does our theory of everything require 18 (or more?) dimensions to describe the universe? And now we have a slightly smaller question: Why does our theory of everything require 10 dimensions to describe the universe?
- Sakes 13y agoThey took two different universe models, neither of which match the one we live in, and mathematically produced the same black holes. The key differentiators being that one universe has gravity and multiple dimensions while the other has no gravity and 1 single dimension. While the article likes to take a logical leap and assume this supports the theory that our universe is a hologram, what was actually proved by this numerical experiment is eloquently explained in the article's quoting of theoretical physicist Leonard Susskind. "They have numerically confirmed, perhaps for the first time, something we were fairly sure had to be true, but was still a conjecture — namely that the thermodynamics of certain black holes can be reproduced from a lower-dimensional universe" - Leonard Susskind
- proofofconcept 13y agoWhen I see "experiment X backs up/supports/proves conclusion Y" in a headline I always mentally correct it to "experiment X does not definitively disprove conclusion Y" where X and Y are random variables operating on whatever the actual scientific experiment and conclusion respectively are.
- gjm11 13y agoIn fairness, the way even the most firmly established scientific theories get firmly established is precisely by having a lot of experiments done that fail to disprove them. (Disclaimer: That's a bit of a simplification. In practice the acceptance of a theory also has something to do with how explanatory the theory feels, how elegant it is, what prejudices the highest-status experts have, etc.)
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 13y agoI was confused till I read the comment by uncle Al, and that didn't help either. He's talking some science pidgin.
- garraeth 13y agoI'm a huge Susskind fan. One of the coolest books I've read was his "The Black Hole War". And he's got tons of his lectures (full lectures from Stanford) on YouTube -- so if you're curious you can hear it straight from him.
- vagarwa 13y agoI just needed to capture this moment :) http://goo.gl/BDM15O http://goo.gl/BDM15O
- ygmelnikova 13y ago..who (God) stretchest out the heavens like a curtain. - Psalms 104:2 (pre 537 B.C)
- mVChr 13y agoExcitement builds as more of the article is read until near the end... > Neither of the model universes explored by the Japanese team resembles our own, Maldacena notes. ...way to hide the disclaimer guys.
- tomrod 13y agoCould we use these observations to increase storage density of data?
- avaku 13y agoI knew it!
- analog31 13y agoSomething puzzles me about the hologram analogy. A hologram seems totally garbled, and is "played" by projecting it in a particular way so that we see an image of the original object. In contrast, our 4-d world doesn't seem garbled to us at all, and there is no way to "play" it and see an image of a higher dimensional world.
- robinduckett 13y agoI think it's more that, it isn't a 4D world we live in, we live in a 2+ND world, and it can be mathematically simulated using ND physics, so that anyone in the 2+ND world is unable to percieve the ND information. We can't "Play" our world because it's already being "Played".
- aaren 13y agoConsider the Anthropic principle: observations of the physical Universe must be compatible with the conscious life that observes it [1]. We don't think things are garbled because we have evolved to make 'sense' of the chaos. Perhaps everything is a garbled mess that we think we can understand. “I have come to believe that the whole world is an enigma, a harmless enigma that is made terrible by our own mad attempt to interpret it as though it had an underlying truth.” ― Umberto Eco, Foucault's Pendulum [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic_principle edit: I think I went off on a tangent. The answer to your original question is that our observable universe is the thing that is being played - it is the stuff on the boundary that might be garbled. We are the projection.
- glifchits 13y agoHmm, now wasn't there a commentary article on HN earlier today about how papers in Nature (et al.) are sensationalized?
- simonh 13y agoHas this got anything to do with the fact that, given relativistic length contraction, from the pov of a photon the universe is two dimensional?
- islon 13y ago"Breaking news: we live in the matrix!"
- marsay 13y agoDoes it mean our dimension is projected to a higher dimension also? Wonder how this world would look like.
- mabbo 13y ago"In two papers posted on the arXiv repository" aaand I'm out.
- auggierose 13y agoIt means we are all Flatlanders.
- mtdewcmu 13y agoThis sounds like it could have been an Onion headline, e.g. "Simulations back up theory that Universe is a simulation"
- david_otoole 13y agoReally a better title for this article would be "Simulation backs up theory that universe is a simulation". I find them very curious, the "TheUniverseIsAComputer" people. Suppose there is an experiment proving that the Universe is indeed a particle simulation whose discoverable elements are being actuated by unspecified interactions of presumably very different elements in some other, underlying "universe", say a substrate of Rule 110, and consciousness can be marked out as a computable pattern in such, and that the simulation process works well enough for a group of researchers (presumably "us") to feel as if "we" are really here. Okay great. But for this to qualify as a simulation, surely the experiment (and the conscious experimenters) would have to be reproduced exactly, right down to the consciousnesses apprehending the results that establish scientific consensus that the UniverseIsAComputer, in precisely the consciousness-simulating way that these people fantasize about? We are to understand that the scientists in the "real" universe presumably would not reach the same consensus, because theirs is the actually Real Universe, not the simulated one, and so the Reality Detection Experiment fails in some way. So if this alleged difference appears---then why does the "simulation" even qualify as a simulation? For that matter, why does the author's own computer simulation qualify as having something to say about the real Universe? I suppose the simulation is "good enough" for consciousness to be reproduced more or less exactly, except for just recently the aspect of scientists becoming conscious of the fact that TheUniverseIsASimulation. I guess I could accept that everything is perfectly simulated except for... the evidence for the simulation? Meh.