5 ms·
It is entirely unclear what they are protesting, other than 'not working at Google.' The alleged trespass of using 'public infrastructure for private profit' i
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
It is entirely unclear what they are protesting, other than 'not working at Google.'
The alleged trespass of using 'public infrastructure for private profit' is unsupported. People pick up and drop off people at the sidewalk (required, no stopping in the middle of the street).
The staged appearance of a guy who is a union organizer (reported elsewhere) added a bit of melodrama.
Looking at the action critically, what is to be gained by calling attention to Google, Facebook, and others providing their own bus fleets?
- dap 13y agoThe corporate buses often stop at public bus stops, sometimes blocking MUNI buses from the stop.
- rubiquity 13y agoAs the article states, gentrification and "income inequality" (lol?) were the main reasons for these protestors surrounding the Google bus. I'm sure Google bus is an inconvenience for other busses but that wasn't why these people were protesting.
- md224 13y agoJust curious, why the "lol" for income inequality?
- thomasz 13y ago"Your poverty makes us sick"
- rubiquity 13y agoI recognize it's a real thing I just can't stand the mindset that such a word creates. If income/money is an issue for you, go out and do something to change that, don't sit around and be toxic against people that aren't having income issues.
- wavefunction 13y ago>>aren't having income issues. It's ok, you can call them poor.
- Natsu 13y agoOne of the problems people face is that those with weaker employment prospects in the first place often have other issues which screw them out of reasonable employment and leave them worse off in terms of pursuing anything better. Anyone who has been subject to factory life (or equivalent employment) knows that no sane person could work a job like that for their entire life. You're not completely wrong: many of these people have made mistakes, but the nature of how those mistakes get compounded can pretty thoroughly screw someone who was born with a bit of a handicap and who got off to a bad start. So while it is possible to overcome these setbacks (and people should be encouraged to do so), it's not something one should be glib about.
- jpwright 13y agoWhat do you mean by "be toxic"? And how do you expect people to work against income inequality without calling it what it is? Your comment ("lol income inequality") is dripping in upper-class privilege, as if you're the one suffering when poor people bring up things like the disappearing middle class & tax breaks for the wealthy -- because they're being "toxic".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nhaehnle 13y agoLooking at the action critically, what is to be gained by calling attention to Google, Facebook, and others providing their own bus fleets? A bus fleet that works for everybody? You know, the kind of public transportation that is common in industrialized countries that have their act together when it comes to the provision of public services.
- Houshalter 13y agoAnd are they aren't preventing anyone from doing that.
- scott_karana 13y agoThey are, if they're occupying their spots.
- enneff 13y agoHah, so the woeful state of the Bay Area's public transport system is the result of private buses being in the wrong place at the wrong time? Surely the issue is a bit deeper than that.
- xster 13y agoHad similar reflex. The SF way seemed very strange to me as an outsider and it would almost appear like the primary 'benefactor' of these confrontations are the city governance who are paid by tax payers to make sure the housing supplies are sufficient and public transportation are efficient. If Gmail can't keep up with demand and the SF city council just opened 1000 new account, one for each city employee, and Gmail speed slowed to a crawl, would Google and the public say "aha! they're using all the resources, let's protest"?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- adventured 13y agoNot to mention those Google employees pay a lot in taxes. They fund that public infrastructure, more so than just about anyone else in fact.
- kingnight 13y agoWhere is the data that proves that Google employees pay more taxes than what is proper for their individual incomes.
- yid 13y agoThat was not implied. Google employees generally have high salaries, and therefore pay a higher net dollar amount than the average taxpayer.
- kingnight 13y agoWhat I believe is implied is that since Google employees pay more in taxes than the average bloke, they are due more of that public infrastructure (privileged access to bus lanes, in this situation) — which is not how things work.
- Cookingboy 13y agoNobody implied that, he was simply saying that it's good we have high income residents in the area, since they contribute significantly to the local tax revenue.
- ryguytilidie 13y ago"The alleged trespass of using 'public infrastructure for private profit' is unsupported. People pick up and drop off people at the sidewalk (required, no stopping in the middle of the street)." I'm sorry but this is simply wrong. If you tried to pick up and drop off someone in a bus stop everyday, you would get ticketed for it. These buses do not. If you need to make things up to support these people it kind of worries me, especially when you seem to be mocking their opponents. I'm all for criticizing these protestors for certain things, but not so much for made up things.
- Houshalter 13y agoAccording to a comment below they have a permit for it which they pay the city for.
- ryguytilidie 13y agoThe article says that the city is working on a permitting system, and that one does not currently exist. Which means that these buses are parking illegally everyday and instead of fining them, the city is coming up with a plan to accommodate them. Think they would do that for your parking tickets?
- Houshalter 13y agoHmm perhaps. Still seems like such a minor issue to protest over.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoThat's because they're not really protesting about the buses using public stops. What they're really protesting is gentrification -- a decreasing amount of affordable housing in the city. Which is another way of saying they are protesting their own collective refusal to add higher density housing in the city.
- ryguytilidie 13y ago
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoYou want it spelled out? FB and Google have a lot of money. Somebody wants a piece of the political action. So there will be lots of hoopla, then a big check gets written to a pet PAC, then it all goes away -- until it's time to pay up again.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoMy guess is that the protests are targeted more generally at gentrification. People of privilege moving to the Mission, mostly ignoring the culture of the neighborhood and it's long-time residents, fueling out of control rent increases, slowly destroying a cultural landmark. I suspect the damage has more to do with CA property tax and SF's NIMBy zoning laws than silicon valley bussing, but they do have a point that it's a real problem. Not sure what the solution is. This protest doesn't seem to be it, but I applaud them for taking a MVP stab at it. Time to iterate now, protesters!
- Lewisham 13y agoThere is no solution to it, all big cities that I am aware of have a cycle of gentrification of urban renewal. To think SF is some special snowflake where it wouldn't happen is naive, to think that it wouldn't happen in SF when housing is so constrained and the economy is booming is just crazy.
- xster 13y agoBut then again, to push the conservatism to the extreme, not much of the actual original SF Ohlone native culture is still remaining.
- prodigal_erik 13y agoThis. The Mission is a giant game of musical chairs, and it's weird how anyone thinks the people who have only been there since the 1950s deserve to have it forever.
- mullingitover 13y ago>People of privilege moving to the Mission, mostly ignoring the culture of the neighborhood and it's long-time residents, fueling out of control rent increases, slowly destroying a cultural landmark. I dunno, just peering at the crime maps for the Mission[1]...Gentrification isn't the worst thing that could happen to the place. Not gentrifying probably is. [1] https://spotcrime.com/ca/san+francisco/mission https://spotcrime.com/ca/san+francisco/mission
- deleted 13y ago
- erikpukinskis 13y agoMy guess is that the protests are targeted more generally at gentrification. People of privilege moving to the Mission, mostly ignoring the culture of the neighborhood, fueling out of control rent increases, slowly destroying a cultural landmark. Granted, I think the damage has more to do with CA property tax and SF's NIMBY zoning laws, but they do have a point that it's a real problem. Not sure what the solution is. This protest doesn't seem to be it, but I applaud them for taking a MVP stab at it. Time to iterate now, protesters!
- codemac 13y agoThe picture they took is of the MUNI stop where my 48 bus used to stop, and yes, the Google bus would actually block out the MUNI busses. I haven't experienced it anywhere else though. I think this is basically just a highly visible spot for these buses, and they do interrupt MUNI service during morning traffic. Though I'm not sure they interrupt service any more than any other piece of traffic..
- cpucycling 13y agoThe problem is not that Google, Facebook, and others are "solving a problem" by providing these bus fleets. They are offering jobs on the peninsula paying more than jobs tend to pay in SF [because SF companies have to pay more for rent and ACTUALLY PAY THEIR FUCKING PAYROLL TAXES TO PAY TO MAINTAIN THE BUS STOPS], with a greater likelihood of becoming filthy rich, to people largely moving from other parts of the country and/or world, with the promise that they can work in one community and live in another. When such employees are not being recruited from other places, they are being recruited from SF. Google and Facebook have a problem that their offices are in FUCKING BORING monoculture suburbs which young, smart, energetic people do not typically want to live in. And their big, monolithic companies aren't a great match for the culture of SF, though companies like Twitter have been trying to make it work by insisting that SF is doomed without them. One has to ask, why do people want to live in SF rather than Mountain View or Palo Alto? Is it because those places are FUCKING BORING? Yes. And they are not FUCKING BORING because they lack craft cocktail places, they have a monoculture that is unattractive to people accustomed to diversity. That is why these buses are gross, and that is why it is gross that people who just recently moved to SF after rents roughly doubled think that people should just get a better job if they want to live here, because who ever lived in SF except rich people? How can someone who moved here as a student and began trying to build a life for themselves in the bay area ever fit without basically letting Larry, Sergei, and Zuck declare the sort of job that people who live in SF can have? How can people ever own a home in this city if the only way is by being [un]lucky and boring enough to be at a behemoth company or a random startup that couldn't easily be predicted to hit, and take a bunch of stock away? Also, if SF becomes a place where most people who can afford to live here have to work in another city, it will be largely devoid of employed people during the day. There will be jobs serving coffee in the morning, dinner in the evening, mostly stocked by people who live in the east bay, and we're likely to see some of the crime problems that Oakland has which I believe directly have to do with this, specifically that lots of people who pay rent and mortages in Oakland have to go to another city to do so, on woefully overloaded transit systems that are struggling for funding, leaving the city largely full of unemployed people and violent police officers during the day. SF is an amazing place and I can't imagine why anyone would only want to work here during the first and last hours of the day, when I do my best to be here as many hours of the day as possible, though I can't afford to live here. Plus a lot of these assholes don't even like SF. It's like a fancy fucking pair of shoes for them to brag about.