7 ms·
Except that, most creative ideas are bad. Like the famous observation about Churchill: "His chief of staff Alan Brooke complained that every day Churchill had
by crazygringo 13y ago
Except that, most creative ideas are bad.
Like the famous observation about Churchill: "His chief of staff Alan Brooke complained that every day Churchill had 10 ideas, only one of which was good -- and he did not know which one."
And when I think of product meeting's I've sat in on... generally 90% of the "creative" ideas would be complete disasters. And a lot of the remaining 10% might be good, but the work involved in figuring that out for sure would often be prohibitive, for an unclear payoff. But occasionally you get a gem that everyone gets excited about.
I would say that people do like creativity, but only when it's clear that the particular creative solution will likely work. Which is generally not the case.
And if people went chasing every plausible creative idea, we wouldn't have time for anything else, like normal productivity. That's why it's a very difficult balance to get right.
- mrcactu5 13y agomost people don't have time to risk investing their personal or business resources on a bad idea. So they don't try anything. This is classic "fear of failure". I agree -- people like creativity when someone else takes all the risk
- WalterBright 13y agoIdeas are a dime a dozen. It's the risk, time and effort involved in making them work that has value.
- sitkack 13y agoThat is because ideas come from artists who are mostly really really bad at capitalism.
- no_wave 13y agoI disagree. People get angry at the exercise of creativity. Look at the reaction to the financial independence/lifestyle design. People HATE them. Tell many Americans that you're going to stop working for six months to read books in Thailand and they will despise you. There are so many upsides to creativity, and so much human potential for it - the thing that stops most is the shame that gets splashed on you every time. And then you start splashing it yourself. And that's the game.
- buckbova 13y agoNot sure how reading books in Thailand is creative. Being counter culture doesn't make you creative. People react negatively to the "financial independence/lifestyle design" because they suspect you are telling them they are stupid for wanting to build a life the traditional way by working hard, starting a family and saving money for the future.
- psweber 13y agoThe creativity came before the reading. Coming up with a plan to allow taking 6 months off and living in another country. The 6 months of reading fuels the next set of creative ideas.
- Millennium 13y agoSounds more to me like the "creative idea" was "convince someone to pay me to take 6 months off to go read books in Thailand." Seriously. Why should creativity go unquestioned?
- no_wave 13y agoI can't understand this line of reasoning. Creativity is the result of a process, and that process is ignoring (or at least comparatively devaluing) the horrific and sneering grasp of the status quo. To separate the result of the creative process from the process is an abstraction that ends up excluding the actionable content from the concept. To argue over which acts are and aren't creative will do nothing to serve you in your life, so why do it except to try to bring others down?
- Millennium 13y agoThen explain the process. Tell me what you hope to create, why you want to create it, and why you think your chosen method will work. As it stands, all I see is a six-month vacation in Thailand. I don't see the grand vision you say you have. Make me see it, and then we'll talk. And if you cannot help me see it, then why should I support you? Why should you go unquestioned?
- dmazin 13y agoYou are demanding something you're just not going to get. You want it to be clear that a solution will work. Next you'll say you want market research. Next you'll say you want to test 42 shades of blue. This is why it's important for an idea to be distilled into something that can be tried without much investment, so that a lot of ideas can be tried and that you'll stumble onto something great. Larger ideas usually end up being tried through force or by going behind somebody's back, and that's probably how it'll stay.
- roberthahn 13y agoYeah, I don't know. Look, You're close. I think the process of trying out ideas is poorly understood by most people, and based on the way you wrote this, even yourself. You touched on it a bit - "distilling ideas into something that can be tried without much investment". That's the gem. This is what you're supposed to do with an idea: * Identify the hypotheses that make it work. * Identify which hypothesis is the most critical one - if that one fails, then you know the idea isn't going to work. It's fair to say that an idea depends on 2 or more hypotheses - the key here is to identify the critical ones. * Finally, figure out how to fail each critical hypothesis as fast (and as cheap) as you can. There is always a way. If you can't fail it, then you got something good. You don't need market research. You don't need the assurance the idea will work. Just test the hypothesis. What about testing the non-critical hypotheses? You'll get to them. Failing those doesn't mean the idea should be thrown out, only that you need to adjust the idea to take your new knowledge into account. That's it, really†. I'm using this process to build my own business, and it's working out extremely well. I've thrown out tons of bad ideas and got some great traction on the good ones. The scientific discipline to testing the ideas is the key. †I lied. There's one more step: keep track of your critical hypotheses - that's your business intelligence. You can use them to validate future ideas. (edit: formatting)
- dmazin 13y agoSo what's the part of the process that I understand poorly? I'd like to know, so I can improve. Honestly, we agree.
- CapitalistCartr 13y agoCreativity is not simply an idea in the same way that a start-up is not simply an idea. The ability to execute is essential to creativity. A lot of real skills are involved.
- gngeal 13y agoExcept that, most creative ideas are bad. If you never fail, you're not trying hard enough to do stuff that's appropriately difficult for you.
- Millennium 13y agoBut if you fail too often, you wind up dead or worse.
- dgreensp 13y agoI encourage you to test this hypothesis. I think you'll find it's incorrect. You can actually fail daily, in the ways you're most deathly afraid of (typically, looking foolish in front of others, facing a setback, or otherwise being knocked down a peg), and you won't die or worse (whatever "worse" is). People have tried this, for example instituting regimens of daily experiences of rejection, and it has only positive benefits. Even a failed business or poor performance at a job won't kill you. These sound like worthier fears since they're more closely related to putting bread on the table, but typically the worst fears of corporate decision-makers are not that the company will execute poorly -- that usually happens anyway -- but that they will be blamed for it. If we're going to talk about "failing" in general, I say fail as often as possible, even if this means the failures must be small.
- ams6110 13y agoRight... it's not really creativity itself that people are afraid of, it's risk. When someone suggests an idea that's new, never been tried before, nobody can really assess the risk. So they go to worst-possible-case scenarios, or just reject the idea out of hand. Unless it's one of those flashes of insight that is immediately and obviously a good idea, people will take the risk-averse position on most "creative" ideas.
- girvo 13y agoAnd that's why "sales" skills are important. If you can sell people on the idea, you'd be surprised what risks places can take. Do I wish I didn't have to? You bet! But for now, it works.
- matwood 13y agoExcept that, most creative ideas are bad. You are right, but that is part of the process. When finding a good idea it helps to find lots of bad ideas and understand why they are bad. In the end it makes the good idea easier to see. When coming up with a system design, db or otherwise I like to understands lots of different ideas, and more importantly, actively reject those ideas with a clear understanding as to why. The helps to find the idea that really does work.
- TrevorJ 13y agoIt is important not to confuse the process with the product. 99% of good ideas do not come out as fully formed gems. Most of the time it takes collaboration with a group of trusting partners to nurture the thing into something good. There's a point in time where you have to look at all the things that are being pitched, and think about it objectively in terms of what will work and what won't, but if that's the first step then what your really doing is looking at the steel ore that's being shipped to the auto factory and saying 'this isn't a BMW, throw it out'. Which turns out to be a great way of not making anything.
- codingdave 13y agoThis reaction -- that "most creative ideas are bad" is exactly what the article is talking about. How are you defining "bad"? Do you mean to imply that all creative ideas must be financially rewarding to be good? Or must have literary or artistic value? I do agree that within the context of a working environment, many creative ideas are not going to result in a net benefit to the company. But does that make them bad? Or are the cliches and the bad ideas necessary stepping stones to finding the right idea? I would posit that the bad ideas are a necessary part of the creative process. You are absolutely correct that spending time on every idea would be a disaster. But being dismissive of "bad" ideas does not respect the creative process, and expressing that negativity to a creative team will just encourage them to be less creative next time. I think your post proved the point of the article.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoWhy would you expect different? Creativity is risk. Without risk it wouldn't be creative, it'd just be the obvious, safe thing to do. The thing about creative risk is it's an investment. Most of the time it's likely to fail but occassionally it'll provide enough RoI to make the risk more than worthwhile. The returns on creative risks over the last century have been astounding. Micro-processors were a creative risk. The airplane was a creative risk. Orbital satellites were a creative risk. The internet was a creative risk. And so on.
- mathattack 13y agoAnd very frequently the Idea Fairies have 100s of ideas for everyone else to spend time either chasing or refuting, but nothing to contribute beyond that. It's a balance.
- stcredzero 13y agoApple and Toyota have 10 groups pursue their ideas. YC does this with groups as well, except they aren't directly salaried.