6 ms·
The simple fix that could heal the patent system
- lisper 13y agoNote that the actual original title of this piece is "The Power of No", which is plainly much less informative than the subtitle, which I actually submitted ("How a simple change could fix the patent system -- but it will never happen" just in case the mods change my submission). c.f. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6834019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6834019 And yes, I realize that this submission directly contradicts my earlier vow not to submit direct links any more. What I didn't realize at the time I made that vow was that it directly contradicts explicit HN posting guidelines. I think that particular part of the guidelines is counterproductive, but as long as the guidelines are what they are I will respect them. But I will also keep pointing out why I think they should be changed.
- tocomment 13y agoSorry, dumb question. What's a direct link and why can't you submit them?
- lisper 13y agoThere are two kinds of HN submissions: URLs, and text submissions. What I called a "direct link" is a URL submission. An "indirect link" would be a text submission with an embedded URL, but these turn out to be specifically disallowed by the HN submission guidelines. (I didn't know that when I wrote the submission referred to in the upstream comment.)
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe guidelines are contradictory. If you want a title that properly explains the article and its relevance to HN you're supposed to make a blog post. But at the same time you're not supposed to submit blog spam. So if you're not going to write an essay about an article there is no way to simultaneously fix a bad title and obey the guidelines.
- etanazir 13y agoLaw is probably an irreducibly complex (NP hard) problem; and a simple solution is most likely naive.
- jheriko 13y agoi dunno. i think this is a problematic perception, and one of the great achievements of modern politics - to make people believe there is a real challenge there - and not a well understood one which is the primary function of government. in essence i feel they convince us that they have a good reason to not do their jobs - they can do this because they are great sales people - which makes sense because we select them by popularity contest. remove patents is a simple solution for instance, its not hard to implement either and it will save running costs etc. the consequences might be complex... i'd like to think it would just help everyone. its not like, e.g. legalising marijuana where you need to think about previous convictions. you really could just invalidate every patent overnight.
- userulluipeste 13y agoI am not convinced neither of your assumption about law irreducibility, nor of the seriousness of your conclusion. The law is in itself a solution to society's demands, each of which can have a more or less justified base. It just so happens that the current law system become exposed to abuse (along with the lack of proper maintenance that should have kept it simple and accessible). The article successfully exposes a blatant legal loophole and its exploits, with concrete examples (with consequences that were later felt in a way or another by all of us). Its a shame to just dismiss it, especially with such a vague stance like yours.
- etanazir 13y agoI don't dismiss the fact that the law is imperfect, but assert the fact that among all possible laws, the simple suggestion will probably still be imperfect.
- lukev 13y agoPlease don't use precise computer science terminology to describe social problems unless you also plan on providing a precise model describing the said problem in mathematical terms. Otherwise, you're co-opting language about things that are precise and provable to make your subjective point. </rant>
- belorn 13y agoThe patent system of today depends on a single core concept left from the 19th century: Government knows everything. It's a 200 year old administrative artifact, removed from every aspect of law, except patents. The assumption of the 19th century patent system was that everything that should be patented already was patented already; therefore, when you would bring a invention to the office, the correct way to determine whether it is novel is to ask whether it is novel in light of the art already in the office. When asking whether it is obvious, you are essentially asking whether the very semi-skilled form of art knowledge possessed by the patent examiner would have regarded this as a natural extension of the existing art deposited in the office. In other words, determining a patent comes down to searching the patents offices' own archive. If the old patent texts would be so lucky as to say: "To unlock the cellphone, the user’s finger moves across the touch screen", it won't match when Apple adds the word "continuous". The patent examiner is forced into a position where the least resistance is simply to grant Apple the patent. This system is not working. The patent office archives do not have every iteration and written description about everything. By certainty, they won't have all the implied descriptions. As such, one should not assume that it is efficient to do an binary determination - 0 or 1, novel or obvious or not - on the basis of the consultation of the patent offices' own administrative records. The simple change suggested by the article would only remove the ability for companies to brute force a claim phrase so it does not match exactly something in the patent offices' archives. It would not fix the patent system, but it might patch it up so exploiters can't run a brute force method like some script kids attacking web forms and see what string returns a SQL injection vulnerability.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThe UK Patent Office certainly searches far, far more art than just the global patent literature. They make use of many specialist databases, extensive internet searches (carefully tailored not to disclose novel material), journals relevant to the art. The search and substantive examiners in the UK are one and the same (or were a few years ago) and the majority I knew of had doctorates. Your example of mismatch according to a word/phrase is laughable. Novelty means novelty of the invention [defined by the claims], no matter how it's claims are worded, not novelty of the claims. If indeed USPTO examiners are searching only on specific word forms then I'd be amazed; that certainly isn't the case in Europe. You give an example of adding "continuous" - the problem here lies in that either that is anticipated or the objection is that it's obvious based on prior art. If an obviousness objection is made the applicant can claim that "if it's obvious why hasn't anyone done it already" - that then forces their hand to leave the analysis to the courts. The classic UK example (quite old now) of the breadth of prior art is citing a children's comic against a "doggy doorbell". The breadth of related arts used in searches has vastly expanded since then. In addition to that search and examination is divided up based on the IPC/ECLA classification systems (and additional subdivisions cast over those that are local) - which allows for specialisation.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoSurely you can't litigate against someone until you have a granted patent? You can't infringe an ungranted patent - that would be ridiculous in extremis.
- lisper 13y agoYeah, you'd think that, wouldn't you. And of course you can't infringe on a never-granted patent, but you can infringe on a not-yet-granted patent. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine_patent http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine_patent
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoSubmarine patents no longer work since TRIPs. When they did work however there was no liability up until the patent becomes granted an unpublished submarine couldn't be used to make money until it surfaced. The idea was that you'd keep it hidden to allow the industry to make use of the invention and then when the invention was established you'd surface the patent and say "stop or pay up". That's been [largely] fixed now with "early" publication (18 months I think it is in the USPTO).
- lisper 13y agoIn the technology world, 18 months is still a very long time. It's actually even worse now since the US switched to first-to-file. Suppose you invent something and show it to your buddy, Fred. Fred can then turn around and patent your invention, and then sue you for using it. And unless you took the precaution of patenting it yourself or formally publishing it to establish prior art, Fred will win. The fact that you actually invented it doesn't matter.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThe fact you invented it means you have prior art. Proving it in court may be hard, but the patent is legally invalid if it counts as a "public" disclosure (cf Windsurfer vs Tabor Marine [it's been a long time I may have misremembered that caselaw it's Australian IIRC but the principle is the same]). There is no requirement for "formal publication". It needs to be disclosed in public, that could be a photo on your Facebook, showing a person in the pub with the public present, anything. The fact that you invented it gives you absolute indemnity in the law and a public disclosure invalidates any subsequent patent application. But as always you can't protect against being sued for anything.
- raldi 13y agoWhat a linkbait headline. It might as well be, "Trolls hate this one weird old trick that could fix the patent system"
- lisper 13y agoUnfortunately, HN rules left me no choice but to submit the headline that the article had. But just out of curiosity, what headline would you have considered appropriate?
- raldi 13y agoI wasn't blaming you; I was blaming Slate. A non-linkbait headline would be, "Doing _____ would, all by itself, go a long way toward reforming the patent system."
- lisper 13y agoWell, it's not really fair to blame Slate either. Their business depends on getting people to click on links, link bait is effective, so they have little choice but to use it. This is one of the reasons that IMO the requirement to submit original titles is counterproductive. The interests of site headline writer are not generally aligned with those of the HN audience.
- raldi 13y ago"It's not really fair to blame a spammer; their business depends on you getting spammed, spam is effective, and so they have little choice but to spam you."
- lisper 13y agoNot a proper analogy. Spam is a property of the delivery mechanism, linkbait is a property of the content. Apples and monkey wrenches.
- spurgu 13y agoWhy couldn't patents simply expire after x years? 2-3 years would give small companies with groundbreaking ideas enough time to develop and differentiate themselves from their competitors. After that everyone would have equal access to the idea and the world would be a better place as a result.
- belorn 13y agoI would very much like to see patent applicants having to argue for the length of the requested patent. When someone goes to the government and asks for financial support, they don't get a "one size fit all" cash bag. It matters how great in need you are, and how great an idea you have for a youth center. But when it comes to get an government enforced monopoly, no argument is even needed. No one will even ask if 3 years would be enough, or what the extra 17 years are there for. It's 20 year or nothing.
- danielweber 13y agoI've been in a place where a bigger company copied our work (including our typos!) and we finally used a patent for our lawyers to get them to knock it off. But it was very painful waiting the 2-3 years for the patent to be granted. We would have gladly taken a shorter term, like 8 years, in exchange for getting the patent granted faster. We didn't need to hold onto the stuff forever, but we needed some breathing room.
- webXL 13y agoThat certainly depends on the complexity of the product. Many take longer then that to successfully market. The last thing you want is a bigger competitor with a huge marketing department to copy your idea and get it out to market before you can.
- thaumasiotes 13y agohuh? Patents do expire after X years.
- dllthomas 13y ago
- edvinbesic 13y agoThe simple fix would be to give you a grace period after the acquisition of the patent (if you file or purchase) to actually put it to use or else you lose your claim to it. This would abolish the patent trolls as well as stop companies from doing preemptive filing because its "good practice". But maybe that's a too simplistic view of the situation.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThere is, in UK law, a clause that allows the patent office to force the grant of a license for a reasonable price. This is supposed to stop people from offering onerous licensing terms or simply sitting on the tech. The thing here is that patent terms are too long for the rate of change of technology nowadays. About 7 years seems like a reasonable term to me. An alternative to limiting years would be having a vastly increasing rate of increase on the patent maintenance fees per year for granted patents; particularly if it could be related to the revenue of any products that it is in. Then at least the public purse would benefit - from the monopoly the public are giving - in proportion to the benefit the private company is receiving..
- nimble 13y agoWhile empowering patent examiners to say "no" will probably help, it's not going to fix patents. Changes I would make to fix patents: - Get rid of license negotiation before the fact and replace it with attribution after the fact. All patented ideas should compete for a bounded slice of the pie of products. Attribution should be incentivized, but failure to attribute shouldn't be penalized excessively. - Instead of just letting a panel of experts (patent examiners) determine which ideas are novel and which aren't, we should further let them determine how novel they are and award the most novel ideas bigger rewards. The current system of granting a monopoly on an idea allows the patent holder to collect a large potion of the total value of an idea, which would be fair only for ideas that occur to just one person in the world. In reality, almost all patented ideas (the good ones, anyway) occur to a number of bright people, even if they wouldn't occur to a person having ordinary skill in the art. - The patent database should be more like the collection of peer reviewed academic knowledge. Ideas should be rewarded based on impact, rather than just who technically had the idea first. We should reward high quality exposition of ideas instead of our current system that mostly rewards obfuscation. Of course, all of this is even less likely to happen that the idea in the OP. Abolishing patents or at least software patents would be preferable to the system we have now.
- throwawaykf 13y agoAhh, Bessen. Interesting that he cites his own "trolls cost $29B" study [1] without mentioning that it's been "called into question" [2, 3, 4] to put it diplomatically. It's not like he's unaware of criticism of his work either, since he has responded to criticism in the past [5]. And par for the course, this article of his has several flaws as well: 1. Giving examiners the power of irreversible rejection is pretty bad, if you think about it. Valid patents are regularly rejected for the very same reasons that people argue invalid patents are allowed. Contrary to popular belief, if examiners are overworked and lack enough time, their default reaction is usually to reject the application. I have seen many a BS rejection issued because the examiner just wanted to meet his quota. And I'm not even a patent agent or lawyer! 2. (Nitpicking) Continuations are not the only way to continue examination after a rejection. You can also file for a Request for Continued Examination (RCE) and continue prosecuting the same application. 3. Continuations are a very valuable tool and not just fodder for abuse. Like TFA says, it allows applicants to claim multiple inventions off a single patent application. But that is often what happens! A single invention could have multiple facets that are inventions in their own right. As a random example, a lightbulb that uses tungsten filament and bulb with an inert gas could actually be three inventions: a) the material being used for the filament, b) the use of an inert gas in the bulb, and c) the combination of both that creates an even longer lasting bulb! What may happen is you file a patent for the combination but may realize each aspect is valuable by itself, and you may later want to claim them separately. And sometimes, this is not in your control. A patent is allowed to only claim a single invention. An examiner may look at your claims and decide that they cover two (or more) separate inventions, and issue a "restriction", which essentially forces you to choose one invention to continue. If you still want to protect the other claims, you have to file a continuation. And even further: Companies regularly dump hundreds of pages of technical specs (or a professor dumps a dozen papers) on to a patent lawyer and ask them to file on all the inventions covered in there. Sometimes this happens under a pretty tight deadlines (e.g. the product has already been on sale, or the papers published, for almost a year, which puts a bar on when a patent can be filed). In that case, lawyers write up one gigantic spec, slap on claims for whatever they think is the invention, and file it. Over time, they can then sit the inventors down and hash out the real invention and cover them in continuations. 4. I looked at the file wrapper for the Apple patent. "continuous" was not the only word added. Almost a third of the claim was amended to make it more precise of what they were claiming. I personally don't think this is a stellar patent, but such misinformation must be pointed out. 5. Strangely (or maybe not so strangely) enough, academics who write so much about patents have no idea how examination actually happens, or even how patents even work. To show invalidity, an examiner must show a one or more references that completely cover each and every element of the claim. If they cannot, no matter how obvious it seems to us, they have to allow it. The reason for this is that the decision must be an objective one, and all our opinions are inherently subjective. Supporting a rejection with previously published information, which is a recorded fact, is the only currently known way of doing this objectively. 6. Bessen implies other countries don't have patent litigation problems because their examiners can issue an absolute rejection. First of all, I highly doubt that is the case - there always avenues of appeal. Secondly, he ignores the legal environment in other countries, such as "loser pays" in EU, which tend to discourage lawsuits in general, not just frivolous ones. Thirdly, this makes no difference in the quality of patents - I have seen a ton of US patents and their international counterparts, and they pretty much all have the same claims. And they can all be just as each other. Nokia actually prevailed in some lawsuit in the EU over a patent that claims, without (much) exaggeration, pausing downloads when something more important is to be downloaded. 7. Rambus, as underhanded as their FRAND patent shenanigans were, was not a patent troll. By this standard, all fabless semiconductor companies would be patent trolls. 1. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2091210 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2091210 2. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2117421 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2117421 3. http://blog.patentology.com.au/2012/06/29-billion-us-troll-tax-or-just-another.html http://blog.patentology.com.au/2012/06/29-billion-us-troll-t... 4. http://gametimeip.com/2012/07/30/patent-scholars-challenge-bessen-meurers-bogus-29-b-npe-costs-figure/ http://gametimeip.com/2012/07/30/patent-scholars-challenge-b... 5. http://www.researchoninnovation.org/hahn.pdf http://www.researchoninnovation.org/hahn.pdf
- WildUtah 13y agoI have a very simple fix to propose. Any patent claim that is or could be implemented in computer software in whole or in part is automatically invalid. Accusing a computer program of infringing is prima facie evidence of invalidity. That would fix pretty much all the nonsense of garbage software and business method patents overnight. It would eliminate nearly all patent trolling. And not a single patent that actually provides effective incentives to advances the arts, technologies, or sciences would be affected.
- Buttons840 13y agoThe purpose of the patent system is to incentivise inventors to reveal their inventions in exchange for a monopoly on the idea. This way, inventions are not lost and society doesn't slide backwards. Imagine someone invented a pill to cure cancer, but kept the details secret and then died; we would lose his invention (a silly example, but it illustrates the point). I believe patent applicants should have to argue how difficult it would be for a peer in the industry to reproduce their work. If you develop an expensive new pill to cure a major disease, we'll give you a patent in exchange for you revealing the details of your important invention. Future generations will benefit. If you put a one click purchase feature on your website, it may be a new idea, but there are tens of thousands capable of reproducing your "invention" on their own. It is a new idea, so grant a short patent (maybe 5 years?) but it hurts instead of helps society to grant a 20 year patent.
- thwarted 13y agoImagine someone invented a pill to cure cancer, but kept the details secret and then died; we would lose his invention (a silly example, but it illustrates the point). This is not only a silly example, but a bad one. If society never learns that it existed before it was lost, society didn't lose anything because it never had it to begin with. If you can't remember the dream you don't know you had, did you actually forget it?
- Buttons840 13y agoI meant the person released to pill to the public, but never revealed the "secret formulate". Though, I never actually said that. Again, silly example. Said another way, I believe the purpose of patents is to get innovations documented rather than kept secret.
- nova 13y agoI'd say the patent system is working exactly as intended.
- dllthomas 13y agoI don't like limiting appeals. What about raising the costs of new applications based on the number of outstanding applications by a single entity? That should leave things affordable for the little guy, but encourage judicious dropping of applications. Of course, there's the tremendous problem of the manipulability of what constitutes "an entity" - shell companies and what have you.
- gyc 13y agoThe premise of this article that patent attorneys wear down patent examiners through dragging on prosecution by continually responding to office action rejections is nonsense. In fact it's just the opposite. Patent examiners would love to see the same patent application over and over because they will already be familiar with the subject matter and will have a pretty good idea of the art in that field from having already examined the applications before. Plus the patent examiner is allotted extra time to examine the application each time an RCE or continuation is filed to extend prosecution. So seeing the same patent application over actually helps the examiner to more easily meet his production requirements.
- lisper 13y agoIt is not nonsense. I myself have received two patents (out of five total) using exactly this method. One of these patents is for a device that sends information faster than light (US Patent 7126691), so it plainly should never have issued. (I prosecuted this patent specifically to test the theory that one could patent anything using this method.)
- gyc 13y agoAccording to PAIR, your patent was allowed after you responded to the first non-final office action. So no you did not use the method set out in the article of wearing down the examiner by continually filing continuations to get a yes.
- Dylan16807 13y agoDoes it really matter which method of resending the same patent was used to get something invalid granted?
- lisper 13y agoFiling official actions is not the only way to wear down an examiner's resolve. And does it really invalidate my point that it only took me two iterations instead of N to obtain a patent on a device that violates the laws of physics?