9 ms·
How Old Is The Shepherd?
- hopp_check 13y agoI wonder if I do an abstract version of this in code sometimes when I'm being lazy...
- NoPiece 13y agoEspecially with younger kids, when they are asked a question by someone with authority, there is a reasonable presumption that it can be answered. I'm all for teaching them to challenge that presumption, but I think you'd get a more fair result if the question was, "Can you figure out the age of the shepherd if you know how many dogs and sheep he has in his flock?"
- jcutrell 13y agoAgreed. I think this is also an issue with the way we teach; we should teach students to have the confidence to deny the solvability or soundness of a problem on their own (rather than forcing irrational thought in order to arrive at a solution). This is the equivalent of teaching a programmer to "shut up and code", even though they may have objections to the proposed solution.
- sailfast 13y agoAgreed - it would be interesting to run the numbers with "questions may not have an answer" as a qualifier. If I try to put myself back in my young student mindset, I would only expect to be correct with a non-answer response for a specific kind of test, or with a certain type of teacher that asked non-structured problems. If given this problem in a structured environment such as a standardized test I would likely look for a possible answer, realize none was possible, write a number as a guess with some notes about the median age of shepherds, and then be extremely frustrated at the test designer haha. I get that this is supposed to outline the differences between structured / unstructured learning, thinking, and classroom conditioning, but it's not quite fair to draw a conclusion that doesn't take that conditioning into account.
- dragonwriter 13y agoWhile I think this is true, I see the same thing in adults in professional positions (when given information and asked to respond to a query based on it, they will recombine the information and use it propose an answer even if where there is no sensible relationship between the question and the information rather than seeking additional information or identifying that the information offered is not sufficient to support a response to the question given) disturbingly often.
- Vaskivo 13y agoOne of the most important things I learned in college was to say "I don't know". Many students (even college students), will dance around a question trying to get a hint of the answer. I have no problems saying that I don't know, followed by asking the teacher what was the answer/solution. Teachers are much more assertive when you admit that you don't know, rather than being trying to prove your worth everytime. Of course, this kind of maturity is hard for little kids, specially when the "differences in power" between the kid and the teacher are the biggest.
- mikeash 13y agoIsn't that the whole point? We are teaching children badly by always giving them clear-cut problems that always have an answer, when the world is full of fuzzy problems that may not have an answer. Given the environment, why wouldn't the children guess? For years, we give them homework and tests where a guess is always equal to or better than no answer at all. But that's nearly the opposite of how the world works, so we're clearly teaching them the wrong things. I don't see how revealing that is not "fair".
- cunac 13y agoeverything has answer we just don't know what it is :-)
- dredmorbius 13y agoFor a given problem, can you write a program to determine whether or not it has an answer?
- brettm247 13y agoThe "Education" system doesn't teach sheeple to be critical thinkers. It trains a subservient citizenry. You don't want your slaves to be critical thinkers, just trained enough. The student is disciplined and trained to guess based on incomplete information given to them. We have got to teach children to build upon first principles. Poor kids, they are so afraid of being wrong! They would rather guess then take the time to figure out the fundamentals. They want to tell the teacher what he/she wants to hear regardless if it is a correct solution or not. I suppose that's what humans learn in a prison. School Sucks. Enough with Civic Religion. https://mises.org/daily/2937/ https://mises.org/daily/2937/
- jcutrell 13y agoThis is incredibly interesting to me, and points to a problem in our schools. We traditionally teach children to solve problems that have solutions. In particular, eighth grade teaches pre-algebra and algebra, so the way students approach problems is directly connected to how the student decodes the language of a "word problem". We need to change our conceptual understanding of what learning actually requires, and give students a situation in which they must write the problem themselves. Instead of "decoding" a predefined word problem, the student then must explore the situation and interpret the available information. A good way to handle this problem is to allow students to write word problems for other students based on a set of data, and subsequently create the "answer key" that includes the mathematical proofs. Proofs should be taught from a much earlier age.
- nimble 13y agoThis would never happen if there was a laptop in every classroom. (EDIT: Sarcasm alert -- see my response below before you downvote me) EDIT: Just watched the video. Scary.
- arbitrarilyHigh 13y agoWait, how would having a laptop in the classroom prevent this situation?
- thomaswmeyer 13y agoWell, they could google "How old is the shepherd" and find a link to articles discussing that there's no answer...
- nimble 13y agoThat was sarcasm. My point was that if this level of critical thinking deficiency is really present, then there is something seriously wrong with the way kids are being taught, and calls that you hear for extra funding to pay for things like laptops in the classroom are really a giant waste of money until we fix whatever that is.
- kbenson 13y agoThat's a good example of Poe's law. I decided to reply with (hopefully more apparent) sarcasm, because if it wasn't sarcasm, I didn't want to let it go, and if it was, I didn't want to be an ass, and I assumed you could take it as me going with the joke.
- dragonwriter 13y agoWell, if students could use the laptop during the test, since its a no-answer question that comes directly from well-publicized earlier research, at least some of them would google it and probably get the correct answer. This doesn't, of course, address the fundamental issue that the test reveals, but it would impact the results of the test.
- 13y ago
- hyperpape 13y agoI thint there is an unfortunate temptation to look at the students and think "how stupid are they?", but I wonder if the issue is more about familiarity of tasks. If students are going along solving word problems that always make sense, they have zero practice in identifying which questions are well posed and which aren't. It may not be that they're bad at reasoning through word problems, so much as they aren't used to word problems that make zero sense. Given that context, it makes partial sense for a child to think "I must be making a mistake--I can't see how this problem works, but it must work somehow, because these problems always do make sense, even if sometimes I get them wrong, because I am not smart enough to understand them." Is that a good attitude? Heck no. If nothing else, this experiment shows that we need to teach students that math problems aren't always going to be nicely set up so that they make sense. But that's different from thinking kids are dumb for not adapting to an unexpected wrinkle on a test. An interesting companion experiment would be to prompt the students to explain the problem first, or see whether they could accurately determine which problems made sense and which didn't, when they knew that was what they were doing. My prediction is that the results would not be great, but that they'd be better.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I think there is an unfortunate temptation to look at the students and think "how stupid are they?" I don't see any evidence of that in the comments on the original article or here. All of it seems to be focussed on the process of education and the habits it forms and the psychology of teacher/student (or more general authority figure) relations.
- hyperpape 13y agoYeah, I wasn't calling anyone out. Or if I was, I was calling out my first reaction. But the point that I still think is an issue is that we don't know how much of the effect is about what the students _understand_ as much as it's about how they see the situation they are in. What incentives are there, and what is the student actually thinking?
- MBCook 13y agoI think the last kid was extremely revealing. There are two numbers, and they didn't say "product", "sum", or "difference", so it must be division. Clearly the problems she gets in school are extremely rote and don't really require reading the problem much. Just look for a keyword or two and you can 'solve' it.
- lasermike026 13y agoWe can learn from Descartes, Aristotle, and others to develop a curriculum teaching children how to think and process. The idiots that run this country do not want that. It's about the curriculum. We can develop the world we want by teaching the next generation.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> how to think and process. The idiots that run this country do not want that "No one is going to give you the education you need to overthrow them." -- Assata Shakur
- Falling3 13y ago"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity."
- jessaustin 13y agoWere you taught that at school?
- Falling3 13y agoNo, but nice try!
- yongjik 13y agoI don't really understand this kind of categorical bashing of public education. Descartes, Aristotle, and most "others" you're thinking of lived in societies where the majority couldn't even read, and they didn't consider that a problem. Reading without moving your lips was considered an exceptional skill during the middle ages (or so I've heard). Are you sure they really knew much more about a practical system of education than we do now?
- niuzeta 13y ago> Reading without moving your lips was considered an exceptional skill during the middle ages (or so I've heard). You are refering to what contemporaries wrote about Thomas Aquinas, a well-renowned theologist in medieval era. I believe he was considered a genius because he could read without moving your lips. While it is a good food for thought for intellectual capabilities, one should also take note that in his time books were not what books as we know. No typography existed and whitespacing blocks between words were non-existent. Truly, they were mostly transcribed words with sometimes bad spelling and without a paragraph break. To read without reading out aloud meant that the reader had a mental capability to quickly parse out words, form a sentence, understand what the author meant out of context.
- scragg 13y agoI just asked my 2 yr old this same question. He just responded with "yellow!" /facepalm
- Kluny 13y agoAsk a stupid question, get a stupid answer!
- mistercow 13y agoThat answer isn't really any more wrong than "His age is 25 sheep per dog".
- charlieflowers 13y agoLike the AT&T commercial guy would say, "That's adorable."
- j2kun 13y agoLink appears to be down :(
- McLeopold 13y agoLet's assume the shepherd graduated high school at 18 then bought 2 lambs and a farm. He was nice to his sheep so didn't breed them until 2 years and not after 7. The average litter size is 2 and the average age is 11. Let's assume an even number of male and female sheep. At year 2 he'll have 4 sheep (2 original and 2 new lambs). 2 more at year 3 and then 4 at year 3 (the first litter can now breed). At year 7 the original sheep stop breeding. The shepherd is about 30 years old after he has passed the 125 mark. The dogs didn't matter. (Some story problems throw you a red herring.)
- jessaustin 13y agoA certain amount of inbreeding of livestock is OK, but your hypothetical shepherd is asking for problems. b^)
- will_work4tears 13y agoOr, conversely, the shepherd is 16 and they are the father's sheep. Nobody said they were his sheep.
- McLeopold 13y agoYou're right, nobody did say that. The point I was trying to make is that with the absence of data, you have to make assumptions and they should be clearly defined. My assumptions defined his starting age and how he obtained the first 2 sheep and the fact they were his. I guess I would want my kids too look at any math problem with the following things in mind: * identify units of measurement * identify useful data * identify non-useful data * identify assumptions needed to complete answer There are more or different assumptions I could make, such as cooperative breeding amoungst other breeders or a larger flock to start with, or a completely different model of breeding sheep. I could have described a scenario where he started with 2 sheep and went through several trading and auction rounds until he had 125 with some bonus dogs like the guy that got a house from a paper clip. We don't have a time measurement in years, so we need some type of sheep per time or time per sheep unit. I choose an assumption of breeding and came up with about 1 sheep per year per sheep. The original question is very close to a nonsense question, which requires so many assumptions that probably most answers can be well defended with the right set of assumptions. But at the very least you would hope a student could identify an answer in years could not be obtained with the given data of # of sheep and # of dogs. (And, no, I don't think the units method is beyond an eight grader, even if the educational system thinks it is. The fermi problem may be.)
- jessaustin 13y agoI think many eighth graders would be sophisticated enough for some dimensional analysis if it were presented in the right way. It's hard to imagine students who had been taught that, making these sorts of mistakes.
- mistercow 13y agoBut dimensional analysis is just another mathematical process turned into a rote method which does not require deeper understanding. The problem is not the pile of rote techniques is too small, but that students aren't learning how to actually think mathematically.
- jessaustin 13y agoI find this "think mathematically" concept you invoke to be a bit fuzzy. Even geniuses (not me, but I've met some) can be caught out by novel constructions if they haven't had time to consider them carefully. Much mathematical sophistication consists of adding to "the pile of techniques". If a student has too shallow a pile, the goal of educators should be to pile on more. If we suspect the research under discussion represents something real and not simply a series of methodology blunders, then it points to an improvement that educators could make. It's likely that basic dimensional analysis is not a complete answer, but I suspect that an admonition to "think mathematically" is not even wrong.
- mistercow 13y ago> I suspect that an admonition to "think mathematically" is not even wrong. I am not suggesting that we admonish students to think mathematically. I'm suggesting that we teach them to.
- tedsanders 13y agoIt's important not to confuse understanding a topic with having been taught the topic. If someone understands dimensional analysis, sure, they won't make the mistake. But it's easy to imagine students who were taught dimensional analysis making these kinds of mistakes. I think it's a mistake to argue that because students don't understand method X to solve a problem, they should be taught method Y. The problem is the lack of understanding, not the method.
- trinovantes 13y agoI remember back in my first year engineering physics midterm, it was 13 multiple choice questions and each question had a "there is not enough information given" option. I guess that's why everyone at my school calls it the rite of passage to university.
- programmarchy 13y agoThis is fascinating. I would be intrigued to see the results of asking the same question to students undergoing self-directed learning, either in a home schooling setting or in more progressive schools.
- epochwolf 13y agoThis is totally unsurprising. Most word problems in textbooks are poorly written and have little to no basis in reality. My experience as a grade school student is that most teachers get annoyed when you question the logic of the questions being asked. Critical thinking is not rewarded in those situations. So that given, which student is going to stick their neck out in that situation? It's better to risk a wrong answer than to risk annoying the teacher. The students may not think in those terms. They just know they need to provide the correct answer in the correct format. Understanding why is not important or rewarded. Only the result matters.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> This is totally unsurprising. Most word problems in textbooks are poorly written and have little to no basis in reality. There's a difference between a basis in reality and a internal completeness. I think the problem isn't the way "most word problems in textbooks" are written, except insofar as most are, in fact, internally complete and so students are not taught to verify that the question is complete and are instead encouraged to just throw math at the numbers in the problem until they get something that looks like an answer. Pedagogically, there may be some sense to this at certain levels, but eventually it becomes problematic if students don't have the both the skills and the understanding that it is desirable to first evaluate whether the question is complete.
- jumbled 13y ago"If two sides of a triangular garden are 3 and 4 feet respectively, find the length of the third side." Okay, hand me a tape measure. In a middle school algebra class we had a word problem on a test that had us divide by the number of cards in a deck of cards. I didn't think this was a fair question, because it assumed that everyone knew how many cards were in a deck of cards. I went to the teacher's desk and whispered this concern to her and she said "Come on, even my 5 year old knows how many cards are in a deck of cards." Not 10 minutes later, another student raised his hand and asked how many cards were in a deck of cards.
- dragonwriter 13y ago
- computerbob 13y agoGoogle Cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://robertkaplinsky.com/how-old-is-the-shepherd/ http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://...
- rprospero 13y agoThese kids were in something of a no win situation. I'm imagining a different class where 75% of the students said that there wasn't enough information to complete the problem: --- Our younger generation is doomed because they clearly don't understand math. After all, this is a fairly basic Fermi problem. The shepard probably started his own flock at around 18 and with two sheep. A sheep is a large mammal, so I'll assume that it has a gestation period around 9 months. We'll also guess that a sheep reaches sexual maturity after 3 years, or four gestation periods. If we assume that all adult female sheep are kept gravid and that genders are divided evenly, we know that the number of female sheep after n gestation periods is a(n) = a(n-1)+a(n-5)*0.5 Solving the recurrence relation and assuming that both sheep are adults when we start, there will be 60 female sheep, or 120 sheep in total, after 19 gestation periods. Thus the shepherd is around 33. Of course, I've made several assumptions in my solution and I wouldn't expect eighth graders to come back with the same answer. However, the fact that they just threw up their hands and declared that the problem is insolvable shows that our school system is failing the next generation of entrepreneurs. We don't need people who give up and declare that nothing can be done - we need people who make guesses and take risks. Yes, expecting an eighth grader to solve a recurrence relation is beyond their ability, but they could make simpler approximations. Heck, they could have just divided the number of sheep by two and been right to within an order of magnitude. It works as a model - say a sheep is born every six month and be done with it. It may not be the best model, but the perfect is the enemy of the good. Instead, we've taught our student to be dependent on our teachers to provide them with all the information and not make any guesses on their own. -- Obviously, the above is exaggerated, but the point remains that any answer or non-answer by the students can be interpreted as a lack of math skills and evidence of poor critical thinking. I'm not going to deny for a moment that our schools do a horrific job of teaching unit analysis - I've taught intro to physics and know how little our high school graduates know. Still, students are caught between two masters. When lacking information, students who guess are punished for lack of critical thinking and those who don't guess are punished for lack of effort and creativity. The blog post obviously indicates that the pendulum is currently swinging toward rewarding creativity over critical thinking. However, the pendulum will swing back and, in twenty years, we'll be complaining about how are students aren't doing nearly as well as the brilliant, creative children this blogger visited.
- RyanZAG 13y agoI weep for humanity.
- pfarrell 13y agothe 12th fibonacci number is 144. Assume some of the sheep didn't make it through a winter or that one of the dogs attacked some of them and had to be put down. So, 125 sheep left from a potential of 144 after 12 years of shepherding seems possible. Assuming the shepherd lives in a country that still has shepherding as a profession, we'll assume s/he started at 15. The shepherd is 27 years old Q.E.F.
- phaemon 13y agoWhat's scarier than the kids in that video are the number of people on HN who don't seem to have grasped the concept of where "lamb" and "mutton" come from. :-) EDIT: Too harsh! Tone down!
- C1D 13y agoI don't honestly think that the students are "dumb", I think they tried to work out the answer so they wouldn't fail the test with out trying. That's usually my method, if I don't know how to work out the answer I'll guess or try a logical method so that I might have a chance. I also think that because they don't expect a teacher to lie they tell themselves there has to be a answer.
- x0054 13y agoThe problem is teachers! One of my relatives is taking Community College level math right now. I was helping her with some homework, which was multiple choice. The problem was simple, find an area of a triangle. We did the problem, and the answer was not among one of the possible solutions. I quickly double checked my work, making sure I was right, and we decided to mark none on the problem sheet and give the right answer + show work. The teacher said that in this case you should always guess what the closest right answer is, and just mark that. WTF. The actual answer was roughly 65, the closest number to that on the answer sheet was 73. Math in USA is taught like religion, you have to believe what you are told, and god save you if you ask for proof. I remember in School we were reviewing Pythagoras Theorem. I asked the teacher to explain why it worked. She proceeded to draw on paper a triangle with sides of 3 and 4 inches, and then measured the long side, and said ‘see,’ with a very proud tone in her voice. When I asked if there is any more definitive proof, she replied that “it’s a theorem, there is no proof, that’s just the way it is.” I spent the first 6 grades of my education in Ukraine, admittedly in the communist equivalent of prep schools. There we were given math problems, and we were expected to solve them OR prove that they were unsolvable. At least one problem on every test was unsolvable, and they actually expected you to provide proof. My experience with college level math on US was the same, the teachers were smart and taught well. But Middle School and High School level math in USA is pathetic, in my experience.
- tedsanders 13y agoI think students (who are themselves a product of their parents and their culture) are also part of the problem. When students don't try, they fall behind, and when they fall behind, they have no choice but to make silly guesses.
- dublinben 13y agoIt sounds like you just had a bad math teacher. The Pythagorean Theorem has quite a few proofs, a number of which are understandable to students with only basic geometry knowledge. I'm almost certain I had to prove it in my math class at the time.
- tedsanders 13y agoWhen I tutored sixth grade math, it was not uncommon to see kids who guessed that 7 + 3 was 9. When you are that far behind in math, your only possible approach to the subject can be weird heuristics that make no sense.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 13y agoI have an idea for whenever I'll have my own kids. I'll buy them as toys as many measurement devices as I possibly can. This will show them, I hope, that numbers are not an abstract thing. They are everywhere. Not visible at first glance but with proper device you can see them. I think the fact that my grandfather (electrician by trade and self-taught carpenter, shoemaker and general DIY guy) owned and used vernier scale, micrometer, folding rule, voltmeters and ammeters contributed to my ability at mathematics, physics, chemistry, computer science and being a reasonable person. Surely I used a vernier scale as a makeshift futuristic gun, micrometer to squish my fingers, folding rule as kind of pretend switchblade but later also for seeing numbers in the world.
- gislifb 13y agoWell, looks like the kid on 2:22 is on to something.
- benched 13y agoI would really, really like to see more HN readers asking their young children, and posting the results.
- JshWright 13y agoYour first data point: My daughter smiled and tried to hand me her juice. Granted, she's 15 months old...