11 ms·
3-5 years?! THREE TO FIVE YEARS???!!! There are no words. Agents of the law need to be held more accountable for their actions than your average citizen, not l
by jjoonathan 13y ago
3-5 years?! THREE TO FIVE YEARS???!!!
There are no words. Agents of the law need to be held more accountable for their actions than your average citizen, not less. This is disgusting.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's a white collar crime and she's an educated person who isn't black or hispanic. That's not every factor behind the sentence, but it's an uncomfortably large subset of those factors.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rosser 13y agoJust because you can point out exceptions — and that's all they are: one-off exceptions — to the racial imbalances in the American criminal justice system doesn't mean they aren't glaringly and egregiously there.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rosser 13y agoNo offense, but the degree to which you're focusing on the color of Dookhan's skin is, frankly, creepy. And your remark about an "NAACP award" reads awfully petulantly, to me.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoThe racial and class disparities in sentencing is well established. Also, the fact that you say she's brown shows you don't understand how race impacts sentences. Its not a matter of being light or dark. Its a matter of being black or Hispanic and the economic and social status of blacks and Hispanics and how voters react to the kinds of crimes endemic in black and Hispanic communities. Why is the sentence so light? First, its a white collar crime. Sentences haven't been inflated across the board for white collar crimes the way they have for "poor minority" crimes (that is, crimes endemic in poor minority communities). The high sentences for crimes like drug dealing are tied up with both race and class issues, and as a result 3-5 seems like a particularly light sentence. Second, she's a sympathetic character in sentencing. All sorts of factors can be used in sentencing, and they disfavor people from poor minority communities. Have a wife and child? That's more sympathetic than having an out of wedlock child and baby momma. Grow up in the hood where gangs are pervasive? Well it'll be easier to dig up unfavorable bits of your past than if you grew up in a middle class community. The root of the outrage is that 3-5 seems so light in comparison to the sentences of the people this chemist helped convict for drug crimes. A big part of that is that the latter sentences are so high because of the race and class issues mentioned above.
- maratd 13y agoNothing in your response excuses you throwing race into the mix. Race has nothing to do with it. Economic standing does. Yes, blacks and hispanics suffer disproportionately for the very reasons you cite, but they do not suffer because they are black or hispanic ... they do so because they are disproportionately poor. Rather than focusing on the real issue, insane sentencing for crimes common in poor neighborhoods, you throw race into the mix, which adds nothing and simply pisses people off.
- rayiner 13y agoBlacks and Hispanics suffer disproportionately, when it comes to sentences and everything else, even adjusted for economic status. I'm sorry pointing out that fact pisses some people off. But why the heck do that think blacks are disproportionately poor to begin with, if not for reasons having to do with their race? Its not like we didn't just get done with a couple of centuries of race based slavery and oppression. But no, the attitudes that animated that oppression have simply vanished within my parents lifetime![1] Sociological evolution happening in a historical blink of the eye. Again, I'm not bringing it up randomly. What drives sentences? Fear. You think fear has nothing to do with race? That's utterly naive. Nobody who has even the barest experience with the criminal justice system can come away without the feeling that racial issues pervade how it works. [1] Even less. Sentence inflation in the US started in the 70s and 80s, just a decade after George Wallace proclaimed "segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever!" Sentence inflation happened in the aftermath of desegregation, race riots, and white flight. Even if people are much more open minded today, the legal structures and policing apparatus we still have today were forged then.
- ics 13y agoI have mixed feelings about jail terms in general, but I agree– this is precisely the sort of crime I would imagine carrying a life sentence. The number of cases affected & lives disrupted here is hardly fathomable.
- sentenza 13y agoWhat is the punishment for helping somebody to hold a person captive in their basement? The sentence should be that times sixhundred (how many wrongful convictions she caused, number might rise yet).
- gaius 13y agoThe sum of those 40000 sentences.
- msandford 13y agoHonestly I think this is a situation where the death penalty is entirely appropriate. I don't like the idea of more suffering when there is already plenty to go around here, but I can't see how you can call it "justice" if she is allowed to live. An example must be set that this kind of thing is so repugnant to civilized societies that it WILL NOT BE TOLERATED. EDIT: The scale of her crimes is thousands of person-years of human life in jail. Some of them probably deserved it, others probably didn't. There is a serious asymmetry here, she has only 50-100 years that she can be imprisoned and that's not a strong enough message to people in the government who would think about doing the same to further their own careers as well.
- thenmar 13y agoFor someone supposedly concerned about human life, you seem awfully eager to end one.
- msandford 13y agoSuperficially I have to agree with you that I look like a hypocrite. The government is the body which has a monopoly on violence. In other words, they're the only people who can legally do things to people that nobody would volunteer to have done to them, like going to prison. It's the government's job to provide courts through which disputes can be resolved, since you aren't supposed to take matters into your own hands. One class of those disputes is the government vs citizens who have violated the government's rules or the laws. When those kinds of cases are going through the courts the government should be extra careful to be impartial because everyone can tell that it's potentially a situation ripe for corruption. The government is adjudicating a case between the government (the DA or prosecutor) and someone not in the government ("normal people"). Given the choice you wouldn't choose your wife's parents to settle a dispute between you and your wife; but this can be a very real fear when being prosecuted. The problem here is even though you can name the different parts of the government and call them separate (courts, prosecutor, forensics, etc) ultimately we find out that forensics and the prosecutor are both "on the same team" and that when the courts get involved again to try and fix the mess, that the forensics person is still "on the same team" as the prosecutors and maybe everyone else. If you're in the class of people called "the government" you have to be extra right, extra careful, and extra following-the-rules so that ordinary people get a fair shake when dealing with an entity that has virtually limitless funds to prosecute versus their usually meager funds to defend (unless you're in the top 1% to 0.1% or so, then it's just "lots more" rather than "infinitely more"). Here's a case where not only was the forensics person not extra careful, right and proper, not even sloppy and foolish but malicious. And not just a little bit either, she didn't tamper with one case that involved a cheating ex or something. She did it systematically over thousands of cases depriving people of their liberty wrongly. You could build a strong case that she perverted justice in a very horrific manner. If you add up all the person-years of people's lives that she conspired to help imprison and divide by 100 year in a life (round numbers) you'd get to the point where she's effectively "taken" tens if not hundreds of lives. That makes her in a roundabout way something akin to a very impressive mass murderer. In that case I'm not sure that the death penalty is an over-reactionary knee-jerk kind of punishment.
- 4ad 13y agoAlso, nothing for the prosecutors that "hired" her?
- scoot 13y agoThe simplistic view would be that every unjust sentence served by someone else as a result of her tampering should transfer to her.
- 3pt14159 13y agoIt should be every unjust sentence awarded not served. The terror of being told 20 years and living out 1 them is enough to award 20 years to someone else.
- lemonberry 13y agoYou're all being kind of harsh. She was just trying to advance her career.
- jgamman 13y agoi believe you forgot the /sarcasm and /troll markups in your comment.
- lemonberry 13y agoI thought the sarcasm was fairly obvious.
- sejje 13y agoI agree, in context. If she's purposely stolen years and years from others' lives, she needs to be held accountable for each and every instance. And the idea that this happened in a laboratory doesn't make it any milder...this is, in my opinion, far worse than most violent crimes. I think the time served should be very long, given that most of our violent crimes have very long terms. That said, I think we need to revisit very long terms. I don't know the answers, but I think that taking decades for seconds of rage, etc, can be extremely harsh. I hope we can amend this system, or eliminate the need for it, someday. To me, I'm equally or even more scared of prosecutors that have the power to destroy my life as I am of thugs on the street that have that power. It's far scarier in cases like this, where they only risk a slap on the wrist balanced against absolutely destroying lives. I literally cannot imagine losing years in prison, when you have so few already.
- malandrew 13y ago"... she needs to be held accountable for each and every instance." Accountability is nice, but let's not lose sight of the bigger picture here which is a sharp correction of the system that not only allowed her to carry on for years, but more than likely actively encouraged her. Personally, instead of having her serve a 100 year jail sentence, I would have no problem letting get a jail sentence of 1 year if it meant that everyone else complicit in these crimes also got 1 year of jail. Spreading it among all those responsible is a much bigger deterrent than throwing one person under the bus. Going to jail for a serious crime you are guilty of is a lottery. It is a much more effective deterrent when being found guilty and spending time in jail is a likely event when a crime actually occurs."
- sejje 13y agoCan't agree more. I think they should all be held accountable, no doubt, and I don't think that was lost in the discussion here on HN, thankfully. I personally find it more contemptible the more power those involved have. This chemist likely felt pressure from her higher-ups. No excuse for her, but disgusting of them to exert their power in that manner. I hadn't thought much about your last sentence before, but it's very valid. It's a lottery because you're not always caught (and then in some cases, white-collar-crime, you're likely to get a slap on the wrist). I imagine that most criminals are dumb enough to convince themselves they won't be caught, making their odds to "win" seem even higher. I think crime & punishment is such a complex problem, and our current system is barely passable, and has incredible room for improvement. I just don't want to be the answers guy, because I don't know how to improve it, and the risks are high.
- enraged_camel 13y agoI wonder how they plan on keeping her safe from the other inmates, some of whom will undoubtedly accuse her for their sentence.
- marshray 13y ago"So... what are you in for?"
- bmelton 13y agoCompletely agreed. I think a workable compromise would be to sentence her to 3-5 years for each count -- or even, hell, let's be generous... 1 day for each count of tampering. That's 40,000 counts, 1 day per, continuous -- 109 years and change. Those entrusted with protecting the law should have far more obligation to uphold its tenets than the hoi polloi, lest we start conceding that there really are two classes of citizenry and start a class war.
- atmosx 13y agoisn't it weird that that the numbers of years is 109? A whole number? Which also happens to be a prime.
- bmelton 13y agoIt wasn't a whole number, I rounded. Actually, I rounded twice, because it was actually like ~36,000-something occurrences, which I rounded off to 40 because I'm very lazy.
- rpenm 13y agoI think we should be more worried that this is a systemic problem and not a single bad actor. There is something wrong with a system that is so vulnerable to this type of manipulation.
- malandrew 13y ago3-5 years is fine as long as everyone else who colluded or was complicit also gets caught up in this, especially DAs. The citizens of Massachusetts should demand a thorough clean up of the lab to bring it back to reputability, and that means cleaning house. I reckon that all other 49 states should see this as a sign to perform their own audits. I just hope that if such audits are performed, that they don't get swept under the rug. Otherwise the problem will be solved, but many who didn't get due process will continue to rot in jail so that other states can save face. 20+ year jail sentences are already excessive for the overwhelming majority of people in jail with 20+ year sentences.
- sergiosgc 13y agoOh, don't worry. She screwed over 40000 people. The number of lawsuits she'll have to defend against should see her ass parked in court for a decade. Even without any conviction.
- kubiiii 13y agoShe also made her colleagues production figures look very bad. I'd sue her too over lost bonuses.
- acconrad 13y agoLiterally my first thought, and glad this was the top comment. It seems insane to me that someone ruins the lives of THOUSANDS and is only given a 3 to 5 year sentence. True irony at its finest.