13 ms·
Government Chemist Tampered With 40,000 Cases
- pasbesoin 13y agoSo, it appears that evidence processing has something akin to zero controls and (effective) auditing? Where prosecutors either knew of or had strong reason to suspect this misbehavior, their immunity should be dissolved and they should be prosecuted. Their personal assets should also be subject to forfeiture for compensation.
- sigstoat 13y agowell, usually the state government has some body which certifies these labs. that works for shit (see colorado). the only real audit is defendants having the evidence retested by their own experts. reputable privately operated laboratories doing this sort of testing for forensic purposes do exist.
- kmfrk 13y agoDon't worry, it gets worse: http://www.npr.org/series/133208980/post-mortem-death-investigation-in-america http://www.npr.org/series/133208980/post-mortem-death-invest....
- sigstoat 13y agobuddy, that's not even scratching the surface. when rural counties are barely willing to pay the elected coroner their stipend, they're surely not going to fund a forensic pathologist ($$$!) and the staff/tools/testing to make them effective. there are homicides that go undetected left and right, and a distressing number of forensically sophisticated criminals out there. but everybody thinks the cops whip out some crazy CSI team for every case, and leave no stone unturned, and no test unperformed (hahaha!), so there's no motivation for anybody to try and get the funding necessary.
- moocowduckquack 13y agothere's a second employee at the same place now caught up in it, with possibly up to 190,000 cases now needing review - http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/11/26/chemist-related-dookhan-case-fired-for-allegedly-misstating-credentials/HhWnT898pjWVJgdAKSnUWJ/story.html http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/11/26/chemist-related-...
- seivan 13y agoOh this is rich. 'she took some chemistry classes in college but her degree is actually in sociology,' Hot diggittiy. Edit: Goes to prove that a _GOOD_ defense lawyer would have dig that up during cross exam. (if that is a thing)
- sigstoat 13y ago> Edit: Goes to prove that a _GOOD_ defense lawyer would have dig that up during cross exam. (if that is a thing) sure, the defense lawyer can ask questions, but what series of questions do you think they could've asked that would've done anything here? they would've needed to perform pre-trial investigations of the lady (such as the state police performed) to discover this. which isn't out of the question, but isn't very likely to be worth it for the defendants. (cost high, likelihood of useful information low.)
- seivan 13y agoHmm not sure, but well, wouldn't a simple question of "where did your degree in chemistry come from" while the person in question is under OAuth? EDIT: Oath. I've been working too much recently.
- lttlrck 13y agoDon't worry OAuth made sense to me in this context somehow..
- sigstoat 13y agosince that is exactly what she was lying, or confused about, i fail to see how asking it one more time would help. in fact, the state prosecutors probably asked her that question a bajillion times, as part of qualifying her as an expert witness. (added: in case you don't know, i'd like to clarify that qualifying expert witnesses occurs in open court. the defense, judge, jury, anyone watching the case, etc would all hear the question asked, and her answer. this would come after a copy of her CV, including relevant degrees, was submitted.)
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoThose convicted should be released pending retrial immediately.
- computer 13y agoAll 190,000 of them?
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIf that's the true number, then yes, absolutely.
- Shivetya 13y agothey do deserve a new trial. if their offense was not sufficient to warrant holding in jail before the trial I think they should be let out on ankle bracelets or such. The simple matter here is, the evidence was faulty. Hopefully no prosecutors were in on it, but if the evidence was used to convict then any conviction is suspect. Numbers don't matter when justice is determined. The government should have better means to validate its employees are doing what they are supposed to do. I would have liked to seen the Chemist sentenced to life, or at least the cumulative number of years of all sentences with tampered evidence.
- DanBC 13y agoHow many of those 190,000 pose a risk of harm to other people? How many of them were violent, or sexual[1], offenders? [1] Laws are different in different places, but here I'm talking about actual sex offences, not things like public urination. (Which is gross, but usually not a sexual offence).
- aqme28 13y agoIt doesn't really matter what their offense was if the prosecution can't convict them for it legitimately. Any convictions dependent on that chemist's work should be void.
- sejje 13y ago
- vph 13y agoWhat about the prosecutors who have been asking her to tamper with evidence? Are they going to jail?
- TDL 13y agoThe investigation is expanding. Another lab worker is now being investigated and I read something about some of the prosecutors behavior be questioned. It seems as though this is the beginning not the end.
- jjoonathan 13y ago3-5 years?! THREE TO FIVE YEARS???!!! There are no words. Agents of the law need to be held more accountable for their actions than your average citizen, not less. This is disgusting.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's a white collar crime and she's an educated person who isn't black or hispanic. That's not every factor behind the sentence, but it's an uncomfortably large subset of those factors.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rosser 13y agoJust because you can point out exceptions — and that's all they are: one-off exceptions — to the racial imbalances in the American criminal justice system doesn't mean they aren't glaringly and egregiously there.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rosser 13y agoNo offense, but the degree to which you're focusing on the color of Dookhan's skin is, frankly, creepy. And your remark about an "NAACP award" reads awfully petulantly, to me.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoThe racial and class disparities in sentencing is well established. Also, the fact that you say she's brown shows you don't understand how race impacts sentences. Its not a matter of being light or dark. Its a matter of being black or Hispanic and the economic and social status of blacks and Hispanics and how voters react to the kinds of crimes endemic in black and Hispanic communities. Why is the sentence so light? First, its a white collar crime. Sentences haven't been inflated across the board for white collar crimes the way they have for "poor minority" crimes (that is, crimes endemic in poor minority communities). The high sentences for crimes like drug dealing are tied up with both race and class issues, and as a result 3-5 seems like a particularly light sentence. Second, she's a sympathetic character in sentencing. All sorts of factors can be used in sentencing, and they disfavor people from poor minority communities. Have a wife and child? That's more sympathetic than having an out of wedlock child and baby momma. Grow up in the hood where gangs are pervasive? Well it'll be easier to dig up unfavorable bits of your past than if you grew up in a middle class community. The root of the outrage is that 3-5 seems so light in comparison to the sentences of the people this chemist helped convict for drug crimes. A big part of that is that the latter sentences are so high because of the race and class issues mentioned above.
- whiddershins 13y agoHow hard would it have been to insert a random cross check in to the system? So every 300 tests, the sample is retested by another lab? There's no motivation or incentive whatsoever to structure the process to decrease convictions, that is one of the unspoken but defining features of our legal system. There is an ideal that two sides are arguing something in a neutral setting, but one side is the government, and literally everyone who should be acting impartially is also employed by the same government. How can that create a balanced process? Only in a naive and delusional imaginary world.
- interstitial 13y agoAdd some "parallel discovery" courtesy of the NSA and you've got a recipe for tyranny.
- drjesusphd 13y agoParallel construction is the NSA informing local cops of crimes that they actually have evidence for, albeit obtained illegally. This is just straight lying. Trading hundreds of years of others' lives for a modestly higher paycheck.
- sigstoat 13y ago> How hard would it have been to insert a random cross check in to the system? So every 300 tests, the sample is retested by another lab? the states are barely willing to pay for this sort of testing in the first place, let alone having it performed repeatedly. defendants are generally able to get the evidence retested themselves. very hand wavily, that sort of thing will tend to cost $100-$1000.
- ryanhuff 13y agoOr even inject some known negatives and see if they turn out positive. Seems pretty simple.
- makomk 13y agoNot that hard, but it costs money, and in any case she had evidence to the actual samples and intentionally contaminated them with real drugs.
- DanBC 13y agoThis kind of case is fascinating. The woman wasn't evil. But her actions really are. It's very easy, too easy, to say that she is evil because what she did was so bad. But that's lazy, and it misses the interesting stuff. How do people get caught up in performing such horrendous acts? There's a bunch of cognitive stuff going on, and some subtle manipulation. I suspect that something similar is how we end up with app stores full of "free" games that are full of micro-payments and ads. (Instead of the Doom model of a few free levels and a paid for full version).
- wpietri 13y agoDefinitely. I was thinking about that too. In the same way that you can build a reliable system from unreliable components through clever system design, I think you can build an evil system from good but limited people. I think a lot about the housing bubble, the popping of which has had a terrible human cost. There may be nobody on earth who is willing to say, "Yes, I helped make that happen." But there are an awful lot of borrowers, mortgage brokers, bankers, executives, and investors who are very sure that it wasn't their fault. After all, they were just doing their job or obeying the incentives.
- venomsnake 13y agoGo check Robert Sheckley's Ticket to Tranai - it had the opposite - utopia created on the basis the human nature is flawed and some creative design. Fun read.
- wpietri 13y agoAwesome. I read that years ago but had forgotten it. Here's a link for those interested: http://www.e-reading.co.uk/chapter.php/149381/8/Sheckley_-_Citizen_in_Space.html http://www.e-reading.co.uk/chapter.php/149381/8/Sheckley_-_C... It reminds me of "And Then There Were None": http://www.abelard.org/e-f-russell.php http://www.abelard.org/e-f-russell.php And "The Midas Plague": http://www.e-reading.co.uk/bookreader.php/1010251/Pohl_-_The_Midas_Plague.html http://www.e-reading.co.uk/bookreader.php/1010251/Pohl_-_The...
- 13y ago
- goldenkey 13y agoAre we seriously up in arms about the chemist? The prosecutors are the worse filth here. And the worst thing about it is that the DA and the prosecutors are going to bury her into the ground, and villify her, while they get away totally scott-free. The system just keeps on churning.. “Any help would be greatly appreciated!” he wrote, punctuating each sentence with a long string of exclamation points. “Thank you!”
- aeturnum 13y agoI agree that the prosecutors are probably guilty of some kind of misconduct. However, I think the email you quote is the kind we would see either way. We expect prosecutors to be unabashed in their pursuit of convictions - it's their job. They should cajole and berate, in turn, people who help or hinder their cases. That may be a shitty model, but it's the model we use. We have a responsibility to only punish people for things they knew to be wrong - thanking a lab tech for a favorable result doesn't cross that line.
- goldenkey 13y agoResults should be impartial. Bribing the lab tech is not what I would call a fair and balanced process.
- aeturnum 13y agoThat email, unless pleasantries or enthusiasm count as bribes, would not be considered a bribe. It's just good practice to be polite to those who can help you. Perhaps we should legislate that prosecutors should be dour towards everyone they encounter, less a pleasant experience bias someone? P.s. I realize that improper conduct by both parties is probable in this case, but the quoted email certainly does not cross the line.
- goldenkey 13y agoAsking for help with a quantitive measure, ie. a lab test, indicates bribery (perhaps non-monetary.)
- DigitalSea 13y agoThe chemist involved was believed to have tainted over 40,000 cases over the duration of about 10 years and they'll only get 3 to 5 years? Seriously? Weev who was involved in the arguable AT&T data breach got a 41 month jail term, people who've been caught selling counterfeit DVD's have been given similar sentences. Dookhan should serve the sentences that she was responsible for, every single case. If anything, I think the death penalty is fair. Imagine all of the lives she ruined. all of the families and children who grew up thinking their dad, mother, grandparent or relative were convicted criminals. Not to mention the trouble convicted inmates have when they get out adjusting to reality and getting a job, credit, etc. What about the main prosecutor involved here? Is he going to be subjected to a court case as well? Or will the system prove itself reliable once again and the chemist will be vilified and blamed. This is appalling.
- goldenkey 13y agoWhy is your focus on the chemist despite the fact that she was basically bribed? This is a conspiracy and the prosecutors and DA should be investigated. But of course, they're going to be the ones bearing the case against her, and taking the spotlight off themselves. And the only ones who will correctly investigate the DA/prosecutors would be the FBI, I really doubt anything is really going to be done here that will be substantial other than a political panzy-dance.
- DigitalSea 13y agoThe chemist could have easily spoken out. Protections would have been put into place to ensure that she and her family wouldn't have been harmed. Obviously blackmail and fear plays a part here, but evident by the fact she didn't seem to be upset about being caught nor deny anything, sounds like a classic case of a sociopath (or even part sociopath). How could you live with yourself knowing for ten years you've ruined countless lives? Whether she believes it or not, she had her chance and the blame sadly does lay with her and the prosecutor for being complacent in the crimes taking place.
- goldenkey 13y ago
- b6 13y agoHow were her crimes discovered?
- b6 13y ago> In July, the AG’s Office began a criminal investigation into the matter after there were allegations of impropriety at the Hinton State Laboratory. http://www.mass.gov/ago/news-and-updates/press-releases/2012/2012-09-28-dookhan-arrest.html http://www.mass.gov/ago/news-and-updates/press-releases/2012...
- marze 13y agoWhat about the prosecutors involved in requesting faked evidence? One would expect some long sentences.
- gergles 13y agoI would expect them never being allowed to be a prosecutor ever again. There's plenty of other legal jobs they can have, but they abused the public's trust too much to ever hold this one ever again.
- scarmig 13y agoUh, no. They shouldn't be allowed to have any legal profession again. Think about all the wrongfully convicted people who are marked as felons now. They can't get a job in the legal field now. Hell, they have difficulty getting a job at a fast food restaurant. The fact that the sociopaths who committed this travesty against justice have expensive mortgages to pay and private schools to send their kids to isn't any reason for excess gentleness.
- jules 13y agoYea, no. How about prison time? If you knowingly try to subvert the process that is there to keep innocent people from being found guilty, for personal gain, then you deserve a greater punishment than having to look for another job.
- sejje 13y agoI would want, but not expect, far stiffer punishment than that. This isn't "you suck at your job," this is "you are an evil person, and willingly have broken the law that you know so well to destroy the lives of others in an attempt to further yourself."
- drjesusphd 13y agoWhat makes you expect such a thing? "Hope"? Sure. But "expect"? In what world?
- Someone 13y agoEmbarassing for the government, criminal, etc? Yes, but the title (both on HN and in the original) is sensationalistic. 40,000 cases in 10 years? That's around 15 cases per working day. She must have almost done a search and replace to be that 'productive'. Because of that, I suspect the 'up to 40,000' means there are 40,000 cases that she might have affected, not that she is known to have affected.
- mr_spothawk 13y agoDid you see the link @ the bottom of the article? > "Another Chemist at Dookhan’s Lab Accused of Deception, More than 180,000 Cases Need Review" Seems your suspicion about how the counting gets done is accurate.
- robryan 13y agoI guess she might oversee a lab staff and that is the total case volume going through that lab?
- atmosx 13y agobreaking bad? hehe
- austinz 13y agoI find it hard to believe she'd be the only person to do these sorts of things. How many other people across the US in similar positions are surreptitiously tampering with the legal system right now? And how can we find them?
- gradys 13y agoGiven n>40,000, statistical analysis is one approach.
- mixmax 13y agoyour hypothesis is backed up by this story claiming that at least one other chemist has also been tainting evidence and that 180.000 cases now need to be reviewed. http://filmingcops.com/breaking-another-government-chemist-accused-of-deception-over-180000-cases-now-need-review/ http://filmingcops.com/breaking-another-government-chemist-a...
- marvin 13y agoSpot on. It's outrageous that one person was able to cause this much damage, but the sentencing in this case very strongly indicates that there is a perverse system of incentives which allows things like this to happen. As long as someone profits, economically or otherwise, on people being sent to jail, there is an incentive structure which perverts justice. It's shocking to be that there isn't more focus on this problem.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoRemarkable is the motivation of this chemist. No substantial money has changed hands, and she probably hasn't even received a promotion due to her higher conviction rates. She probably did it for the recognition or out of some perverse sense of justice. That's actually good news, because it means this case is probably very special.
- dreamdu5t 13y agoJustice has not been served. People get longer sentences for marijuana possession. The prosecutors in those emails should be jailed for life along with the chemist. ... this is not justice.
- honzzz 13y agoThe chemist did something horrible and I am not trying to justify her actions. But I think that the true culprit of this is the system of incentives typical for US penal system. If the prosecutors are rewarded based on the number of convictions and prisons can be privately owned and prisoners can be exploited for private gain... something like this is inevitable. If sending people to prison is profitable business there is always going to be someone who decides to expand their 'business' by making sure as many people as possible get sent to prison no matter whether they are guilty or not.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tjaerv 13y agoPreviously: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI_Laboratory#Controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI_Laboratory#Controversy
- spdmn 13y agoShe'll get off on a "tampering with evidence" loophole. Sick sick woman.
- rooshdi 13y agoSick sick system.
- noonespecial 13y agoShe did not act alone. It is abundantly clear that the prosecutors knew that there was some funny business going on. There are extremely perverse incentives for prosecutors to cheat by any means possible for career advancement. The only way to fix this is to set it up so that "getting a conviction" in no way whatsoever enhances a prosecutor's career.
- forktheif 13y agoI find it disappointing that the majority of posts here only want revenge with long sentences or even death, and only a minority want to change the system or put systems in place to make this less likely to happen again.
- gaius 13y agoIt's a deterrent, so it's both.
- squozzer 13y agoI gather from the article there was a lot of contact between the chemist and various prosecutors. That should stop. Maybe we should consider evidence-gathering a judicial function instead of an executive one.
- memracom 13y agoThis indicates a serious level of corruption in the police, in the prosecutors, and possibly even in the politicians who are in charge of these things. If this had happened in Putin's Russia, the people in charge would all be fired in disgrace, and the prisoners would be freed with compensation payments. But in America? What will happen? Americans like to talk loudly about corruption in other countries but when they learn about corrupt police in many states, corrup sherriffs, corrupt prosecutors (2nd recent case in Mass.) then what do they do? Not much! This is why the American Empire is on the way out. My family is learning Mandarin Chinese and Russian because it is clear that the two big powers of Asia will dominate the world of the 21st century.