9 ms·
New Bacterial Life-Form Discovered in NASA and ESA Spacecraft Clean Rooms
- andyjohnson0 13y agoI wonder if this article is confusing two different types of clean room. I can understand why a lander like Phoenix has to be biologically clean, needing bio-isolation and alcohol-swabbed surfaces, but why is there this requirement for the Herschel space telescope? It stays in space. Surely the telescope would just require protection from dust, etc. during assembly in an environment similar to a chip fab? I'm not too surprised that bacteria could find their way into such an environment. Disclosure: Obviously I'm not a rocket scientist.
- mhurron 13y agoWouldn't bacteria possibly pose the same issue as dust to the telescope.
- avar 13y agoI used my Internet superpowers to Google "clean room use for orbital telescopes" and came up with this: http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/1897/why-was-the-hubble-space-telescope-purged-with-nitrogen-gas http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/1897/why-was-the-hu...
- andyjohnson0 13y agoI also read that page, although my search used different terms. Seems I have the same internet superpowers that you do. There is no mention of biological isolation in the Q/A you linked to, just controlling the atmospheric environment around the vehicle.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoIt's probably a combination of general cleanliness and a desire to avoid mildew (one spore + humidity = army of spores).
- afandian 13y agoThe humidity!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- oso2k 13y agoI worked IT for JPL's Cleanroom Group a few years ago. Biological contaminants are only one factor. 95-99% of the cleanrooms they have are not much cleaner than something like a typical elementary classroom with a well kept air filtration system (not great). These are Class 100K rooms [1]. Less than 100K particles of 0.1 um size or bigger per m^3 of air (dust, hair, skin, anything really). Offenders of contaminating the rooms some brought in unapproved or contaminated materials, like non-cleanroom notepads or gaseous/non-cleanroom markers/pens, cardboard. The reason why the rooms were not operated cleaner is because of their size. Some were large like 40m by 40m by 40m (the main Spacecraft Assembly Facility where the Herschel instrument saw final assembly), others housed special capabilities like the 25-foot Space Simulator [2], shakers and bakers (rotation/vibration test pedestals, and space vacuum hot/cold chambers), or isolation pads (pedestals mounted on ultra heavy 40'x40'x40' blocks of concrete to reduce vibration for optics instrument testing). It was also common practice to certify a room at one level, and operate it like it was the next higher level with minimal cost and maximal benefit. Things like additional air exchanges, daily or twice daily cleanings (instead of weekly), extra HEPA filters, stricter ESD operations, stricter temperature and humidity control (ESD & Planetary Protection reasons). This was often more than sufficient to appease the Principal Investigators, Instrument Designers, and Planetary Protection. Many rooms were Class 10K capable. A few were Class 1K or Class 100 capable. But those were very small rooms, sometimes even 10'x10'x10' tents setup in a one level less capable room. Only two rooms operated were even capable of operating at Class 100, IIRC, and only did so when necessary. There were apart of chip fabrication building. To answer your question, Herschel has its base requirements similar to anything we send off into space, and then it had it optics instruments requirements. Projects have been ruined when instruments do not work or do not work as well as designed because of dust, ESD, or a hair particle. It's really hard/expensive to wipe your lens with a microfiber cloth in space; JPL once did a study to determine the cost/feasibility. It dwarfed the original project. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleanroom#ISO_14644-1_cleanroom_standards http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleanroom#ISO_14644-1_cleanroom... [2] http://www.universetoday.com/97249/jpls-torture-chamber-for-spacecraft/ http://www.universetoday.com/97249/jpls-torture-chamber-for-...
- sneak 13y agoThank you for your contribution. Your post exemplifies why I continue to personally justify spending a statistically significant portion of my productive hours each day scanning HN.
- vor_ 13y agoThe article's second page answers this: Scientists go to all this trouble for the purpose of “planetary protection”—which usually means protecting other planets from contamination by microbes originating on Earth. Most spacefaring countries have agreed to follow guidelines from the International Council for Science’s Committee on Space Research to reduce the chances of their vehicles carrying Earth organisms to other planets. The clean room procedures also safeguard against scientists mistaking Earthly microbes as extraterrestrial in origin if they are discovered on another planet, having caught a ride with a man-made spacecraft. “The whole idea of collecting information about what kind of bugs we have in the spacecraft assembly facility is to have baseline information so that in the future, if you find it on Mars, you have some grounds to rule out the possibility that it came from Mars,” Vaishampayan says.
- dekhn 13y ago120kg of matter is exchanged between Mars and Earth per year, already. They've just reduced the possibility of contamination by their spacecraft, compared to natural events.
- Crito 13y agoBeing able to make the distinction between panspermia induced by human activity, and panspermia that occurred through some other mechanism is important. The possibility that life jumped the gap on meteorite strike debris does not make protecting against contamination any less important. Actually, I would say that it makes it more important. If there was no possibility for non-human related panspermia, then if we found an organism on Mars that appears closely related to an earth organism, then we could write it off as contamination and ignore it. However since non-human related panspermia could conceivably happen, it would be more difficult to pin such a discovery on contamination.
- Groxx 13y agoCitation please (sounds interesting, but yeah), and does it get exchanged at the speed that this stuff does, or does it take thousands^x years to arrive? Not that I disagree. Just wondering if there are a few orders of magnitude that need to be considered.
- pazimzadeh 13y agoIt's partially so that if we do in fact discover life in space, we're not "discovering" something that we actually brought up there with us.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoPlanetary protection protocols. It's a best effort approach to minimize the risk of "contaminating" planets with Earth life. It applies to any spacecraft in interplanetary space, not just landers, because it's impossible to predict where an object that ends up in heliocentric orbit will end up, it could end up hitting another asteroid, planet, or moon.
- Aardwolf 13y agoWell, there probably already is life on Mars thanks to us now :)
- dekhn 13y agoAs long as NASA doesn't try to claim this is more evidence for astrobiology (rather than plain old terrestrial damn-tough bacteria), I'm OK with this.
- nitrogen 13y agoDiscovering new niches in which life survives gives us more possible extraterrestrial habitats that could, potentially, also harbor life.
- bonestamp2 13y ago"The researchers are not sure yet if the bug lives only in clean rooms or survives elsewhere..." They think there's a possibility it only lives in clean rooms? Am I missing something, or does that seem very unlikely?
- Aardwolf 13y agoIt doesn't want to live in dirty rooms, only in clean rooms.
- jeremyjh 13y agoPresumably it did not spring into existence fully-formed in a clean room in the last hundred years. So, it must be able to live in other conditions but at population levels that are virtually undetectable.
- emiliobumachar 13y agoMaybe it's very vulnerable to competition, predators etc.
- insickness 13y agoThat's the mind-blowing thing for me about this article. The idea is that it can't compete with other organisms out in the wild. Out in the wild, other organisms reproduce too quickly, are too aggressive, devour these bacteria, etc. But these bacteria have something that allows them to survive in a clean room's extreme environment, something that kills off other more competitive organisms. This is the very definition of niche.
- jlebrech 13y agodoes it have dna? what if it's a branch new genome?
- toufka 13y agoIt's only 96% similar to other bacteria we know of. Which is greater than the difference of most mammals to each other. But still pretty similar and not entirely radical in its genetic makeup (in the grand scheme of things).
- ryanmarsh 13y ago"New" or "previously undiscovered"?
- unoti 13y agoI have a bunch of questions born of my ignorance of microbiology: Is it possible this organism evolved in the last few decades, with the advent of clean rooms? Or is it more likely that a few of these are around all the time, and only multiply extensively in clean rooms? Also, what do they eat or use for energy to reproduce in such environments? And if they don't really eat, how do they not die on a long space journey?
- icegreentea 13y agoIt is possible for it to have evolved in the last few decades, but really unlikely. The stated figure of less than 5% DNA commonality implies a really extensive divergence. Given the low energy environment it grows it, the bacteria likely reproduces at a very slow rate, making the divergence over the last few decades very unlikely. That said, its probable that the strains discovered are probably some slight "modification" from the "wildtype" bacteria. As for what they eat in a clean room, there are a couple options. A) They might be driven mostly by alcohol metabolism and feeding off residual alcohol from the containimation. Or might likely B) they're feeding off the skin flakes coming off the "unshielded" areas of the workers, and that they are just very very slow.
- tokenadult 13y agoThe stated figure of less than 5% DNA commonality implies a really extensive divergence. Your reasoning is correct, but in case you'd like to edit, I'll point out that the article wrote, "The scientists determined that T. phoenicis shares less than 95 percent of its genetic sequence with its closest bacterial relative." The figures "less than 95 percent" and "less than 5%" imply very different degrees of similarity.
- bananacurve 13y agoVery niche lifeforms by definition are hard to cultivate in a lab and therefore go undocumented and there are loads of them, more than we even suspect probably.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt's likely a new kind of bacteria, because of the genetic difference. But that doesn't mean it hasn't made any additional adaptions for living in clean rooms specifically. Maybe it started out as a bacteria that could survive in an environment like that but has become even better at it since. Though the hostile environment of a clean room would keep population size relatively low and keep them from reproducing too often, compared to bacteria in normal conditions. So their evolution would be slower.
- ams6110 13y agoLife finds a way.
- riggins 13y agofor a second I thought this was indestructible bacteria accidentally brought back from a trip to outer-space and was momentarily terrified.
- kimonos 13y agoHmmm, I guess the title is a bit confusing. I was expecting a different article.. But thanks for the info though!
- snoonan 13y ago"Life form" subtilely connotes alien life, doesn't it? Especially when you put it in a sentence with NASA and Spacecraft. When they discover actual life on Mars and Europa, it's probably going to have a lot less impact due to the lack of self restraint in using desensitizing wording like this among journalists (Scientific American??)