9 ms·
While I tend to agree with you, the problem is we'll then have a lot less livestock to eat, and there will be a global food shortage. The house of cards is sta
by grecy 13y ago
While I tend to agree with you, the problem is we'll then have a lot less livestock to eat, and there will be a global food shortage.
The house of cards is stacked very, very high.
- rosser 13y agoIf even some of the land that was freed up by a fall-off in livestock production was instead used to grow plants, we'd actually have a food surplus, and a significant one. EDIT: "even some of"
- SwellJoe 13y agoNot to mention we'd reduce water usage dramatically in a lot of places where water use is one of the most pressing issues people face.
- bobbydavid 13y agoAnd don't forget air quality! Cow farts are a leading cause of greenhouse gases. Seriously.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 13y agoMany places which are unsuitable to crop production can be used for livestock production with very wide grazing. Most livestock production is done in hyper-concentrated confinement operations which take up negligible land space. For the wellbeing of the animals, the quality of the environment surrounding these sites, and the quality of the meat -- these confinement operations should be done away with. The space, though, is irrelevant. Eliminating livestock production increases food availability because the feed-conversion-ratio is between 4 and 40 (how many pounds of feed turn into 1 pound of cow,pig,chicken, etc). It is certainly not about space.
- geoka9 13y agoWhat about the space required to grow food for livestock?
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoLivestock can utilize food sources that we can't (pigs are the greatest food recyclers ever created), and they can graze in wastelands that we otherwise find difficult to make productive. India is primarily vegetarian ONLY because they have lots of land in which to grow things. Most other regions do not have so much grow-worthy land, and require a mix of farming and livestock to sustain their populations.
- maxerickson 13y agoThe U.S. devotes 80 million acres to corn production, corn that is mostly used as animal feed: http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/crops/corn/background.aspx http://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/crops/corn/background.aspx (ethanol has shifted that mostly some, yay!)
- randomdata 13y agoThat doesn't mean those 80 million acres are able to grow food humans can eat though. Not every year. For instance, on my farm, while our soil and climate is quite good for growing beans of many varieties, which are great for human consumption, you still need to maintain a rotation to maintain a viable farm. We've had to push cereals out of some of our land because it simply won't grow on their soils. That basically leaves corn as our only real rotation option. To add to that, corn is essentially worthless right now. Its market price is below what it costs to grow. I'd rather grow something I can make money from, but I don't know what that is. You just have to roll the dice and hope the price improves before you have to sell it. As an interesting aside, a neighbour of mine actually did try growing beans year after year, but he soon found himself out of business completely when disease started running rampant and his yields dropped to nothing. It was kind of sad to watch, and frightening to think what could be if we lose the animal markets.
- DanBC 13y agoWe already have a food surplus.
- wwweston 13y ago> we'll then have a lot less livestock to eat Even if that's true, while meat is tasty, it's a luxury, and arguably a step in the food chain that's a waste. If the entire industrial meat sector evaporated today, my guess is the biggest impact would be an economic disruption from large number of suddenly unemployed and businesses no longer buying services/products, rather than any kind of food shortage per se. But if we're talking about an antibiotic ban, the impacts wouldn't even reach that far. ABX don't enable production, they enable cheaper production. The most likely outcome isn't a serious collapse in supply, it's some combination of an increase in costs and modest reduction in supply.
- baddox 13y ago> Even if that's true, while meat is tasty, it's a luxury No more a luxury than, say, cancer treatments.
- rosser 13y agoIf you don't get your cancer treated, you die. If you don't eat meat, you don't eat meat.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoIf you live in Tibet or any other 4000+ meter environment where growing things is quite a bit more difficult, and you don't eat meat, you die. Say whatever you want about the Chinese, but the Tibetans do very much welcome the fresh vegetables that they can now get via better transport links and internal trade. I visited north Xinjiang once, and was quite over-exposed to meat so much that I was happy to get back to lower elevation lands where I could actually get some vegetables again.
- gohrt 13y agoThat's completely off-topic in a conversation that is obviously about large-scale ranches. Do those Tibetans use antibiotics to promote growth?
- contingencies 13y agoLess cheap industrial meat in the overfed west (particularly the US) is not equal to global food shortage.
- logicallee 13y agopumping them full of antibiotics under factory farm conditions seems like an awful hack anyway. it's like running eighty concurrent webserver processes and killing them 100 times per second round-robin because if you don't kill them constantly they will bring down the whole system. I mean maybe this setup "works" but aren't we really stretching the definition of that word?
- jff 13y ago> it's like running eighty concurrent webserver processes and killing them 100 times per second round-robin because if you don't kill them constantly they will bring down the whole system Ruby on Rails?
- maxerickson 13y agoA significant portion of the drugs used in feed are used to tip the digestive chemistry so that the feed is processed more efficiently. It isn't that big an effect, but it isn't really wildly crazy. There's a bunch of studies on feeding ionophores to graze animals (which I take as a demonstration of intent).
- edvinbesic 13y agoIt all seems like a vicious cycle of us discovering better ways to fight bacteria and feeding more and more people at the same time at the same price or less. Everything adapts bla bla bla. This could all be alleviated if we just took a step back as a society and took control of our own lives, food included. Maybe spending 20-30 minutes a day on growing your own supply (where applicable) isn't the worst thing in the world if it came down to it.
- maxerickson 13y agoThat's a very modest estimate of the time involved if you start talking about people growing a significant portion of the calories they need.
- edvinbesic 13y agoAbsolutely, but maybe there is more then one wrong here. Plus the nutrition you get from mass farming these days is less then desirable. It's not about quantity ,but quality as the cliche says. I understand this is not possible everywhere but I grew up on a pretty small suburban home that grew maybe 50% of its own vegetables outside of winter. Having moved to a heavy industrialized nation and moving that down to 0% I can see the difference in quality when eating mass produced food. Again, not everyone if willing or able to do this, but where applicable it should be encouraged and promoted instead of looked down upon as another hippy mentality blabedibla...
- jrochkind1 13y agoSo, which would you rather have, a lot less livestock to eat, or no way to treat bacterial infections? Oh, but guess what, you don't get to choose that trade-off -- you'll have a lot less livestock to eat either way. You can do it with or without entering the post-antibiotic era. (Or at any rate, a lot more expensive meat, which will likely result in a lot less of it, sure.) Fortunately, a lot less livestock to eat does not mean a global food shortage. People are quite capable of living with a lot less meat. It may be a global deliciousness shortage, because meat is delicious; but most people on the planet don't eat much meat already (cause they can't afford it). The OP is odd in suggesting "We have a few chances left to turn back the tide of resistance — but only a few, and not much room for mistakes. I hope we take them." -- without any hints as to what these chances are -- and then suggesting that if we don't take them, what we'll 'lose' is cheap meat from routine antibiotic use in livestock! But in fact, ceasing the use of routine antibiotics in livestock production -- before they become useless, because it'll be stopped when they become useless anyhow -- seems like the #1. What else you got?
- ekianjo 13y agoErm. People have been eating meat on a regular, frequent basis only very recently in History. 60 years ago it was meat just one a month or something. And people didn't just die off because they couldn't eat meat anymore.
- dnautics 13y agoThat's simply not true. Inuit have almost exclusively eaten meat for centuries. And there are parts of the world where agriculture and irrigation don't work and animals which can feed on scrub are the staple.
- ekianjo 13y agoWell, I was talking about Europe, mainly, and I assume in most countries of the developed word this was very much the same. I don't think Inuits have very much to do with the industrial production of meat we have nowadays, do they ?
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoActually, I believe the Inuit don't practice animal husbandry either; they mainly get their food from the ocean (mostly as meat).
- kayoone 13y agoIt is, at least in Europe. Ask your grandparents and they will tell you that they maybe ate meat once a week
- circlefavshape 13y agoWhat? I'm Irish and my grandparents ate meat, fish or eggs pretty much every day of their lives
- kayoone 13y agoWell not in the post WW2 germany my grandparents lived in.
- mistercow 13y agoIt's pretty doubtful that a reduction in livestock would lead to a food shortage. The amount of resources it takes to produce a calorie of meat is vastly larger than to produce a calorie of plant-based food.