7 ms·
Ah, an earth-shaking discovery made by a man in his fifties who was barely within academia [1]. Guess he won't get a Fields Medal for that. It seems like more
by joe_the_user 13y ago
Ah, an earth-shaking discovery made by a man in his fifties who was barely within academia [1]. Guess he won't get a Fields Medal for that.
It seems like more and more of the really big discoveries are being made by people who go off and work really hard on their own.
I vaguely recall a claim that the greatest discoveries aren't being made by people in their twenties any more just because math is so huge you need ten years of study to get to the bleeding edge.
Anyway, it seems to say something about academia.
Edit: Just to be clear I neither deny that academia can achieve great things nor do I claim that young people can't do similarly. Certainly, anyone halfway near academia probably see many flaws but that's for another post.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yitang_Zhang http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yitang_Zhang
- sillysaurus2 13y agoIt's easy to believe academia is fading when you categorically ignore all of its achievements.
- cscheid 13y agoJohn Baez has had an interesting series of posts about this on G+, but IIRC the gist of it is that even though both Grigori Perelman and Yitang Zhang were somewhat outside the mainstream of academia, their work was not. Both of them built on well-known theories and methods to prove their groundbreaking theorems. Perelman's primary tool, for example, was Ricci flows, which had been used at least 25 years before his work. (I know even less about Zhang's work)
- hyperbovine 13y agoI think the mathematical edifice is sound, but I can certainly see how being as divorced as possible from typical faculty responsibilities makes it easier to do original / groundbreaking research. Too many professors I know spend the bulk of their time attending to e-mail, grant writing, and traveling to give talks about work others have done. What little remaining time they have is often devoted to teaching. Some of them openly complain about how little time they have to actually think about things, while others seems to roll with it (being famous in your field is not a bad gig). Worse, the more successful you become the more these tertiary responsibilities encroach on your time. It's an open secret that the best-known professors in certain fields basically sign their names on the papers their postdocs and grad students write and that is more or less the extent of their research contribution. Cutting all this out, even if it means moving in with your mom in Moscow, could indeed be a viable option...
- cscheid 13y agoAgreed! What I'm trying to get at is that there's two ways you can think of academia: 1) roughly the set of people in traditional institutions, and 2) a basically unorganized set of people that happen to come together through working on related problems, in related ways. 2) is arguably the purer view of academia, and in that sense, it's as strong as ever. I agree with you that there's deep, serious problems with 1), and they have to do with Pournelle's law, (in the US) with Bayh-Dole, and a litany of other hard, nasty problems of social life. But, even in that case: is that any worse than other cultures?
- darkmighty 13y agoThe bare truth is this kind of mathematics (and, say, theoretical physics) is "hard" and requires a kit of thinking and thus a lot of time. Breakthroughs are named that for a reason -- they involve a distant, non-local solution. If you're doing your research on a topic you will most likely only focus on local improvements to the problems, simply because they lead to more steady results -- they are both safer and don't require you to pretty much think all the time about the problem at hand -- you can't really expect every mathematician to prefer that kind of work.
- Steuard 13y agoBut Zhang was teaching as a adjunct (or at least, a non-tenure-track instructor) before he made this breakthrough and skyrocketed (apparently) to full professor. Adjuncts generally have enormously less time for research than full time professors do (at least if they want to make a borderline living wage).
- icambron 13y agoI don't get it. The article talks not just about Zhang, but also about James Maynard, who is a postdoc and looks young, and is part of what you might call standard academia. His result is independent of Zhang's and is orders of magnitude stronger and is much easier to understand. Comes off pretty good for academia, really. Also, remember that most people on Earth aren't in academia, but most people still think. So the null hypothesis is that most innovations won't come from academia. But a huge amount of them do anyway, including even your counterexample, who--despite his economic struggles--was still a lecturer at a university. You could make a similar argument for young people. Our university system and our cultural obsession with youth deserve plenty of criticism, but the accusation that they're not making important discoveries isn't one of them, and it's totally unwarranted from this article.
- fspeech 13y agoAre you saying that Maynard independently tackled P(2) or that he independently came up with a better sieve? My take from reading the article is the latter.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- icambron 13y agoI guess I'm saying the latter too. Can you explain the former?
- fspeech 13y agoIt is my understanding from reading Maynard's preprint that he claims independence from Terrence Tao and the Polymath8 project. He doesn't claim independence from Zhang and neither should he, even if he uses a different approach. His result may well turn out to be important or more important but Zhang's result is clearly earlier and well-known. My differentiation is that number theorists are looking for better sieves all the time. Zhang's work was a breakthrough in bringing the prime gap from infinity to a finite number. It is not surprising that better sieves could bring the gap a lot closer.
- rrrrtttt 13y agoEstablished scientists stop producing groundbreaking results because of tenure. Once you have tenure, the biggest incentive to work hard goes away; it's simple economics. (Hence "mathematics is a young man's game".)
- adiM 13y agoFor most people in academia, the incentive to work hard is not the fear to get fired, but the intrinsic satisfaction of working on a certain class of problems. Tenure does not take that intrinsic value away.
- pmiller2 13y agoI take it you've never heard the term "6 year job interview"? :)
- thedufer 13y agoPretty sure that applies to the bullshit you have to do that isn't research. I'd be surprised to find a math professor who isn't there because he/she enjoys studying math - there just aren't any other good reasons to do it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 13y agoYou might want to look into what "groundbreaking" entails because excited news articles lead nowhere all the damn time. Tenure exists to escape people from the "3 papers a year" BS which means you get a neverending stream of minor refinements and very little thorough investigation.
- GigabyteCoin 13y ago> an earth-shaking discovery made by a man in his fifties who was barely within academia It's stories like these that make me jump with joy inside every time I think about the wonder that is the internet and the possibilities that creates for us as a human race. The possibility that exists by having things like free 2,000 book encylcopedias (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia%3ASize_of_Wikipedia#Hard_copy_size http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia%3ASize_of_Wikipedia#H...) at the fingertips of nearly every human on earth is just mind boggling. I won't be surprised if Joe Average discovers the cure for Cancer tomorrow. Or AIDS. Or our fossil fuel addiction. In fact, I expect those things to happen sooner than most of us might think.
- Ar-Curunir 13y agoNah, I don't think the average person will discover the cure to cancer. While access to freely available knowledge is increasing, this knowledge is mostly broad, not deep. So we can have information on a lot of topics, but these topics aren't covered in very much depth. Also keep in mind that Zhang was very much within the fold of academia when he discovered the 70 million upper bound on the separation of primes.
- thaumasiotes 13y ago> While access to freely available knowledge is increasing, this knowledge is mostly broad, not deep. So we can have information on a lot of topics, but these topics aren't covered in very much depth. This has bothered me quite a bit. I want to go to wikipedia and be able to find, to use Feynman's term, a map of the cat. I don't understand why it's not there.
- crassus 13y agoPrecisely the reason to push for free and open academic journals that anybody can read.
- rimantas 13y agoI expect nothing like this will ever happen. You underestimate effort and amount of work (and training) needed for such breakthroughs. Also the cost of the research. I am afraid most of the low hanging fruits are already gone. You don't find cure for cancer just by reading a scientific journal over the evening tea and then dreaming up the formula.
- thaumasiotes 13y ago> I vaguely recall a claim that the greatest discoveries aren't being made by people in their twenties any more just because math is so huge you need ten years of study to get to the bleeding edge. This depends heavily on what you mean. Of course there are areas of math requiring ten (or more) years of study before you can work in them. However... - In theory, all high school graduates have studied math for at least twelve years. - There are many, many problems on "the bleeding edge" of mathematics, in the sense that no one can solve them, but which can be stated in terms an algebra student would have no trouble understanding. Further, there are many mathematical techniques which are "advanced" in the sense that they are never taught in school, but are "simple" in the sense that the algebra student I mentioned earlier would have no trouble following a proof using them. If you're interested, try reading through the archives of Tanya Khovanova's blog; she has plenty of examples of IMO problems and special Soviet math exam problems for Jews.
- gizmo686 13y agoThe difficulty with proving bleeding edge results in mathematics is normally not that the question is particularly advanced or difficult to understand, but rather that if it had an easy solution, then it would likely have been solved by now. The only times I can think of where this is not the case is after a major, yet easy to understand, discovery makes a lot of formerly hard problem easy, or a field of mathematics that is either young enough, or uninteresting enough that it has not yet had significant time devoted to it.
- atmosx 13y agoBeing barely within academia today means having access to all the papers released along with many blog posts by PhD's who analyze the results and repercussions of a paper or a discovery. The only example of out-of-academia, in the real sense, was Ramanujan[1] who was a sort of pure genius out of nowhere and was able to pull out formulas like this [2]. He wasn't constrict by the rigorous need for proof that Europeans were looking in order to accept any discovery for being true. De Sautoy[3] states that Ramanujan non-formal (western-style) education kept him away from European mathematical achievements and but also away from European fears of inability to attack specific problems (i.e. like Riemann's Hypothesis for example[4]) and that was a good thing. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan [2] http://bit.ly/1dh0E5w http://bit.ly/1dh0E5w (Google image) [3] http://plus.maths.org/content/music-primes http://plus.maths.org/content/music-primes [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_hypothesis
- dominotw 13y agoAh yes. Andrew wiles preferred to work on his own and he 'disappeared' for years before he came up with his proof.