4 ms·
"wah wah wah corporations are bad, growth is bad" Corporations and economic growth are directly responsible for the possibility that this discussion is happeni
by raverbashing 13y ago
"wah wah wah corporations are bad, growth is bad"
Corporations and economic growth are directly responsible for the possibility that this discussion is happening: the internet, cheap and powerful computers, etc
Or even better: https://twitter.com/Kasparov63/status/391943773963304960 https://twitter.com/Kasparov63/status/391943773963304960
- atmosx 13y agoYour comment reminds me of this awesome article by the WSJ[1]. The funny thing is that, it's so out of reality that I wouldn't even bother arguing. See the miners filled lawsuits against the company, because weren't for capitalism their life and working conditions would have avoided a life-threatening situation. But then again depends what you wanna do: Find the truth or find evidence - even risking ridicule - to support your beliefs. [1] http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052748703673604575550322091167574 http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405274870367360...
- VikingCoder 13y ago"wah wah wah monarchy is bad, empire is bad" The British government is directly responsible for the possibility that this discussion of "taxation without representation" is happening; colonization, trade, etc. Sometimes when you stand on the shoulders of giants, you realize that the old ways were lousy. America as it is today wouldn't exist without slavery and Native American genocide. I'm not comparing Capitalism to Genocide, but I am saying the form of argument you used is ridiculous, because I can use the same argument to defend awful things. If you stop and listen for one minute, people like me are saying, "Maybe the current system is TOO excessive, and should be reigned in, in some ways." We think laws should help fight the excesses of unchecked capitalism. We're not proposing the "share everything" that Kasparov ridicules, and posing our argument that way is an absurd straw man. That said, I don't represent a united front of people who believe identically to me, but your argument is so absurd that I think it might practically be targeted at only a tiny minority of people currently saying anything negative about corporations and our current means of economic growth.
- raverbashing 13y ago"but I am saying the form of argument you used is ridiculous, because I can use the same argument to defend awful things." Except you just used a straw man. Of course it's ridiculous then. "America as it is today wouldn't exist without slavery and Native American genocide." Of course not. But those things went away, and the USA is still there. But you can't have the internet without equipment, without servers built by guess who? Corporations. Take that away: no internet.
- dasil003 13y ago> But you can't have the internet without equipment, without servers built by guess who? Corporations. Take that away: no internet. Now you're the one strawmanning by painting it as corporations existing or not existing. It's not a binary issue. A corporation is just an organization of people with a specific legal status. There will always be organizations of people. However, I don't think we need to confer the rights of personhood to a corporation even though they don't have the same responsibilities or vulnerabilities. Similarly, it doesn't need to be the case that corporations should be able to extract value from the commons at the expense of the poor so that the privileged upper-middle class can have the cheapest possible gadgets. It is definitely possible to draw a better line between individual freedom and the wholesale rape of the environment. For starters, those things aren't represented in GDP, and so it's of no real concern to those in power. What gets measured gets improved.
- raverbashing 13y ago"However, I don't think we need to confer the rights of personhood to a corporation even though they don't have the same responsibilities or vulnerabilities. Similarly, it doesn't need to be the case that corporations should be able to extract value from the commons at the expense of the poor so that the privileged upper-middle class can have the cheapest possible gadgets." Good, I agree with that. But the issue with cheap gadgets goes both ways. Chinese factories allow people in India and other 3rd world countries to have a cheap (read: affordable) mobile phone. Yes, they could pay more and give better conditions, the profit gains coming from economies of scale would still be there.
- karlshea 13y agoYou are of course totally right, it wouldn't be possible. However it is possible to have large corporations and growth but also do it in a responsible manner. It won't be an overnight fix but there are a lot of smart people in this world that could make it work. And of course lots of the solutions to the problems are also vilified (nuclear is a big one) so it isn't going to be easy. But I think the general point being made shouldn't be dismissed entirely. They are right about many of the "solutions" that are presented being sort of a waste of time, intended only to make people feel better about themselves without making any real progress towards fixing the problem.
- raverbashing 13y agoThanks, yes, corporations do make excesses and yes, it's possible to do it responsibly. Oh yes, most of the "personal solutions" are not really helpful (well, in a way they are, but it ends up happening over time, like using CFLs instead of incandescent lighting, etc)
- dalek_cannes 13y agoLet us take iPhone-carrying anti-corporate protesters. Should we attribute the iPhone to 'Apple Corporation' and shun it, or to the individuals -- designers, engineers, accountants and managers -- who made happen? Corporations are a means of bringing these people together to work in a coordinated manner. I don't think anybody (except communists) says that people with skills working together for financial gain is a bad thing. It's the prevailing model of doing that people are objecting to. It has no safeguards against corruption.
- djrobstep 13y agoThat's right kids: Any reform of the status quo is literally communism.
- hawleyal 13y agoAnd the mass consumption and pollution of the earth. No big deal.
- informatimago 13y agoSure. But there may be a better way: http://thevenusproject.org http://thevenusproject.org
- eitally 13y agoThe specific reason for the Apple supply chain factory worker abuses mentioned everywhere is BECAUSE apply has depressed their supply chain so much and forced such high velocity execution on their orders. Without captive labor, it's nearly impossible for anyone to meet the ridiculously spiky demand.