14 ms·
Of course Yasser Arafat was killed. I don't think anyone sane ever thought otherwise considering the circumstances... Same goes for Slobodan Milosevic... The
by Mikeb85 13y ago
Of course Yasser Arafat was killed. I don't think anyone sane ever thought otherwise considering the circumstances... Same goes for Slobodan Milosevic... There likely are others, but they don't come to mind at the moment.
Love the anonymous downvote for saying something unpopular politically, but more than likely factually correct.
Dangerous political prisoners/personalities dying in mysterious circumstances at opportune times is not coincidence. The US reign death from above via remote controlled drones and this isn't contested, yet thinking that very suspicious deaths at expedient times are likely assassinations is some crazy conspiracy theory...
- gvkv 13y agoEven if true, why do you assume it was the US? There are many actors with the willingness, capability and motivation.
- Mikeb85 13y agoI don't assume the US (merely using it as an example when we question the possibility of conspiracy theories being true). Arafat could have been killed by other (more radical) Muslims, by the Israelis, by any number of people (though the method suggests a government was probably involved). Milosevic was likely killed by some western government, based on circumstance (being in custody at the Hague), and the fact that he revealed that people were trying to kill him before it happened...
- anigbrowl 13y agothe fact that he revealed that people were trying to kill him He claimed people were trying to kill him. Revealed implies that this claim has been proven as fact, which it certainly has not. Suppose I claim that people are trying to kill me. Have I revealed a truth, or is it possible that I'm making things up?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- moocowduckquack 13y ago<ignore reason=probably not true>There aren't many with the capability.</ignore> Polonium has no stable isotopes and is naturally so rare that the nuclear industry synthesises it from bisimuth using neutron beams in specialist nuclear reactors. <ignore reason=probably not true>Also, apart from triggers for nukes and poisoning dissidents, it has very few uses.</ignore>
- KMag 13y agoBut consumer anti-static brushes (http://www.amazon.com/Static-Master-Brush-1-Inch/dp/B0000AE67S http://www.amazon.com/Static-Master-Brush-1-Inch/dp/B0000AE6...), industrial anti-static coatings, industrial coating thickness measurement, and oil well inspection are a few of its uses.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI didn't realise it was used so widely. I just read this about the brushes - http://www.amateurphotographer.co.uk/photo-news/538049/polonium-210-present-in-darkroom-gadget http://www.amateurphotographer.co.uk/photo-news/538049/polon...
- jessedhillon 13y agoI don't understand who/what your markup is meant for? Are you claiming that things you're writing are probably not true and should be ignored? Then why are you writing them? This seems a little too clever.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI put the markup in after it was pointed out I was probably talking bollocks there. I didn't want to delete the wrong info as that would make the comment after make no sense, so I did that instead.
- jdmitch 13y agoI think a lot of people may agree that "of course he was killed," but it is particularly interesting because of the poison used (polonium-210) which has only been confirmed in one other poisoning case, that of Alexander Litvinenko, the Russian dissident. Secondly, it is of interest because Arafat's movements and those he had contact with were very limited around the time that he fell ill, so it raises interesting questions about who could have done it. Hopefully this won't have a negative impact on ongoing peace negotiations.
- mcantelon 13y agoThe IDF had him more or less confined to a small area, IIRC.
- rooshdi 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mukataa#Arafat.27s_compound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mukataa#Arafat.27s_compound
- eli 13y agoHere's a really interesting long form article on Litvinenko's death and the mechanics of how poisoning via Polonium works: https://www.readmatter.com/a/bad-blood-the-life-and-death-of-alexander-litvinenko/ https://www.readmatter.com/a/bad-blood-the-life-and-death-of... The substance has a very short half life, which suggests only people with access to a nuclear reactor could have created it.
- api 13y agoThe phrase "conspiracy theory" has been used to great effect to silence criticism and shut down real investigative journalism. It's a simple guilt by association technique: if you think anything other than the official line, then you are engaging in "conspiracy theory" which means you are like those people who think the queen of England is a reptile. We are actually in worse shape than Soviet Russia. In the USSR, educated people knew that quite a bit of what was in Pravda was a lie. In the West, an attitude of malfeasance-denialism has been encouraged in the educated and upper crust elements of society to the point that erudite people tend to almost deny the existence of elite deviance or official criminality. Given the higher-educated demographic of HN, you can see it around here. Just try arguing that, say, widespread financial shenanigans have anything other than prosaic and innocent explanations.
- rdtsc 13y agoYou know it is sad. I remember laughing at people yelling how the government is spying on everyone. In the end they ended up having the last laugh. These are rather sad times when what we thought crazy conspiracy loonies from yesterday seem to be right today. And yeah "conspiracy theorist" is like "terrorist" it can be used to discredit someone very quickly.
- api 13y agoA conspiracy theorist seems to be an investigative journalist or a social critic with poor epistemology. I have noticed over the years that the concretes reported upon and the trends pointed out by conspiracy theorists -- even some of the wackier ones -- have a pretty good hit rate. The paranoid are often very perceptive. It's in the theory department that they fall down, imagining wild and unlikely scenarios to account for things that boil down to simple elite deviance, oligarchy, political opportunism, and corruption. Most of them also have a political, religious, or ethnic bone to pick and try to ascribe all the wrongs of the world to some hated group. But as I said... they're often right about the concretes. It's sad times we live in when unstable nutjobs are the only ones pointing out our obvious descent toward naked plutocratic oligarchy and gangster-statism. Well nutjobs and comedians... what was that quote about the state of a society when only comedians can tell the truth?
- eli 13y agoYou may be getting downvotes because of your tone. I'm sure there are people who previously (and perhaps still) believe that Arafat was not killed. It's not very nice to suggest they are not sane.
- Mikeb85 13y agoYou're right, a little hyperbolic perhaps...
- simias 13y agoYou're being downvoted because you don't back your facts up with any source. You're not contributing anything to the discussion. It's like saying "of course the moon landing is/isn't a hoax, I don't think anyone sane ever thought otherwise considering the circumstances...". It says nothing. Stating something as a fact doesn't make it a fact. For the record I have absolutely no agenda here and I must say I have absolutely no opinion on the subject at hand (nor do I think it belongs on the frontpage of HN, but that's an other subject).
- joe_the_user 13y agoIsn't the source a detailed and convincing report claiming that he died of Polonium poisoning? Sure the comment doesn't have further facts, just a broad gesture to the context. But hey, when a situation has been established, you comment on it.
- anigbrowl 13y agoThis is crazy thinking. Famous people do typically have access to better medical care, through personal wealth or the goodwill of their supporters, but you seem to think that power/celebrity confers immunity from disease and misadventure. It lowers the risk, is all. This does not mean I disagree with the findings of this report, not least because I haven't read it yet. It's entirely plausible that Arafat could have been murdered...but considering that he was a thorn in Israel's side for around 40 years, you're in no position to talk about him dying at an opportune time. I'm sure there were people who wanted to assassinate him over the last several decades. For the last 2 years of his life he was effectively under house arrest by the Israeli army, so why wait 2? Is there something terribly unusual about 75-year old men dying? Hardly. It's certainly possible that he was assassinated, but by your logic we should also be investigating the death of counterculture icon Lou Reed, who was a mere 71. Also it's rain, not reign.
- nl 13y agoOf course Yasser Arafat was killed. It certainly seems more likely today than yesterday. But who killed him? It almost certainly wasn't the Israelis or the US - they liked the fact that they could mostly deal with Arafat, and he'd keep more radical Palestinian elements under control. Milosevic.. why would anyone bother killing him? He was going to be locked away for life, and there wasn't anyone he could really blame, so I can't see what the motive would be? Love the anonymous downvote for saying something unpopular politically, but more than likely factually correct. That's the HN way of saying "eeee it's not fair I'm being downvoted. Someone vote me up". I don't see you complaining about the anonymous up votes.
- pjbrow 13y agoIt's simply incorrect to say that Arafat kept the radicals under control - there was clear evidence that he was involved with the militant / terrorist wing of his political party, Fateh (the Al-Aqusa Martyrs Brigades), which carried out a great many suicide bombings. I won't repeat myself (my theory is above), but if you understand the political circumstances at the time, Arafat was in fact the last remaining major road block to a grand bargain that Sharon was moving heaven and earth to get done. There were very compelling reasons to knock him off.
- nl 13y agoArafat's relationship with al-Aqsa was complicated. It is true that Fatah was paying al-Aqsa, but it's also true that Fatah was trying to get al-Aqsa to stop attacks[1] Around the time of his death al-Aqsa was seeking to cut links with Arafat[2]. To claim that Sharon was trying to cut any kind of deal with the Palestinians is... unusual. (For those not aware, it was former Israeli PM Aiel Sharon's visit to the Moslem area of Temple Mount in Jerusalem that sparked the second intifāḍah[3] (prior to him becoming PM). The al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade is named after this incident). Additionally, Arafat's Fatah group was seen as the one group strong enough to keep Hamas controlled. The al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade was a problem for Israel, but it was seen as much less of a problem than Hamas. Subsequent events would show this view was probably correct: When Abbas took control of Fatah it quickly lost control of Gaza to Hamas, and the Israelis have consistently struggled to find a successful approach to dealing with Hamas in Gaza (eg, they later fought a fairly unsuccessful war to try to control Hamas in Gaza). Edit: Although I disagree with you, I think you do make some good points. You were downvoted when I wrote this, so I have upvoted you. [1] http://books.google.com.au/books?id=CGiot772MSEC&pg=PA77&dq=Al-Aqsa+Martyrs%27+Brigades&sig=tZif7ASqqEZYer5I5Q_ubsrjSO0&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=Al-Aqsa%20Martyrs'%20Brigades&f=false http://books.google.com.au/books?id=CGiot772MSEC&pg=PA77&dq=... [2] http://www.worldtribune.com/worldtribune/WTARC/2004/me_palestinians_07_12.html http://www.worldtribune.com/worldtribune/WTARC/2004/me_pales... [3] http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/538892/Ariel-Sharon/288104/The-launch-of-a-political-career http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/538892/Ariel-Sharo...
- rockyleal 13y ago>There likely are others, but they don't come to mind at the moment. Chavez
- Mikeb85 13y agoWhile it's certainly possible, it seems somewhat less likely. He was sick for a few years, and his decline seemed much more gradual. Not saying it's not possible, but seems less likely IMO.
- pjbrow 13y agoAt the risk of getting down voted on what is an emotional issue for a lot of people, here's my (quite realist) view. I was living in the West Bank when Arafat died, and I knew a bunch of people who worked in his compound. He got very sick, very quickly. The doctors around him were baffled by the steep decline, which is why he was flown to France just before he died. I acknowledge that my theory on the issue is purely circumstantial, but a good place to start with these things is "qui bono?". Ariel Sharon (and Israel, and in my view, everyone) had a lot to gain by Arafat's death. Whatever you think of the nastiness that he'd been involved in, Sharon was a remarkable human - Israelis aren't given to overstatement and they called him the "Lion of God". Sharon was clearly making a dash for a grand bargain, and it's obvious that the "bulldozer" (another of his nicknames) wasn't letting anything get in his way. By pure force of will, he withdrew Israel from Gaza (an absolutely wrenching move for Israel to make), and then left Likud to establish Kadimah so that he could move forward without blockage from the right wing radicals in his old party. In a very short time frame, Sharon bent a famously fractious Israeli parliament into a position to make a grand bargain that would stick - the last major road block to a bargain was Arafat. Israel had had a real go at negotiating with Arafat with Bill Clinton at Camp David. It didn't work out. Of course, there are a bunch of conflicting opinions on who's to blame for the breakdown in talks, but the basic, unarguable outcome was that Arafat wasn't willing to take Israel's best offer. Sharon obviously knew that, and also knew that Arafat's successor was going to be the comparatively mild mannered Abbas, who Sharon was already dealing with constructively. I think Sharon basically decided that, given Arafat's previous form, he was a very high risk as a grand bargain spoiler - Arafat's moral authority with the Palestinian population remained high. So, in the absence of any other option (since Arafat was essentially a dictator), good night Arafat. If you think that Sharon wasn't capable of something that cold, take a look at his conduct in the massacre at Sabra and Shatila in Lebanon (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabra_and_Shatila_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabra_and_Shatila_massacre). Sharon had a stroke shortly thereafter, and with that, arguably the only person capable of cutting the gordian knot in the medium term was out of the picture. Gotta love ash-sharq al-awsat.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- hayksaakian 13y agoWhile I agree with you in principal, your comment sounds a lot like the "no true scotsman" fallacy, which could be a source of the downvotes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman
- jpatokal 13y agoWell, it's worth noting that the one known time Israel did assassinate a PLO leader, they used the rather less subtle method of sending in a Mossad hit squad to shoot him: http://www.france24.com/en/20121101-israel-admits-responsibility-1988-murder-plo-deputy-arafat-abu-jihad-tunis-palestine http://www.france24.com/en/20121101-israel-admits-responsibi...
- e40 13y agoI don't think anyone sane ever thought otherwise This got the downvote for me. It means anyone that disagrees with you is insane, and that's a bad place to start.