13 ms·
Google announces uProxy
- guidopallemans 13y agowhy should I trust google for an application that would enhance my internet privacy?
- binarymax 13y agoPrivacy is not mentioned at all in the article. This is about bypassing censorship.
- gbrindisi 13y agoWhat if censorship happens in USA?
- JonSkeptic 13y ago>What if censorship happens in USA? Then people who who use a Google proxy to bypass it get picked up by the FBI. It's not like Google doesn't give the government data hand over fist.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoExcept the bit that does mention it? "The service has yet to launch, but its creators -- the University of Washington and Brave New Software -- have opened a restricted beta for select, technically adept users to make it as "secure, private, and robust" as possible."
- venomsnake 13y agoBypassing censorship without privacy is just good way to invite someone knocking on the door if you are interesting for the authorities.
- adventured 13y agoIt's not a Google product.
- mostafah 13y agoIt will be very interesting for us living in Iran. We have a lot of friends abroad.
- venomsnake 13y agoDoubt that it will help a lot - metadata is valuable. Sometimes the fact that you are communicating with someone is as damning as the communication itself. Unless the addon is really sneaky and confirmed by a lot of people chances are it will still be detectable by DPI. And you have the problem of the addon traversing the state firewall in the first place. And you need secure OOB way to transport password anyway. From what I see you need secure way to transport keys and don't minding to raise a few red flags with the authorities. In that case just rent micro instance with any out of country cloud provider you have access to and ssh tunnel trough it.
- nfm 13y agoOfficial links: http://googleblog.blogspot.com.au/2013/10/new-free-expression-tools-from-google.html http://googleblog.blogspot.com.au/2013/10/new-free-expressio... http://uproxy.org/ http://uproxy.org/
- andyjohnson0 13y agoMuch more useful than the engadget link. Thanks!
- StavrosK 13y agoWhy isn't there a link to this from the Engadget article? That is useless and shoddy. Do they not know how the internet works, or have a single shred of common sense?
- jessaustin 13y agoIt's almost as if they care more about traffic than informing their readers.
- StavrosK 13y agoInforming their readers is their traffic.
- amiramir 13y agoThanks. I like some of the other initiatives listed there. Digital Attack Map is interesting to peruse though the graphics could be a bit clearer.
- gbrindisi 13y agoSorry Google, I can't really trust you anymore.
- simfoo 13y agoOpen source + p2p. Why wouldn't you trust it?
- _wmd 13y agoAutomatic updates?
- mhaymo 13y agoSo turn them off. You can do that in Firefox, I don't know about Chrome, but if you're using that then you already are trusting Google just as much as if you use this extension.
- idlewan 13y agoIt's not open source until we can have the source. The old repo (https://github.com/UWNetworksLab/uproxy-common https://github.com/UWNetworksLab/uproxy-common) mentions the new repo, which is hidden / not available. So, not yet open source. So, still closed source, for now.
- tombrossman 13y agoFast forward a year, HN headline: "Google shutting down uProxy". It looks interesting and I'm sure some number of people will find it useful while it lasts.
- andyjohnson0 13y agoHow exactly could they shut it down? Its a client-side browser extension that uses peer-to-peer connections. It doesn't run on any of Google's infrastructure. I'm getting a bit tired of seeing this comment every time Google release a new product. I understand that people think they're being insightful in saying this, but they're really not.
- dpd126 13y agoFurthermore, it's not even created by Google directly: > "uProxy has been developed at the University of Washington, with help from Brave New Software. The project was seeded by Google Ideas."
- Shish2k 13y agoOk, to rephrase for the pedant: "Google pulls core developers off of uProxy; without leadership, multiple incompatible forks form and quickly die" (Not saying that that will happen, just clarifying what I presume is the grandparent's point)
- andyjohnson0 13y agoI'm not a pedant. And the core developers work for the University of Washington and Brave New Software, not Google. [1]. [1] http://googleblog.blogspot.com.au/2013/10/new-free-expression-tools-from-google.html http://googleblog.blogspot.com.au/2013/10/new-free-expressio...
- ma2rten 13y agoI knew that this was going to be a comment before I even opened clicked on the link or looked at the comments. Yes, Google shouldn't have shut down Reader and now get over it.
- shazow 13y agoWhile we're speculating about trust and such, the video mentions that it's a browser extension which connects to a trusted peer and uses the peer as a proxy. This leads me to believe that, 1. Since it's a normal browser extension, the source will be readable and verifiable. 2. It probably uses WebRTC. It seems Google merely plays an incubator role here for the authors. Either way, I don't see much trust issues that other comments are complaining about. Looking forward to trying this out when it's released.
- toyg 13y ago> the source will be readable and verifiable. that's all well and good, but if it's executed by an unverifiable binary build of Chrome (i.e. the one distributed by Google), it's not worth much. For what you know, Chrome might just detect the extension is installed and silently eavesdrop on all its calls. If this extension will work as-is on third-party Chromium builds compiled from public sources, then yeah, it can be trusted on those builds.
- lwf 13y agoYou say that like it probably won't. They state in the FAQ that it will work on FF and Chrome; there's no reason to think it won't work on Chromium as well.
- toyg 13y agoNo, I say that from a paranoia perspective. Any security measure is only as strong as its weakest link.
- ye 13y agoWe actually don't know with 100% certainty that Chrome runs the code that we see. Considering Google is forced to comply with NSA's shit (and other agencies in their respective countries), I wouldn't trust my life to this extension.
- gbin 13y ago
- draugadrotten 13y ago> "If someone from a country with limited internet access installs uProxy, they can get a friend from the US to authorize them to surf the open web using their connection. " In effect, they would also be sending all their sensitive, potentially illegal traffic to be read and copied by the american NSA agency. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_%28surveillance_program%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_%28surveillance_program%2... People proxying illegal traffic through the USA would immediately be "on file" in the US registered as dissidents, criminals, and potential spies vulnerable to blackmail from US agencies. I can see CIA looking at how their propaganda are affecting foreign nations by seeing who reads it from where. Foreign nations could even see proxying subversive traffic through the USA as being a worse crime than the subversive traffic itself. Think twice about using this.
- Grue3 13y agoWhy would somebody who lives outside of USA care about US agencies? All I want is to bypass my own country's censorship.
- nyrina 13y agoI don't think you care a lot, but I bet your friend, that is allowing you to use his network, loves your bomb search results on his IP.
- anon1385 13y agoBecause non-Americans still have to worry about being abducted off the street and tortured by American agents: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khaled_El-Masri https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khaled_El-Masri
- adventured 13y agoIt's a valid issue, in that it's vile the way the US Government sometimes behaves, but that is not a realistic concern for 99.999999% of the world population.
- gohwell 13y agoWhat about corporate firewalls?
- nakedrobot2 13y agoNice! So I can use uProxy to access the Google Play store to buy a Nexus phone? ("Sorry, not available in your country") Thanks Google :-)
- ygra 13y agoAnd people in Germany can finally watch Youtube music videos ;-)
- sentenza 13y agoI wonder how many of my compatriots actually live with those restrictions and how many find ways to circumvent them. By blocking so many Youtube videos, GEMA has done a huge service to internet literacy in Germany. It still surprises me that, every now and then, I overhear complete laypeople discuss among themselves the setting up of proxy servers.
- ygra 13y agoI find myself to be too lazy to circumvent them, even though I know how. I just close the tab and move on. Oftentimes there are better ways to spend my time than thath anyway. But at least among people I know there are few who know what a proxy is and how it helps them in that regard. (It also should be noted that GEMA isn't alone to blame there; Youtube basically wanted the rights to store and distribute that content for free or close to, which doesn't work well if GEMA wants compensation.)
- jsilence 13y ago(It should also be noted that the GEMA distribution scheme is fundamentally flawed and that it overproportionally compensates well established "big" artists while neglecting young and upcoming artists. But that is another story)
- svantana 13y agoRemains only to figure out how to route the physical delivery via a US address... anyone know of such a service? I'd find that pretty useful actually. A lot of stuff on e.g. Amazon is only available for delivery to the US.
- knob 13y agoI wouldn't trust Google with this. Fuck no. Why don't they help develop the Tor plugin? Why don't the open up a whole bunch of Tor nodes? Wait... scratch that last one. This is just bad.
- esteth 13y agoBecause it appears to be open source and peer to peer, so you don't need to trust Google at all?
- nwh 13y agoOpen source does not mean secure. Half the time nobody even reads the source, let alone compares the binaries to the repository.
- esteth 13y agoIt's a chrome extension, so the source you see is the code executed by your browser.
- nwh 13y agoThat wasn't my point. Have you ever read the source of the extensions you have installed? No. If everybody has that mentality then nothing gets "checked" and malicious code makes it though.
- rryan 13y agoI have read the source of extensions I've installed.
- Dylan16807 13y agoAnd are you a crypto expert?
- tensafefrogs 13y ago
- saljam 13y agoThis sounds good. But how is it better than just installing Tor?
- fiatjaf 13y ago"just"? Man, normal people can't install Tor. It is not that it is difficult for them, it is impossible. Also, this solves a problem slighlty different from what Tor solves, in my opinion.
- saljam 13y agoFair point. They make an effort with the Browser Bundle but I just tried it and it broke on the second run... Now I want to write a Tor compatible client that 'just works'. Just one static binary that implements the proxy. It embeds a static firefox binary and a prepared profile, which gets extracted into a visible location so the user can delete it if desired. Basically minimize its dependence on the environment as much as possible.
- iSnow 13y agoSlackers rejoice! No way to block you from surfing porn at work anymore :)
- venomsnake 13y agoBecause the slackers that surf porn at work have no idea how to bring a tablet to work loaded with porn.
- wil421 13y agoSo is this kinda of like Tor but without the anonymity and only one peer to connect to?
- parfe 13y agoI see uProxy as giving a friend my wireless network password. I'd compare a Tor exit node to printing the network password on my mailbox or posting it to craigslist. I regularly share my wireless network access with friends without thinking, while running a tor exit node/publishing my network password gives me serious liability concerns.
- r0h1n 13y agoAnother "free" Google service that blinds lay people from objectively considering the cost vs. benefits of online privacy/anonymity (since "free" tends to make us act irrationally). Instead, consider paying the equivalent of a cup or two of coffee and buy yourself a real VPN subscription. Even if you must get yourself a free VPN, consider someone other than Google, a company that already has so much data on your digital lives.
- StavrosK 13y agoDid you read the article? It's not a Google service. Why buy a "real" VPN subscription instead of running things through a friend, which is way more decentralized and harder to surveil en masse?
- r0h1n 13y agoI did. I also went to the uProxy site which mentions it was seeded by Google Ideas. Also, >> One of the ways uProxy connects you through your friends, is by connecting to existing chat networks, such as Facebook or Google Hangouts. uProxy can use a chat network to discover new friends and setup peer-to-peer proxying from your friends. If a user does so, then the chat network can see that the user has uProxy installed. A user's chat contacts may also see this. So Google funded uProxy; it will be able to see who your VPN "host" is via Google Hangouts; and lastly it controls one of the two browsers on which this plugin runs, Chrome. That's too much Google for me, personally.
- lallysingh 13y ago.. So don't use it on hangouts and run it on Firefox. Scan the source for any "call home code."
- r0h1n 13y agoThis isn't about me. I already use a different VPN. I don't use Hangouts or Google+. Those rare Google services I do use, I use sparingly. My point was the average Internet Joe or Jane needs to look beyond "free" services and be willing to spend some money buying better alternatives. One of the reasons we're all so compromised on the Internet today is our collective blindness towards the hidden "costs" of free services.
- lispm 13y agoSo US government employees could install it to read Snowden's documents? Then the NSA gets a list of those who do?
- venomsnake 13y agoI have a better idea - bring the cost of project loon balloons really low (order of magnitude below the price of the rockets needed to shoot them) and just flood the censoring country sky with them. The country will either have to bankrupt itself or open its internet.
- StavrosK 13y agoFrom a cursory reading, 70% of the comments in here are people who came straight to this page to say "I don't trust Google/why wouldn't they do <something else>/Google will just shut this down". Can we stop with the kneejerk reactions? This is a p2p browser extension, doesn't run through Google, wasn't developed by Google, the only involvement Google had was maybe fund it. Are we going to be getting these comments any time Google is mentioned from now on?
- jstalin 13y ago...and how many of these people's own government are doing the same thing as the NSA? I abhor what the NSA is going, but goodness, I bet 90% of the nation's governments do the same thing.
- ScottWhigham 13y agoAre we going to be getting these comments any time Google is mentioned from now on? Yes, and I think rightly so. What evidence do you have that this will not happen? None - which is the less evidence that the people saying it will happen have. Google has earned that rep and, until 1-3 years have gone in which they've not done something like that, people will continue to bring it up.
- StavrosK 13y ago> What evidence do you have that this will not happen? "This" being "shut it down"? My evidence is that this is a third-party extension, developed by a third party and doesn't touch Google's infrastructure at all. They couldn't shut it down if they wanted to. The most they could do would be to cut its funding, but it's still open source.
- gibwell 13y agoThe point is that Google was once held in high esteem because it acted in an unusually trustworthy way for a large corporation. Almost everything they were fundamentally trusted on has turned out to be a betrayal. It is right and natural to question and distrust them until they have reestablished trust, which is likely to be a long process. You will notice that as well as the appropriate distrust, there are also comments from people including yourself who have examined the proxy and determined that Google's trustworthiness is irrelevant to the trustworthiness of the proxy. This is exactly how it should work. People are right to distrust Google, so the question should be asked. But we are also a technical community who can then analyze and understand the situation to determine whether concern is warranted. The last thing we need is for people to silence their distrust and for scrutiny to stop.
- runn1ng 13y agoCan I look at the source code ? The source code will be released by the University of Washington under the Apache 2 license after the trusted tester phase is completed . This is the important part.
- lotsofcows 13y agoGood timing as nyud.net seems to have stopped working.
- xr09 13y agoSo Google helps building a proxy for by passing their own censorship, Bravo Google, Bravo. (I'm being ironic of course) This is what I get any time I try to download anything from Google Code or Android sdk or even read something hosted on GAE. http://s24.postimg.org/gr0lto1l1/work107.png http://s24.postimg.org/gr0lto1l1/work107.png I'm in Cuba but the same should be for Iran and others "bad boys".
- lwf 13y agoBy "their own", you mean "as required by US export restrictions that all US companies have to abide by", right? See also https://sourceforge.net/blog/clarifying-sourceforgenets-denial-of-site-access-for-certain-persons-in-accordance-with-us-law/ https://sourceforge.net/blog/clarifying-sourceforgenets-deni...
- hrjet 13y agoThe irony here is that they are announcing a tool to subvert restrictions in other countries, but they are following their own countries restrictions to the letter.
- lwf 13y agoRight, which they're obligated to do. As a company, you're bound to follow the laws of the countries in which you do business. You have the option to direct lobbying power against laws you feel are unjust.
- jsilence 13y agoWhy don't they simply run Tor end nodes in each of their server farms all over the world. That would actually help. But that would not make any mainstream news, would it? Bleh.
- Lewisham 13y agoThe problem with Tor is that it's not clear who is running which nodes and where you'll come out. uProxy is designed for people who know that their endpoint is friendly, such as a friend who no longer lives in the country, or a journalist that you are working with.
- jjoe 13y agoThis is going to be a nightmare if you verify and process transactions online. How do you now know whether someone who purchased a product is really really on Comcast from SoCal and not someone who's exploited a hole in uProxy?
- fbeans 13y agoHow is this new? I can create a proxy server now, and I can share it with a friend and they can use my internet connection. They can do the same. This is new because, It's likely easier to use, and it's all done in the browser. The technology is certainly not new though... Apache with mod_proxy, nginx, squid, ssh, just to name a few of the many ways to do this... Further to this, one doesn't need a browser plugin to do this, firefox for example already has configurable options to connect to proxy servers.
- X4 13y agoIf a dissident hacks into a government site or does something else like speaking out his opinion, will I get arrested for them, when I live in a neighbour country? Or even get arrested for their actions on hacking stuff? I mean the US and Europe both ban hacking and penalize it with more jail time than rape and in some cases even murder.
- lallysingh 13y agoUProxy is a point-to-point proxy, where both sides know each other (by being buddies on the chat network) and choose to participate with one another. Don't proxy for your hacker friends.
- ScottWhigham 13y agoI'm interested to see if their AdWords/AdSense algos will detect uProxy and choose not to serve ads to its users. Right now, the US/UK/Canada are huge markets for Google AdWords/AdSense but most US-based companies do not have their ads shown in Latvia/Iran/Russia (just to randomly pick some faraway countries). There's a good reason - if I own a restaurant in Dallas, for example, I want people searching for "best dallas steak restaurant" to see my ad. If that starts getting shown worldwide, the CTR will plummet which would not be good for Google.
- awakeasleep 13y agoWow. If they added an option to be an intermediate proxy for traffic you were unconnected with, could they turn this thing into a global tor with authorized exit nodes?
- benologist 13y agoOriginal url: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/10/22/google-tools-idUSL1N0IB25B20131022 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/10/22/google-tools-idUSL...
- cromwellian 13y agoThe article has reached a new low in bullshit, knee-jerk, commentary. No one bothers to read the FAQ, or the technical information on how it works. Oh no, just hit "Reply", put on the tin-foil hat, and get going. Yeah, vote this down. I'm frustrated at the quality of HN posters recently.
- tete 13y agoOkay, sorry I didn't read the source code yet, but don't pretty much all the standard block-censorschip-circumvention approaches work here? They don't mention anything that makes it a tool for actively circumventing censorship like... well, all the tools that exist today and have been analyzed throughly.
- caiob 13y agoHulu, Pandora and other US-only internet services now available. Brought to you by Google.
- vsviridov 13y agoSo now you also expose your confidants? So if you are targeted they automatically get on the list? Why inconvenience the secret service with doing tedious network analysis to flush out your peers - uProxy might (they are not very specific about the security of peers) disclose that automatically...