12 ms·
Valve demonstrates Steam Controller [video]
- purplelobster 13y agoLooks like what I expected. When it comes to FPS games, it's difficult to know his skill level, but it's probably not something you'd use competitively. Many times better than an analog stick though, so I'd use it for casual gaming.
- skizm 13y agoYea, I can't remember where I saw it but i think they tried pitting top COD players from console vs PC and even with auto aim assist on PC player destroyed console players. Mouse is just too accurate of a pointing device compared to joysticks (physical or virtual).
- brymaster 13y agoThis might be what you were remembering? http://games.slashdot.org/story/10/07/23/2127253/pc-gamers-too-good-for-consoles-gamers http://games.slashdot.org/story/10/07/23/2127253/pc-gamers-t... It also reminds me about how CS:GO was originally supposed to allow true cross-platform play (PC against console) but Valve scrapped that support because they couldn't work out a reasonable way to patch on consoles due to "patch scheduling" on PS3.
- PeterisP 13y agoThe demonstrated FPS aim-and-shoot was very slow, it's not clear if it's because they couldn't do it better because of the controller, or didn't do it faster because they did everything slowly to be clearly visible how it happens. A full speed try-to-do-the-best-you-can FPS aiming demo would be welcome.
- cheald 13y agoI suspect part of it is familiarity and practice, too -- I'm very quick and precise with the mouse, but I use it all day long, and have been gaming with mice for years. It looks like the touchpad resolution is quite good, and it's not "jumpy" like some touchpads tend to be, so it might be that with enough practice, this could be as usable as a KB+M setup.
- purplelobster 13y agoBasically, give it to a professional players for a week, then record them playing at his best. If they have any chance against another team, then I'd consider that a success.
- MLR 13y agoThey wouldn't, one because it's not precise enough, and two because there's no way a week is going to compare to a lifetime, and thousands of hours in a singular game, of using a mouse.
- baby 13y agoThey're not trying to emulate mouse + keyboard precision neither. I don't think you could have played like that with a Xbox/PS controller (I know I couldn't have, it would have looked more smooth but not as precise for headshots). For me it seems like FPS with this controller will be somewhere between Xbox/PS3 controller and mouse+keyboard.
- PeterisP 13y agoI'd like to see a video that I can compare with, for example, controlling the same game on a good laptop touchpad - the current video is weak even compared to that; if they can do better, then they should make a video that proves it.
- baby 13y agoI was really skeptical about this and I'm getting more and more skeptical. 1. See how he always lift his right hand thumb to reproduce the same movement, sometimes three times, just to go through the screen (in Civ5). 2. Also the fact that buttons get mapped like a "pie chart" on the trackpads could have been a good idea, but we need buttons. We forget the luxury of having buttons with all those new tactile screens because we want more tactile surface, but for a controller we hold in our hands, we need some feedbacks bellow our fingers. This is really a bad idea... 3. I'll have to admit that it looks like a better alternative than joysticks for FPS games. EDIT: As someone else pointed out, if you get two controllers : a valve one for FPS, RTS, games that works well with it, and a Xbox/PS4 controller for the rest, then it's a very good thing.
- Fuzzwah 13y ago1. If I can play Civ5 while sitting on my couch, I'll put up with it.
- baby 13y agoTrue, it look playable compared to what a joystick could offer. The real problem is going to be with platformers, fight games, third person games who relies heavily on buttons.
- Fuzzwah 13y agoIts just a matter of using the right tool for the job. Plug in an xbox 360 controller for games where it makes the most sense. Use this steam controller for any game which you'd normally use mouse and keyboard for but want to play from the couch.
- dial_up 13y agoI feel it was a somewhat poor demonstration of the controller. Each demo was set up for a game without, or as if the game did not have, controller support. Games with controller support would make it feel more like a traditional console controller. No idea why did not show that aspect of it.
- bobbles 13y agoI'd like to see a traditional platformer like rogue legacy played with this, and how the left pad compares
- kemayo 13y agoThe developer of Super Meat Boy, which is a very precision-platformy game, talked about trying it: http://tommyrefenes.tumblr.com/post/62476523677/my-time-with-the-steam-controller http://tommyrefenes.tumblr.com/post/62476523677/my-time-with...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ahomescu1 13y agoLooking at this, I'm starting to wonder why trackballs on console controllers never became popular.
- cbhl 13y agoLikely for the same reason that mouse balls went out of favor -- they get gummed up with dust and gunk from your fingers, and are a PITA to maintain and keep clean.
- jlgreco 13y agoMy guess: dirt. With as few moving parts as they typically have, console controllers already experience durability issues for less... hygienic, players. With trackballs that issue is compounded, even if you make them easily removable so you can clean them (just having to clean them at all would be more of a hassle than people are use to).
- Sanddancer 13y agoLogitech's optical trackballs are pretty bulletproof. No moving parts; they use a special dot pattern to detect how the trackball's being moved around.
- cabirum 13y agoThey could just make an app for a phone to act as a wireless controller. In fact, many mobile games already use similar control layouts.
- lukifer 13y agoThough it's heavily touch-driven, the new Steam controller does have several physical buttons, as well as tactile feedback (ridges) on the circular touch controls. Not having to look at the screen to use the controls radically changes the experience.
- __david__ 13y agoAnd that would be just as horrible an experience as current joystick style controls are on touchscreen smartphone games.
- winslow 13y agoI was surprised to see the negative comments on the article page. I'm personally excited for it. As I think it will open up "couch" gaming to more genres and it looks like a pretty decent controller when compared against other controllers. I don't think it will be a true mouse + keyboard replacement but will do great for big screen HTPC / SteamMachine type setups.
- yeukhon 13y agoI get tired of using mouse and keyboard, and the same goes to a controller. It would be nice to play with hands in the air..
- zobzu 13y agoI wanna aim with my finger and with zero latency. Heck it's probably possible to hack something like that already in fact. Not sure if we'd be as good as with the mouse as you will lose awareness (hand in front of you = can't see as well) but it'd be fun.
- yeukhon 13y agoHehehe or maybe with eyes. Hence virtual reality :3 imagine you could just sleep in and imagine all the actions <3
- dfkf 13y agoMaybe his aiming in a fps is not up to competitive level of quake/cs, but this is definitely a step up from controllers for these types of games. Hopefully, this thing will bring the skill of being both fast and precise to consoles. It will be good for consoles, and good for gaming in general.
- Miyamoto 13y agoLooks like a great alternative to the Xbox PC controller, but like everyone has been thinking, this is in no way a serious replacement for a mouse. Especially if you're a competitive gamer.
- Avitas 13y agoIt would be nice if a single two-handed controller or even some type of two element controller (ala. wii) could somehow approach the accuracy of a mouse and a keyboard. This clearly does not appear to be at the same accuracy and speed level as the combination of a mouse and keyboard. There may be a console controller that can approach, equal or exceed the speed and accuracy of a mouse and keyboard, but this doesn't seem to be it. Addition: I suspect that every steambox will have USB ports available for whatever controller, keyboard and mouse floats your boat.
- yaiu 13y agoValve released this video on their Youtube channel. I don't think it was necessary to link to a blog post about the video.
- Miyamoto 13y agoJoystiq has a habit of downloading YouTube videos and self-hosting them with their watermark. (How is that even legal?) Then when people visit their blog articles, they see watermarked videos and think they're exclusives.
- WhoIsSatoshi 13y agoIf anyone else is looking for the straight youtube vid it can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eeAjkbNq4xI#t=12 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eeAjkbNq4xI#t=12
- bbx 13y agoValve's main objective was probably to replicate the keyboard/mouse combo rather than improve or alter the standard joystick gamepad (like the X360 Controller). In the end, it looks like a controller halfway between these 2 types of input. The main problem with a controller-based "mouse" (and it shows in the video) is that you control the cursor with only your thumb rather than your full hand gently set down on your desktop. I guess we'll never obtain a perfect alternative to the mouse. And the Steam controller will probably leave both joystick users and mouse users somehow frustrated because it tries to be both at the same time. But considering the variety of Steam's library, it was probably Valve's only solution. Anyway, like this comment, everything still remains speculation until you've tried it yourself (for a reasonable amount of time).
- Steko 13y ago"I guess we'll never obtain a perfect alternative to the mouse" Because Valve's first effort doesn't completely replace a mouse? That seems a bit defeatist. "control the cursor with only your thumb rather than your full hand " Control with the thumb vs hand isn't the problem so much as that thumbs are not pointy like mouse lasers. Valve should look at adding a tiny fingertip digitizer. Of course they are still lacking proper text entry and sitting out motion input (i.e. the big innovation in the last 10 years), voice input (the big innovation over the last 5 years) and telepresence isn't going to be a core feature unlike all the competition. And of course they are going to be the most expensive option with the least bang for the buck.
- keeperofdakeys 13y agoI really don't see why they would want to add motion input. In most situations I've seen it used, it has been little more than a gimmick.
- alan_cx 13y ago"Because Valve's first effort doesn't completely replace a mouse? That seems a bit defeatist." The mouse was patented in 1947. Since then is has not been bettered. Valve are not the first to try.
- 13y ago
- NormaHHopson 13y ago<B>my friend's step-sister makes $84/hr on the computer. She has been laid off for nine months but last month her check was $21144 just working on the computer for a few hours. Continue Reading =================http://www.Works23.Com================= http://www.Works23.Com================= <B>
- grogenaut 13y agoBasically we still don't know enough to know how good it's going to be. Having used the next gen controllers at PAX, it's going to very hard to be as good at they are at being a controller. Valve's controller does seem to be a good 1/2 step for mouse/keyboard replacement, eg very good accuracy, but maybe not the best of all worlds. Also able to do controller based games but not quite as good as a real controller. to me it's a sign that they hope to help developers support console versions by making a control system that will work well for games designed for mouse and keyboard, if not as well as a mouse and keyboard. But to be honest, standard controllers on games not designed for them are quite bad. Moving a "mouse" pointer replacement with a controller is not good. So I think it will be good in that regard. It'll also be better than a keyboard and have MUCH better support than a logitech controller for games that want controllers. So I see it as a good middle ground. And I think this will allow game devs to support both more easily. It's not the tactic I would take to make games work on both, but I think it's a good approach even if it isn't going to be the best of either world. However, if it IS as good as the next gen console controllers and it does better than them at mouse/keyboard then it's a big win.
- haberman 13y agoI have never been able to get good at using analog sticks with FPSs. I'm so bad at it that if the game doesn't have auto-aim, I basically can't enjoy the game because I am sucking so badly. The problem for me is that the analog sticks are velocity-based; ie. you don't get to control the position directly, you can only control the first derivative of the position, the velocity. That means instead of just moving the controller where you want to go, you have to move in the direction you want to go and hold it there for just the right amount of time. I'm amazed that so many people can do this so well, because no matter how much time I play I still suck at it. It just feels so clumsy. So the idea of being able to use a handheld controller that isn't velocity-based really appeals to me, though I do worry a bit that the active area is so small.
- jotm 13y agoI can't believe that the trackball (very old tech might I say) hasn't replaced the analog sticks yet! People have already modded controllers with a trackball, and it works great for the most part, bringing the best of both worlds together, yet Sony and Microsoft still insist on using analog sticks...
- banachtarski 13y agoThe reason is because it doesn't work. How do you walk forward continuously for a long stretch? Do you roll it to some position and keep it there? Do you keep rolling?
- thu 13y agoYet you have two such analog sticks. But usually only one is used the way you describe, to keep walking continuously. The other is usually used to rotate a bit, to look around you. So it seems having an analog stick on the left of the controller and a track ball on the right would be nice.
- emil0r 13y agoThe rollers for the tracking ball would collect a lot of dust. Could be one reason they opted out of it. Cleaning the rollers for the track ball every other week to get a smooth feeling would quickly become bothersome, contrary to the nice feeling of relaxation or thrill the console is supposed to give you.
- vyrotek 13y agoThe biggest problem is not the controller itself but the expectation that people that use this will be able to compete at all with those using a keyboard & mouse. The only reason FPS games currently work on consoles is because everyone is essentially equally handicapped. Even a casual player using a mouse dominates versus game pads.