4 ms·
While I have no idea what actually happened, and don't think that anything in the indictment should be accepted as fact, it's still an interesting situation if
by nkurz 13y ago
While I have no idea what actually happened, and don't think that anything in the indictment should be accepted as fact, it's still an interesting situation if we assume that DPR knew that Alice and Bob (henceforth AB) were the same person. I don't know that DPR was acting stupidly.
Supposing AB had real information that would be harmful to DPR if released, it's in DPR's interest to prevent this release. One major risk is that even if he pays, he is still susceptible to future extortion. His approach sends a message to AB (true or not) that he is a casual killer, and that it would be an unwise risk to attempt this stunt a second time.
It also further implicates AB in DPR's crimes: in the same way that DPR will have great trouble explaining in court that he was not actually arranging a murder but deterring an extortionist, it would be unwise to try to argue in court that one accepted money to commit a murder, but is innocent because the murder was not actually performed due to a complicated backstory.
Also, the extended negotiation provides DPR more opportunity to discover more information about his adversary --- rather like the 'try to keep them on the line so we can trace the call' trope. It seems likely that if there is any substance to the accusation, that AB is a Silk Road seller and not a third party. Perhaps this dance helps DPR to gain more information so as to take future action against this seller? Or buys time so as to warn others that their buyer information is compromised?
- cityhall 13y agoIf you accepted money to kill yourself, the onus would be on the prosecutor to prove a crime was committed. A reasonable defense would be that you feared that if you didn't pretend to carry out the murder, the buyer (who knew your identity) would find an actual hitman.
- MacsHeadroom 13y agoA reasonable defence would be not to say anything. There is no evidence that this person who was allegedly killed ever existed in the first place. The Canadian Investigators say that nobody by that name ever existed and that there were no homicides or deaths which they can attach to this alleged hit. You can't commit an impossible crime. I can't murder your sister if you don't have a sister. It's highly likely that both the hitman and the hit were the same FBI informant entrapping DPR.
- mbetter 13y ago> I can't murder your sister if you don't have a sister. But I believe you can conspire to murder my sister, even if I don't have a sister.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoPerhaps. But against whom was a crime committed. If you pretend to have a sister and I order a hit on that figment of your imagination then have I committed a crime? So whilst there was conspiracy it was not against a person and there was never a plan to harm an actual person. Despite there being the mens rea in the conspirators there's no crime, just moral turpitude. It seems that if the conspiracy were against a person who never existed and were adjudged to be a crime that writers would be similarly guilty when they plan a storyline in which someone is purposefully killed. Of course there is a significant epistemological difference for the writer. Fascinating.
- ostrakon 13y agoThink about it like this: In any given sting operation, the John gets arrested, bt there was never any prostitute. The arrest occurs on the basis that, if there were a prostitute, the John would participate in the exchange. Then, at that point, he's dragged before a judge or jury, and they don't really care about the crime, they just want this guy off the street based on the character assasination. The layman/plebian juror doesn't need to involve any sophisticated thought process, because his goal is to clock out of his "civic duty" by 5PM on the dot. The patrician judge is permitted the luxury of aloof detachment, and is a fallible human being. A person with a social life, biases and any other human weaknesses, despite whatever image or persona they may project into their social sphere of influence. It doesn't really matter whether the sting is a bomb plot, drug deal, or a setup for hookers, Johns and online chat room predators. The maguffin is there to demonstrate intent, and prove that police are doing there job, the streets are safer, when this slob gets thrown in jail, and branded with a scarlet letter. But the slob is real, and more often than not, simply being placed in the hot seat is enough for judge and jury to usually be swayed in favor of a conviction. It really doesn't take much for a person to get slapped with a jail sentence. Neither imaginary crimes nor genuine crimes weigh heavily on the mind of your typical juror. Or rather, to the juror, all crimes are essentially the same degree of fiction. They are tales of intrigue presented to strangers who play the role of critic for a day, while attending the performance of fatal charades.