6 ms·
Troll-Killing Patent Reform One Step Closer
- YummyTempura 13y agoThere are certainly some good points covered here, and it looks like it would be better than the current status quo of extorting payments as "settlements" when one party can't afford the legal fees. I do wonder if all these new measures will head us into a situation of patent entrenchment though, whereby patents already granted to (or subsequently acquired by) the biggest players actually increase substantially in real values due to the greater difficulty in getting new patents granted. What I'm sure a lot of us would like to see is a better means by which to invalidate existing patents that have become standards-essential. Of course, the problem then is that you're seen as effectively punishing the most successful of ideas (in reality a lot of those patents should never have been granted in the first place). This has become a longer response than I intended. Hopefully someone eminently more knowledgable on this will be along to solve the problem shortly!
- EGreg 13y agoI don't think this will increase the cost of getting a patent granted. Rather, it will shift the costs / risks to the patent holder when they bring suit against defendants. They will no longer be picking on small entities to push them into capitulating out of court, but rather engage in real court cases against companies that they have a bona fide belief are infringing. Together with boosting discovery of prior art (askpatents etc) this should go a long way towards righting the economics of the problem.
- dhimes 13y agoOT: Got tired of Fajitas?
- amikula 13y agoAt least this would make it easier for a company to justify digging in and fighting a patent. If they're confident they can win, they can anticipate legal expenses being reimbursed. A lot of companies who today are on the fence about whether to stand up and defend themselves would suddenly be willing to go to court.
- YummyTempura 13y agoIn theory it would, but if the company fighting the troll loses, surely that would mean they'd need to pay the troll's legal fees also?
- rarw 13y agoAs a lawyer I'm always concerned about changes designed to make it harder to sue someone. You almost always end up with unintended consequences. Take for example the heightened pleading standard. This standard has been used with other case types in which the allegations are considered dangerous to one's reputation, like fraud or discrimination. In many situations, people with legitimate claims have been unable to overcome the heightened pleading standard, not because their claim is weak, but because the evidence required to plead the claim is difficult to come by. Many of the changes suggested by the article can already be accomplished using existing procedural devices. The only provision I see as having any teeth is the one that deals with fee shifting. Fee shifting provisons are a big deal as recoving attorneys fees is very rare in the American legal system. Generally fee shifting provisions allow the winner to collect legal fees even if nominal damages (e.g. $1) are awarded. This greatly increases the risk of trolling since any loss, no matter how small, could equal hundreds or thousands (probably millions) of dollars in legal fees owed to the other side.
- hotpockets 13y agoWill fee shifting make it too risky for small companies to protect their IP?
- chum 13y agoSome have proposed a sort of patent "small claims" court to address these issues: http://www.uspto.gov/ip/global/patents/comments/patent_small_claims_court_rev_3.pdf http://www.uspto.gov/ip/global/patents/comments/patent_small...
- rarw 13y agoProbably not. Enforcing a patent is expensive (as most litigation is). If this law penalized trolls who filed worthless claims but rewarded those who were legitimately being infringed on then if anything it would make it less risky.
- hotpockets 13y agoIt sounds like the "expected" return on litigation may be positive for small legitimate startups, so that over the long run, it might be expected to work our well for small startups. However, each individual small company may not want to risk their survival on hard-to-predict judicial idiosyncrasies.
- WalterBright 13y agoA way to stop frivolous lawsuits of all sorts is to have the loser pay the winner the lesser of (what the loser paid his lawyer) and (what the winner paid his lawyer).
- EGreg 13y agoWhat if the loser was a lawyer or had a very cheap one / a friend litigate?
- rarw 13y agoGood luck finding a cheap patent attorney. All those admitted to the patent bar must have a technical background. That only raises the price.
- tzs 13y agoThe big problem with a general "loser pays" system for the US is that we use private civil suits for many things that much of the rest of the world uses government intervention for. For instance, much of our civil rights enforcement comes about through private civil suits for employment or housing discrimination. We use malpractice lawsuits as a major part of dealing with bad doctors. We use consumers suing over bad products as a significant part of keeping consumer goods safe. Your suggestion that the loser pays the lesser of what the two sides paid their lawyer is interesting, because it would not discourage lawsuits as much as a general "loser pays winner's costs" system, which is what is usually posed. Effectively, in the common case of a small party suing a big party, your proposal would double the plaintiff's cost if he lost. That would probably be a small enough risk that it wouldn't stop, say, a person who thinks they have been discriminated against in housing from suing--it would just mean he'd go with a less expensive lawyer than he might otherwise have used.
- WalterBright 13y agoThe issue with "loser pays winner's costs" is that if there is a large disparity in the wealth of the two parties, the wealthier one can essentially bully the other with the threat of a massive bill, even if the other party has a solid case.
- tzs 13y agoThese fail to address the actual problem--poor standards for issuing patents. Fix things on the issuing side, and all the patent troll problems go away. These random attempts to fix things on the enforcement side of things tend to seriously harm the ability of small inventors to bring legitimate infringement suits against large infringers.
- adventured 13y agoNot quite, although it's obviously important to start crippling the supply side of the troll equation. There are 2 million patents in force in the US alone. Even if you began choking off the stream of inbound patents, you'd have one to two decades of patent trolling left (and most likely they'd get drastically more aggressive in a last ditch feeding frenzy, knowing there aren't as many meals coming in the future).
- HNLogInShit 13y agoAmen. Until software and "business-method" patents are abolished thoroughly, all of these patent "reform" maneuvers are a sham. And no, a "step in the right direction" isn't always a good thing. It means legislators will slap themselves on the back as if the mission were accomplished, then the issue will be shelved for ages. We need REAL reform, and that starts with not awarding bullshit patents to begin with.