12 ms·
Intel proves once and for all that PCs are not coming back
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sturd 13y ago>SemiAccurate Says it all... /thread
- mmohsenazimi 13y agoSteve Jobs said PCs are trucks of our time. Companies make trucks, some people use trucks but not everyone needs a truck. I hope this trend do not lead to slowness in PC innovation.
- melling 13y agoWhat PC innovation? PC's are the same trash can size devices they were two decades ago. They just get a little faster every couple of years. Innovation will be driven by mobile (both phones and tablets). It requires a lot more innovation to build these smaller devices that operate all day on a battery.
- ekianjo 13y ago> Innovation will be driven by mobile That's only true because mobile started from scratch a few years ago. You just see innovation because this market (for "smartphones and tablets") barely existed 6 years ago. Obviously this will tone down very fast as performances stop increasing significantly. You see that the latest ARM chips are only marginally more powerful than the previous ones in terms of operations/Watts. So, they will, also, get only "a little faster every couple of years." Do not kid yourself.
- AsymetricCom 13y agoAnd that's all they need to be. It's software that needs innovation, but that requires critical thinking people and people to have power over processes and business. So before we can even let people do that, we first have to tell them how to think and keep secrets and fight each other, work against each other, build walls and checks for themselves, and deliver their value to stock holders while not doing the same types of land-grabs via software and regulation that Microsoft & co. is empowered to do.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoWe are getting 4K displays this year. Granted, phones, then tablets, then laptops got high res displays first; but dammit, I really want my 31" 4K monitor. If the PC space starts to innovate again, or at least catch up to mobile, people might start loving PCs again and gasp...buy new ones.
- regularfry 13y agoGPU innovation is happening in PC's, because they can dictate the power budget and space isn't an issue. Multicore is also bigger in PC's than smaller devices, but that's mostly trickle-down from server-space.
- vidarh 13y ago> PC's are the same trash can size devices they were two decades ago Do you actually visit your local PC stores regularly? Because while it was not unusual to see full sized towers on display, these days it's rare to even see a standard ATX case. The typical form-factor even for the desktops have slimmed down massively, and a large number of the devices are now "all in one" models with the PC and monitor in one. That's actually why I agree with you about mobile - the performance _most_ people needs is low enough that the form factor has been steadily going towards mobile, and yet sales are still anaemic while mobile device sales have sky-rocketed. With the rise of Android "TV sticks", coupled with increasing support for mirroring/streaming display from your mobile devices, and/or HDMI/MHL ports and bluetooth keyboards, the desktop is going to be redundant for most people within a few years. The irony is the desktop trend towards small devices, bluetooth keyboards and "all in one" models are accelerating the demise of the desktop more than it is propping it up, by making people used to wireless keyboards and not having a big box PC.
- breckinloggins 13y agoIt's a rant, so I'm not going to critique this post too much, but I'd like to call this out: [...] Intel is desperately trying to figure out what to do to combat the phones and tablets that are eating them alive from the ankles up. It is pretty obvious that the company both doesn’t understand what the problem is and is actively shutting out all voices that explain it to them. I don't think this is true. Intel certainly understands the market and where it's headed. However they are committed to x86/64. What Intel is doing in my view is taking a series of huge but calculated risks. They seem to be betting that: - Laptops will stick around and have Intel Inside for quite a while. The market may be boring, but it will be there for years. Corporate America helps. - Servers won't be switching to ARM any time soon (I'd argue this is the riskiest bet). - The desktop and enthusiast/gamer PC market will be around for a while, and also won't be switching to ARM any time soon. So all of these "shoe-ins" buy them time, and I believe they think that in time they can pull off the biggest risk of all: - Intel is betting that the biggest differentiating factor is and will be performance per watt. They are willing to gamble that they will eventually eclipse ARM cores in this area. In their view, if they have an x86/64 core that trounces competing ARM architectures in ppw then phone, tablet, and set top manufacturers won't have a problem putting those chips in their devices. Granted, I'm not saying I think Intel is 100% correct or that they'll succeed with their long term bets; I just don't think they are as clueless as this rant makes them out to be. No doubt about it, though, UltraBooks DO suck. EDIT: I'm going to revise my statement on UltraBooks. Not all of them suck. In particular, the Lenovo Yoga is fantastic.
- ekianjo 13y ago> UltraBooks DO suck. You mean, in comparison to ARM based tablets?
- lelandbatey 13y agoYeah, what exactly are we comparing this against? Because if you know of something that has a nice screen, a long battery life, an excellent keyboard, and the ability to run decades of software aimed at helping me develop and get work done, then please let me know. However, if you're saying that ultrabooks suck at consuming content compared to tablets, all I have to say is "well duh."
- taspeotis 13y ago> During this time Windows 8 came out and PC sales dropped 15% in the first full quarter after launch. I don't think it's all Windows 8's fault. The average desktop PC is just too powerful. I've been using Visual Studio 2010/2012/2013 with an i3 and an SSD for years now and I rarely run against any sort of performance bottleneck. To compare what sort of performance requirements I have: in the project that I work on I have a solution with 28 projects that takes about 50 seconds to build from a clean build. Visual Studio takes care of incrementally building the projects during normal development, so usually I'm looking at ~5 seconds to build then launch the debugger. I have absolutely no need to upgrade. No need = no sale. I'm using Windows 8 as my operating system. It takes one step forward and one step backwards. I'm looking forward to Windows 8.1 but there's nothing so seriously wrong with Windows 8 that I need 8.1. When I'm sitting in front of my PC and using Visual Studio, I'm not thinking "I wish this was actually a docked tablet". I have an iPad for mobility. PC sales are probably undergoing a bit of a course correction as people who are satisfied with tablets buy tablets instead of PCs. But I suspect PCs will be around for a long time to come and, until that day, there's nothing for them to "[come] back" from.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoSame here. 4 years ago I bought 2 desktops, one for work and one for home. I quit contracting and got employed, so both sit in my office at home now. I still use them, develop on them, do everything else on them and they are fine. I wont' be buying a new desktop for at least another year if then. And I CERTAINLY won't be 'upgrading' to win8.
- jyrkesh 13y agoI would really reconsider your upgrading decision. It's easy to get past the start screen-ness or spend 5 minutes setting up a 3rd party taskbar and making sure opening files (e.g. jpg, pdf) default to the "non-Metro" applications. After that, you'll have an OS that is functionally identical to Windows 7 with better boot times (non-fresh upgrade install from 7 to 8 HALVED my boot time), an even more stable kernel (I've literally NEVER had a BSOD since upgrading from 7), and better performance. The FUD surrounding Win8 is kind of crazy. You want to know the easiest, fastest way to launch an application? Hit Windows key, type application name. Same on Win7, same on Win8...hell, it's the same on Ubuntu.
- ehutch79 13y agooh man, I know all the people at work using solidworks are going to be pissed that they have to start using it on an ipad now... seriously though, can someone break down the article, i'm having a tough time figuring out what it's trying to say.
- breckinloggins 13y agoIt appears to be a stream-of-consciousness rant (as all good rants are), so it is not quite as structured as one would like, but the tl;dr seems to be: "Things in the PC space suck, and absolutely no one seems to be interested in making them suck less. Instead, they keep putting different shades of lipstick on the same pig and calling it 'innovation'."
- nfoz 13y agoThanks for the tl;dr. Isn't this the same for most industries, and for pretty much everything? Genuine innovation takes lots of effort building things that people don't know they want yet, even IF they are in fact monetizable. And a LOT of things are not monetizable, or face serious difficulties gaining marketshare in environments with deeply entrenched players and expectations. The history of computing has much more to do with "innovation" in monetization schemes rather than computing itself. Great things get built only when someone discovers some hackish way to get people to purchase it. The monetization itself usually makes the product/technology worse than it would be without the monetization (e.g. DRM, copyright, ads, preinstalled spyware).
- nly 13y agoThis 'the PC is dead' nonsense will come full circle eventually. Phones and tablets are PCs, we just haven't yet got to point where we can satisfactorily dock them with a full desktop accessory set. I personally see a scenario where everyone has a nice big LCD screen, full sized QWERTY, and probably still a mouse, in their study at home but carry their 'beige box' in their pocket. Just 5-10 years out imho. Unfortunately I think Windows is still positioned best to make this happen.
- nitrogen 13y agoUnfortunately I think Windows is still positioned best to make this happen. Have you looked at the Ubuntu phone OS? It's designed to be the same software, hardware, and UX from phone to desktop. I don't necessarily like it, but it shows promise of doing exactly what you say Windows is best positioned to do.
- nly 13y agoYep, and I'd put them at #2. I'm pragmatic, I don't necessarily think the best solution will triumph. One thing Ubuntu phone is doing wrong is dismissing Android. Dual booting is absurd, it doesn't promote sharing app data or a seemless user experience.
- lectrick 13y ago> Unfortunately I think Windows is still positioned best to make this happen. As a user who has been very impressed by the combination of http://elementaryos.org/ http://elementaryos.org/ and the fact that Valve/Steam has recommitted to Linux, I think Windows is on the downturn and Linux is on the upswing.
- yaeger 13y agoLet's hope so. As long as Valve keeps the desktop side of Steam and the Big Picture mode separate from each other we would be fine. I really hope they won't make Microsofts mistake and start trashing the desktop UI of Steam and instead giving those users the Big Picture Mode UI to use. Because, you know "Everything must look and work identical. No matter how different the use cases may be" Microsoft could have avoided all of this by just offering a small option during install "Where do you want to install win8? Tablet or Desktop". And according to that selection install MetroUI or otherwise leave it uninstalled. But their notion that from phone over tablets to desktop, all just have to have the uni colored tiles everywhere certainly isn't doing the trick.
- pmelendez 13y agoOh well... This rant has little sense and a lot of angriness. The phrase "The PC is over and PC sucks" appears several times with little explanation other than citing the grow of other markets. The true is there is no replacement for the PC and it doesn't seem to have a serious replacement any time soon. People can't make movies, edit images properly, use a compiler, debug, use a nontrivial spreadsheet,etc in phones or tablets. Until that doesn't change the desktop PC won't die. They might not been as popular as before nor have the same upgrade cycle as before, they might had lost relevance as a growing market, but they are far from dead.
- ekianjo 13y agoWell, that's a very popular position taken recently in the media. "the PC is dying... Tablets will replace everything we know... look, the sales are going up, it means it's a zero sum game and PC share will go down to ZERO!". As you mentioned the future is fragmentation, certainly not a monolithic tablet-only future. There are still too many incentives to keep using PCs for many, many usages.
- everyone 13y agoAlso for me this is all very familiar. As a pc gamer for years, maybe a decade! I have been hearing about how pc gaming is dying or dead. All the while playing the best games which are usually not released on consoles with the best graphics and performance + controls and setup that I want.
- ekianjo 13y agoYeah, and playing on Full HD since a while, while all the consoles out there rely on crappy upscaling to fake Full HD. It's been a while I did not take my Xbox360 or PS3 out. And I'm far from being convinced by the PS4 and XboxOne even after playing with them in the last week.
- NTDF9 13y agoWell, true all that. Except, my non-technical parents won't be buying any more PCs. They can do everything they want on their ipad. And I'm pretty sure they don't want media editors, compilers or complex spreadsheet editors either.
- TheLegace 13y agoI think people are really underestimating where things like perception computing are going. Something Intel is also invested in. But maybe people start looking at which jobs require using a computer to get essential work done vs. not needing one and therefore not using it. If people really think that entire generations of people are not going to need computers to do work are seriously mistaken, especially in BRIC/developing countries. I don't think the question really is are PC dying, the question should what the hell can I do with the ~$1000 machine other than look at cat pictures. We can thank Microsoft mostly for that. Seriously I think people really underestimate how turned off the entire industry is from Windows 8, especially when they need to upgrade the only reasonable choice is Apple. Remember Apple is the only company that is actually increasing sales to laptops(MBA models). Clearly there is a market it's just not being served by current parties.
- justincormack 13y agoWhat sorts of jobs do you think these people will have then? If you aren't using a computer your job can be replaced by one...
- AsymetricCom 13y agoComing back? Where did they go? When did they arrive? I don't think there was ever a time where the PC enjoyed significant market saturation. If anything, the PC "bubble" is deflating back down to normal levels. It may be popular and "obvious" to accept that Intel and Microsoft own the PC market and decide where it goes, but the reality is that the market makes the demands and Intel either meets them or they don't. I think this is clear when AMD pushed 64 bit first and Intel adopted it. This is also illustrated with the fact that PC sales have declined along with the stagnation of Moore's Law. That last point seems counter-intuitive but it shows that Intel can't force a market if it doesn't deliver. Now both CPUs and GPUs are "as fast as they're going to be" for some time now. For some reason, next gen GPUs are joining the theoretical ranks of "Moore's Law is more threat to economics and security than fruit of civilization," giving us 10% yoy speed improvements but doubling up on security and management overhead, added coupling, APIs for compilers only, dedicating more silicon to hypervisors and management that should go to the programmer and his compiler. IT has become a completely dysfunctional market at the macroscale. The demand doesn't know what they want or how to shop for it, and the supply is to scared to deliver anything new. At the micro-level, those who know what they want are still taking it one step at a time with their own feet, to their own drummer, but the mess that is the macro-market is just destroying knowledge and value like a wildfire. However, those few programmers who know what the Internet should look like, instead of one that's built to be profitable for thing manufactures, aren't able to keep up with the complete mess big software is doing to the collective wisdom of the netizens and the internet infrastructure, both physical and social.
- Raphael 13y agoYou have good insight here, but it's hard to follow.
- mentat 13y agoFor those who didn't make it to IDF, it felt dead. There was very little attendance in most sessions and the expo floor was also pretty much empty. They actually moved food into demo areas so it looked like there was buzz. I'm pretty sure the "outside of Intel" attendee count was remarkably low.
- rayiner 13y agoPCs are dead, but Intel will be fine. Bay Trail will be the beginning of the end for ARM as Intel brings its massive lead in fab technology to bear on the mobile market. You heard it here first.
- JetSetWilly 13y agoExcept that the apple A7 has already trounced baytrail, despite being hobbled by a 28mm process: http://www.anandtech.com/show/7335/the-iphone-5s-review/5 http://www.anandtech.com/show/7335/the-iphone-5s-review/5 baytrail has the vast expense of cutting edge foundries and the entire expensive might of intel r&d behind it, and it just got beaten by a cpu produced with far less engineering and r&d expense on a last generation foundry. Doesn't look good for baytrail then.
- rayiner 13y agoLets wait for a fuller set of independent benchmarks. There is a lot of speculation on RWT and my conclusion is that nobody really knows what's causing the difference. Also note that a lot of these benchmarks use JS, which puts the quality of the JS engine into the equation.
- JetSetWilly 13y agoThat is very true. Also, bay trail still won a lot of benchmarks on said page. I cannot shake the feeling through, that while bay trail is competitive and will be very interesting for many purposes (looking forward to getting a small home server based around the new atoms) - it needs to truly trounce arm to initiate an industry change.
- gph 13y ago>The basic PC experience sucks As opposed to what... tablets? Or are you suggesting we leap forward to Computer Terminals right out of the Hitchhiker's Guide. I couldn't read much further than that. Really bad article.
- epochwolf 13y agoApple products perhaps? The computers people currently own?
- lelandbatey 13y agoWait, what? I don't feel the Apple experience is a lot better than the PC one, and I say that as someone who fully bought into the dream (I used a MBP as my main machine for 2 years, and an iMac as a desktop for that same two years). After those two years where up, I totally went back to PC, built my own desktop, bought a nice Lenovo laptop and called it a day. However, I guess I really don't understand why everyone's getting so uptight about. What we're seeing is not everyone in the world suddenly making a change to mobile for no discernible reason. It's not as though suddenly the winds changed and now PC is mysteriously dying. No, what happened is what always happens: someone made a better tool for the mass market to do what they want to do, which is to consume content and be entertained. Magic wireless Netflix screens that fit in their pockets are just better at that than PC's are and there's nothing wrong with that. It's evolution, and even as a PC enthusiast and power user, I'm more than glad to see people better able to do what they enjoy. That's not to say I'll be giving up my hand picked keyboard, large screen, and heavy tower, but I'm not to worried. There's always going to be money in serving the needs of people who get work done on computers, even if it's not quite as much money as it used to be.
- Samuel_Michon 13y ago> I don't feel the Apple experience is a lot better than the PC one That comes across like you do think it is better, if maybe not by a lot. But then you write the following: > I totally went back to PC, built my own desktop, bought a nice Lenovo laptop and called it a day. I don’t understand. You hated your Macs so much that you bought 2 new computers? If it was just OS X that you hated, you could’ve simply kept the Macs and ran a different OS. So what was it about the hardware that you disliked so much?
- general_failure 13y agoI don't see how Intel can fix the windows/software problem. Just try out http://html5dev-software.intel.com http://html5dev-software.intel.com and judge yourself what Intel can do in software.
- bigphishy 13y agowewll... at least the website domain name is pretty accurate.
- pvdm 13y agoLast time I looked MacBooks are x86.
- PhasmaFelis 13y ago"Then comes the hardware, you know the part Intel does. It sucks too. Why? Because for the last 5 or so generations it doesn’t actually do anything noticeably better for the user. Sure the CPU performance goes up 10% or so every generation, battery life gets better at a slightly faster pace, and graphics improving extra-linearly but that is irrelevant if you aren’t benchmarking." In a sane world, this would be a feature, not a bug. PCs are now mature enough that you can buy a decent machine and expect that it will not be hopelessly outdated in two years. This is a good thing. The problem is that hardware and software manufacturers have a mutually beneficial relationship whereby new software just won't function without that extra 10% hardware capacity you get from a new computer. Even if it's a word processor or a not-terribly-impressive game. (Remember "DirectX 10 requires the power of Vista", which requires a much faster computer that XP?) And the other problem is that doofuses like the article writer have been so thoroughly gulled by the planned-obsolence treadmill that they actually think that's how it's supposed to be, and throw tantrums if this year's hardware isn't at least 10 times shinier and more sparkly than last year's.
- orangecat 13y agoIn a sane world, this would be a feature, not a bug. Being able to get use out of older hardware is a feature. New hardware not providing any new possibilities is a bug, and that's where we've been for the last 5 years at least. I think the core point of the article is valid. It's ridiculous that my $230 tablet has a better resolution than nearly every "high end" laptop. And apparently nobody has any ideas for using our tremendously powerful multicore CPUs and near-teraflop GPUs other than rendering increasingly bloated websites.
- mark-r 13y agoThe 1920x1280 Nook HD+ is now available for $149. I checked NewEgg and only 7 laptops met that resolution, and 5 of them are from Apple - the cheapest is $1399. The problem here is Microsoft, not Intel. They never figured out a way to make sure that things looked consistently good on a high resolution display. When the OEMs all decided to piggyback on the TV industry and declared 1920x1080 was "high end", that nailed the coffin.
- uslic001 13y agoTotal Apple fanboy rant. The latest Ultrabooks are superior to the Macbook Air IMO. They are faster with better battery life and cost less. I prefer Windows 8 and 8.1 over Mac OS X ML and over IOS 7. I will never buy another iPad or iPhone ( I have an I iPad 3 and iPhone 5 atm) as I prefer the flexibility of my Ultrabook and Android phones have leapfrogged iPhones in almost all aspects.
- rossjudson 13y agoThe article is a giant pile of stupid. Umm...I think my Air is a nice laptop. It's packed full of Intel stuff. Why the anti-Intel rant? He's dumb or a liar. Intel doesn't care whether Apple/Intel wins, or Microsoft/Intel wins, or ??/Intel wins.
- jfoutz 13y agoIntel should care if Apple wins. Apple is in the best position to change architectures. Again. Ubuntu is probably in good shape. But Linux by nature can't really switch primary architecture in an afternoon quite the way Apple did.
- shearnie 13y agoI don't think PCs are dying. I think computing consumption is increasing so desktop productivity looks like it is declining. I think when a dock for tablets or phone finally happens for consumers, they'll just get it. Desktop mode is not intended for using your fat fingers on a touch screen. "Metro" mode is for that. Windows 8 is all about for when you get off the bus in consumption tablet mode and dock into your desk and your dual monitor with keyboard and mouse lights up and you go into productivity mode.
- bane 13y agoWhat's actually happening is that the PC market is basically saturated with machines that pretty much do whatever anybody asks of them. The market has pretty much plateaued. Pretty much everybody has a PC at home and work. Most households already have multiple computers. Heck, I know entirely non-technical powerwasher/gutter cleaner guys who have 2 or 3 computers. In fact, I don't know a single person older than 10 years old who doesn't have at least one Personal Computer of some kind. Any commodity off-the-shelf PC will pretty much do whatever you ask of it (at least for most consumers). I used to replace my computer every year or two just so I could run modern software. I haven't felt compelled to do so for the last 6 years and even then I'm 50/50 on doing it. The rMBP my work issued to me is fantastic for virtualization, but unbelievable overkill for everything else I do (mostly email, word and web). There's just not much of a reason to buy more machines outside of regular replacement rates due to failure and total obsolescence and new humans buying them as they get old enough. It's not that PCs aren't coming back, it's that the constant growth in the market has plateaued. Everybody was hoping China, India and Africa would explode 3/5s of the world's humanity moved into the middle-class and needed computers, but the growth has been far slower than was hoped and these first time computer buyers won't really be constantly upgrading like previous markets did -- the market characteristics are such that it won't be a simple repeat of the 80s, 90s and early 2000s. Smartphones and Tablets are an entirely new segment and still growing (though showing some signs of flattening out as well). That's why they're exciting, because those markets are still building out and upgrading. But there are signs that those segments are flattening as well. Tablets and phones are awesome, but they're definitely not a replacement for a general purpose PC. Even my mother and father, who're quite the luddites, regularly needs capabilities that don't work well on a tablet -- like doing taxes. Even if those things were magically fixed and working awesomely tomorrow, they'd still want a bigger screen than a tablet afford. PCs aren't going anywhere, it's just that the market has to shift to sustaining the market not growing it (which is infinitely more expensive, meaning loads more money sloshing around in the secondary markets). This is fundamentally the problem that both Intel and Microsoft are dealing with. Apple escaped it largely because they created new segments to grow into. Heck, the one new market segment that PC makers did manage to get into, netbooks, they managed to screw up so bad that the entire segment was dead within just a few years. (If you think of where netbooks needed to go as a segment, the Surface Pro would probably be a reasonable outcome, except that market is totally hosed now and Microsoft has to rebuild it).
- zedpm 13y ago>...change tact Ugh. Change tack[1], which is a sailing reference[2]. As for the actual content, I feel this analysis lacks nuance. Mobile is booming, of course, but the PC is not dead, nor will it be dead five years from now. There are a hundred use cases for which a desktop or laptop is the only practical solution. Fantasize all you want about businesses abandoning real machines for iPads; reality begs to differ. [1] http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/change+tack http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/change+tack [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tack_(sailing) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tack_(sailing)
- jacques_chester 13y ago"Change tack" is like "would of" -- people haven't made the connection between the written and the spoken word. Then you add almost-homonyms and it gets worse. I am often amused to find people "flaunting the law".
- MaysonL 13y ago"would have", no?
- lotsofcows 13y agoI think he meant "change tact" is like "would of".
- axefrog 13y agoUntil general literacy improves, we're just going to have to make due with whatever people want to post.
- lotsofcows 13y agoEye halve a spelling chequer...
- jacques_chester 13y ago
- frozenport 13y ago1. Its not sucking if its only meeting 95 out of 100 of your requirements. My desktop can do everything my iPod can do, with difference. There is a very select group of tasks, ie eBook or drawing surface, that the table excels at but these are not shared by desktops. They are two different products with one offering a miniaturized and inferior version of the former. 2. Users see laptops that run faster on desktop relevant applications: games, spreadsheets and programs like Adobe CS and MATLAB. The rest don't count as they arent' motivation to buy a desktop.
- Mikeb85 13y agoPCs are not coming back in the sense that they won't see growth like they used to, but at the same time they're not going away. To be fair, most people don't actually need a PC. My wife uses a Nexus 7 as her main computing device, and loves it (she prefers it to a PC). As an aside, Chrome OS devices are gaining alot of traction... Probably because they're more than adequate for most people's needs as is, and developers can always switch on development mode for a full set of Linux-y features...
- bhauer 13y agoMy own thoughts on the negligence and indolence of the PC industry are full of rage. But this guy makes my rants seem a little tame. I love it! I believe I have an unpopular opinion about desktop PCs. The conventional thinking is that desktop computing is boring because a modern PC does everything it is intended to do just fine. That may be true, but the problem is that the industry is not interested in establishing new usage patterns—new things the PC should do. At the end of last year, I started a series of rants about how modern technology sucks [1] with particular emphasis on the frustrating stagnation of desktop computing and the bothersome way every new portable computing device wants to be a center of attention. I was pleasantly surprised that the author of the linked article hits the target squarely when he lists off what PCs need. The first item: better displays. He may be speaking more about laptops (and they are deserving of the shame), but allow me to rant a bit about my preferred computing medium—desktops. The stagnation of desktop displays is, and has been for a decade, the crucial failure of desktop computing. Display stagnation is the limitation that allows all other limitations to be tolerated. It is the barrier that leads the overwhelming majority of users (and even pundits!) who tolerate mediocrity to declare everything else—from processors, to memory and GPUs—as "good enough." I absolutely seethe when I hear any technology declared good enough (at least without a very compelling argument). Desktop displays, and by extension, desktop computing is so far from good enough that it should be self-evident to anyone who observes users interacting with tablets or mobile phones(!) while seated at a desktop PC. Everything that is wrong with modern computing can be summarized in that single all too common scene: 1. Desktop displays are not pleasant to look at. They are too small. They are too dark. They are too low-fidelity. And they often have annoying bezels down the middle of your view because we routinely compensate for their mediocrity by using more of them, side-by-side. 2. The performance of desktop computers is neglected because "how hard is it to run a browser and Microsoft Office?" This leads to lethargy in updating desktop PCs, both by IT and by users ("I don't want the hassle"). In 2013, I suspect many corporate PCs in fact feel slower than a modern tablet or even mobile phone. 3. Desktop operating systems are actively attempting to move away from (or at least marginalize) their strong suits of personal applications and input devices tailored for precision and all-day usage. 4. Desktop computers--and more accurately personal home networks--have lost their role as the central computing hub for individuals by a misguided means of gaining application omnipresence: what I call "the plain cloud." This is because none in the desktop industry (Microsoft most notably) are working to make personal networks appreciably manageable by laypeople. 5. Mobile phones and tablets are often free of IT shackles and therefore enjoy more R&D (more money to be made). Desktop displays stopped moving forward in capability in 2001, and in large part regressed (as the article points out) since then. Had they continued to move forward--had the living room's poisonous moniker of "HD" spared computer monitors its wrath--I believe we would have breathtaking desktop displays by now. In that alternate universe, my desktop is equipped with a 50+" display with at least 12,000 horizontal pixels. Desktop computing needs to leverage immersion (without nausea; VR goggles need not apply, yet). Large form-factor super-high-definition displays would bring all manner of new technology needs with them: 1. Gesture controls. 2. Ultra high-bandwidth wired networking (win for wired network folks) to move super high definition files. 3. Ultra high-capacity storage. 4. Extremely fast processors and GPUs to deal with a much greater visual pipeline. Such a computing environment is a trojan horse for today's tablets: it turns tablets into subservient devices as seen in science fiction films such as Avatar. The tablet is just a view on your application, allowing you to take your work away from the main work space briefly until you return. I say trojan horse, but that's not quite right because I actually want this subservient kind of tablet very much. I do not want a tablet that is a first-class computing device in its own right (even less do I want a phone to be a first-class computing device). I only want one first-class computing device in my life, running singular instances of applications for me and me only, and I want all my devices to be subservient to that singular application host. For the time being, that should be the desktop PC. In the long haul, it could be any application host (a local compute server, a compute server I lease from someone else, or maybe even a portable device as envisioned by Ubuntu's phone). But for now, the desktop should re-assert its rightful role as a chief computing environment, making all other devices mobile views. [1] http://tiamat.tsotech.com/technology-sucks http://tiamat.tsotech.com/technology-sucks
- ivanbrussik 13y agoI don't feel like the title matches the content of this piece. I thought it was going to primarily be about how users are shifting away from PCs (which it did touch on). But really it was just an angry rant about chips not getting better, even though Intel makes the best chip on the market. U mad bro?
- Bahamut 13y agoI'm on the complete opposite boat - I think the laptop experience generally sucks still. Battery life only recently got improved to a great point in the past few years, but performance is still generally lacking. Meanwhile a great desktop lasts longer than ever, is cheaper than ever, and does everything extremely fast. I have a 5 year old desktop that outperforms a lot of laptops out there, including my new Macbook Air & my work laptop (not even a month old), and that desktop pales compared to my half year old desktop (which costs maybe $200 more than the 13" cheapest Macbook Air). I think part of the shift in the market is due to the great state desktops have become as long lasting devices (& thus declining sales), and some of the improvements on more mobile devices - I'm highly skeptical of any call that the desktop is going away anytime soon though, because the mobile experience is still seriously lacking in the sweet spot of performance, battery life, weight, and price.
- silveira 13y agoI just bought a overpriced ultrabook with Windows 8 (Microsoft tax). The Windows 8 experience is indeed terrible for touch screen. Seems like someone made an amateur touch screen mod for Windows 7. The product isn't ready. I can fell the Steve Ballmer signature in this product. I just wanted a PC because I tough it would be easier to install a traditional Linux on it, but UEFI. Oh the humanity, UEFI is the most disgraceful scam the industry ever did. How they could be so wicked? I don't want to live in a world that the only good option is a monopoly of Apple machines and software but the PC industry is not even trying.
- exodust 13y agoThe fact that tablet devices and phones have entered the market, reducing the need to do everything on a PC, doesn't spell the end of PCs. It just means they aren't the only go-to computer anymore, which is a good thing for everyone. A rock solid PC in the home connected to a nice big monitor and other useful peripheral devices, is a good thing to have. Be it a compact PC, laptop or desktop, Windows or something else. "Post PC" is a stupid agenda-driven term. We live in a "post horse and cart" world, but the PC has no inherent limitations preventing it from evolving. If you bother to look, there's currently more enclosures, cases, and interesting "desktop" configuration variety for PCs than ever before, cheaper than ever before. In short, the article sucks.
- pasbesoin 13y agoWell, I am currently shopping for some used ThinkPad T60's and T61's because I cannot stand the shite keyboards (and also, not infrequently, displays) that have taken over current designs. This doesn't really speak to market trends, I guess, but making your products physically unpleasant to use probably isn't helping your cause. I should delete this comment as a pointless rant... but, I'm shopping for 7 year old laptops, dammit. I want to type quickly and pain-free, and also have some vertical context without eyestrain.
- kayoone 13y agoI dont really buy his arguments. I think the Surface2 is a good example of where the PC and Windows 8 is headed. For most people such a tablet with the option to use it as a desktop pc trough a docking station is all the computing they need. The Surface2 seems to do this job very well and with Haswell finally has decent performance and battery life. In 5-10 years, i am pretty sure that the real desktop PCs will be for professionals only, while most consumers are using some mobile tablet/laptop hybrids.
- alexchamberlain 13y agoArgh, PCs never died. I am reading this on a PC in an office full of PCs. I can't develop code for other people's PCs on a tablet - I couldn't develop code for a tablet on a tablet, it would be horrible. I need a PC.
- kayoone 13y agoWhat do users want and ask for vocally? Screens that aren’t garbage quality, resolutions that are not worse than mainstream laptops from 2007, SSD instead of error prone and driver dependent ‘hybrid’ garbage, an OS that isn’t grating to the user, decent Wi-Fi, good build quality, and a decent price. Do they really ? Imo most consumer couldnt care less about any of that, its a tech savy minority that wants higher quality screens and SSDs. Thats exactly the reason why we are seeing zero innovation in the PC monitor space, because the market doesnt really care. It cares for price most importantly which leads to popularity of low res screens and slow HDDs in the first place.
- InTheSwiss 13y agoI still run on a Core 2 Duo from January 2009 as my main machine (a laptop) and it is still plenty fast enough for me. I just don't find the latest generation CPUs to offer me anything that I don't have except doing things "a little bit quicker" but that isn't all that noticeable to me. I suspect this machine will die (in a way that makes fixing it financially unviable) before I out grow it. Visual Studio 2012 starts in ~1 second (warm startup) and performs great. The only issue I have is that Hyper-V (as part of Win8) requires SLAT which my CPU does not support which is annoying but I just use VMware Workstation instead. For me there has not been enough improvement in CPU features since the Core 2 range was introduced for me to need to upgrade. Sure a Haswell would be nice from a battery life POV but as I am plugged in 99.9% of the time that isn't an issue to me.
- everyone 13y agoI dont get this article. Seems to be nothing but hearsay and opinion with no references to facts. Also point of author just seems nonsensical to me. I have a big-ass powerful pc and I love it! Use it for gaming, game development, 3d modelling, music making. I built it myself from components, set up OS and software exactly the way I want with win7 and Crunchbang (linux). No other device would be able to do exactly what I want like this. Maybe most people dont want that but most people have never been technically minded, if theyre happier with tablets then thats fine.
- dgrant 13y agoJust want to validate this... I feel the same way. PCs are faster than they've ever been and cheaper than they've ever been. I just bought a custom smoking fast computer for my parents in an awesome tiny mini-ITX case with a fast SSD drive and an awesome i5 Ivy processor (I think 3570k?). Including monitor it was < $1000. I priced out even cheaper PCs with cheaper, larger cases for $300. I also have a big-ass powerful PC and I love it.
- tsenkov 13y agoI assume this discussion is already more about the transition from desktop to laptop, than about the PC to Mac etc. Have you looked at Windows on 27" Thunderbolt display? The first time I saw that display with Mac OS X rendering on it, I thought: "Wow, that looks awesome. The glare from the glass is bothering, so there's that, but placed right in the room, it's totally fine and well worth for that size and clarity.". Then I went to the specs and saw that the PPI of this monitor was exactly 6 points above my own (1920x1080, 21.5", 102 ppi vs. 108 ppi)? Is it possible 6 points to be such a differentiator? Of course, it turned out it wasn't - I immediately tried windows on the same Mac machine and there it was - everything looked almost as badly as on my own PC. So, I asked the guy that owns the machine (he is a graphic designer), why there is such a difference and he said: "Microsoft simply doesn't care enough about detail. Check the default icon sizes in the OS - OS X's icons on regular-density display (non-retina) are 4x bigger (512x512 vs. 256x256 on windows) and on retina this grows to 16x more pixels (1024x1024)." So factor #1, IMHO, is people ditch Desktop PCs because of Microsoft's lack of flexibility and innovation - they decided "If we have a monopoly over desktop computing, why should we care what our users say? They still buy 'it'.". Factor #2 - Microsoft still has the numbers!!! They have locked the enterprise tight, and still don't care about "personal" user experience. So we have this giant corporation that gets enough money and has no incentive to innovate and we hope it will bring us the great singularity of software and hardware we have all been waiting for... And the last factor I will point out is relevant mostly to developers - Mac hardware runs it all. Then having a Windows and a Mac machine, doesn't really make sense, both as expenses and simplicity of work. Apple made the, arguably, "evil-corporate" decision to be totally in control of the hardware running its OS. So you, developers, have the option to buy: - iMac, that sits tight on your desk + Macbook (probably Air) for your work on the go; - Mini + Thunderbolt + Macbook (probably Air); - Pro + Thunderbolt + Macbook (definitely Air after what you paid for the previous 2); - Macbook Pro. Well, as I see it, most developers are headed for the Macbook Pro with eventually adding a Thunderbolt. For developers in need to support the Mac ecosystem, this is not even #3 reason - it's #1. I had to make this transition and I am glad I did, because Mac OS X turned out to be no less then great, and although smaller in size, my 15.4" retina display got me into the 21st century. :)
- jheriko 13y ago
- Tichy 13y agoI don't understand why people don't like Ultrabooks. They like MacBook Airs, so what's wrong about creating slim and lightweight notebooks in general? That some vendors produce crap is irrelevant. But there are nice offerings out there. I've seen a Samsung in the shop recently that looked and felt great. They only screwed it up in offering max 4GB RAM and their lineup is so confusing that I don't even know which one I would have to look at online. But that is not a general issue of "Ultrabooks".
- glogla 13y agoMy problem with ultrabooks is what is intel doing with the brand. At first, ultrabooks were supposed to be laptops with good battery life, high-resolution IPS screen and a SSD. Also it should be thin, which I think is meaningless, but whatever. However, it seems that this disappeared somewhere, and now laptop with 1366*786 15" TN screen and rotary storage (with a measly 16 GB "SSD cache" that does pretty much nothing to make it faster), but it is required to have Windows 8 and touchscreen. The brand lost meaning, it went from "Apple quality from someone else than Apple" (so we can buy nice computer without supporting walled garden approach)
- Tichy 13y agoI was never under the impression that I could just buy any notebook that has an Ultrabook sticker and get the equivalent to an MBA. So I guess I don't really care about the brand - I care about getting a lightweight, powerful notebook.
- mratzloff 13y agoYou do realize you can install whatever you want on a Mac, right?
- andyzweb 13y agoI will check back on this comment 5 years from now to see if that still holds true
- Fuxy 13y agoYes the PC seems to be stuck I bought a desktop PC in 2005 and replaced it this year love the built in graphics and more powerful processor but anything extra is useless crap i don't want. It's amazing how hard it is to find a screen with a decent pixel density and how expensive these average screens are. I'm actually considering buying I-Pad screens off e-bay and creating a wall of them to get what i need. How deplorable is that? The PC needs to become the main machine of the house and to do that it needs to step up its game.
- walshemj 13y agoThe reason Intel can rest on its laurels and only release incremental updates is that AMD has such a poor product line up
- zobzu 13y agoThis article sucks? why? because it's not semi-accurate, it's totally inaccurate, everywhere. And writing "sucks" every paragraph doesn't make it right. 10% speed improvement a year isn't nothing. The small battery improvement this year? Oh.. We went from from 6H battery life to 13H.. it's only double, it sucks! Heck, it's better than my smartphone with screen on. The rest is on windows, which is an OS, not the OS. (Which isn't even a _bad_ OS, despite the hate for Microsoft)
- otikik 13y agoOne thing I would add to the list of requests is: being quiet. Ideally, fanless. For that I need processors that don't become small suns 20 minutes after booting up.
- drill_sarge 13y ago>Semiaccurate Please stop reading this. Also the "PC is dead" discussion pops up every 5 years or so.