3 ms·
The idea that >20% savings rates are not "realistic" is a serious mindset problem. Almost anyone on Hacker News with a paying job (i.e. not an early-stage no-f
by JoshTriplett 13y ago
The idea that >20% savings rates are not "realistic" is a serious mindset problem. Almost anyone on Hacker News with a paying job (i.e. not an early-stage no-funding startup) should easily be able to save much more than that. Sure, saving two-thirds of your income might be out of reach, and even the 20% advice is better than most sites that often say 5-10%, but consider carefully whether you can increase it and retire years earlier (or become effectively retired, in the sense that you no longer depend on having an income).
EDIT: "Almost anyone on Hacker News". Yes, 20% would be significantly harder on minimum wage.
- drivebyacct2 13y ago:eyeroll: about the level of response this post deserves
- throwaway812 13y agoYes, >20% is viable for Software Devs. Ask someone making minimum wage with no benefits to save more than 20% of their income and they will laugh at you.
- timr 13y agoEven if you're a "rich" software engineer, the advice is overstated. You need to make a lot of money (or be really lucky in the stock market) to have a 66% savings rate lead to any sort of real retirement in 10 years. Say I make $100k gross per year. That's a very nice salary for a new grad engineer -- the kind of person who might take this ten-year-retirement advice to heart. Roughly 1/3 of that income goes to taxes, so I'm actually taking home $66k per year. If I save 66% of that, I'm saving ~$44k per year. These numbers can shift a little depending on where you live, how you save, etc., but they're not going to change by a huge amount. Multiply that $44k by 10 years, and you're not even at half a million dollars. That's not retirement money (unless perhaps your "retirement" is to continue to live off of $20k/year indefinitely and die young from eating too much ramen). The other half of the equation is finding investments that return a reasonable yield without betting the farm on timeframes <= 10 years. In this market, that's nearly impossible. Your choices are stocks and bonds (which are fine, but are risky on anything less than a ten-year window), or investments that don't yield anything.
- Afforess 13y agoa 4% rate of return, on average from the S&P 500 index is reasonable. With 1 million, you could live off of $25000/yr, which is more than enough to live like a king if you do not have other debt payments. You could rent a $1000/month apartment, pay for a $400/month car, eat $300/month in groceries, and still have thousands and thousands left over.
- timr 13y ago"a 4% rate of return, on average from the S&P 500 index is reasonable." Not if you're depending on using that money in the next ten years. Or if you believe in inflation. A 4% rate of return from an index fund is long-term average behavior, not instantaneous yield. Historically, depending on when you entered the market, a ten-year outlook could have led to anything from a huge gain to a huge loss. If you're the unlucky investor who started saving 66% of your income in the stock market in 1999, you'd still be putting off your retirement today. Also, your definition of "king" is pretty context-dependent. I can assure you that 25k will not allow you to live like royalty in San Francisco. Or, say, if you have children. It's a difficult concept to grasp when you're in your 20s, but most people do tend to reproducing by the time they're in their 30s. Oops. There goes that 25k retirement...
- Afforess 13y ago4% return is conservative. 7% is actually the historical average. So my 4% left plenty of room for bad years. RETIRING in San Francisco would be a massive mistake. If you are retired why the hell are you living in a uber-expensive city. Location matters less when you don't have a job. Move up to Oregon. Also if you decide to have children, that is a conscious decision you made to dump your millions down the toilet. I guess some people like kids enough to work an extra 30 years. I sure don't.
- timr 13y ago"4% return is conservative. 7% is actually the historical average. So my 4% left plenty of room for bad years." It's only "conservative" if you don't understand variance. The risk isn't in the value of the average. The risk is in the variation around that average. Like I said: if you invested 66% of your net income in the stock market in 1999, you'd be a long way from retirement today. And if you're tempted to keep arguing this point, you might want to take a moment to consider how I know this. (Hint: the reality of a great many investors trumps your theories of how the stock market works.)
- dionidium 13y agoThe idea that your retirement years are a better time to live than your 20s and 30s is a serious mindset problem.
- Retric 13y agoIt's not about assuming that your 60's are better than your 20's. It's assuming that having 7 dollars inflation adjusted tomorrow is worth not having 1 dollar today. Clearly, the higher your savings rate the sooner you can retire but the lower that multiple becomes. More importantly when something bad happens you both have a cushion and a cheap lifestyle so it can last.
- dionidium 13y agoI'm sure we all agree that saving is both prudent and desirable. My comment is in response to the idea that you should be saving most of your money.
- kjs3 13y agoLogan's Run wasn't really intended as a desirable way to structure society.
- kamaal 13y agoAnd at the same time, saving nothing in your 20s and 30s. Having all the fun in the world, and then expecting the government to take care of you when you are old is also a very serious mindset problem.
- dionidium 13y agoLuckily, I didn't suggest that.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoA good-sized retirement isn't just for fun. It's to work against inflation and maintain financial security / independence, it's to prepare for potential catastrophes, and it's also to prepare for your declining years. Actuarial tables show if you make it to age 40 you have a very high likelihood of making it to 80 or 90. Statistics show that the last decade of your life - thanks to health care needs or assisted living necessities - is often more expensive than any other decade of your life. That's absolutely important to plan for in your 20's and 30's when you have the time (and energy) to make a difference.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou dont have a family with kids I take it.
- coldtea 13y ago>The idea that >20% savings rates are not "realistic" is a serious mindset problem. Almost anyone on Hacker News with a paying job (i.e. not an early-stage no-funding startup) should easily be able to save much more than that. You know that 50% or so of HN readers are not in the US, right? Some have to do with $300-$1000 a month (or less), with the same costs for food and costlier computers, clothes etc -- oh, and 3x the price of gas. And renting some small-ish appartment.