6 ms·
Snowden Disclosures Finally Hit 12 on a Scale of 1 to 10
- soora 13y agoWhat does a 12 on a scale of 1 to 10 even mean? What criteria are they judging damages on? So far, I do not think the NSA has lost any of the capabilities it previously had. I have not heard of any NSA backdoors being removed from existing software.
- nonchalance 13y agoRead the article: > Nonetheless, this is truly information that plenty of bad guys probably didn't know, and probably didn't have much of an inkling about. It's likely that many or most of them figured that ordinary commercial crypto provided sufficient protection ... > Now every bad guy in the world knows for a fact that commercial crypto won't help them, and the ones with even modest smarts will switch to strong crypto techniques that remain unbreakable. If you accept that most bad guys were using commercial crypto and not strong crypto, NSA may have been tapping communications but now won't be able to
- toyg 13y agoI wouldn't be surprised if it turned out that this switch will actually weaken opponents. Criminal masterminds are often not uber-hackers who can reliably roll their own encryption scheme, so to speak.
- toyg 13y agoThey're losing a lot of political capital, which should limit their ability to further expand their reach in the immediate future. They're also an item of debate now, which could potentially result in loss of capability further on. At the next round of elections, Democratic candidates will likely have to defend an unpopular intervention in Syria, they'd rather not add to that pile a defence of some invented Federal right to unwarranted spying on everyone's communications; and it's a potentially easy target for small-government Republicans.
- jes5199 13y agoRepublicans have, so far, not been willing to use the "big government" label to attack anything to do with military, police, or espionage - their "law and order" platform trumps their "small government" one. In the bizarre logic of American politics, Republicans and Democrats are both pro-NSA, while the Greens and Libertarians are anti-NSA.
- toyg 13y agoThat's why I said "potential". Depending on how the wind blows, the small-gov platform could give them an easy angle, and if it doesn't, they're still the party of law and order, so it's a win-win. Dems have a harder job, for them it's a wedge issue.
- ensmotko 13y agoI think the former employee just wanted to stress how this is way worse for the NSA than their worst case scenario. It's just to draw attention, nothing else really...
- mc32 13y agoI think it means that while those weaknesses capabilities have not gone away, the data exposed to such, might evaporate (be moved away) from such exposure. Example, the claim that FSB is moving to typewriters.[1] Or criminals moving to other methods of communication, if they perceive the internet as inherently insecure. [1]http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/afp/130711/kremlin-turns-back-typewriters-avoid-leaks http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/afp/130711/kremlin-t...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- astrange 13y agoConsumer encryption products employ "strong encryption". There's no difference between the two - this isn't the 90s. If you're worried some specific product isn't enough, you have to say which one it is.
- Karunamon 13y agoSure there is. "Consumer" encryption products are almost all commercial, and therefore necessarily closed. And considering the NSA has demonstrated they're willing to coerce or subvert companies, that makes it awfully hard to trust commercial security products.
- contextual 13y agoA writer's job (among other things) is to get and keep your attention. This article did that very well using hyperbole (i.e. 12 on the scale of 10). I think the rest of the article is hyperbole too, but not much more than that.
- ihsw 13y agoThe US Government and the NSA have made it painfully clear that there are two options for the US to participate in the global internet: capability to decrypt everything or an American version of China's Great Firewall. The capability to decrypt everything is largely outside of their control, however they can exert pressure of ISPs, SSL certificate authorities, commercial software vendors, social networking services, and a variety of other organizations. The rationale being that the US Government pressures those organizations to intentionally implement weaker security measures to facilitate the ongoing capabilities of the government's suspicionless surveillance systems. Since this system of clandestine supportive relationships is potentially unreliable (since it is directly outside of their control and it relies on reciprocal partnerships) then it stands to reason that the simply revelation of these relationships could jeopardize the US Government's surveillance capabilities.
- cmyr 13y ago>>What does a 12 on a scale of 1 to 10 even mean? Integer overflow!
- ohWhatever 13y agoIt very obviously means that this goes beyond even the kind of wattage that Spinal Tap's amps are capable of. This one doesn't just go to eleven. Twelve is greater than eleven.
- auctiontheory 13y agoHe seems to be saying that it would be better (for the US) if the NSA continued to secretly spy on all the world's communications networks. That's certainly one point of view, but it's not one I expected to see in Mother Jones, or on HN. Isn't the whole point of this uproar that we do not trust these unelected (by the US, never mind the global population) spooks with unfettered access to all communications?
- ihsw 13y ago> Isn't the whole point of this uproar that we do not trust these unelected (by the US, never mind the global population) spooks with unfettered access to all communications? Yes, however some people think "the government" can do no wrong because it "works for the people." The government they support also happens to be fighting a "War on Terror" where terror can include personal opinions that are critical of the American government and her corporate pillars[1][2][3][4]. Many still see distrust of government as indicative of mental illness, where such distrust is born from paranoia and anarchist/libertarian propaganda. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_oil http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_oil [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharmaceutical_lobby http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharmaceutical_lobby [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_conglomerate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_conglomerate [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_triangle_(US_politics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_triangle_(US_politics)
- datanotdata 13y ago“Every word that is spoken and sung here represents at least this one thing: that this humiliating age has not succeeded in winning our respect.” -Hugo Ball
- blackcat 13y ago>Many still see distrust of government as indicative of mental illness, where such distrust is born from paranoia and anarchist/libertarian propaganda. If you are actually worried that you will be spirited away to be tortured by the US while living as a normal, non-radical muslim in England you may have cognitive issues. If you are white triply so.
- the_french 13y agoThe way I've understood the recent leak was that we know the NSA has been concentrating on breaking SSL, 4G and others but that the actual techniques haven't been revealed. Besides, I feel that it is very important to know that bank, internet, and wireless security have been comprised by at least one actor.
- jmadsen 13y agoI'm not going to come out on either side on this yet, still thinking about it. But to anticipate those who will say, "do you think the bad guys are really dumb enough to use basic encryption techniques?" - The 1993 (failed) World Trade Center bombers were caught because they went back to the rental truck company to try to collect the deposit on the "stolen" truck. So yes, some of them certainly are.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoThey have children, though, and some of those children are probably smart, and might train their old men to use Tarsnap via Tor in order to transmit encrypted messages/photos/other data anonymously and securely. I'd imagine the NSA is concerned about future intelligent adversaries who have finesse, which is why they stay as far as possible ahead of the curve. (I'm trying to come up with an alternative to our standard explanation of "the NSA does this because it's a soulless governmental machine that wants access to the world's information for corrupt purposes.")
- jmadsen 13y agoLOL - actually, OT but lot of recent articles are showing that "young people know all about computers" is a complete falsehood.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoThe point was more along the lines of "intelligent people are generated by being born, so it's a matter of time before we face an intelligent adversary" rather than "young people are intelligent."
- sliverstorm 13y agoI'd imagine the NSA is concerned about future intelligent adversaries who have finesse I'd imagine the NSA already has such adversaries. Note how difficult it appears to be to track down members Al-Qaeda, and how relatively well-informed bin Laden's hiding scheme was. There are doubtless also other less-publicized malicious operations of the same breed.
- tomasien 13y agoI wonder what criteria Snowden used in his disclosures in terms of what to release and what not to release.
- alan_cx 13y agoI thought that was what the Guardian's lawyers job was.
- mpyne 13y agoSnowden himself was quite clear in his initial interview that he was being selective with what he took (if not what he actually released to the journalists), in order to set himself apart from Manning's behavior.
- milsorgen 13y agoHopefully none. The information should be free to the public that paid for it. You can sit here and quiver over national security or how some "know better than others" and how they can be trusted with information that the public can't. But at the end of the day that is all verbal excriment, tax dollar paid information is property of the tax payers and anyone that argues against that is living with their head in the sand.
- tomasien 13y agoAnyone who ends a tenuous argument with "anyone who argues against this is (insert any insult here)" is being ridiculous.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoPer the article the gains that were made in breaking existing systems have been made public, so all of that effort goes for naught as people move on to new systems (which requires all new efforts). Basically if you want to consider the "cost" (as in $$) of Snowden's leaks, this shows a bunch of budget $$s that were spent on the assumption that these broken systems would remain in use for a period of time. Since that assumption is removed, the $$s spent on breaking those systems won't be as useful as forecast, hence the cost estimate. That said, at the big crypt-a-geddon moment, when Leon Panetta said [1] "It does not mean that the Department of Defense will monitor citizens’ personal computers. We're not interested in personal communication or in e-mails or in providing the day to day security of private and commercial networks. That is not our goal. That is not our job. That is not our mission." he was lying. Both by omission and by commission. And perhaps the most painful aspect of Snowden's act is that by exposing this failure of integrity in the NSA, they will never again be able to take the "high road" of we need this to defend the nation. [1] http://www.defense.gov/speeches/speech.aspx?speechid=1728 http://www.defense.gov/speeches/speech.aspx?speechid=1728
- masswerk 13y agoNow this is quite a national-biased view (again). On the other hand standards, protocols, and the trust in networks are an international affair as well. So what is probably a future damage viewed from a national side is a damage already caused from an international point of view.
- malandrew 13y ago"For what it's worth, this is about the point where I get off the Snowden train. It's true that some of these disclosures are of clear public interest. In particular, I'm thinking about the details of NSA efforts to infiltrate and corrupt the standards setting groups that produce commercial crypto schemes." If anything this new information should put more people on the Snowden train. In the 90s, legislation was proposed which would have put backdoors everywhere via the Clipper Chip. Back then, we voted against that bill and all was good. This new information is shocking because we've already told the government that backdooring things was unacceptable behavior, yet they've done so anyways. We should all be outraged by this because it clearly doesn't represent the interest of the people.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI can't any record of a Congressional vote on the subject, only that its adoption was the subject of a proposed FIPS #185. I don't think your statement above is founded in fact. I refer you to Michael Froomkin's lengthy but readable analysis from 1996: http://osaka.law.miami.edu/~froomkin/articles/planet_clipper.htm http://osaka.law.miami.edu/~froomkin/articles/planet_clipper...
- lukejduncan 13y agoThat stood out to me too. It's exactly at that point I would hope for the opposite reaction in the general public.
- rondon 13y agoMaybe Kevin Drum can provide the government a live encrypted feed of his family's bathroom and bedroom. I'm sure they will only crack the encryption if they think a bad guy is on the video.
- ewoodrich 13y agoThe Clipper Chip didn't fail because of any vote, and a Congressional vote wasn't really necessary because it was intended to be a "opt-in" technology mainly for telcos and electronics manufacturers. It was never adopted due to backlash and criticism, but it's not as if they were explicitly banned from similar pursuits. Of course, that isn't to say that this justifies recent actions or is really even relevant to the latest releases, but you made the connection. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip
- ig1 13y agoArticle 12. (The Universal Declaration of Human Rights) "No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks."
- brudgers 13y agoAll the latest revelations show is that corporate and consumer encryption is just corporate and consumer encryption. It's never going to phase a state sponsored intelligence organ. What they can't decrypt, they buy, what the cannot buy they subvert or cripple or backdoor. In fairness, it would be grossly unprofessional if they did not. The three letter agencies take pride in their craft and part of their job is staying in front of any wide spread encryption technology.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- blcknight 13y agoWe need to stop posting these non-technical ravings of people who haven't a clue. Kevin Drum can certainly have an opinion about the NSA (and he's mostly wrong, I think), but his musings about what the NSA can do is clearly uninformed. He seems to believe that all commercial crypto is suspect; and there exists some other nebulous category called "strong crypto." D'oh! If only we had all been so smart enough to use this obviously better "strong crypto" instead of "commercial." It's meaningless. The NSA has it's hands in all the crypto cookie jars. The NY Times slides: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/09/05/us/documents-reveal-nsa-campaign-against-encryption.html?loadDynamically=false&commentsPosition=middle&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/09/05/us/documents-r... give us some new details that have some usable specifics that can be gleaned.
- kalkin 13y agoYou beat me to this complaint.
- drcode 13y agoExactly. The idea that the NSA has can break arbitrary SSL without access to source keys is an EXTRAORDINARY CLAIM that goes against most of what we know about the science of cryptography. Just some managment type in the government saying a single time that the government has made "major breakthroughs" in cracking SSL does not meet the standard of ETRAORDINARY EVIDENCE.
- a3n 13y ago"It's not clear to me how disclosing NSA's decryption breakthroughs benefits the public debate much," Backdoors, bought or coerced. If I obtain crypto capability, I expect it to be at least as good as advertised. Or, in other words, they went to the public in the 90s and asked for Clipper. They were denied. So they went against the public and implemented what they were told, by their supposed masters, that they couldn't have. If your dog is eating your children, is he your dog?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kalkin 13y agoThe distinction which is the basis of this article between "commercial" and "strong" encryption seems confused. Kevin Drum in this post makes it sound as if commercial encryption is algorithmically weaker, which as a rule it is not, rather than just easier for the NSA to plant backdoors in by strongarming vendors. The distinction matters here since we're meant to believe that most "bad guys.. figured that ordinary commercial crypto provided sufficient protection." But this translates to, they trusted Google, Microsoft et al. That seems less likely to me. Disclaimer: I am not a cryptographer or security researcher. (On the other hand, given that I've done various kinds of antiwar political organizing and associated with members of Muslim Student Associations whose infiltration by NYPD later became a matter of public record, maybe I can speak as a government-classified "bad guy!" I should really do an FOIA request one of these days...)
- sillysaurus2 13y agoYou know, there's one very valuable piece of info that I don't think has been revealed anywhere yet, or I missed it: Recall, for example, Glenn Greenwald's admission that he "almost lost one of the biggest leaks in national-security history" because Snowden initially insisted on communicating with strong crypto and Greenwald didn't want to be bothered to install it. What exactly did Snowden insist Greenwald do, precisely? Whatever Snowden insisted on, it's guaranteed to be an NSA-proof method of communication. So it seems like it's an essential first step to figure out the details and train people to use it habitually.
- ewoodrich 13y agoA document properly encrypted with AES or similar modern methods would be considered "strong crypto" (using the article/'90s political terminology) and would be infeasible with current computing power to crack (assuming AES does not have a major vulnerability/backdoor, which has yet to be discovered by the top security researchers who depend on it). As tptacek and others frequently say: "Crypto is hard to do right". There is sufficient encryption technology to evade the NSA (at this point in time) but the social-engineering aspects and difficulty confirming a bug-free, secure implementation present the most issues.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoIndeed, which is precisely why it's so valuable for us to figure out exactly what Snowden insisted on: it addresses every single one of the problems you mention, which is no small feat.
- gwern 13y agoPGP email. And Snowden has already specifically stated that a PGP/GPG encrypted document is safe from the NSA (assuming no one leaves around a plaintext or private key, anyway).
- sillysaurus2 13y agoI appreciate your comment, thank you. May I ask for a source where you got your info? It's probably accurate, but it's good practice to insist that hearsay not be trusted on faith. EDIT: Ah, it appears to be confirmed at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/10/edward-snowden-glenn-greenwald_n_3416978.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/10/edward-snowden-glen... ... Thanks!
- Steuard 13y agoIt's very valuable to see this reaction to the latest Snowden disclosures: I expect it will be common, and the tech community needs to be prepared to make it clear why this really does reflect another betrayal of trust. Personally, I can't blame the NSA for trying to intercept and read lots of "suspicious" internet traffic: that's their job. Governments do this, and whether it's good or bad, it's expected. (I'm not happy about the degree to which the NSA seems to be stretching the rules against them acting domestically, nor am I happy about massive all-encompassing interceptions rather than targeted ones, but those are separate issues.) So there really is a legitimate argument that these latest Snowden disclosures damage national security. The thing is, they also indicate that the NSA has been doing its expected work by actively weakening the protections that we (and large parts of the global economy) depend on. Their actions and strategies have also undermined global confidence in American technology companies. And those are factors that I think the average watcher (like the author of this article) may not recognize unless folks like us point it out.
- kordless 13y agoWe definitely all need to step up and help explain this shit to other people. It's a challenge to understand for a layman.
- GoodIntentions 13y agoNot really a challenge. This is how I explained it to my non-technical father years ago: "Nothing you do online is anonymous. There is a record of everything you do." He understood it right away and ( I think ) has always treated everything online as public. No need to go into any technical details.
- Steuard 13y agoThat's not really the same issue as in these latest revelations, though. The latest bit really is fundamentally technical, and folks like the article author may only focus on the easier-to-understand national security interest and overlook the downsides of the NSA weakening public crypto.
- sehugg 13y agoThe author has posted an update which kinda-sorta retracts this article: http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2013/09/hed http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2013/09/hed
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nly 13y agoIt's a shame we'll likely never see the "Annexe (available to BULLRUN indoctrinated staff)" that contains a breakdown of their capabilities.
- sliverstorm 13y agoGive it fifty years. They seem to have been pretty good about releasing documents from the Cold War.
- cjdrake 13y agoFalse. A scale of 1 to 10 only goes to 10. :).
- B0Z 13y agoI have a question from the article that I hope someone here can answer... What's the difference between simple encryption and the "strong" encryption Snowden was insisting on? Truecrypt volumes?
- nraynaud 13y agowe need facts, the list of compromised ciphers, the bugs they are exploiting etc. I guess those NSA guys can't travel abroad, since spying is a felony in most countries.
- kawera 13y agowe need facts, the list of compromised ciphers, the bugs they are exploiting etc More than that, we need the names of those involved.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- reader5000 13y agoYou know, it's really only an accident of history that human communication historically primarily took place through air vibrations (which are difficult to acquire, store, and query). Digital communication is a new medium with different principles of interpretation. It is stupidly cheap to algorithmically monitor and query digital comms on a mass scale. Why wouldn't it be done? If you think the NSA is the only institution in the world doing this you're an idiot. The only thing Snowden accomplished was demonstrating how large an undisciplined joke US intel is that a high school graduate with a narcissism complex could accomplish these leaks. Here's an idea: if you don't want your neckbeard anime discussions pinged by the world's intel/ad agencies, don't digitize and broadcast them over the internet.
- grannyg00se 13y agoWhat is this strong crypto vs weak crypto he's talking about? Apparently strong crypto is more of a PITA I gathered that much. But weak crypto is no crypto. If you are going to go through the trouble of using any at all how much more annoying is it to use NSA proof methods? Has any well established crypto methodology been declared broken because of Snowden leaks?
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoThis so horribly misinformed or just naive. The "bad guys" should assume the sites can read their data or the NSA has the private keys or whatever ... I mean really? This is the straw that breaks the camels back ... That "bad guys" didn't known "the man" was actually serious about reading their data?
- at-fates-hands 13y ago"and the protection used on fourth-generation, or 4G, smartphones." This quote was particularly eye opening to me. In the early 2000's I remember speaking to a Verizon engineer who said their encryption on CDMA was bulletproof. He went on to explain over the course of an hour how impossible it was to crack their encryption or even eavesdrop on their network. See page 34 here: http://www.scribd.com/doc/22599374/Security-Encryption-in-GSM-GPRS-CDMA http://www.scribd.com/doc/22599374/Security-Encryption-in-GS... "The security protocols with CDMA-IS-41 networks are among the best in the industry. By design, CDMA technology makes eavesdropping very difficult, whether intentional or accidental. Unique to CDMA systems, is the 42-bit PN(Pseudo-Random Noise) Sequence called “Long Code” to scramble voice and data. On the forward link (network tomobile), data is scrambled at a rate of 19.2 Kilo symbols per second (Ksps) and on the reverse link, data is scrambled ata rate of 1.2288 Mega chips per second (Mcps). CDMA network security protocols rely on a 64-bit authentication key(A-Key) and the Electronic Serial Number (ESN) of the mobile"
- jdiez17 13y agoHoly shit, that's a whole lot of nothing.
- bsaul 13y agoOne theoretic question : suppose that the nsa did manage to crack encryption using very advanced technology such as quantum computers. Would that seem outrageous as well ? I don't think people would have reacted the same. On this subject i believe what piss people off is the mean rather than the result. Somehow people hoped for a smarter NSA, not for a meaner one. But that's a bit naïve isn'it ? After all they're here to save lives in the end.
- gmuslera 13y agoAnother shoot the messenger article. Somewhat they try to convince us that every single person ten miles around NSA is basically an archangel, incorruptible and honest, that work just for justice and fairness, and given by God the right of being over everyone else rights. And everyone in the other side must be punished, stripped of privacy and intellectual property and keep be unsafe while there are "bad" people around. This really means that thousands (hundreds of thousands?) of people which ultimate goal is to get money, and have little to none auditing on what they do, some NSA employees, some from private companies, can access your trade secrets, your bank account, or whatever that can be used to blackmail you, and make any kind of profit from it, no matter from where you are, or who you are. And that won't be even noticed by the authorities (if they even care, they have the "state secret" wildcard) unless they become public on that (they noticed what Snowden did because he went public, on pourpose). And that also means that that information (that they are "careful" having it safe) on which vulnerabilities they introduced on pourpose on every kind of "secure" software, if ever leaks, get reverse engineered or found out by luck, will be exploited by the bad guys too. Hanlon's razor is not an excuse for this kind of article anymore.
- lakeeffect 13y agoWhat are the implications of this on bitcoin? Seeking a technical understanding of farming bitcoins.
- enko 13y ago> It's not clear to me how disclosing NSA's decryption breakthroughs benefits the public debate much, unlike previous disclosures Well, that's the problem with trying to keep everything secret. If the majority of these "disclosures" were in the public interest - they should have been public knowledge. That would have made it far less likely for someone like Snowden to feel the need to "blow the whistle". There is such a thing as a "presumption of trust", which the NSA has squandered. They likely had it before these leaks began, but now they have lost it, no-one listens even when they might have a good point.
- notdrunkatall 13y agoWhat's the latest news on Snowden? Is he still holed up in Russia? Have they started prodding him for information in return for protection yet?
- Qantourisc 13y agoDoes anyone has a list of what is considered unsafe now ?
- frank_boyd 13y ago> “These capabilities are among the Sigint community’s most fragile, and the inadvertent disclosure of the simple ‘fact of’ could alert the adversary and result in immediate loss of the capability,” That's a statement designed to mislead. "the adversary" certainly assumes that the NSA does what it does and acts accordingly. Now, if "the adversary" is the general public, then the statement actually makes sense. EDIT: The consumer is indeed part of "the adversary": Extract of one of Snowden's documents: "These design changes make the systems in question exploitable through Sigint collection … with foreknowledge of the modification. To the consumer and other adversaries, however, the systems' security remains intact." Taken from http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/05/nsa-gchq-encryption-codes-security http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/05/nsa-gchq-encryp...