10 ms·
Japan's maglev train runs test at over 310 mph (with video)
- eriktrautman 13y agoThat makes me curious what the braking performance and stopping distance is relative to normal trains and at different speeds.
- pedrocr 13y agoA quick look at wikipedia[1] shows that these trains often have regenerative braking which means you can have both the wheels and the maglev system stopping the train. So at the same speeds these should be able to brake faster than traditional trains. I assume these have the potential of going significantly faster than normal trains making braking harder. In this test though they didn't reach even the peak speed of normal trains. Apparently the french TGV has the record for normal trains at 575km/h[2] (vs 500km/h in this test) even though normal operation is "only" 320km/h. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglev#Power_and_energy_usage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglev#Power_and_energy_usage [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGV https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGV
- ojii 13y agoThe difference is that the TGV you mentioned was a highly modified version just for this speed record. The L0 [1] shown in the video is planned to be the production train and run 500km/h in actual service. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L0_Series_Shinkansen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L0_Series_Shinkansen
- touristtam 13y agoThen again both train use different technology. Running gear on a TGV is a massive friction generator compared to a maglev, I would think, and consequently the record is very impressive. Still I would love maglev line to be build through Europe.
- LaGrange 13y agoNah. Space and diminishing returns have been the main blocks for improving EU HSR investment since quite a long time. Dedicated lines take up space that could be used by local rail, are expensive to build, and while they work in an all-the-rails-lead-to-Paris mode, in a less centralized country they're significantly less effective. In fact, three countries probably most often praised for railway quality would be Switzerland (barely any HSR, and huge fail, and while they are adding more tracks between Zurich, Bern and Geneva, they're going to be used by local traffic as well), Netherlands (where railways were limited to 140km/h for way too long, and HSR is also limited) and Germany (there is an extensive HSR network, but it's significantly slower than the French one. All also because getting it faster would cost more than it's worth for them). French HSR is excellent, but the railways in general are a bit lacking (but also used to the point of track and station saturation). Anyway, one possibility many people ignore unfairly (in my opinion) for longer routes are night trains: you might arrive on the same day, but modern night trains often offer a hotel-quality accommodation, so I will be there in the morning, rested, and the time I've spent on the train will be time I'm sleeping anyway - so in many ways the trip actually would take less time than for an airplane or fast rail. And it's far more energy efficient as well.
- seszett 13y agoNight trains are great, but only when it's an option. In France, they are basically limited to the south nowadays, when just a few years back at least some used to run up to here, in the west. Most non-HSR offers are being squeezed, seemingly to orient people towards the more lucrative HSR trains.
- masklinn 13y ago575km/h is hardly the peak speed of "normal" trains, V150 was a custom trainset (higher than normal power output, AGV bogies on a POS trainset and 3 cars to the standard 8) and running on a prepared track (increased catenary mechanical tension to handle the speed, and increased voltage from the standard 25kV to 31kV for increased power) Also note that the MLX01 demonstrator (a better equivalent to the customized trainset used in the TGV record) has reached 581km/h. It's also done so on the 42km Yamanashi Maglev Test Line where V150's run took a ~140km section of (non-test) track.
- masklinn 13y agoNot bad, it's not completely clear from the article but checking wikipedia L0 should be a "production" maglev, similar to Shanghai's Transrapid (except Transrapid's maximum operating speed is 410km/h. It did reach 501km/h in early test runs but doesn't reach that on scheduled traffic). It's good to see that tech finally get in production (Japan's maglev demonstrators first breached 500km/h in 1979). FWIW, if all goes well the L0 should be used in the (planned) Chuo-Shinkansen line going straight from Tokyo to Osaka through Nagoya in 67mn: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuo_Shinkansen http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuo_Shinkansen (the fastest runs on the Tōkaidō Shinkansen currently take 2h25)
- mrsharpoblunto 13y agoPretty sure the Shanghai Transrapid does 430kph in regular use, or at least it was the last time I rode on it. Definitely worth taking for the trip from the airport into Pudong if you're ever flying into Shanghai.
- moca 13y agoConsidering the cost, time of construction, time saving, the project doesn't seem to make much sense. China already dropped maglev due to high cost. On the other hand, Japan is making very slow progress on cleaning up its nuclear mess and almost all of its nuclear reactors are suspended right now. Why a new railway is more important than nuclear disaster in hand?
- uniclaude 13y agoRemember how governments work. Transportation and energy are different budgets managed by different entities.
- snogglethorpe 13y agoNot to mention that the Chuo Shinkansen will be privately financed, and is being built by a private company, JR central. They almost certainly need government cooperation (you can hardly escape that with something so huge and covering so much geographical area), but this isn't a Japanese government project, and the government isn't paying for it. From Wikipedia: "On December 25, 2007, JR Central announced that it plans to raise funds for the construction of the Chuo Shinkansen on its own, without government financing."
- warmwaffles 13y agoI wish this mode of transportation would be practical and affordable here in the US. I like the light rail in Denver, and the subways in San Francisco. Made getting around town really easy and affordable. Unfortunately with the distance between cities here it is more practical to take a flight.
- masklinn 13y agoDepends on the cities. NY-SF by train will remain nonsense forever, but the eastern seaboard and a bunch of other clusters (LA-SF, Great Lakes stuff, I think the obama admin had a map of zones they wanted to put HSR proposals for a few years back) could be serviced by high-speed train, even more so with maglev (which extends the competitive range of train against plane) My personal rule of thumb[0] is modern HSTs (280~320km/h top speed) are superior to plane up to ~1000km, and can remain competitive to 1500km. (although, though that's much more of a personal advantage, having really shitty ears and great difficulty with pressure equalization the odd train tunnel — even at high speed — is much less painful than going from 0 to 30k ft and back) [0] modulo specific settings, including the current security theater shit which I don't have to experience on train and considering that most of my experience is on european lines where city center to city center is what you want and airports are commonly 30~40mn away from city center
- blackaspen 13y agoEven with the fact that planes fly slower now than in the 60s, I'll gladly fly DEN-SFO. I can be finishing dinner in Palo Alto when you're in the Salt Flats.
- Anechoic 13y agoUnless it's raining/snowing/windy in Denver or SF (or even an unrelated location like Chicago or Boston which might prevent your aircraft from getting to DEN in the first place) in which case you might be sleeping in an airport terminal while masklinn is finishing a late supper in Palo Alto. I write this as someone who has had two cancellations and 6 delays over ten air trips in the past three months.
- LAMike 13y agoIt's only going to be ready by 2045? Won't better tech be developed in that timeframe making this train obsolete?
- masklinn 13y agoThe core of today's HST tech dates back to the 50s (the 0-series Shinkansen, the latest of which was only retired in 2008, went in service in 1964). And the first section of Chūō Shinkansen should be open in 2027, with partial opening possible as soon as 2020. FWIW, even standard (non-maglev) high-speed rail construction are not short-term projects, the 300km LGV Est Phase 1 took 5 years between the initial earthworks and the line's opening and France isn't exactly as mountainous as Japan.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eob 13y agoIt takes time to vet, test, and build things, especially when representative government and massive land usage planning is involved. Much of the tech in modern airplanes is still from the 1950s and 1960s. The tech developed in the 2020s and 2030s will be in the trains of the 2050s-60s.
- rayiner 13y ago2045 is only ~30 years from now, and part of the line will be operational by 2027. It seems like a long time for people used to computer technology, but it's a typical generational cycle for industrial technology. The 787, for example, which is just trickling into fleets now, was in development since the late 1990's (15 years ago). Power technology has developed even more slowly. E.g. the efficiency of coal power plants has only improved by about a factor of two in the last century or so. Heck, even computer technology is progressing more slowly these days. E.g. I wouldn't call Win2k obsolete, but it's 13 years old now! So yes, the train will be a bit behind the state of the art by the time it's released, but it won't be obsolete.
- 13y ago
- ihsw 13y agoTo put this into perspective, the distance from Tokyo to Osaka is 506KM. It's roughly comparable to: * Ottawa->Toronto (449KM) * LA->San Francisco (622KM) * Washington DC->NYC (363KM)
- rsync 13y ago310 mph in 2013. As opposed to 220 mph top speed in the year 2029 for california "high speed" rail. What a bright, wondrous future we will all be living in!
- thu 13y agoIsn't the maglev to be used publicly only in 2027 ?
- larsbot 13y agoFrom the article: The line between Tokyo and Osaka is expected to cost approximately $90 billion and it won't be completed until 2045 I think California's high speed rail project should be cancelled, but big infrastructure projects do cost a lot of money and take a long time, both in Japan and the US.
- melling 13y agoIt's going to be even more expensive in 30-40 years to build a maglev between LA and SF. Much of the cost is in obtaining the land. Wouldn't it be cheaper to build the first train now then turn it into a 320 mph maglev in 40 years?
- larsbot 13y agoThe cost is going to be high, maybe $100 billion by the time the project is done. Even with the feds helping, that is a huge sum. Are we really going to get the most "bang" for our bucks? How often do people travel between LA and SF anyways? Improve BART, VTA light rail and CalTrain (in the Bay Area), and I suspect it will have a much larger positive impact on the lives of more people.
- thezilch 13y agoGood thing we're building a POS here in CA...
- jusben1369 13y agoWhat's a Point of Sale system have to do with this train?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cpleppert 13y agoI can't imagine there won't be major improvements to conventional high speed rail that will be able to run on existing lines. This requires an entirely new track that can't be used for anything else and the trainset itself can't be upgraded as easily as it is tied to the track. These will be also limited by the noise they produce; even if they can go faster in theory noise pollution is going to be a major issue as is. I'm not sure they have solved most of the tunnel boom problem; a major requirement in Japan. So I wouldn't expect there will be a lot of room for improvement of this design over the next 30-60 years. It will probably cost a lot more than expected as well. Comparatively, there are a lot of new technologies that could deliver major improvements in transportation efficiency and speed without the large capital investment of a maglev line over the next 30-60 years from traditional rail to self-driving cars to new aircraft. I'm really skeptical of the wisdom of this project to be honest. If you want a maglev design you might as well go with a near-vacuum tunnel and more than triple your speed rather than just increase it by 50%. This would also have the advantage of eliminating the noise issue. I believe China is looking at something like that.
- vilhelm_s 13y agoThe vast majority of cost of the project goes towards building the track (through the mountains, 60% of the distance will be inside tunnels). That investment will probably still be useable when train technology improves.
- tacticus 13y agoI think maglevs are actually quieter and have reduced rail\line wear than conventional track already. Though i think a partially evacced tube would be amazing as well.
- Anechoic 13y agoMaglev is quieter (much quieter) than conventional rail at lower speeds (below ~ 90 mph) but at higher speeds, once the aerodynamic noise region kicks in, they get very loud very quickly.
- tgb 13y agoWhy are maglevs so much slower than airplanes? We're looking at a factor of 2 difference and airports don't take over 30 years to install. Isn't the point of a maglev to reduce the friction against the ground, so aren't both planes and maglevs fighting primarily against air resistance? Or is it not that they can't go faster, just that it's too loud or they need to turn too much or something?
- jessriedel 13y agoI think g-forces from turning is a real concern, but so is the fact that there's a lot more air at sea level than 30k feet. Planes land and take off at less than 200 mph.
- adrinavarro 13y agoPlotting (can't be all straight), air density (as mentioned by jessridel). Current high speed trains go at 180-200 mph due to sharply increased consumption above those speeds, even though they could go a lot faster in current setups. In 30 years we'll probably have more efficient airplanes, and less fuel, so higher prices. Maybe it's more expensive in the short term, but it's much more sustainable to have ground-based transportation for trips under 400 or 500 miles. In Spain, we have the Madrid-Barcelona route. It's 50 minutes by plane and 2h30 by train (620 km, 385 miles). Airports are outside cities, stations are in the center of them and very well connected by road and commuter trains from everywhere. It's gone from being one of the busiest air routes to losing more than half of its traffic to high speed train. Why? Much more comfortable and, in the end, takes the same time.
- Patrick_Devine 13y agoAir density on the ground. Air is a lot soupier close to the surface in the troposphere vs way up high in the stratosphere.
- vedant 13y agoMost commercial flights are actually in the troposphere, which is about 17km deep in the temperate zone. Your point is still right: air density at 36000ft is ~0.37 kg/m^3, as opposed to 1.23 kg/m^3 at sea level.
- eliben 13y agoThe price and time-line estimate make me sad and pessimistic for some reason. 30 years and $90 billion just to pull a fast train line between two cities in Japan? How long and how expensive then will real futuristic projects be, like colonization of other planets, space elevators, fusion reactors and so on?
- 6d0debc071 13y agoI wonder how much they're paying for land and tech development in that figure - doing something the first time is often rather expensive.
- rorrr2 13y ago$90 billion is not a large sum of money, considering the pointless wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan costed 3-4 TRILLION dollars. We could've had every major city connected to a maglev network by now if we didn't let politicians spend our tax money on bullshit. Many space missions NASA designs are quite affordable, and the SpaceX innovations will make them even cheaper. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_cost_of_the_Iraq_War#Direct_costs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_cost_of_the_Iraq_War#...
- stcredzero 13y agoI wonder how fast they could make the train if it had the smaller cross-sectional area of the Hyperloop pods? Another way to put it: What about a 310 mph maglev on a solar-panel shaded elevated track between SF and LA?
- Pitarou 13y agoEven better, do away with MagLev altogether, and have them "float" the way an air hockey puck does. (You have read Elon Musk's proposal, haven't you?)
- stcredzero 13y agoI have, but I am thinking more steps ahead than you. The air bearings are at a bit of a disadvantage. There's less experience operating them for this purpose in the less controlled environment outside of an enclosed tube. Also, there's much more operational experience and existing R&D for mass transportation. Lastly, a smaller cross section would give the advantage of reduced drag. Though it would be larger than in the hyperloop case, it would be a lot smaller than the conventional train. (Paid attention to basic economics, physics, and math, haven't you?)
- mrb 13y agoThe article does not mention it, but 310 mph is still below previous maglev's speed records, done 10-15 years ago(!) on the same test line: 361.0 mph in December 2003 343.0 mph in April 1999 329.9 mph in December 1997 See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCMaglev#Manned_records http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCMaglev#Manned_records
- jpatokal 13y agoIt's one thing to set test records with test equipment, and another to set them with production equipment -- this model is the actual train they're going to run on the line. Kind of like how the Bell X-1 was the first supersonic aircraft, but the Concorde was the first commercial supersonic aircraft. (And I have a sneaky suspicion that Japan's maglev, running in a depopulating country with economy in a terminal downward spiral, will end up as marginal and unprofitable as the Concorde, but that's another story.)
- Pitarou 13y agoThe comparison with the Concorde was the first thing that sprang to mind with me, too.
- moca 13y agoShanghai has been operating Maglev line for more than 6 years, see [1] and [2]. The top speed is 431km/h and 268 mph. The Japanese line will have much higher capacity as the Shanghai one is not full production design, but I don't think it has material advantage. The real challenge is economics and noise, and China decided to go with conventional high speed railway system. Even HSR was designed for 350km/h, it is actually operated at 270-300 km/h to reduce operating cost. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Maglev_Train http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Maglev_Train 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-54gBLwK3s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-54gBLwK3s
- kposehn 13y agoOne important note: the Chinese HSR is also operating at reduced speed for safety and rail wear reasons.
- Pitarou 13y agoSigh. I've got nothing against thinking big, but this is not the kind of investment Japan needs right now. BIG money, for only an incremental improvement. (The public transport infrastructure is already very good.) If the boys in the ministry really wanted to boost Japan, they'd be investing in renewable energy, not playing with train sets. But there are too many vested interests...
- snogglethorpe 13y agoThe "ministry" isn't paying for it—it's being privately financed by JR central (which is a private company). From Wikipedia: "On December 25, 2007, JR Central announced that it plans to raise funds for the construction of the Chuo Shinkansen on its own, without government financing."
- Pitarou 13y agoAn accounting trick to keep the debt off the government books. A project of that scale could not possibly happen in Japan without whole-hearted government support. (I know I sound like a grumpy cynic, but I've learnt from experience that one can rarely go wrong being cynical about powerful Japanese institutions.)
- snogglethorpe 13y agoThe government is certainly involved to a degree—you can hardly build something of this scale otherwise, there are simply too many third parties to deal with—but I've seen no reason to think that the financing is "an accounting trick." Simple general cynicism is all well and good, but it isn't really worth much absent actual evidence. This is particularly true in the case of JR-central / east / west, which are well-run and solid companies, and a model for how to do privatization successfully.
- na85 13y agoWhen this baby his 93 mph, you're going to see some serious shit.