10 ms·
This is why the most interesting OC on the 'net seems to come from the swamps of 4chan and reddit (and SA and YTMD and the like). There is very little to gain
by angersock 13y ago
This is why the most interesting OC on the 'net seems to come from the swamps of 4chan and reddit (and SA and YTMD and the like).
There is very little to gain (other than targeted advertising and srs bznz) from giving up anonymity online, and if you make friends somehow you can always coordinate out-of-band.
I'm really sad that so many places want me to integrate my gmail or my real name or my birthday or whatever other bit of personal info I claim into their registers.
We're still recoiling from the NSA stuff: why the fuck should we accept companies that want to do the same things to us?
EDIT:
I'll go one step further. An author I'd read in some scifi story or something similar had suggested that the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy. The idea was that, having embraced moral relativism and given up any attempt at judging people on a cultural basis, nerds and soon the rest of people flocked to the last bastion of the judgemental: chiding others for doing something other than what they'd preached, or saying something different at different points in time.
Without anonymity, it can be very difficult to conduct useful intellectual discourse, especially if you aren't strong-willed enough to deal with trolls and jerks who say "But aha! Yesterday you claimed A, but today B; which is it?".
- dageshi 13y agoOr "your future prospective employer is going to google your name when you apply for a job" In which case I'd suggest you've got a very strong motivation for not posting anything remotely controversial under a real name account.
- angersock 13y agoAt this point, even with my handles and nicks, that cat is out of the bag. I look at it this way: if they wouldn't hire me over something I said online, I don't want to work there anyways.
- dageshi 13y agoThat assumes you'll always have the luxury of being able to pick and choose your job. For you perhaps that's the case, for others it won't always be the case.
- angersock 13y agoI wouldn't want to claim that mindset for anyone other than myself--and again, I support anonymous pseudonyms for people.
- clicks 13y agoYou bring up good points. And speaking of privacy in anonymous forums and NSA snooping, I've been thinking as of late: We can reasonably conclude now that NSA is probably in the game of data mining in a manner much like Google or Facebook, graphing networks and all. Data mining is considerably easier to do on social networking sites like Facebook where there's a push from the beginning to tie accounts to real identities, unlike anonymous forums. Now, the thing is, Reddit/4chan is a breeding ground for contrarian thought, indeed it is where a lot of the interesting stuff is born in the eyes of three-lettered agencies -- half of the Lulzsec memebers were active Redditors, Edward Snowden was a Redditor, every other programmer with unorthodox political interests is on Reddit. So I am really very confident that NSA/FBI keeps a special tab on Reddit, but what I'm curious about is how they go about doing that. I don't think Reddit staff has made a deal with three-letter agencies to help them tie anonymous accounts to real identities... but I wouldn't be surprised if these three letter agencies are putting a concerted effort on gathering data from anonymous networks in hopes of linking all things said and done under the guise of anonymity back to some real world id. (I imagine are probably sitting on a good many zero days, and can presumably carry out operations in which they surreptitiously steal a lot of data that can help them to tie Reddit accounts to real id's, for example).
- hershel 13y agoFirst, basic reddit isn't even encrypted. Many probably use it that way because their https is slow. Now since there are time stamps on reddit posts, even https could be possibly annonimized using traffic analysis. And if you use Tor, there are tools that might work against Tor. Considering all this, the fact that reddit sells anonymity, and people use it for really personal info - which could easily be hacked even by someone with a network sniffer - is not honest.
- morpher 13y agoI don't think the point of this post was anonymity against those with large resources, but rather day-to-day anonymity for social interaction.
- 13y ago
- nnethercote 13y ago> An author I'd read in some scifi story or something similar had suggested that the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy. Sounds like Neal Stephenson's "The Diamond Age": http://steveedney.wordpress.com/2006/11/08/hypocrisy-relativism-and-the-diamond-age/ http://steveedney.wordpress.com/2006/11/08/hypocrisy-relativ...
- angersock 13y agoAha, I believe that was the one!
- berntb 13y ago>> the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy. You must live on a different planet than me. :-) Let me take an example I saw this week: I have some Eastern Europeans with different opinions in my Facebook. One upset discussion right now is about why Russia gets so much criticism for homophobia these days. They assume it is an old Cold War prejudice, since the whole Middle East and much of Africa are something like a factor of ten worse.. And they get almost no media cover. Including the immigrants (at least in Sweden), which have the same opinions. It might be some unspoken racism from the left wing (not expect better of the primitives), but it is probably just hypocrisy -- harsh criticism of an external example as a way to get everyone on the same page. I'm all for tolerance and acceptance of the gay community, but I seem to be quite unusual in being equally shocked by hypocrisy and double standards as by homophobia. Even if you use double thinking in a good cause to spread tolerance in a group, it clouds your analytic capability in the group. That is a bad thing.
- stygianguest 13y agoThis is not hypocrisy and has nothing to do with the cold war. Quite to the contrary: we hold Russians to a higher standard than Saudi Arabia. Like we hold the USA to a higher standard than either country in regards to privacy.
- berntb 13y agoIf totally different standards for different people/countries regarding intolerance is neither hypocrisy nor racism -- what is it? My theory above is that totally different standards for different parts of the world really is political propaganda to the citizens of the country where the media writes. Do you have another explanation? (To take another example -- even with a Palestinian description of Israel, the Sudan atrocities were a thousand times worse. My local leftwing media (more or less all local media) complained many times more about Israel, anyway. And never about that Israel was criticized every year in UN but Sudan very little. How many thousands of times is reasonable for different standards?) Edit: Note when I wrote that immigrants, even citizens now, in Sweden is criticized much less.. Not even that is neither racism nor double standards?!
- RandyRanderson 13y agoI completely agree that you really don't gain anything (as a user) by using a real identity. I'm not so sure the organization gains much on the other side either...
- cstross 13y agoFootnote: An author I'd read in some scifi story or something similar had suggested that the mark of our era was the relentless pursuit and shaming of hypocrisy. That was "The Diamond Age" by Neal Stephenson. Lots of other interesting sociocultural post-scarcity speculation there, too.
- lutusp 13y ago> Without anonymity, it can be very difficult to conduct useful intellectual discourse, especially if you aren't strong-willed enough to deal with trolls and jerks who say "But aha! Yesterday you claimed A, but today B; which is it?". I believe being held to account for one's past actions and present views is called "personal responsibility", and yes, that has certainly fallen out of fashion. If you think being forced to be consistent from moment to moment and day to day hinders useful intellectual discourse, maybe we're using different definitions of "useful".
- Dylan16807 13y agoBeing responsible has nothing to do with not changing your mind. What in the world are you talking about?
- lutusp 13y ago> Being responsible has nothing to do with not changing your mind. Being responsible has everything to do with changing or not changing your mind. An anonymous troll can lie and say, "I never said that." A named person cannot -- he has to accept personal responsibility for his past statements and actions.
- Dylan16807 13y agoI think you're confusing different scenarios. Nobody was talking about lying. A responsible person will respond "I said that, but I changed my mind because X", and everyone should be happy. But in the problem angersock mentions, people complain, accusing hypocrisy as if everything you have ever said in your life was uttered mere moments ago.
- superuser2 13y agoReddit to me serves a completely different purpose from GMail, Facebook, and Google+. Those are for using the internet to talk to people I know (or knew) by real name. If Facebook was pseudonymous I would never touch it again. The only advantage it presents over email is that I can find out about and message someone in my real-world life when all I know is their name. It's email without the need for an address book. Reddit is a community in its own right, just like HN, so it makes sense to have separate identities in those spheres. That's not an argument for letting my friends make me discover and remember AIM-esque screennames just to send them messages.