28 ms·
The salient quote from Greenwald's article on this: They completely abused their own terrorism law for reasons having nothing whatsoever to do with terrorism:
by grey-area 13y ago
The salient quote from Greenwald's article on this:
They completely abused their own terrorism law for reasons having nothing whatsoever to do with terrorism: a potent reminder of how often governments lie when they claim that they need powers to stop "the terrorists", and how dangerous it is to vest unchecked power with political officials in its name. [1]
This is a great example of why we should treat terrorism like any other crime, and why the police should never be trusted with exceptional powers simply because we feel under threat. Give them the powers, and they will be misused - in this case they were used on a relative of someone nothing to do with terrorism purely for the purpose of intimidation. The security services even called Greenwald to give him the news that his partner had been detained.
[1] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/aug/18/david-miranda-detained-uk-nsa http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/aug/18/david-m...
- rolux 13y ago> they were used on a relative of someone nothing to do with terrorism purely for the purpose of intimidation Intimidation is the purpose of anti-terrorism legislation. This is not an abuse of some exceptional powers -- it's their most common use.
- grey-area 13y agoI disagree. These are exceptional powers (they deliberately negate several important rights like the right to know the charges against you and have a lawyer present), and if they are being misused, they should be taken away. They are justified to the population on the basis of extreme measures for extreme opponents - if that is shown to be a smokescreen and the security services to be inveterate liars, I think the population will be far less inclined to accept any calls for special terror laws. The war on terror as an excuse just became rather more transparent.
- rolux 13y agoI'd rather see these powers as an institutionalized state of emergency. They're permanent -- there's no concept of "taking them away". And I'm not so sure about the role of the population either. It's not exactly them who can either accept or not accept the call for such laws. If you had someone, on a national ticket, who would openly call for their abolishment, matters would be different, of course. But then -- how do you get onto a national ticket? A hysterical, broken democracy is a hard thing to fix from inside.
- hga 13y agoThis is the same country that used a slightly later, post-9/11 terrorism act to freeze the assets of an Icelandic bank that were in the country: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landsbanki_Freezing_Order_2008 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landsbanki_Freezing_Order_2008 Icelanders replied with some good pictures: https://www.google.com/search?q=iceland+terrorism&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=iceland+terrorism&tbm=isch Then again this is the country that inspired Nineteen Eighty-Four (Minitrue from Orewell's time at the BBC) and The Prisoner.
- saraid216 13y agoAnd the entire spy film genre. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spy_film http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spy_film
- claudius 13y agoIf you read the Wikipedia article[0] on the ‘Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001’, you will notice that it is not restricted and applicable to areas other than terrorism – serious economic damage to the UK being one of them. So there is at least some slight hyperbole in calling it a ‘post-9/11 terrorism act’, even though its passage was clearly motivated by 9/11. As an aside, what exactly is wrong with freezing the assets of a company that does not appear to plan to meet its liabilities? [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-terrorism,_Crime_and_Security_Act_2001 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-terrorism,_Crime_and_Secur...
- jacquesm 13y agoI wonder from how high up this order came. After all, it's not like Greenwald is going to take this lying down and that's something that they could predict quite accurately ahead of time. To abuse these powers on the partner of the journalist that is reporting the abuses is the worst tactical mistake made by any government to date, short of the diversion of a diplomats plane. Taking into account that the UK law enforcement and Brazil have a bit of a history when it comes to labelling people terrorist wrongly makes it even worse.
- acqq 13y agoThey were able to do two things: 1) Spend 9 hours pressing the guy in order to learn any details they are interested in. He was probably not prepared enough for that, most of people aren't. Apparently, in such an occasion you don't even have the "right to remain silent!" That is, Mr. David Miranda had no Miranda rights there. I guess they had a good laugh. 2) Get anything from the electronic devices. It's reasonable to expect that both GG and his partner aren't crypto security specialists (GG had problem even starting using crypto). That they make the pressure to the journalists they saw as the added bonus. Obviously they don't expect that the "public" reacts much. Note also that UK has laws where you have to give your passwords to the police.
- jacquesm 13y ago1) That's a huge assumption. Especially given that he went to see Laura Poitras 2) Sure, but for that they didn't need to seize them, they could have copied them. I take it that Greenwald et al are smart enough to use an encrypted dead drop on the net rather than to hand-carry unencrypted bits with the keys in the head or the possession of the carrier. From the government perspective I can see only bad stuff coming from this, it is a very clear abuse of the law, it will take a lot of tapdancing to explain this one away as a rogue employee.
- acqq 13y agoI guess they estimated that there won't be many occasions where they'd have to explain that at all. When the Bolivian president's plane was already taken down, who's gonna react about the "ordinary Brazilian guy" kept on the customs? Moreover, TSA already prepared the people to be numb about the inconveniences at the airports. It became hard to make news about that.
- muzz 13y ago> This is a great example of why we should treat terrorism like any other crime Perhaps it is, but the American people don't seem to want that. Kerry voiced a similar opinion in 2004 and Bush took great advantage by pointing that out. Popular opinion appeared to be on Bush's side i.e. that terrorism is not a law enforcement matter: http://www.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/10/10/bush.kerry.terror/ http://www.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/10/10/bush.kerry.terror/
- oscargrouch 13y agoto see how bad thing is, because its was the UK government abusing its use of force to a brazillian citizen.. so.. the point remains.. things are very much out of control just because a bunch of red necks dont understand what civil rights is, and became puppets of a terrible president.. if you guys did want to burn your constitutional rights, what the rest of the world got to do with it?! we value civil liberties, civil rights and freedom.. i know half north-america also do.. but you must put these guys under control, at least until their IQ raise a little bit, so they cannot push the buttons if your country machinery.. but anyway, now it was also the UK.. we could see this one comming from the US, but UK? as sex pistols would say: nevermind the bollocks All of our contries has its own bad apples, but its a pretty bad thing when they are running our governments.. shame on you UK!
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThe very fundamental underlying premise of the entire US constitution is the idea that government power should always be carefully limited and extremely well checked. It's shocking how far we've drifted from that ideal. Unchecked power in the hands of folks with good intention can sometimes be used to great affect to achieve good ends but almost inevitably such powers fall into the hands of folks who would abuse them. More so, even people operating under what they consider to be good intentions can lead to tragedies of unimaginable proportions.
- anologwintermut 13y agoI hate the governments expanded terrorism powers too, but the "we should treat it as a crime" policy is either a naive statement or one where it's non-obvious how to go about it. The criminal justice system is used to punish criminals and through that deter crime. This has little effect on a suicide bomber (nor does the ability to detain people for 9 hours for that matter). At the same time, treating terrorism prevention as a police mater appears to militarize the police.
- regularfry 13y agoIt's not aimed at the suicide bomber. It's aimed at the person convincing them to strap the vest on. As any organisation, you don't survive very long by detonating your leadership class.
- anologwintermut 13y agoOk, but the leadership class is usually in a foreign country. Historically, hostile foreign countries or ones where you can't trust the local government. So to get people in those countries, you need a militarized police force. We could have sent in police to arrest OBL in Pakistan, but they would have looked a lot like seal team 6 ( or maybe we could have had the Pakistanis do it, but that doesn't work in all cases. For example, the Taliban in 2001 would not have helped us) Also, the leadership may not care about their consequences too much either, other than preferably living to fight another day.
- j_baker 13y agoI think the officials who do things like this should be prosecuted under the same terrorism laws they're supposed to be enforicing. This is clearly an act of terrorism on the part of the NSA and GCHQ.
- norswap 13y agoUsing anti-terrorist laws to terrorize. Clever.