15 ms·
Ripping Off Young America: The College-Loan Scandal
- koppo 13y agosure there must be some wall street guys betting on a college-loan bubble like they did for the housing-loans.
- rayiner 13y agoBetting on what instrument? Loans are mostly federal. For what it's worth, the student loan program is solidly in the black for the federal government.
- toomuchtodo 13y ago"The U.S. government is forecast to generate $185 billion in profit over the next decade from students and their families under an overhaul of the federal student loan program endorsed by the White House and approved by the Senate on Wednesday. The profit figure, if annually averaged through 2023, would place the U.S. student loan program among the 20 most profitable public companies in the world, according to Fortune magazine’s annual list of the world’s 500 biggest companies. The bipartisan Senate bill would increase the government’s profit off student borrowers by more than $700 million compared with existing law, the Congressional Budget Office said." http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/24/obama-student-loan-profit_n_3648747.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/24/obama-student-loan-...
- rayiner 13y agoHonestly, I'm okay with the student loan system, I just think schools need to face tuition caps to be eligible for federal student loans. My wife and I have substantial student loans from law school. We got good jobs and can afford to pay. Meanwhile, lots of people don't and can't, and rely on the governments very generous and flexible repayment terms. As long as the program as a whole turns a profit, its a cross-subsidy, and I think that's great. People who take student loans should be uniquely willing to pay to spread out the risk.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoLet me take this a step further then. If we're going to cap tuition (price controls), why not increase taxes as well? College becomes much cheaper ($10K for your degree, not your semester), and society, the student, and every future employer benefits. I understand people don't like taxes sometimes. Even me. But with them, I buy civilization.
- rayiner 13y agoThere is a place for that, but the thing I like about the student loan system is that the people who benefit from the system pay for it. I think we have too many taxes in the US where the benefits aren't broadly distributed, which undermines support for those programs.
- jessaustin 13y agoI'm not an investment adviser, but I have to think there are many ways to bet on a rise in bankruptcies among young working people.
- iyulaev 13y agoExcept education loans don't get cleared in bankruptcy!
- tghw 13y agoNo, but it'll help send them to bankruptcy.
- jessaustin 13y agoYes, that's what I meant. Bankruptcy won't get the federal mafia off your back, but it will discourage all lesser loan sharks.
- NoPiece 13y agoWhat about betting against for profit universities which, on the shadier side, seem to be using unqualified students to grab federal loan money? Seems like they could get hit hard if the loan money starts to dry up.
- ihsw 13y agoIt will be interesting to see how Oregon's Pay-It-Forward will pan out, but it will take half a century to get any real data: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/03/pay-it-forward-oregon-tuition-free_n_3543827.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/03/pay-it-forward-oreg... Ohio has also shown interest: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/18/ohio-tuition-plan-oregon_n_3616473.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/18/ohio-tuition-plan-o...
- Zimahl 13y agoCommenting as an Oregonian, it isn't going to solve any problems it just makes college more accessible, allowing students to kick the can down the road. College is still too expensive and costs have risen for no reason. I went to state college in Washington (Washington State, go Cougs) and when I started there tuition was $1300 (semester system, so $2600 per year). My middle-class parents were easily able to cover my full costs (tuition, room and board), with a part-time job I contributed to room and board. It's now well over $9000 (insert Dragonball Z joke here) for the year just for tuition. Now, I'd have had to graduate with student loans. There's just too much waste in the college system and I have no idea where it's going. Facilities? Sports? Salaries? Marketing? It's certainly not inflation or value since salaries are stagnant pretty much across the board.
- gte910h 13y agoI'm fine if costs stay where they are....as long as there is a mandatory forgiveness 15 or so years past graduation. Then lenders will discriminate based on major (as it should be) and not fund english degrees and other such things that we have a glut of.
- Zimahl 13y agoThe problem is costs won't stay where they are, they just keep climbing for no reason. The quality is only marginally better, if that. It is one thing if the states are covering less tuition for their constituents that would make the cost rise make sense, but out-of-state tuition has almost doubled since I started college back in the mid-90s. Here's the problem. My alma mater is Washington State. They want to be a 'world class' college and it's a nice goal, but that's not the point of the state system. World class costs way too much money for little benefit. I'm not saying aim low, but be realistic. The job of a state institution is to provide an affordable opportunity for those who might not have otherwise. It's not Harvard or Stanford but it's accessible and it allows for upward mobility.
- cliveowen 13y agoYou can tell Matt Taibbi's articles just by looking at the title.
- graeme 13y agoMatt Taibbi isn't the author of that article. You saw an ad for one of his articles buried in the text of the article. Edit: Well, I was wrong. I realized that on my mobile, I read "By Victor Juhasz", referring to the photo credit.
- twoodfin 13y agoNo, he is the author. And if nothing else, it provided me with the pleasant knowledge that I think he's a terrible writer even when I agree with him.
- disgruntledphd2 13y agoReally, I think he's somewhat wonderful. The way he marshals words in the service of outrage, anger and disenchantment with authority is extremely appealing to me, even when I disagree with him.
- twoodfin 13y agoThat's my problem with him. What do you learn from this article except to be outraged? Surely the folks perpetuating this system aren't all mustache-twirling villains: Somebody out there has a case to make for the current system, but Taibbi isn't at all interested in that case.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoThere were plenty of balanced articles about the faults of the student loan system. Nobody noticed, and now student loan debt has grown to be the largest source of consumer debt, even with the ease of obtaining credit cards, mortgages, and car loans.
- gxs 13y agoAmazing, perspective is everything. I don't deny that college kids are being taken advantage of. Graduating from a small liberal arts college in South Dakota that no one's ever heard of with a degree is Culture Studies and 80k in debt really is a rip off. The flipside of this coin however is someone like me. My parents are immigrants and I was the first to go to school. To my parents, the fact that someone would be even willing to give you money to go to school is ridiculous. I graduated with 20k in debt with a math degree from Cal. The ease of getting loans and financial aid are the main reasons I was able to attend college as my family was otherwise poor, at least at the time. In some countries, you don't even have the OPTION to take out a loan to go to school. You either have the money and you go, or you don't and it is that much harder to climb the social ladder. I'm not sure which evil is worse, but I'm damn glad I was offered those loans.
- geebee 13y agoYou used these loans wisely. When did you go to Cal? I was a grad student there in 1999-2000, and the tuition for the year was only a little over $4,000. It's much higher than that now, about $15,000 for the year. That's still relatively low, assuming that you're an academic student. Professional schools can charge what they like ("data science" is 60K!) It's still possible to get an excellent education for less money. Part of this is that we need a cultural shift as well as an institutional one. Four years of cal is now very expensive (about 60K in tuition). But a lot of immigrants (many in my neighborhood) go to 2 years of community college (while living at home to keep costs down), finish at a UC, and study something with good job prospects. That's not reading poetry by the the leafy glen next to a beautiful old building, but at least it is affordable. I suppose I shouldn't just say "immigrants", I do know california natives who do this to, plenty of them, but it doesn't really fit the traditional middle class notion of "4 years of college, away from the parents". Also - Cal has a good name, but rankings like US News and World Report haven't helped either. They reward colleges for everything that costs money, but they don't reward colleges for keeping costs under control or for enrolling low income students. Not a single public institution in the USNWR undergrad top 20, including UC Berkeley. Bill Bennet, the republican and quite conservative former secretary of Education, made some very good points about this in a recent book "is college worth it". His take on it is, if you get into stanford, go. If you are inclined to study petroleum engineering, go (PE used as a stand-in for highly employable majors), even if you go to a small college in South Dakota (though if it's engineering you're studying, state schools are often more prestigious than their private counterparts, especially in the western states). The danger is in between. Don't go to an unknown third tier school and run up a huge debt studying liberal arts - or, if you do, make sure you double major with something that will lead to better employment. One thing - I don't want to give the impression that I think a cultural shift is all that is needed. Students do need to turn away from the high-cost model, but the government did play a role in this problem. Unfortunately, making loans available wasn't helpful to many students. By guaranteeing the loans, the government made it possible for students to borrow far more than a private lender would have considered prudent. By changing the bankruptcy laws around student loans, the government created a far more poisonous form of debt for students. And then lastly, by making the money so freely available, the government allowed institutions to raise their prices - so even if students wanted to "just say no" to high prices, institutions knew they could charge this cause someone would take out the loan. In short, the gov't may have ensured that the low cost education that would have been demanded never emerged.
- error54 13y agoRemember a while back when the price of gold skyrocketed and suddenly there were all "Cash 4 Gold" places that were willing to pay you "good money" for your gold. I've noticed the same thing has happened with the education system with a of a bunch of college popping up seemingly out of nowhere with promises of making more money by having a better career. The whole college system seems like a racket to saddle people with debt that takes them often decades to pay off. The ironic part is that despite more and more people going to college, our overall educational rank in the world hasn't improved. Oh and don't get me started on the college textbook scam.
- jessaustin 13y agoYeah when there is growth in easy-to-qualify loans that may only be spent with one industry, that industry will prosper. The great part about it (for schools) is that they don't actually have to work that hard to lobby for more government-underwritten education loans. ...our overall educational rank in the world hasn't improved. If you just look at the top end, it isn't actually possible for the USA to improve its rank. ( http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/world-university-rankings/2012-13/world-ranking http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/world-university-ranki... ) I know there are some awful lower-level schools, but I assume there are all over the world as well.
- codegeek 13y agoon that note, I work on wall st and there is a Cash 4 Gold store right on wall st. Go figure!!
- mbesto 13y agoI am seriously interested in understanding how an individual would go about shorting college loan securities. I have no doubt in my mind that this the next big crisis just waiting to burst.
- nonchalance 13y agoUnless you have the money to cut a deal with a major investment bank (like how paulson worked with GS to short MBS), you could just try to amass as much student loan debt as possible and wait for the government to force lenders to take a haircut. That way, you "win" insofar as the cash you have exceeds how much you have to pay back. But TBH it's a really really bad idea because if there is a 100% federal backstop you will end up losing. You could also short servicers and lenders like Apollo Group (NASDAQ:APOL) and Nelnet (NYSE:NNI). If you asked me for a compelling short in the space, I would say DeVry (NYSE:DV), but do your own due diligence before entering a trade
- stygiansonic 13y agoWell you could always take up a short position in Sallie Mae (SLM), however such an undertaking would be fraught with risk. They are a GSE, though both Freddie and Fannie were as well. And don't forget the timeless Kenyes quote: "Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent." (paraphrased)
- jacquesm 13y agoOne big problem I have with college loans is that people that sign up for it are not adequately informed on the long term consequences of their action. Since this is a loan for education one would expect that before being allowed to sign for the loan there would be a test that you'd have to pass to be able to apply. That would get rid of a lot of people that find out the hard way that they've borrowed themselves into a very deep hole. Job prospects, interest rates, cumulative interest, evaluating the small print and so on. There are many ways to get burned on a student loan and there is only one way you can get out, and that way out takes not just skill but also considerable luck and long term stability. A few of our Canadian employees were saddled with long term versions of these and we managed to get rid of those, and we managed to keep one intern out of debt by paying him enough that he didn't have to apply for a loan. I don't think student loans are bad in and of themselves, they just don't work out for everybody and for quite a few people that get squeezed by them the risks were not readily apparent when they entered into the agreement. Student loans are a tool, and like any other tool they required some study and mastery to make the most of them.
- brucehart 13y agoI don't know if the rules have changed since I was in college, but I actually did have to take an online test showing I understood the nature of student loans before my loans could be approved.
- jacquesm 13y agoThat would be very good news. The time I'm talking about is the year 2000.
- RougeFemme 13y agoAs of last year, that online test is still required.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoI learnt how compound interest worked long before high school. I don't mean to sound unsympathetic, but the notion that people who have applied to and been accepted to a university wouldn't be capable of making simple cost/benefit decisions or understand the consequences of a loan should be laughable. The fact that so many people are apparently approaching graduating without yet having thought about the consequences is a sign that our education system sucks long before student loans become an issue. edit: I recently discussed this with a friend who just received an MBA with an emphasis on finance. He was complaining that the interest rates on his loans had gone up every year, even before he started graduate school. It's disgusting that he could be accepted to a graduate school to study finance and didn't see that one coming.
- splrb 13y agoStudents didn't want to go to Vietnam and stopped it. Students are getting plundered for going to college, it's probably time to stop that too.
- albemuth 13y agoStudents in Chile did: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011%E2%80%9312_Chilean_student_protests http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011%E2%80%9312_Chilean_student...
- vaadu 13y agoA degree that provides the recipient with little foundation for income should not be underwritten with tax dollars. You want a teaching or nursing degree, I'm there. If you want a degree in puppetry, not happening.
- itsybitsycoder 13y agoIn many parts of the English-speaking world, there is such a glut of teachers that a teaching degree doesn't give you a much bigger shot at a career than a puppetry degree. And of course, this all depends on supply/demand, which can change significantly and unpredictably over the course of a new graduate's working life. So how exactly are you going to make this call?
- minikites 13y agohttp://press.princeton.edu/titles/9112.html http://press.princeton.edu/titles/9112.html > Historically, the humanities have been central to education because they have rightly been seen as essential for creating competent democratic citizens. But recently, Nussbaum argues, thinking about the aims of education has gone disturbingly awry both in the United States and abroad. Anxiously focused on national economic growth, we increasingly treat education as though its primary goal were to teach students to be economically productive rather than to think critically and become knowledgeable and empathetic citizens. This shortsighted focus on profitable skills has eroded our ability to criticize authority, reduced our sympathy with the marginalized and different, and damaged our competence to deal with complex global problems. And the loss of these basic capacities jeopardizes the health of democracies and the hope of a decent world. I know this is Hacker News and any non-STEM field is generally disrespected, but the liberal arts are quite important.
- WalterBright 13y agoI categorically reject the notion that STEM does not teach critical thinking. After all, STEM fields have a built in reality check for one's thoughts. If you design an airplane and it doesn't fly, you're forced to develop critical thinking skills so that doesn't happen again. Physical reality isn't going to bend to your thoughts.
- johngalt 13y agoI don't see how an obvious result could be considered a scandal. We beat the drum for 30 years that all HS students must go to college and pursue their dreams of being marine biologists. We offer loans that people are unqualified to repay; allowing costs to balloon without constraining demand.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- codegeek 13y agoThe student loan issue is kinda like the Health Insurance issue in America (strictly an opinion). Prices are driven up because colleges can charge whatever they wish and the students pay for it in the form of loans mostly backed by the Government (STAFFORD etc.). Colleges have no incentive to reduce tuition cost because the money flows either way (student or the govt. ). Remove the option of getting subsidized/backed by the Govt, the colleges will either have to reduce the fee or be at the risk of not getting enrollments and ultimately lose money. They don't want that. No one does. Similarly, remove the middleman i.e health insurance companies, doctors/hospitals can directly charge a patient and voila, a visit to get stitches will not be billed at $1000.
- jonlucc 13y agoI wish it were that simple. I think if you remove the government backed loans, the private loan market will be happy to have no competition.
- jessaustin 13y agoWe'd also want to restore the force of bankruptcy for these loans. When the student loan goons have to get in line with all the other sharks, student loans won't seem so much like free money for them. Also, it's precious to describe a market that the government has exited as then having "no competition".
- parennoob 13y agoAs someone who comes from outside the USA, it is always extremely surprising to me how much just the fact of getting a college degree is lionized here. New graduates are made to think they are accomplishing a great deal just by virtue of having graduated, i.e. having completed the minimum requirements laid out by their program. I can't count the number of Facebook statuses I have seen that say "So proud I'm graduating!!!!" or something to that effect, without having even a vague concept of what to do after that are cheered on and congratulated by similarly clueless people. Add in a mix of pictures in those $70 graduation caps and gowns effing everywhere, and you have the recipe for something younger students will rush into doing without thinking of the consequences. I think an immediate lessening of the adulation showered on people who have graduated from college, and an increase in the respect for those who have actually learned a useful trade or done something (note: a summer exchange program in Europe that your parents or the Govt. paid for does not count) would go a long way towards getting people to think carefully before signing up for one of these predatory loans.
- tghw 13y agoWhat really breaks this is that the current education bubble is essentially unpoppable. Until lenders start losing more by allowing people to default on student loans, they have no incentive to turn down anyone. And with all of that money so readily available, colleges can keep increasing tuition, since the loans will always provide enough students to fill their classes. The problem with fixing this, however, is that any measure that makes loans less available will be seen as a negative, since it will limit who can go to college. In a country where people have declared that everyone should be able to go to college, this will be a very unpopular position. We need social acceptance of some viable alternative, like vocational schools to fill our ever dwindling ranks of skilled workers. * Note, this comment is focused on the US. I don't know enough about other country's systems to comment on them.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoI agree with this comment so much! The negative stigma of "only" doing high school is so harmful. Take welders for instance. It's an honest job, provides a useful and necessary service. If somebody finds welding interesting enough to occupy them and satisfy their career ambitions, it's a smart decision not to go to college. They will contribute to society just as well for their choice.
- RougeFemme 13y agoI recently attended a high school graduation - in America - where one of the top 5 students planned to become a certified underwater welder. Granted, this was not the most academically competitive high school in the area, but still a pretty decent one. You could hear the audience gasp. But then we all applauded. Afterward I told her I admired her guts, not only for her unusual vocational choice, but also for ultimately deciding in college. She applied to several, was accepted and received partial scholarships to all, but decided that she wasn't "crazy" for being #5 in her class and deciding to forego college.
- danielweber 13y agoEmployers are allowed to discriminate against people with "only" a high school education. This is not so bad in a society where 10% of the people have a college degree. Because there are still a lot of smart -- to say nothing of hard-working -- people who don't go to college. It is bad in a society with 70% of people have a college degree. What kind of idiot weirdo doesn't go to college?[1] [1] NB: I really don't subscribe to that view, but employers do, for rational reasons.
- anExcitedBeast 13y agoRolling Stone should stick to music.
- theorique 13y agoThe major problem is that university administrations are becoming top heavy. Instead of hiring tenure-track faculty to teach real subjects like computer science or mechanical engineering (or even English lit, so as not to be prejudiced to the humanities), universities are creating $300K per year sinecure positions like "Vice-President and Associate Dean of Student Diversity". Guess who pays for this? Students and their families.
- pekk 13y agoThere's no way to win this issue. If you don't give loans, you are doing wrong. If you do give loans, you are doing wrong. If you expand no-strings grants, those are expanding entitlements.
- ScottWhigham 13y agoI think that's an over-simplification - "this issue" is not just about funding; it's also about costs. Ultimately costs have to come down - if costs come down, then so much of this is not an issue (or at least goes back to being what it was in the 80s and 90s).
- wil421 13y agoI know plenty of people in this same situation, degree in psychology, social work, communications and my favorite opera, with a mound of debt accruing. All while they struggle to pay off their debt while working at the same college job they had, working at a restaurant waiting tables or being a barista at Starbucks. Some of these people are in way over their head and beyond just the government loans. A few of them went to smaller private colleges and accrued well over 150K. Luckily I was in a technical degree (Information Systems but I didnt graduate from the business school ;-), Math and Science school along with the CS majors) and was able to get a few job offers before settling on what I considered the best one.
- maerF0x0 13y agoIts interesting to me that they didnt mention the fact that the Gov't is essentially upgrading an asset. It seems to me that people w/ degrees on average earn more. If they on average earn more, their taxes ought to be higher as well. So the student is borrowing money at interest, to upgrade themselves and in turn will also pay the government more money in the long run. Seems like a great deal for the Gov't.
- altoz 13y agoFirst, about half of people that go to college don't graduate in 6 years. That means the asset isn't upgraded but the costs and loans still live on. http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2013/02/27/college_completion_rates_54_percent_of_first_time_students_graduate_within.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_slatest/2013/02/27/college_co... Second, the very idea that college "upgrades" the asset is specious at best. http://www.amazon.com/Academically-Adrift-Limited-Learning-Campuses/dp/0226028550 http://www.amazon.com/Academically-Adrift-Limited-Learning-C... Third, people with degrees do earn more, but remember that they actually take four years or more off. That's 4 years of taxes and raises that the government doesn't get. Given wages in a lot of non-degree jobs that don't require degrees (public employee unions and public safety work come to mind), this is not an insignificant amount.
- cko 13y agoIt's just strange to me that "technology" is improving yet costs of "education" is increasing at rates that cannot be explained by inflation (and also "medical care" but I digress). Fifteen years ago I remember wanting an encyclopedia set to read and my computer was ten times crappier than any entry level smartphone on the market. > The New York Times did a story earlier this year declaring the college degree to be the "new high school diploma" I have developed this view from reading links from Hacker News, that every reader/contributor taught themselves how to code from the age of ten and subsequently freelance/consult/sold their startups for decent money, and would therefore find that statement laughable. Yet in my experience this view is so entrenched within the middle class - that in order to learn a skill you have to have information spoon fed to you, that people who are self-taught anything are geniuses. I'm a pharmacist learning how to code and when I tell my coworkers that I would someday like to be an entrepreneur web developer, they say "but you have to go to school for that... " Yet most knowledge is a few Google searches away. Maybe the first few searches you don't really know what you're even looking for, but as you read and gain familiarity with the vocabulary of your subject of interest, it's all there. So the idea of a college diploma as a surrogate marker for aptitude/potential/diligence is very much the perspective of my family and coworkers. There's got to be a better way of finding data, ranking it in terms of credibility/robustness, and testing for knowledge (startup idea?). With all the stuff that's available out there shouldn't we all be building solar-powered Arduino robots that can produce food and defend our family? Information is more accessible now than ever with more powerful tools to gather them, and many people still buy into showing up physically to a lecture hall and then filling in bubbles on a narrow strip of paper for four years for a beautiful piece of parchment.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoIMO, The issue is that it is a near societal necessity that everyone go to college, but the cost of it has not been lowered to reflect that. There is a supply of students, and the universities know it. Competition amongst schools for top talent is easily reflected in sports where colleges go head over heels to pay a student athlete's way through school if they would just play for them. The tables would need to be reversed to affectively lower the price of education as universities competed for students. Essentially, remove the abundance of students or introduce more universities to compete against the currently entrenched. That would be a free market method, because this regulated version isn't working out. Somethine
- Balgair 13y agoMy brother now works at a University of California school. He says that the professors are in on the con-game; they know that the kids know that this is all a bubble. Trouble is, everyone involved is tied to the mast. The admins can't find other work for this kind of money, the profs have tenure, the grad students can only otherwise work slinging dope or burgers, and the undergrads have even worse prospects than the grads. Its a mess. And it can't continue, and everyone knows it. One real wave generator is the MOOCs. The profs know it. At UCLA they just started allowing kids to take classes completely virtually. If the class is too full for the fire marshal, you can opt to take it online completely. The profs fought it, but lost. They all knew that was the camel's nose in the tent. Look to see MOOCs take the place of degrees real soon. Man though talk about a 'flat world'
- CoachRufus87 13y agoThe problem w/ MOOCs are that many students lack the discipline to successfully finish the class. A blended approach (classroom + online) is the best combination, imo.
- Balgair 13y agoI agree! Imagine taking a chem class entirely online without a lab. Obviously, certain classes need the skills and hands on approach. Also, Weight Watchers is a good example here. The effort to loose 50 lbs. and the effort to learn calculus are comparable. You do need that social component to motivate you along. Ok, ok, I need it. Still, the days of the professor-preacher are coming to a close. The days of the super-star explainers and lots of grunt lab assistants are coming. Sort-of like Turbo-Tax and the accounting industry.
- RyJones 13y agoThat's what we found at CTLT (former part of Washington State University); distance learning + some classroom time was better than distance learning.
- scott_s 13y agoThe NY Times did a seven-part series last year that I felt was a much more thorough and nuanced treatment of the topic: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/13/business/student-loans-weighing-down-a-generation-with-heavy-debt.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/13/business/student-loans-wei...
- scott_s 13y agoAlso, "For Poor, Leap to College Often Ends in a Hard Fall": http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/23/education/poor-students-struggle-as-class-plays-a-greater-role-in-success.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/23/education/poor-students-st...
- danielweber 13y agoI said it before, but this points it out all the more: the educational credential race hurts the poor the hardest. Even if college was cheap and guaranteed to graduate, it would still be the poor who could least end up able to sacrifice 4-9 years of their life on it.
- ianhawes 13y agoI like the name "The Silent Bubble" for this impending crisis because when it bursts, the voices of the millions of Millenials this affects will be drowned out by the constant bitching of the Baby Boomers.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoAll real bubbles are silent. Just because everyone screams "bubble" at any growth curve, does not mean that anybody knows for sure when it is going to burst. Eventually most growth curves falter or crash every so often. Then the same people will say "Ha! I knew it was a bubble for the last ten years!"
- northwest 13y agoFirst of all, high school and college education is supposed to be covered by tax money. It is in the country's general interest. But no, your tax money goes to more important issues, like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- JonFish85 13y agoWhatever happened to personal responsibility? You're 18, you can smoke, drive, join the army and take out gigantic loans you can't repay. It's a fine line between making it easy for everyone to go to college and making it easy for a mathematically disinclined person to take out a huge loan for a dumb reason. It would be great for everyone to have the chance to go to some college. For some reason, people seem to immediately want to get the Porsche experience when they should be opting for the Honda. So should the government step in to say "hey you can't afford to go to X school because it's too expensive", or should the government allow people to take the risk? Should more be done to push people into in-state schools, where tuition is often orders of magnitude cheaper? The people in the article bemoan how easy it is to just sign these documents. Whose fault is that? They didn't read what they're signing for? Isn't that their own damn fault? Couldn't you say the same about stupid car loans? Stupid short-term loans? No one forced them to go to college, especially not one that leaves them $40k in debt. In my opinion, too much has been made of the "follow your dreams and let the rest sort itself out" is a big reason for this. Sometimes you have to weigh following your dreams and figure out if that's your life-long dream or just "hey that sounds like fun". Just because you get accepted to a great school doesn't mean you can afford it or should go there.
- jlgreco 13y agoIn this case, going for the Porsche experience is fine even if you can't afford it, so long as you are smart about it. Make sure you have a plan to pay it off after graduating, and make sure you have a contingency plan if you fail to graduate (you should find state schools with programs that you can fall back on before even starting at your "Porsche school"). The problem is people want the Porsche experience, and have a bizarre notion that they shouldn't have to do the planning and are entitled to just study whatever pleases them. Either of those two attitudes by themselves are more or less fine, but when you combine them then you get problems.
- citricsquid 13y agoFrom the first day of school children are taught two things, to obey authority and if you want to make something of yourself, go to college. A large number of people go to college because they believe that is what they have to do, they've had it drilled into their heads that if you want to be successful, you go to college. If you can go to college, whatever the cost, you go to college. No one is forced at gun point to go to college but they are pressured into it throughout their entire lives, most people truly believe that they need to go to college to be successful, to end up with a spouse, a house and children, they think college is the only path. You can quit smoking, you don't have to drive, you can leave the army after a few years, but what you can't do is reverse the decision to take on student loans, they're just not comparable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- megaframe 13y agoMy feeling is we should put the burden on the Colleges or the Loan providers. Make it so if the student fails to graduate, or graduate and cannot get a job in their field they're forced to pay the loan or at least the loan interest. Their incentive would then become to avoid loosing money and only give out loans of appropriate sizes to people who's college degree has a high probability of investment return. The way it's setup now, the only person who's invested in having a high investment return is the student who usually can't grasp the concept of a loan this large and what it means for their future. Their's probably some balance between this all out harsh approach and what we have now to allow for smaller loans with high risk so students can attend in state universities without bankrupting the university, but an incentive change is needed.
- ScottWhigham 13y agoMake it so if the student fails to graduate, or graduate and cannot get a job in their field In other words, "If the kid doesn't graduate, all of the other students should pay for that kids chance at an education." Do I have that right? If that's your point, why not do away with tuition all together and just have the state/feds pay for "College for everyone"?
- tzs 13y agoThe really interesting question, which for some reason almost no one asks, is why are college costs so low? Most good schools, both private and public, have more qualified applicants than they have space for. Normally, when demand exceeds supply, we expect prices to go up to the point that demand falls to match supply. Yet college stays well below that point.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jellicle 13y agoPeople call this is a bubble. But it lacks one characteristic of a bubble: it can't burst in the usual way. Usually, people bankrupt out or sell assets, creating a cascading effect (lots of bankruptcies or lots of selling). That ends a bubble. But student loan borrowers can't do that - they can't get out of the game via bankruptcy (student loan debts will even be extracted from your social security payments, should that be required), and they can't sell the (possibly overpriced) asset they bought, a university education. There's no exit possible. So for current borrowers, they're totally trapped, forever. Leaving the country is their only escape, which itself is difficult. Many of them will spend their entire lives, from age 18 until they die of old age, on the edge of poverty with an unpayable loan balance looming over their heads. The bubble can't pop! The only way there can be a pop is if they all commit suicide at once. What it can do is slowly deflate. What this looks like: an entire generation decides, possibly through seeing the suffering endured by their parents, that college is a bad deal. "Son, don't make the mistake I made." They stop going. No borrowing, no college attendance. My prediction: emigration and noticeably lower college attendance in the future.
- altoz 13y agoThere's another alternative. You can change laws so that student loans will be dischargeable via bankruptcy. It's not popular yet, but more stories like this and that's a much more likely path. Libertarians on the right and Socialists on the left both agree on this one.
- scottmagdalein 13y agoMy (American) cousin has a degree in German from a fancy school. She's now 30, a Zumba instructor, and still living with roommates in an apartment to keep costs down while paying for student loans. She loves her job, but the debt of college is a complete waste for her.
- gyardley 13y agoI don't really think the government should be in the student loan business at all -- but if the government absolutely has to be in the student loan business, then they have to be in the cost-control business as well. That's pretty much how Canadian higher education worked when I was an undergraduate in the mid-90s. There were no private universities, and the government set the university budget. It more or less worked. Canadian universities looked and still look a lot shabbier than their American counterparts, since not nearly as much is spent on facilities, but the education is fine. In America, perhaps the government could only give loans to students of universities who kept cost increases below the rate of inflation or met certain tuition targets. The best of the private universities would opt-out, and the rest would fall into line. Unfortunately, the American government doesn't have the will to do any meaningful cost-control, so this isn't going to happen.
- whiddershins 13y agoIf people need college degrees to perform basic functions in a company, why don't employers subsidize the colleges. After all, they need employees!
- reubensutton 13y agoThe British system is an interesting twist on it, government loans pay for the majority of people to go to university, then the loans are subject to interest at the rate of inflation, and are repaid at 9% of your pre-tax earnings over £15000 per year. So, if you earn £25000 a year, you repay £900 a year.
- aspensmonster 13y agoI wouldn't call myself a victim of the college-loan scandal. I would however call myself an unwilling participant. I see plenty of opining in this thread so far. Might as well jump in :) One big recurring element in many of these comments is this idea that the private schools are a rip-off, while the cuddly old state schools are the choice of the smart, frugal, cost-conscious twentysomething. There's just one problem: state tuition has been rising faster than inflation and real wages for quite a while now. Certainly not as quickly Ivy League institutions of course. And no doubt State U will be cheaper than Ivy U. But let's not fool ourselves into thinking that State U is the panacea to the cost problem. While it might have made sense at one point to live at home and work part time --or full time but only during the summer-- now it doesn't matter what you do for work because it couldn't possibly pay off the tuition and fees for the semester and leave you with something left over to coast on. And that's assuming of course that you're still with Mom and Dad who've got room and board covered for you. Consider my own anecdotal case. At 18 I was accepted to Colorado School of Mines. Nearly a full ride. I still had to come up with about 3k over the summer. After 8 weeks of stocking shelves on the night shift at the local Wal-Mart, I was close enough. Academically I crashed and burned my first semester. Thankfully I still retained aid while on probation. But then sophomore year came. My old aid remained while prices jumped by 4.5 percent on out of state tuition. I crunched the numbers and figured that if such a trend continued, I could be looking at tens of thousands in loan obligations. Combined with a depression of most epic proportions, I dropped out and returned to Texas shortly before finals my third semester. I then spent three semesters at home doing the Austin Community College grind, picking up as many credits as I could, trying desperately to get into UT Austin --where I had previously been admitted at 18-- before resigning myself to Texas State. ACC was a wonderful cost to benefit ratio despite its size at least. At Texas State, not so much. I'm nearly entirely on the hook for 4.5k in tuition/fees every semester for an Electrical Engineering degree that I still had at least five semesters to go in finishing. And of course that 4.5k doesn't factor in a grueling Austin-San Marcos commute that of course implies not just gas but maintenance as well. Really, I'm looking at about 30k in loan obligations anyway by the time graduation comes around this Spring. My transcript is a lost cause, no doubt. I'm sure UT Austin feels they dodged a bullet when they reviewed my records from Colorado and mailed off their form rejection letters that I still keep in a box somewhere next to the old admission packet. I wouldn't expect anyone to give me free money in exchange for the straight A's they consider to pass for academic rigor, because my track record provides ample evidence that I simply won't pull that off. I am intimately aware that my own personal disregard for grades, the only even half-reliable indicator for universities to gauge potential (half-reliable), leaves me cut off in ways that are my own doing. But for fuck's sake, I'd really like to be able to pay my own way without taking out tens of thousands in loans to do it or otherwise take a decade of time getting a 4-year degree. I'd like to have the experience of my aunts and uncles whose tuition bills were lucky to reach 4 figures in a given semester. Really, if I was obligated to spend 4 years educating myself, I feel I could have done a right sight better on my own rather than spending the first two years dicking around getting the "well rounded" education that I had already spent 12 years prior attaining in grade school. But an employer will absolutely require that four year degree to even consider me --before they then spend another year or two bringing me up to speed on the state of the art before I can really be productive on the team, of course. I keep hearing about all these choices I made. Quite frankly, there weren't that many options to begin with if your goal was to be anything other than a working class wage slave for the rest of your life.
- niuzeta 13y agoone of the possible way would be to follow the French model, where all secondary education(university-and-higher level) is free, but is agonizingly difficult to pass. If I remember correctly, the French universities fail 75% of first-year and second-year students in yearly exams, with only one chance to re-take the exam; in other words, you get only three shot of writing an yearly exam, which you must pass twice within 2 years. Only when you prove yourself worthy(of national investment) and get to the third year do you get the respect you deserve. If you fail twice in your area before the third year? Too bad, you can't study your degree in any school from the country and have it paid by the country, ever. It's rather harsh 'weedout' system that may be unfair in some regard, but the point is that you only let those who are dedicated enough to climb up, to walk home with a diploma which they deserve. Nowadays it seems as though the diploma isn't a sign of distinction, but a norm; in other words there are simply too many university graduates. This should change, in my opinion. Someone mentioned the era of baby-boomers, and I partially agree; back then, entering the job market with a college diploma meant that you were promised a prospect for a house, a car, and a life with a backyard: the middle-class American life. A point I'd like to make is that in the era of baby-boomers, a college diploma was worth it because there hadn't been many with higher education. Besides, what parent wouldn't want his/her children to have a worse life than him/her? If you spent your twenties to forties with the benefit of diploma, or have watched others' life with the benefit, wouldn't you want your children to live with the diploma, the promise you hadn't got? This resulted in a vastly high supply of college/university graduates; and as the law of supply-and-demand dictates, the value of diploma has now been in steady decline. The problem isn't that the university is too expansive; it's that the university education is too expansive compared to the benefits it promises. If I were to suggest the solution to this problem, I would suggest to make diploma really, really worth it. We already have mandatory weedout courses in computer science: Generally one with pointers or operating system, the one most kids without the aptitude simply can't pass. Reduce the number of graduates we produce, either by capping it, or making the graduation impossible without the aptitude or dedication. Is it unfair to some people? Yes, to the slackers who treat university as a away-from-parents paradise with fun and booze. Liberal arts or English majors shouldn't be made fun of because of their life choice, but should be respected for their dedication to the studies. If you ask me, I'd say there are simply too many kids graduating with Lib. Arts major who don't deserve a tenth of the elaborate philosophy.
- Futurebot 13y agoGreat article, and many good comments so far. Let's take a look at the core issue - the new core issue really: lack of jobs, which was touched on in the article. If we were in a situation where jobs were truly plentiful for everyone, we would likely not be having many of these conversations (or at least we'd be doing so with less urgency.) Aside from the fact that the costs at many schools are exorbitant, the simple fact is that degree or no, you're still (and likely will continue to be) facing a job market with little on offer. Income-based repayment is a great step, but that does not help if somone remains unemployed - and even if they do get something - do these people study for 4-6 years in order to be a Barista? About the suggestions that these people studied useless subjects: true, many of them did. What, however, would happen if they all decided to go into STEM instead? Assuming they all did amazing, we'd wind up with a glut of people with degrees in "good" subjects, which does nothing to magically create jobs (having a STEM degree does NOT mean you're going to start a company!) - it only helps where there are shortages. Once those are filled, we're back where we started (and wages may get pushed down due to a talent glut.) That's the best case scenario, too. What would be worse? What would the reality likely be? If everyone did rush into STEM, a good portion would fail out (not everyone is cut out for it. Really, some people just do not have the attitude, mindset, demeanor, worldview, interest, etc.) and be left with no degree (or they'd switch to one of those useless ones) and still be debt - right back where we started again. For some real world examples, just look through some other discussions on HN about this subject about people in countries who DO exactly this and they're stuck with unemployed and underemployed STEM grads up the wazoo. So lowering tuition is great. Initiatives that allow income-based repayment or schemes to just make it free at the point of service and pay for it out of taxes are great, but lack of jobs as the core issue remains. For those of you who believe college should not be considered a job training program, that's wonderful; it means, however, that people going into debt for a great education that does not get them a job is a terrible idea (and we should either move to a free system or tell people to just use MOOC and books.) Either college is a job training program with high costs and horrible returns (and degrees are first-line filtering mechanisms for jobs), or it's purely for edification and should be free. This world where we pretend it's the latter, but know it's the former continues to end for so many in nothing but tears.
- 205guy 13y agoI'm glad the big picture is getting more press. I felt this article laid out a lot of the issues (obscure loan terms, diploma mills, college salary bloat and "gilding," government policies and lack of transparency). These comments also added some interesting perspectives, from foreign comparisons to local initiatives (Oregon's pay-it-forward), student maturity (or lack thereof), and failure of the school system to actually prepare people for college, responsible borrowing, and a career. I've been seeing and feeling a lot of these individual topics before, so it's nice when they all come together to really shine light on the situation. I've got 2 links related to this: - Ken Ilgunas wrote a book "Walden on Wheels" about living in a van to avoid graduate school debt (after working hard to pay off his undergraduate debt). I haven't read the book, but from his blog, he's a good writer and adventurer. http://www.amazon.com/Walden-Wheels-Open-Road-Freedom/dp/054402883X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1361737956&sr=8-1&keywords=walden+on+wheels http://www.amazon.com/Walden-Wheels-Open-Road-Freedom/dp/054... http://www.kenilgunas.com/ http://www.kenilgunas.com/ - Mr Money Mustache gets mentioned every now and then on HN, and his advice is to live frugally, avoid or pay off debt, save 50-75% of your earnings and retire early. For those that don't have 6-figure jobs in tech, he just wrote a 2-part series on jobs that could earn 50K without a degree. While some of it is unrealistic, it's also a good reminder that tradespeople and small-business owners are out there making a decent living by being creative and self-starting, and that you don't need a degree to deal with people in the real world. http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/07/25/50-jobs-over-50000-without-a-degree-part-1/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/07/25/50-jobs-over-50000... http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/08/05/50-jobs-over-50000-without-a-degree-part-2/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/08/05/50-jobs-over-50000...
- BrandonMarc 13y agoNot only has Congress almost completely stripped students of their right to disgorge their debts through bankruptcy (amazing, when one considers that even gamblers can declare bankruptcy!), it has also restricted the students' ability to refinance loans. Even Truth in Lending Act requirements – which normally require lenders to fully disclose future costs to would-be customers – don't cover certain student loans. Not so surprising. With high tuition costs, and practices like the above ensuring the amount will almost always be back 100% or more ... and the recipient of these payments, the original entity billing the tuition in the first place? The government. Of course the government pulls out every trick they can to ensure their loans never go unpaid.