14 ms·
The NSA is Commandeering the Internet
- panacea 13y agoThat 'trusted' privacy policy link in the footer of nearly all commercial websites? That's backed up by legislation that makes it about 'privacy' protection, yeah?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- joshuahedlund 13y agoSchneier had this posted on The Atlantic two days ago, previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6199706 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6199706
- wslh 13y agoYes.... but it didn't catch my attention because the domain was atlantic.com but now... is schneier.com so the context changed, at least for me. I have one message to the executives of those companies: fight.
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoHonestly curious: why do some commentators seem to hold The Atlantic in disdain?
- jhart3333 13y agoFor me, it's not that The Atlantic is held in disdain but that Schneier is held in high esteem.
- wslh 13y agoNo, it was not disdain. I like The Atlantic (indeed a little bit less after reading they manipulated Reddit) But I read a zillion of posts daily and thought that the author was another opinionated journalist. If I had been more interested I would have clicked in the submission and read it after recognizing the Schneier signature.
- DanBC 13y agoWell, they were caught in a vote ring. EDIT: All the Reddit ban is easy to find. here's some discussion on HN: (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4108929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4108929) mattobrien submits the same article twice, deliberately evading the dupefilter. The article was written by someone called Matthew O'Brien. Most of his submissions are to the Atlantic.
- RyanMcGreal 13y agoHmm. That's unfortunate. Their content is generally interesting - it's too bad they're willing to discredit it with manipulative social engineering.
- leephillips 13y agoThat, and the Scientology advertisement scandal: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2013/01/15/the-atlantics-scientology-problem-start-to-finish/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/erik-wemple/wp/2013/01/1...
- pivnicek 13y agoThis deserves discussion. The parallels are striking and all but undeniable. <edited for clarity> I suppose the question business owners have to ask themselves is, do they feel that their country is at war in dire enough straights that they feel the need to surrender control of their businesses for the war effort?
- api 13y agoWhen the state comes and asks you to help fight its war, this is not a request. It's an order. If you do not cooperate, there's quite a bit that can be done to you. A lot of it is in the category of "soft power" -- your stock price falls, your shareholders vote you off, your offshore accounts will be investigated, you might get anti-trust scrutiny... Google wins massive points to me for asking questions at all. Granted it was a timid little hand raised in the classroom of a psychotic nun with a ruler in her hand, but it's something.
- api 13y agoYou know, I thought of another fallacy behind all this stuff. We're told this is to prevent the next 9/11, but there's a problem with that. It's very unlikely -- for basic political reasons -- that this will be used to investigate the rich and powerful. Huh? I thought people in caves in Afghanistan attacked us cause they hated our freedom? The cave dweller thing is probably the biggest lie about 9/11. Bin Laden was rich, from an even richer family, was financed by some of the richest people on Earth, and had state support. The next Osama bin Laden probably owns stock in the companies that are acting as contractors for the NSA right now. Or if he doesn't, his supporters and financiers probably do. Case in point: So now the DEA is using it to bust drug dealers. Why isn't the SEC using it to bust criminals on Wall St.? Think about it. Who's richer? Who's more connected? Who's gonna lawyer up and bust your chops hard if you come after them? Who's got friends and family members who might actually sit on committees in Washington that oversee your project? Edit: Given the above, I also consider it a good possibility that systems like this could be used against us. Recall 9/11 again. They were our planes that were flown into our buildings, not someone else's. What's the probability that a well-connected rich state-linked international terrorist will use systems like this to gather intel against the United States itself in preparation for a terrorist attack. Want to smuggle in a nuke? Wouldn't it be helpful to pull all the personal information and movement schedules for all the people who work security at the Port of Long Beach...? to give just one example. That could be made to look like a routine investigation quite easily, and if Snowden can exfiltrate so much data so can someone else-- especially someone with a higher level of expertise and sponsorship. How many NSA analysts have access to these systems? How much does that job pay? And do any of them have dangerous personality traits or ideological affiliations? Guerilla domestic terrorism from within is also a possibility. Remember this? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_anthrax_attacks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_anthrax_attacks
- throwaway987654 13y agoOsama bin Laden didn't go to Harvard. His (half?) brother, Abdullah bin Laden, graduated from Harvard Law School.
- api 13y ago
- uptown 13y agoIn light of some of the revelations about companies being coerced into providing access to user data, it's made me wonder about other potential targets. Has anyone inquired whether GoToMeeting, TeamViewer, Carbonite, CrashPlan, Mozy, etc. have anything to say about government access to their systems? All of these companies protect vast amounts of what's thought to be private data, and seem like they'd be prime targets for the "collect it all" philosophy.
- api 13y agoSmaller companies are mostly hosted on the "cloud." Hell even bigger ones like Netflix are. They don't need to cooperate. All their data is already there at the data center. Only the cloud provider needs to cooperate. So the question really to ask is: is Amazon, Linode, Digital Ocean, RackSpace, etc. cooperating?
- tjr 13y agoI once felt this was kind of extreme, but I now increasingly find it rational... http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-serve.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-se...
- wslh 13y agoI was thinking to migrate my email to Rackspace but now I am looking to another provider with similar quality outside US.
- api 13y agoIf it's owned by a U.S. company or if the country in question has intel-sharing agreements with the U.S., that won't help you. Also if the data is coming in or going out to a foreign server, it falls under the "foreign intelligence" umbrella so it better be encrypted.
- wslh 13y agoYes, that's why it's difficult to find one! If you have any recommendation... I use encryption for sensitive information but I want to also minimize the probability of interception and storage of my messages for unencrypted ones.
- wslh 13y agoProbably the next freedom revolutionary will be an user in HN?
- nohuck13 13y ago"It's time we called the government's actions what they really are: commandeering. Commandeering is a practice we're used to in wartime, where commercial ships are taken for military use, or production lines are converted to military production. But now it's happening in peacetime. Vast swaths of the Internet are being commandeered to support this surveillance state." This is an exceedingly well-framed point. Just because it's information and not "stuff" doesn't make it not commandeering. If you're a communications company, reputational damage and other indirect costs have real value, i.e. indirectly intercheangable with money, beyond just the costs of directly complying. It's commandeering.
- pvnick 13y ago>Commandeering is a practice we're used to in wartime, where commercial ships are taken for military use, or production lines are converted to military production. But now it's happening in peacetime. No it's not. We are technically in "wartime." Congress passed a law in late September 2001 that declared war with "those nations, organizations, or persons [the president] determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations or persons" [1]. The mass-surveillance of the internet is being touted as one of the weapons in the fight against those entities [2]. As long as the AUMF is still law, the fight against terrorists, and all actions taken to prevent "any future acts of international terrorism against the United States," are governed by the rules of war. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authorization_for_Use_of_Military_Force_Against_Terrorists#Section_2_-_Authorization_For_Use_of_United_States_Armed_Forces http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authorization_for_Use_of_Milita... [2] http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/07/31/nsa-director-keith-alexander-insists-mass-surveillance-programs-respect-privacy/ http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/07/31/nsa-director-keith-ale...
- gcr 13y ago2011? I'm curious; why was this done ten years after the original event? And why is the declaration so vague?
- 6cxs2hd6 13y agoBill Gates, having done well, reached a point in life where he wanted to do good. His philanthropy has been exceptional, and he's motivated others to do likewise. Today's crop of well-off tech execs now have a unique opportunity to do good -- take Schneier's challenge. Although few could match Gates on financial scale, they have an opportunity to equal or exceed him on social impact. I hope for the sake of the rest of us they do.
- jes 13y agoBill Gates did good long before he retired. He, with others, built a company that made low cost computing available to millions of people. People who willingly paid the prices Microsoft asked for their goods because those individuals decided that it was in their self-interest to do so.
- ledge 13y agoPeople who willingly paid the prices Microsoft asked for their goods because those individuals decided that it was in their self-interest to do so. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundling_of_Microsoft_Windows http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundling_of_Microsoft_Windows "The Findings of Fact in the United States Microsoft antitrust case of 1998 established that "One of the ways Microsoft combats piracy is by advising OEMs that they will be charged a higher price for Windows unless they drastically limit the number of PCs that they sell without an operating system pre-installed. In 1998, all major OEMs agreed to this restriction."[5]"
- ISL 13y agoIt was nigh impossible to buy a non-Windows x86 machine from any major vendor. That said, the second sentence remains correct.
- 6cxs2hd6 13y agoOf course doing well and doing good aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. Returning to the present situation: Execs who have made more money than they or their heirs will ever need, and who are starting to think about their legacy, have an opportunity here.
- lifeisstillgood 13y ago>> Do you have employees with security clearances who can't tell you what they're doing? Cut off all automatic lines of communication with them, and make sure that only specific, required, authorized acts are being taken on behalf of government. Is this Bruce saying "if one of your employees cannot tell you why he did X, then you should effectively seal them off from the company?"
- blisterpeanuts 13y agoWhy did Google stand up boldly to China but meekly capitulate here in the U.S.? I thought Sergei Brin took this stuff to heart.
- pasbesoin 13y agoIf you care about this, you will focus on the physical layer. Once that is owned, you are a tenant. You may also focus on the meaning and privileges -- and responsibilities -- of our current "ownership". However, that is invariable a social endeavour; worthwhile, but also subject to the desires -- and inattention -- of others. It presents sometimes great convenience, but no guarantees.