9 ms·
Germany Fights Population Drop
- niels_olson 13y agoAnd in other news, American women envy the work-life balance of their counterparts in Europe: http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2010/11/going_dutch.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2010/11/going...
- pmtarantino 13y agoI'd move to German. Where have I to sign?
- bebna 13y agoThere you go: http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/EinreiseUndAufenthalt/Uebersicht_node.html http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/EN/EinreiseUndAufenthalt/Uebe...
- pmtarantino 13y agoI was looking for something simpler :P
- parennoob 13y agoIt's surprising how immigration is almost never mentioned as an alternative to these "population-drop-fighting" measures. You'd think one of the things they'd do was make it easier for immigrants with some level of skill to get permanent residency.
- ultramundane828 13y agoThey mention that briefly, but yes, this was my initial thought as well. I'm sure there are plenty of people itching to fill the empty space.
- grumpygremlin 13y agoThus the policies of cultural marxism reach their inevitable conclusion.
- Cass 13y agoThey actually created a new residency law designed to make immigration to Germany easier for skilled employees just a year ago. Google "blue card". It hasn't had the success they were hoping for, but they're trying.
- raverbashing 13y agoThere are some initiatives towards that, like the German Blue Card After 5 years in the country you can file for permanent residency.
- levosmetalo 13y agoActually, as a Blue Card holder, you can file for permanent residency after 33 months. If you learn language to at least B1 level, you can file after only 21 months. In addition to that, you partner automatically gets work permit without restriction, and you are eligible for all social benefits like health care and Kindergeld from the day one. Compare that with the H1B / Green Card situation, and the contrast is clear. It was an easy choice for me (yes, I had job offers from both USA and Germany), and will probably attract more people in the future.
- raverbashing 13y agoGood Not to mention it doesn't take almost a full year to get like the H1B Getting B1 level in German should be not so complicated and attainable in, let's say, 18 months.
- levosmetalo 13y agoYes. They list a limit of 3 months just to be on the safe side, but nowadays it's usually granted in ~6 weeks.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- philipp-de 13y agoImmigration is unpopular here in germany. Indeed, it is very unpopular among many people. German politicians, in the past (60s,70s,80s), have brought in many worker-immigrants mainly from turkey. They were badly needed to fill the many vacant spots in the booming economy. They left no thought to integrating / assimilating them into the german society. Up until the 1990s the political parties in germany could not even come to grips with the fact that germany was in fact an "immmigration country". They were in denial. Today germany has 12-14% foreigners, mostly from turkey, and many of them have not been integrated well into the german society. Also, unemployment is high among this group. Education chances are depressed, etc - you get the picture. Now, we are in a bind. On the one hand the birth rate has been dropping for decades. This has to do with societal trends (more women working, etc) - but is a complicated issue in itself. Only group with a healthy birth rate, ironically, are the turkish immigrants. Politicians do not have any idea what to do about the birthrate. That has to with a cultural memory of nazi-era family policies, which rewarded having many children. It's a taboo today in german politics to try to directly induce families to have more children in any way. The german economy is already suffering. The term "fachkräftemangel" has been coined for this- which means the industry is already finding it difficult to fill all the vacant spots with qualified personell.
- kayoone 13y agoCorrect, in fact in general families/women from lower income and education levels (no matter if immigrants or not) tend to have more children than higher educated couples that prioritize their career. Overall germany is also not a very family-with-children-friendly country. This is in stark contrast to, for example, the US.
- currywurst 13y agoThey are not happy with the way the last mass immigration (of the Turkish) turned out. But they have recently made a lot of concessions for in-demand skills like tech, nursing and so on. And if you get a salary above a certain threshold, you even qualify for a "Blue Card" that allows you to work anywhere in the EU !
- philipp-de 13y agoThe terms of these initiatives (Fachkräfteinitiative, Blue Card) are so one sided and onerous that very few people from outside actually use them. These initiatives, started years ago, so far have flopped.
- kamakazizuru 13y agoIts a good step. The problem though was never the visa or whatever. The problem was and continues to be the fact that Germans as a society have trouble accepting immigrants. The first assumption (probably because of bad experiences with turks) is that these people are here to mooch of the system and wont learn our way of doing things. Thats disastrously untrue - and only serves to make Germany unattractive.
- rayiner 13y agoImmigration isn't a panacea. You have to be able to absorb and acculturate those immigrants, and you have a finite capacity to do that. This will yield down votes, but I'm an immigrant from the subcontinent and I understand what I'm talking about when I say this: it is vital to preserve western culture. Immigration done right can strengthen it and keep it vital, but done wrong it can dilute and corrupt the culture. Germany is better than India or China or the Middle East or the other countries immigrants would come from. Full stop. Westerners don't appreciate the extent to which a lot of the bad things we perceive to characterize those countries is baked into their culture. Sexism, racism, corruption at the basest level. That will follow immigrants into Germany and take root there unless immigration is slow enough to acculturate the immigrants.
- brazzy 13y agoIt goes both ways: there seems to be a percentage somewhere between 5% and 10% of "strangers" that people can accept living among them without feeling threatened. If that percentage is exceeded and the main population starts to feel threatened, you get xenophobia and things turn ugly.
- kamakazizuru 13y agoThat has to be the most ridiculous statement - especially since you claim to come from the subcontinent yourself. Every country has its share of problems and cultural differences - but you're looking at it from a very pessimistic and negative perspective. Germany and any other country can put in measures to ensure the kind of people do immigrate are also ones that would fit into their societies. They don't need to haul them over in boatfulls.
- rayiner 13y agoFor immigration to serve as a counterweight to declining birth rates, you do need to haul people over in boatfulls. And its a modern classist conceit that the virtues of western culture come from education and wealth rather than socialization and upbringing. There are plenty of educated wealthy middle easterners who cover their daughters faces in public and believe its morally acceptable.
- levosmetalo 13y agoImmigration is really a major point. As an immigrant from south European country that moved to Germany with a plan to stay here with the already formed family, all I can say it's not that easy. It's not only about giving the immigrant right to work, live, later vote in Germany. It's about absorbing them, making their life easier, and truly helping them to integrate into society. That's the effort that, right now, an immigrant has to make himself, but there's no much support from the state. My own example, I came here on Blue Card. That was easy. Then, I had to wait for half a year before my wife and children could join me. Then we had to wait for another half year before my children could start with the kindergarten. Only after that, my wife could actually start going to language / integration course. All in all, a year wasted before we could even start integrating. In addition to that, my son will start school next year, and will have only one year at German kindergarten instead of two. That will severely impact his ability to actually attend school in a yet unlearned language. What I want to say is that integration of immigrant is not easy, and there's much more that needs to be done. If you want them to integrate into the society, you should treat them much better, even better than citizen. Why? Because Germany needs them? If it's not done properly, in 50 years there will be no more German way of life. Majority of the people will not know how to use "der", "die" and "das" properly and would not even care about that. Half of the German population will be made of non integrated immigrants, leaving in small communities of people with the same origin.
- kamakazizuru 13y agoyes - this is exactly the point I made in my comment above. Couldnt agree with you more. Dont just make getting a visa or a job easy - make it easier for people to integrate - make people more accepted.
- lucaspiller 13y agoWhat's the deal with working in Germany as a non-German speaker nowadays? Is it possible to get on alright in tech companies or are they still very much German only?
- claudius 13y agoI met a couple of postdocs and such who didn’t speak German (and, in some cases, their English wasn’t all that good either) during my undergrad in Berlin. I guess it’s possible in larger companies or universities and larger cities where people are used to a fair deal of non-German speakers. But I wouldn’t suggest moving here permanently without knowing, or at least planning to learn, some German. After all, it’s a nice language with a decent amount of original content and if English is your native language probably one of the easier ones to learn.
- Osmium 13y agoAnecdotally (from personal experience) it's absolutely no problem at all, at least if it's tech/engineering-related. That said, picking up some German isn't too hard* and is probably recommended :) *I say this as someone learning through Duolingo at the moment.
- raverbashing 13y agoGo to Germany and try to use it, then you'll find out how hard or not it is
- timme 13y agoIn Berlin: no problem. In the rest of Germany: probably problematic.
- raverbashing 13y agoThis has been my experience as well
- parasight 13y agoI know several companies in Hamburg where English is the corporate language.
- adventured 13y agoWhenever I see these concerns about population decline (occurring in many parts of the world now), I can't help but think: why fight population decline? Embrace it, focus on improving the quality of life per citizen. Leverage robotics to bring drastically higher productivity to a smaller base of workers. Massive populations will be a liability in the not-so-distant future, as nearly all forms of repetitive manufacturing is performed by robotic platforms. For most countries, the larger the population, the more social upheaval there will be in the transition. Within 20 years there will be wide-spread protests against robots in the US, with calls to outlaw robotic manufacturing, union calls to limit robot use and artificially increase robot cost to make it "fair" for human labor, and lobbying efforts to restrict which tasks robots are allowed to take over.
- bausson 13y agoThe major problem doesn't seem to be the population decline, but the aging population, which cost can be terrible (well, that's how I read it)
- IanDrake 13y agoThe problem with population decline is that governments operate as a Ponzi scheme. Every day they spend more than they have and rely on an expanding population (tax base) in the future to pay for today's deficits.
- drone 13y agoThe problem is still there with any social support system for retirement: to work effectively, you need enough people paying now to cover the people on the rolls. If the population drops too much, the social safety net for retirees becomes insolvent. You can, of course, do the opposite of adding new workers: simply cause every new worker to pay more than the previous worker - but at what point do workers decide it's simply not worth it to work, when so much of their income is being spent paying for earlier retirees? It's a balancing act for sure. Previously, most western countries enjoyed a population growth, which meant more workers paying in than taking out, as this trend is reversing in nearly all western countries, it will be interesting to see how each country deals with it. In the U.S. the focus is on immigration and putting additional limits on what one can take out of the system - I'm not entirely sure that this is the right response, but I don't think simply ratcheting costs up on tomorrow's workers is the right answer either. As to robotics, well, that's a whole 'nother basket to deal with. I don't think that expanding robotics automatically creates worker revolts - if done well, it can create opportunities where they didn't exist before. Where once the only low-skilled jobs available were heavy labor and highly fungible services, we could create whole new classes of jobs relating to less fungible services (e.g. hyper-localized services), and with the possibilities of expansion off of the planet - there will be many opportunities for new work. I do believe that robotics will reach the tipping point right around the time that space exploration truly opens up. If it doesn't, my prediction that most employment will be in the armies of nations - as we fight over dwindling resources.
- Tichy 13y ago"what you see is the higher the gender equality, the higher the birthrate" Yeah, I am sure in Bangladesh and Nigeria they have great gender equality. Have more children, we have the childcare also seems like a stupid proposition. So you have the kids but no time to see them? 24h child care - great signal. So I can work round the clock for nothing? I have a different proposal: pay employers for every child that a women employed with them has. So instead of being a liability, employers could earn money by encouraging their employees to have kids.
- lifeisstillgood 13y ago> pay employers for every child that a women employed with them has. I understand the motivation for this policy - to me the all-to-common idea that child-rearing age women are a liability is awful. However, and its a big however, the law-of-unintended-consequences is going to come round to your house and set light to the sofa after nicking your TV.
- Tichy 13y agoThat's true, but the current pro-women-child-laws also have unintended consequences - mainly that women are a risk for employers. I'm not sure I am even in favor of such policies, but maybe at least certain vocal would get their wish (more women in employment+more kids).
- brazzy 13y ago> Have more children, we have the childcare also seems like a stupid proposition. So you have the kids but no time to see them? 24h child care - great signal. So I can work round the clock for nothing? Bullshit. "24h" child care simply means that you don't have to choose your job to fit the opening hours of your child care provider. > I have a different proposal: pay employers for every child that a women employed with them has. So instead of being a liability, employers could earn money by encouraging their employees to have kids. And of course there's not chance that will be abused...
- Tichy 13y ago
- pessimizer 13y agoThis is a dumb article, constantly repeated. Germany, like many countries (though less so), is currently suffering from a demand crisis where there are not enough well paying jobs for the current population. The most important thing to consider is productivity growth, though, which according to some random blog I just googled[1] was 2.5% from 1985-1990, 2.9% from 1990-1995, 1.9% from 1995-2000, and 1.4% from 2001-2006. Assuming an average of 2% productivity growth for the next 47 years, each the 2 2060 workers will be 1.02^47 (2.5) times as productive as today's employees, allowing the three individuals (2 workers and a supported retiree) to live a lifestyle twice as nice as the current population. That calculation doesn't include the added benefits of a lower population, such as more space and crime reduction. (for completeness' sake, assuming a 1% productivity gain a year means that these 3 individuals from 2060 would be living a lifestyle only 5% [edit: my math was bad here, it's actually 33%] nicer than the current standard. Also, both examples assume a reasonable distribution of wealth.) [1] http://www.ulrich-fritsche.net/blog/labour-productivity-growth-in-good-old-germany-is-germany-falling-further-behind http://www.ulrich-fritsche.net/blog/labour-productivity-grow...
- brazzy 13y agoAssuming, of course, that productivity gains are shared equally across the population. The problem: that's not what has been happening. Instead, median wages have not quite kept up with inflation while the super rich and parasitic industries like investment banks reap the gains.
- Tichy 13y agoExactly - so instead of giving people more money so that they can slack of and have kids, make them work even more and take away their kids.
- hawkharris 13y agoContrast this with the United States, where overpopulation is a growing challenge and some organizations are suggesting policy changes to achieve a smaller, more sustainable fertility rate. This nonprofit, called NPG, is a pretty interesting and reasonable one; it advocates for the majority of American women to have fewer than three children, and it calls for non-coercive tax incentives that encourage Americans to have smaller families: http://www.npg.org/faq.html http://www.npg.org/faq.html
- jonknee 13y agoThere are plenty of examples of over population in the world, but the US is not one of them. Our growth is slowing and there are huge amounts of available land. The country could easily be several times its size in population.
- hawkharris 13y agoYour statement about the United States' available land makes the assumption that the American population is evenly distributed across urban and rural areas. In reality, more than 80 percent of the country's population lives in urban areas. The population in those areas grew by 12.1 percent between 2000 and 2010. Just because spacious rural areas exist doesn't mean that Americans are willing or able to move to them. http://www.census.gov/newsroom/releases/archives/2010_census/cb12-50.html http://www.census.gov/newsroom/releases/archives/2010_census...
- yardie 13y agoThen which is it? Is the US overpopulated or just the cities you particularly like? Here are a few places in the US that don't have an overpopulation problem: Detroit, Cleveland, Buffalo, Hartford.
- hawkharris 13y agoThose are interesting examples worth discussing, but, as you know, a handful of anecdotes doesn't invalidate national statistics reported by the U.S. Census Bureau.
- cenhyperion 13y agoWhat's the development job market like in Germany? How hard is it to immigrate if you have skills and are willing to try to learn the language?
- brazzy 13y agoDevelopers are in high demand in cities like Berlin, Munich and Frankfurt. Immigration is probably a major feat of beaurocracy but not too hard in principle if you have looked-for skills ( see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Card_%28European_Union%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Card_%28European_Union%29 ).
- fotoblur 13y ago"If Germany is to avoid a major labor shortage, experts say, it will have to find ways to keep older workers in their jobs, after decades of pushing them toward early retirement" Doesn't it suck when a society is forced into valuing its elderly. It actually seems responsible of a society to balance itself with its environment. Population overgrowth is a major issue in the world and I applaud the people of Europe who, and possibly unconsciously, are reaching a greater balance with their environment in the hopes of securing an actual future in it. Can't help to think of... Humans are a virus: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Na9-jV_OJI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Na9-jV_OJI Humans as Cancer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0R6EvtGnoE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0R6EvtGnoE
- VMG 13y agoMust be depressing to think of yourself as a cancer cell. Who do you think is the host?
- fotoblur 13y agoThe idea is that humans exhibit the characteristics of a cancer within its environment. Its only a metaphor for how humans have treated their environment and is not meant to be taken literally.
- fotoblur 13y agoReally...I don't get the down vote here. Maybe cynicism is not understood or, possibly worse, overpopulation is not seen as an issue. The links were for entertainment value, a simple metaphor.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]