8 ms·
The Man Who Would Overthrow Harvard
- NotOscarWilde 13y agoIt is a definitely interesting project, but what would benefit "us" (as in, humanity, I guess) most is a nigh-free online university with respected accreditation and as much high-quality content as possible while keeping costs at a minimum. Amazon is a good role model when you look for a for-profit giant, but I'd like the top education model to look like Wikipedia. Heck, Wikipedia is a pretty good tool for kickstarting your interest in a given field, and it has plenty of references, too.
- realspeech 13y agohttp://www.londoninternational.ac.uk/ http://www.londoninternational.ac.uk/ offers courses with respected accreditation and (limited) study materials. the cost is tiny compared to tuition in the usa. no real STEM courses though.
- Zigurd 13y ago> The school touts itself as the first elite—make that "e-lite"—American university to open in 100 years. Olin? Too bad they screwed up their endowment and have to charge tuition now. I wonder if that will affect the quality of the student body. But Olin was definitely a try at "instant elite."
- clicks 13y agoI'm reminded now of something that Bill Gates said: universities like Harvard or MIT shouldn't be lauded for churning out smart people... who were already smart before they entered Harvard, we should instead be lauding institutions that admit everyday folks from tough backgrounds that then turn them into smart and able people. In that spirit it is strange that the article goes to great pains to emphasize how "elite" this new university will be, and how 'admission requirements will be "extraordinarily high."' So, to sound not so negative here: I hope this experiment succeeds, but we should be focusing on where real and big problems lie: education for the masses, at affordable prices.
- argumentum 13y agoThe value of great institutions lies not merely in education, but in bringing great people together. Simply attracting already smart people (or determined and otherwise talented people) is a value in and of itself.
- bane 13y agoWe have those and they're generally free. We call them "social clubs" and "mixers". Heck, Mensa is basically a social club for smart folk.
- dnautics 13y agowell, yeah, but in a college, you're not just brought together to be in some sort of self-primping club, but you also do things like "work collaboratively on projects" and "pursue a guided learning track".
- jjindev 13y agoRobin Hanson and Tyler Cowen have had a lot of interesting discussions on the role and extent of "signalling" in higher education. I think Hanson takes the extreme view that it is mostly signalling, rather than skills (human capital). Obviously we see that at some level. "He's a college man" doesn't have the cache it did in 1920.
- peter_l_downs 13y ago> we should be focusing on where real and big problems > lie: education for the masses, at affordable prices. You might be interested to read about the Cristo Rey school network — a group of highschools aimed at exactly that. A buddy of mine is working at the Philly one this summer which is why I've heard of it. Here's the history page: http://www.cristoreynetwork.org/page.cfm?p=367 http://www.cristoreynetwork.org/page.cfm?p=367
- bobbydavid 13y agoI agree but in the same way that the original elite Facebook paved the way for today's Facebook behemoth, I imagine a successful elite e-stitution (c) will legitimize the concept, which will pave the way for something with more universal appeal.
- argumentum 13y agoI would like to see schooling evolve into a loose association between learners and access to learning resources (virtual and physical). I've learned far more outside formal schooling than within (at all levels up to phd). That said, this particular article is hyperbole, as creating a institutional brand like Harvard is something you do not say you are going to do. A great example of this in recent history is Y-Combinator. The perception of quality comes from actual quality.
- objclxt 13y agoThe 'sticker price' comparison is really misleading here. I don't think the Wall Street Journal do anything to correct this. Here's what the article says: > A degree [at Minerva] will cost less than half the average top-end private education, which is now over $50,000 a year At Harvard today, the minority of students pay full price. Over 70% of the undergraduate student body are on scholarship. Notably, if your family earns less than $65,000 per year you will pay nothing to attend. Minerva wants to charge students $20,000. There is, as far as I can tell, no financial aid policy or bursaries available. And why would there be - Minerva is, after all, for-profit. If your family is at or below the median household income in the US then Minerva is an extremely expensive proposition. Whereas at Harvard, and many other colleges, it's free.
- argumentum 13y agoEven if "Minerva" was $1/year, the question is one of value. A degree from Harvard at $50k/year is more valuable than a free one from a UC Berkeley Dean's scholarship student (which is probably about the same difficulty to attain), simply due to the perception it engenders from people that matter.
- rjbond3rd 13y agoNo offense to anyone, but I'll take that Berkeley kid any day.
- argumentum 13y agoAs may I .. that's not the point.
- rjbond3rd 13y agoIf you're saying "people who matter" value the superficial over substance, then I'd further conclude that they literally don't matter.
- 13y ago
- bachback 13y agothis guy is all about talking - compare that with Udacity or Khan.
- rayiner 13y agoYou can't call a university "elite" that doesn't have any history. Where is the multi billion dollar endowment? Where add the scads of important alumni? Where is the name recognition among ordinary people?
- foobarqux 13y agoI don't think this venture will succeed but I do think that it raises an obvious point: Elite and other universities don't groom you to be elite nor do they teach you enough of the basic things that are valuable to employers and therefore to you. Instead universities spend a great deal of time on things that most people, in retrospect, would say were not useful. If you were to ask recent top graduates about 6 months into their first job what basic useful things they learned that they should have or could have learned in school I think you would find many recurring themes. Why are students forced to unnecessarily learn things the hard way?
- ahelwer 13y agoI'll post a small anecdote, which I promise is not an exercise in narcissistic banality. A couple of my friends attend Green College[0] at the University of British Columbia (UBC). I crashed in their residence room for two nights during a cross-Canada road trip at the end of July. The short time at Green College restored my love of higher education, which had been flagging toward the end of a drawn-out CS degree at the University of Calgary. Every morning the students meet for breakfast at a hall in the center of the residence compound, between 7 and 9. This is much earlier than my usual wakeup time, which hovers between 10 and 11. Green College has students from a wide variety of disciplines, and discussions accompanying the meal were a general mash of ideas far outside what I would ever encounter when hanging around my school's CS labs. It was a joy to participate. The experience very clearly communicated to me that this is what I've been missing. Education in a vacuum is horrendously dull when compared to all these ideas bumping into each other around the breakfast table. It's inspiring; without the social aspect, school is reduced to jumping through hoops and learning the secrets behind magic tricks. The idea of forming a close-knit community of students then transposing it to cities around the world has me grinning. Were I younger and capable of meeting the admission requirements... [0] http://www.greencollege.ubc.ca/ http://www.greencollege.ubc.ca/
- da02 13y agoCan you provide some examples of the ideas you bumped into? I'm curious since I've never been in a multi-discipline env like the one you had @ Green.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoI once attended a conference and Jesus College, Oxford. I got the same feeling that you did, just the dining hall experience was way beyond what I ever experienced at UW. But these experiences are quite expensive. It is not clear that they scale to our current egalitarian and pragmatic educational system.
- bsbechtel 13y agoThe value in any educational institution is derived from the ability of its graduates to go out and create value for the rest of the world. I only skimmed the article, but I felt like it completely missed this point. People pay more to go to Harvard and Stanford because they believe they will earn more when they graduate. People pay more for Harvard and Stanford graduates because they believe they will create more value for their firm. This is why every educational institution in the world touts its notable alumni. If Minerva can't create this perception, it won't succeed.
- chatmasta 13y agoPeople go to elite universities because they are the best schools.
- fecklessyouth 13y agoNelson's remarks exemplify a disturbing trend amongst technologists, and especially those trying to reform education: Misidentifying sub-par educational experiences and areas of studies as "the liberal arts," and then attributing insufficient outcomes to the liberal arts themselves. If he went to Wharton Business school for undergrad, he does not have a liberal-arts education. History and literature are liberal arts, business is not. Yet he blames his lack of growth during undergrad years on the very same: >My first six months, what did the consulting firm teach me? They didn't teach me the basics of how they do business. They taught me how to think. I didn't know how to check my work. I didn't think about order of magnitude. I didn't have habits of mind that a liberal arts education was supposed to have given me. Perhaps he thinks he studied the liberal arts because he majored in Economics. But majoring in Economics within a business school is, as Wharton's website proclaims, a specialized, business-focused approach, which the site's copy actually contrasts with "a liberal arts setting." [1] Such programs can't be grudged for failing to cultivate the mind, as their sole aim is "appl[ying] business methods and economic theory to real-world problems." Business programs will always fall-short of real-world experience in teaching business skills, since one is actually real. If he had studied an actual "liberal art" like philosophy or history or French, he might have gotten the mental development that his program apparently lacked. I think those of us who truly delved into liberal arts programs, with the accompanying rigor, breadth of study, and dedication to teaching, found them a great boon to our mental capacities. Edit: Another trend that's been irking me lately: the idea that you can "teach" someone to think through "critical thinking" classes: >In the Nelson dream curriculum, all incoming students take the same four yearlong courses. His common core won't make students read the Great Books. "We want to teach you how to think," Mr. Nelson says. A course on "multimodal communications" works on practical writing and debating skills. A "formal systems class" goes over "everything from logic to advanced stats, Big Data, to formal reasoning, to behavioral econ." There's a reason that "Communications" programs have a reputation for being full of fluff. If you want to learn how to communicate, communicate. Trying to "study" it isn't get to help you personally. If you want to learn how to write, write about any subject, and have your teacher tear your work apart. Communications skills are taught through experience. You can't sit down and "learn" writing skills. [1] http://www.wharton.upenn.edu/undergrad/academic-excellence/BS-versus-BA.cfm http://www.wharton.upenn.edu/undergrad/academic-excellence/B...
- rollo_tommasi 13y agoI don't think yet another institution which selects life's winners based on who they were at age 16-17 is really the solution to the country's educational problems.
- chasing 13y agoHarvard my ass. He's trying to overthrow the incredibly lucrative University of Phoenix. Also, his reductionist approach to higher education means Minerva will lose a lot of the quality of education and community that makes a top-tier program worthwhile.
- MWil 13y agoIf I'm a prospective student for this university (I'm not), I'm thinking I'm going to regret being videotaped in all of my classes several years down the line.
- smacktoward 13y agoIt could be worse -- from the 1940s through the 1970s Ivy League and Seven Sisters universities required incoming students to submit to being photographed in the nude, as part of a bizarre experiment in researching human body types. The result was a trove of highly embarrassing photos of people who went on to reach the highest levels of business, government and the arts. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_League_nude_posture_photos http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_League_nude_posture_photos for more, and http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/11/up-against-the-wall/?hp&_r=0 http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/11/up-against-t... for the story of one student who went through this process, Yale graduate and talk show host Dick Cavett.
- BruceIV 13y agoThis is the first "let's completely overhaul university" idea I've heard that doesn't completely suck. I like the ideas of world travel and reasonable tuition, and doing away with a lot of the useless cruft of a traditional university - Minereva sounds like fun, and if I was in high school right now, I'd be applying. That said, one possible hassle I can see with this plan is that to bootstrap an "elite" reputation, and deliver these big core courses in a useful way, you're going to need some amazing professors, and as a PhD candidate with ambitions of teaching, I'm not sure I'd want to work for this university. Teaching via email and video lectures is unappealing, and (more importantly for catching top talent), I don't think it would be a good career move - they don't have the elite reputation yet, and I feel like at the end of my "flexible short term", I'd have trouble convincing a more traditional university that my experience wasn't from some online diploma mill.
- chasing 13y agoI agree with most of your comment, but I disagree that $20k/yr is a "reasonable tuition" for what Minerva's offering. State schools. They rock. And they're (relatively) cheap. For example, in-state tuition at the University of Texas is about $10k/yr.
- BruceIV 13y agoFair - I don't have a great grasp on what higher education costs Stateside, as I'm Canadian - the publicly funded schools tend to manage ~$6000/yr tuition, and the private schools aren't much more.
- Tycho 13y agoHigher education's product-delivery system—a professor droning to a limited number of students in a room—dates back a thousand years. The industry's physical plant (dorms, classrooms, gyms) often a century or more. Its most expensive employees, tenured faculty, can't be fired. The price of its product (tuition) and operating costs have outpaced inflation by multiples. Why is this the case? Is teaching basically the last great guild?
- abalone 13y agoHow are you going to develop good professors if you only engage them as temps? That's one of the key things that separates a great university from a teaching college. Investments in the long-term careers of research professors. Teaching is just one of their responsibilities; they also research and publish. Same for their grad students. That takes subsidies that come in part out of undergrad tuition. So sure, if you cut that out you're going to have cheaper tuition. But if this model were actually adopted on a wide scale, you'd also dry up the supply of great professors. As an exceptional case it might work, but only by exploiting the investments of other institutions. Very "silicon valley libertarian" in that respect.
- tzs 13y ago> Professors get flexible, short-term contracts, but no tenure. At a place like MIT or Caltech, almost all the professors are also researchers. Undergraduates have a lot of opportunity to get involved in that research. What research opportunities will be available for Minerva students?
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoIt cuts both ways: At a place like MIT or Caltech, almost all professors are also researchers. They really like research, and teaching is kind of a drag. What learning opportunities will be available for MIT or Caltech students? Now, admittedly, the above institutions take teaching seriously, and the students will get a great experience. But the same isn't true in many public flagship universities where professors prioritize research over teaching. That being said, I prefer being a researcher to being a teacher, which is probably why I'm not a professor.
- _delirium 13y ago> Its most expensive employees, tenured faculty... Someone has not paid much attention to the past 20-30 years of developments. Faculty salaries are a falling proportion of university spending. The current cost drivers are administration (both size and salaries) and capital outlays. For example, the University of California system spends only 30% of its budget on faculty salaries (that includes non-tenured faculty). And faculty are rarely, with the exception of med schools employing star surgeons, among a university's most highly paid employees. Look at what the top administrators make in comparison.
- BruceIV 13y agoThe top paid public employee in most states is the football coach at one of the state schools. At most of the others it's the basketball coach.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- MisterBastahrd 13y agoSo a guy with no experience teaching in a classroom decides that he has what it takes to found a university, and then instead of trying to create a transformative experience, he's going to turn out a bunch of trust fund babies with non-accredited general studies degrees who will be almost certainly deprived of the ability to do real research on par with even small directional universities. Oh, and elite professors will just FLOCK to this school in one of the most expensive cities in the world and be rewarded with.... no tenure and no resources to conduct research. Brilliant.