9 ms·
SSD myths and legends: write endurance
- abalone 13y agoZsolt Kerekes is a pretty sweet name. I don't think there is a name that says "solid state storage" better than "Zsolt Kerekes".
- xkiwi 13y agoIn the middle of reading this, I saw a 2TB SSD Advertisement then realized SSD just consumable product, it is just like tires which just change it every 2-3 years, for safety concern.
- wmf 13y agoI think that's the right way to think about it. And we should have already been treating hard disks that way too.
- MPSimmons 13y agoFor quite a while, I've been saying that too. We have the SMART data to know when they're wearing, so why don't we treat them like race car tires? http://www.standalone-sysadmin.com/blog/2012/11/flash-drives-as-replaceable-parts/ http://www.standalone-sysadmin.com/blog/2012/11/flash-drives...
- sliverstorm 13y agoIs this not already the mindset? I worked at a data storage company for a while; everyone knew hard drives fail, because we had so many disks we would have a couple failures just about every day. Everything was designed to be fault-tolerant so we could squeeze the most life out of every spindle, but in the absence of fault-tolerance I'm sure we would have had a spindle retiring schedule. Are there many companies that do not acknowledge this basic fact of operation?
- kayoone 13y agoThats the right way of thinking about it but its not really feasible for consumers. "Oh hey, this Laptop has a SSD drive which is super fast. You will have to replace it every year though and if you dont have a backup strategy you might lose all you data. Did i mention they are quite expensive ?"
- venomsnake 13y agoYou will have to make quite the effort to burn trough a consumer SSD in machine with normal use for a year. 256 GB * 3000 gives a lot of write information.
- masklinn 13y agoIndeed, the standard SSD in a consumer-type usage is 7+ years of write.
- kayoone 13y agoIn theory yes, in practice i have been using SSDs since 2009 and had them both failing (different brands and tech) after about 2 years of daily usage. Now i see i probably use them more than the average consumer, but i cant remember the last time i had a normal HDD fail in one of my machines.
- dchichkov 13y agoI've seen a number of normal HDD failures. I think that the first one that I've seen, been with a double-5 inch slot hard drive, which was failing to start spinning at times. You've had to turn the PC box abruptly, to make it spin ;) But as of now, have to see an SSD fail. Longest running that I have now is a Linux box that've been up since Oct/2007. (Heh, cool part about that linux box - there are no moving parts at all - no coolers, no nothing. Even in the power supply ;) )
- kayoone 13y agoSounds cool :) I am not saying i have never seen HDDs fail, but in the almost 20 years i have been computing heavily, it might have been about 3 in my own machines, while i went through 2 SSDs in 4 years. Id still never go back to HDDs as my system drive :)
- diydsp 13y agoWhat are these RAM SSDs of which the article speaks? I searched around for a bit, but couldn't find any place to order one (keep getting hits for PCs for sale)... are they available in say, 64GB in SATA?
- wmf 13y agoThey tend to be enterprisey or OEM-only; here are some examples: http://www.ddrdrive.com/ http://www.ddrdrive.com/ http://www.stec-inc.com/products/zeusram-enterprise-sas-ssd/ http://www.stec-inc.com/products/zeusram-enterprise-sas-ssd/ http://www.dataonstorage.com/dataon-products/enterprise-class-ssds/zeusram-6g-sas-ssd.html http://www.dataonstorage.com/dataon-products/enterprise-clas... http://www.sandirect.com/texas-memory-ramsan-440-enterprise-ssd-storage-p-1247.html http://www.sandirect.com/texas-memory-ramsan-440-enterprise-...
- marshray 13y agoCan someone explain the discrepancy between > I still hear stories of users thinking it's perfectly normal and economic to replace burned out Intel SSDs every 6 to 12 months and > How long have you got before the disk is trashed? ... 51 years!
- cclogg 13y agoDitto. Also, assuming it's 51 years, that generally means I have nothing to worry about with an iPhone or (new) MacBook, right?
- fletchowns 13y agoAssume that any hard drive can go away at any time, for any number of reasons. Especially portable devices like those. Always use some sort of automated backup to a remote location for data you want to keep around.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dasil003 13y agoBecause time correlates only very loosely with SSD failure, it's all about writes and people write at widely varying rates.
- marshray 13y agoI thought the 51 years was supposed to be worst-case.
- Symmetry 13y agoThere's a big difference between using consumer grade MLC flash and running a very high intensity workload and using enterprise grade SLC flash and only using 80 MB/s of bandwidth. As a consumer you really don't have to worry about write endurance, though. I mean, how much do you write to your drive every day, maybe 5 GB at most? Even with MLC flash and a fairly small 120 GB drive that'll last you for a couple of hundred years. And even when it fails you can still read the data out, you just can't write new data. The problem you should worry about is a firmware bug in the part of the drive that handles the wear leveling abstraction. I haven't seen one of those in a while, but when many companies were just starting to develop SSDs they occurred fairly frequently, though usually the manufacturer would figure out the problem and patch the firmware for new drives after enough failures in the field.
- ck2 13y agoWrite endurance is very real. http://www.ssdaddict.com/ss/Endurance_cr_20130122.png http://www.ssdaddict.com/ss/Endurance_cr_20130122.png http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?271063-SSD-Write-Endurance-25nm-Vs-34nm http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?271063-SS...
- Shivetya 13y agoThe data given on the second link does not inspire confidence in consumer SSDs
- corresation 13y agoHow so? The tests are in no way normal usage, most writing hundreds of terabytes or more before failure, exactly in the expected range for those sizes of SSDs. Consumer devices do not write remotely as much as people seem to think they do. Heck, I ran a very large, endless-churn financial system on a FusionIO platform, and two years in it had barely written several hundred terabytes.
- Shivetya 13y agoI was looking at SSDs as scratch disks and the like, but some of the examples failed in months. Its an electronic device, sorry but other than purposely putting in an environment that is not conducive to its long term health, like heat or dunking it, I should be able to read and write to it to my heart's content. I fully understand commercial grade equipment versus consumer, but in the world of no moving parts it begs the question, what does it take to make them more reliable. Because some of the devices didn't last long enough for me to lose the receipt
- maximilianburke 13y agoOn the first link, what's the red bar represent?
- raesene2 13y agoIf anyone's interested in some more details for write endurance I'd recommend Anantechs SSD reviews. http://www.anandtech.com/show/7173/samsung-ssd-840-evo-review-120gb-250gb-500gb-750gb-1tb-models-tested http://www.anandtech.com/show/7173/samsung-ssd-840-evo-revie... . If the numbers in those are accurate it looks like write endurance shouldn't be a problem at least for any consumer drive. The estimate on that review was 12 years in a typical consumer setup, and I'd reckon that almost everyone would have replaced a laptop or PC in that kind of timeframe.
- jmomo 13y agoFor those in the know, and for the benefit of laymen who don't have the time to do the research, what are the things that a buyer should look for in a SSD, in regards to reliability and longevity? Technology, brand, controller?
- andrewcooke 13y agothe only critical thing is physical size. some (mainly ultralight) laptops take drives that are thinner than normal laptop drives (this is also an issue if you're buying a new spinning disk drive, of course). apart from that, assuming you buy a popular, current model, it will just work (and be reliable). this article is bikeshedding for hardware and enterprise geeks. so, just like anything else, get something reasonably priced from a reputable make (longevity of support, availability). currently samsung seem pretty good. and finally, if you don't already use one, get one. it's by far the best way to improve "perceived speed" of your computer (well, assuming you already have enough memory).
- mdpye 13y agoMy Intel X?? came as a superslim 2.5 package, but with a plastic bumper as part of the construction making it up to full height. Having to disassemble it first thing to remove the buffer went just fine, but wasn't a great start (warranty voided before I even powered it up?)
- gcb0 13y agoHad to remove enclosure of a Kingston drive to fit a notebook also. Just cycled all the storage in the desktop before voiding my warranty... Still sucks In your case it's double ironic since Intel is the one that pushed for slim ssd because of the ultrabook shenanigans while everyone was doing a standard size. Not that having smaller drivers is bad...
- miahi 13y agoThe only thing you have to know about reliability is "always have backups". I bought 5 SSDs and used them as OS drives on laptops and desktops. No SSD actually failed, but they had "glitches" - 3 of them, of different brands and on different PCs and OSes, lost data for no apparent reason - nothing in the SMART logs and tests. Twice the OS had to be restored from backups. The good news is that after the restore (on the same device) everything was fine and I continued using them.
- jasonkolb 13y agoHow does everyone else set up their dev systems? I just rebuilt my dev machine and I'm using one SSD drive for the OS, one SDD for data (database, Cassandra stuff), and then a regular drive to hold code and builds since that gets rewritten several hundred times a day sometimes.
- lnanek2 13y agoOne SSD of Vertex 4 speed or higher, usually in a laptop, max RAM. Haven't seen the need for a workstation in over five years. Have gone through 4 laptops for processor increases/lightness/battery in that time, so SSD is always replaced long before anything could go bad anyway. Develop Android/iOS mainly, although there's often a Jetty/Rails/MongoDB/NodeJS/Postgres server or two and a VM running.
- lutusp 13y ago> I just rebuilt my dev machine and I'm using one SSD drive for the OS, one SDD for data (database, Cassandra stuff), and then a regular drive to hold code and builds ... So instead of one large storage pool, you have three. This means your chance to have your system grind to a halt with a disk-full condition is three times greater than it would otherwise be. I've never understood this logic, but I certainly see it implemented a lot. It's a new version of disk hard-partitioning in *nix systems -- a scheme that stopped making sense once drives because large enough to contain all the resources on one unit. With one drive containing all stored resources and no hard partitions, there's exactly one disk-full failure mode -- when the disk is full. When Charles Lindbergh was asked why he wanted only one engine on his historic Atlantic-crossing plane, he replied that, since the multi-engine planes of his day couldn't stay airborne on one engine, his design was actually safer.
- MAGZine 13y agoIf he combined them, it would be likely he would have to move to an HDD to fit everything. The part that's really unfortuante about that is that HDDs do not have the best reading/writing since the heads actually need to seek the data. These creates performance bottlenecks, especially if he's trying to transfer a build while the database is active. Fewer disks, less chance of failure. it's extra important to back up though, since one disk failure can result in entire catastrophe! Losing an OS but still having DB and Code isn't that catastrophic.
- rpedela 13y agoHow does this affect cloud providers using SSDs? Are they using the reliable and expensive version? Do they use consumer ones and then swap them periodically?
- jlgaddis 13y agoJust a quick note: before you buy a "self-encrypting drive" (SED SSD), do your research and make sure you get one where you can control the keys. A couple of months ago, I spent almost $400 on a Crucial M500 480GB SSD to put in a new laptop only to discover that apparently the drive itself handles the generation of keys. Thus, technically all of the data on the drive is encrypted but you can take the SSD out, put it into another machine, and access the data without any issues. Total marketing ploy.
- rdl 13y agoThe point behind it is you can delete the key in one place and not have to worry about erasing every part of flash in the machine (which, after remapping, may not even be possible through normal means).