7 ms·
We still don't really know how bicycles work
- barrkel 13y agoWell, we know enough to know how to increase stability - primarily by increasing trail and rake. Decreasing rake angle is the primary way of making a motorcycle turn faster, with the known risk that it makes it more likely to head shake or even tank-slap. It's fairly clear that common two-wheelers are stabilized by the rake and trail inducing a counter-steering effect when pushed horizontally - try to shove over a bicycle and the front of the front wheel will turn in the direction of the push because the point of contact of the tyre with the ground is behind its axis of rotation (the amount of which is the trail). And if the bicycle is moving forwards, this turn of the wheel will cause a torquing effect to roll the bike in the opposite direction of the shove. So long as the correction is somewhat less than the overall shove, the system should be self-damping. But if the dynamics were fully understood, we'd be less likely to get motorcycles with issues like the well-known Pan Weave[1] and other high speed stability issues. At the limit, things like aerodynamics, chassis rigidity etc. start coming into the equation. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honda_ST1300#Pan_weave http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honda_ST1300#Pan_weave
- Sharlin 13y agoFor those, like myself, who weren't familiar with the terms "rake" and "trail": http://www.seegercycle.com/Rake-and-Trail.aspx http://www.seegercycle.com/Rake-and-Trail.aspx
- deveac 13y agoThanks Sharlin, that was not only instructive on the terms, but a great read as well. Now I understand precisely why my uncle can always ride is raked Harley with no hands far longer than I can on my stock bike.
- Jimmy 13y ago>Decreasing rake angle is the primary way of making a motorcycle turn faster, with the known risk that it makes it more likely to head shake or even tank-slap. This must be what non-programmers feel like when they hear programmers talk about code.
- peterwwillis 13y ago"Here you go. All that was needed was to parse the cat root slash dev etcetera file for eth 0 and pugle the forward identity-locking rehooliginator and symlink it to the libgc perl humongisooler module after a kernel decompile and basic repatch update. Nothing to it, just RTFM and you'll figure it out!" http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/10/02/mandrake_9_0_vs_mandrake/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/10/02/mandrake_9_0_vs_mand...
- VBprogrammer 13y agoA slightly mind blowing fact is that if you ride a motorbike at reasonable speed in order to enter a turn to the right you actually turn the handle bars to the left. This causes the motorcycle to lean-over to the right and thus entering a turn in that direction (due to the horizontal component of the weight).
- tacticus 13y agoCounter steering is incredibly freaky when on the bike as well. You force yourself to fall and let the bike catch you and damn it is disconcerting the first few (hundred) times.
- Terretta 13y agoThank you. We do know how they work, and that it's nothing to do with gyroscopes and everything to do with (what parent said, but simplifying a bit) front fork geometry. Pretty much anyone can see this for themselves. Walk a bike with your hand holding the back of the seat, not the handlebars. Steer the front wheel by leaning the bike. Lean father to correct faster. If it's a cheap bike, let go and watch this happen on its own till it wobbles too far to counteract. This is one of those idiotic tropes like bumblebees not being able to fly.
- nemetroid 13y agoThere's a huge difference between "know how they work" and "know what influences their dynamics".
- panacea 13y agoDo we know why light propagates through glass in a straight line, but not paper yet?
- madaxe 13y agoWhat? Yes. Quantum Electro Dynamics (QED) has some pretty compelling explanations at a "basement" level as to how this works. Also, light does not propagate through glass in a straight line, it diffuses, refracts, and reflects.
- anonymous 13y ago> bumblebees not being able to fly I'm pretty sure science still cannot explain how bumblebees would be able to fly a Boeing 747
- madaxe 13y agoIf a dude with a boxcutter can, surely a bumblebee could. Hell, rats can. http://news.discovery.com/tech/robotics/brain-dish-flies-plane-041022.htm http://news.discovery.com/tech/robotics/brain-dish-flies-pla...
- vortmeester 13y agoIt's true that increasing trail and rake both increase stability. But curiously, a bicycle can be made stable with both negative rake and negative trail. An interesting take on this, with both mathematical modeling and real prototypes, can be found at [1]. Note also that gyroscopic stabilization is not necessary: in the prototypes, a counter-rotating extra wheel cancels out the angular momentum of the front wheel. According to the authors, it's not yet even proven that a stable bicycle must turn towards a fall. Almost the only sure thing, so far, is that "at least one factor coupling lean to steer must be present". We know a lot of sufficient conditions for stability, but not what is necessary. The conclusion of the paper: "As a rule, we have found that almost any self-stable bicycle can be made unstable by misadjusting only the trail, or only the front wheel gyro, or only the front-assembly center-of-mass position. Conversely, many unstable bicycles can be made stable by appropriately adjusting any one of these three design variables, sometimes in an unusual way. These results hint that the evolutionary, and generally incremental, process that has led to common present bicycle designs might not yet have explored potentially useful regions in design space." EDIT: here's a not-paywalled version of the paper linked in the submitted article. [1] PDF link: https://scholar.vt.edu/access/content/group/141943de-4222-4681-8e93-07454e806e01/Podcasts/kooijman-meijaard-papadopoulos-ruina-schwab-2011.pdf https://scholar.vt.edu/access/content/group/141943de-4222-46...
- zeidrich 13y agoWe know quite a lot about how bikes behave, we've been building them for decades, centuries. While we might not grok all of the specifics behind the physical dynamics, consider this: We also don't know the specifics of why gravity works. We know enough about it to make practical use of it, it keeps us on the ground and we fall at about 9.81m/s^2, but how we are affected by gravity over vast distances is still a mystery. Why we are attracted. If we can get along just fine without being blown away by the fact that we don't even know how we stay on the ground, I don't think it's that amazing that we struggle with the dynamics of a particular system of locomotion. We can make it work well enough.
- aaron695 13y agoExcept we know exactly how gravity works. If you google it all the exact equations are there. As you say exactly why is still a unknown but then so is everything if you keep reducing the problem.
- com2kid 13y agoWe know the equations that describe gravity, but we do not know how it is mediated, thus we do not have a full understanding.
- brudgers 13y ago>"Well, we know enough to know how to increase stability - primarily by increasing trail and rake." ..or, absent ideological zeal, the number of wheels.
- mjn 13y agoIf you want stability above all else, sure; tricycles exist and are more stable than bicycles, and you can go up to 4 wheels, too. They have other downsides, however. More friction, more width needed to both travel and park, and actually worse stability when cornering at speed (they can't lean, so are at risk of flipping in a turn). Cargo bikes often have more than two wheels, but people who don't need to carry significant weight in a basket tend to prefer bicycles as the more practical option. Parents in Copenhagen do often choose the tricycle-with-basket at a moderate speed, as a safer option than putting a kid on the back of a bicycle. But that only works when you have wide bicycle lanes.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoIdeological what, now? Bicycles, you may have noticed, are muscle-powered. adding a few dozen pounds' worth of wheels and frame is going to seriously impact acceleration, hill-climbing, and rider endurance, and the increased width will have major effects on hazard avoidance, navigation in narrow spaces, turning radius, and general maneuverability. I've ridden adult-sized trikes, and they are fun and relaxing, but they're much less suitable for most serious transport/travel applications.
- SeanLuke 13y ago> primarily by increasing trail and rake This is oddly redundant, kind of like saying "primarily by using computers and laptops". Trail is the tendency of the front wheel of a bicycle or motorcycle to act like a caster. If you change the bike geometry so as to increase trail, the bike will increase its resistance to being turned (steered). This makes the bike easier to handle, particularly at high speeds, and makes it much easier to ride no-hands. But it's not all good: it also makes it very hard to control the bike when the wheel has a lot of load on it (like front panniers) and makes the bike less manipulable. You can change the trail by changing the angle of the steering column (steeper angle, lower trail), changing the size of the wheels (smaller wheels, lower trail), or adding "rake", which is the forward swoop that many bikes have in their front fork (more rake, lower trail). Though some think rake is to provide a bit of bounce or suspension, it's really not. It's a device used to add trail.
- whiddershins 13y agoNor do we know how airplanes work. Or whips.
- speeder 13y agoWhat parts we don't know about these?
- rayiner 13y agoI don't know about "don't understand" but did you know that there is a lot more to why a wing creates lift than the "pressure differential" explanation commonly put forward: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lift_(force) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lift_(force). In particular, the typical assertion that the air at the top has to speed up so it arrives at the trailing edge at the same time as the air from the bottom is false.
- speeder 13y agoI see... The speed explanation is not incorrect, except the REASON for it is. I learned on school that the air on top of the wing move faster to catch up with the one in the bottom (this never made sense to me...), the air on top indeed move faster, we only don't know why. Damnit, I should be a physicist, not a programmer :P
- sebbi 13y agoLower pressure = air can move faster ...
- claudius 13y agoIf you were a physicist, you’d likely also have to be a programmer – the inverse, unfortunately, does not hold.
- michael_h 13y agoPublic service announcement for physicists fancying themselves as programmers: Learn the following topics before going any futher: * BLAS (please) * LAPACK * memset * memcpy * 'Segmentation Fault' is not a synonym for 'exited successfully'. Those who maintain your code will thank you for it. Sometimes it might get you chocolates.
- netrus 13y agoI highly recommend the following TED talk on bike physics by Arend Schwab from Delft University of Technology: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Y4mbT3ozcA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Y4mbT3ozcA It focuses on the question why bikes do not fall, even without a rider on them (spoiler: coriolis is insignificant).
- hownottowrite 13y agohttp://ruina.tam.cornell.edu/research/topics/bicycle_mechanics/stablebicycle/index.htm http://ruina.tam.cornell.edu/research/topics/bicycle_mechani...
- speeder 13y agoNow I read this, and the article, and now I am confused, because I was a staunch believer it was gyroscopic effect fault, now the thing can work without a gyroscope and what the hell? Now /I/ want to know why the bike do not fall.
- dljsjr 13y agoAndy Ruina is a great guy to listen to about stuff like this. There's an annual conference for scientists in all fields (robotics, biology, cognitive science, etc.) that study walking locomotion called Dynamic Walking; our lab hosted it in Pensacola last summer and Andy gave a "Greybeard" talk about the mechanics of sailboats and sailing down wind faster than the wind that was really entertaining. I'm not sure where his fascination with esoteric mechanics comes from, but he has a pretty clever and engaging manner of discussing the stuff. Edit: Didn't realize that Ruina was a co-author on the paper referenced in the article. Even better. It all goes full-circle.
- schoper 13y agoWe do know, here is the paper that the journalist refers to: http://www.sciencemag.org/content/332/6027/339 http://www.sciencemag.org/content/332/6027/339 And here is a great video by the author: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YdtE3aIUhbU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YdtE3aIUhbU Short answer: "a bicycle should turn into a fall."
- tudorconstantin 13y ago"Check mate, scientists" :))
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoUrban legend. Bicycle physics is well-understood. My old job, we even made a fuzzy logic model of motorcycles/riders for Harley Davidson. No mystery here, move on.
- larrydag 13y agoWe studied the physics of bicycles (angular momentum if I recall) in engineering school.
- crusso 13y agoIsn't it amazing how confident people are that their own ignorance is everyone's ignorance? It's so much worse when the ignorance belongs to a "journalist" who really just needed to do a little research before promoting such a poor theme. Yes, we know how bicycles works. No, it wouldn't be that big of a deal if nobody was working on solving the mysteries of the bicycle in favor of really hard problems like "dark matter".
- asynchronous13 13y agoThe gyroscopic theory has been proven wrong, yet many people continue to believe it. But just because many people are wrong, does not mean that no one knows. A bicycle in motion adjusts its center of gravity to remain upright. It's very similar to the inverted pendulum problem. Look at a bicycle directly from behind with the wheels exactly lined up. Now imagine that you could frictionlessly slide the two tire patches left and right. The similarities to the inverted pendulum become more clear. Of course, it is more complicated than the classic inverted pendulum. Instead of one point of contact under the mass, there are two. And the two points of contact (i.e. the wheels) have their own complex dynamics. Having a rake angle on the front wheel makes a bicycle self correcting (if the c.g. is on the right side of where the wheels contact the ground, then a right turn is induced in the front wheel by the rank angle) There are two major forces that must be in balance to turn a bicycle - the side force from being off center with respect to c.g., and the centripital force in the turn. Ever watch a cyclist train on rollers? That's much closer to an inverted pendulum. And since there is no forward momentum, there is no centripital force, which makes it more difficult to remain upright on rollers than on pavement.
- raverbashing 13y agoI'm not seeing the relationship between a (running) bike and an inverted pendulum. (or better, I don't see how it explains, since an inverted pendulum is unstable)
- hillbillyjack 13y agoThe bicycle is an inverted pendulum (and is unstable when still) but similar to an inverted pendulum when it is stabilized through rocking back and forth the bicycle achieves this stability in motion.
- lambda 13y agoA bicycle actually consists of two inverted pendulums (the frame and the fork) joined by a hinge. And the bike that was stable with no trail and no gyroscopic effects used this to provide stability; the stability was provided because the fork, with the lower center of gravity, would fall faster than the frame (taller inverted pendulums fall slower than shorter ones, which you can easily demonstrate by how much easier it is to balance a long object like a shovel than a short object like a spoon on your hand). This provided the necessary feedback that caused it to steer into a turn in a way that stabilized. The takeaway is that there are several factors which influence the stability of a bike. We know of certain designs which utilize one or more of these factors to achieve self-stability (and the conventional bike has all of these factors, hence why it tends to work so well), but we don't know the exact set of conditions on the combination of factors which would allow you to characterize which designs are stable versus unstable, without simply trying out any given design and simulating it.
- mhb 13y agoHow does he not even have a picture of the "Anaconda"? OK, here's a paper about it: http://bicycle.tudelft.nl/bmd2010/CDProceedingsBMD2010/papers/kabeya2010simulation.pdf http://bicycle.tudelft.nl/bmd2010/CDProceedingsBMD2010/paper...
- jccalhoun 13y agomagnets
- jokoon 13y agoisn't it because the front wheel change the contact point with the ground when you turn ? when you both turn and inclinate the bike, the contact point is more on the side which you turn, balancing the bike.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoFacepalm. I look forward to New Statesman's thrilling coverage of how bumblebees can't actually fly, and nobody knows why duck quacks don't echo.
- arh68 13y agoIf Feynman were still around, he'd set things straight. I don't think a bicycle staying upright is much different from a train keeping course [1], but I can't describe why. Instead of the rail veering off and the wheel adapting, it's like the bike does what it wants and the ground shifts beneath it. If you've read about Einstein's pail-of-milk-on-a-lazy-susan, it's a similarly unintuitive frame of reference. Also, if the experts haven't figured it out: I don't know what I'm talking about. I find it fascinating that we as a species can observe, define, and exploit Maxwell's law, neutrino physics, etc, but we can't clearly explain bicycles. Or why wings provide lift. EDIT: forgot the Feynman video [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7h4OtFDnYE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7h4OtFDnYE
- mkoryak 13y agoI had an idea to build a tall bike which contained a large and heavy wheel in the center of the frame, above the 2 wheels but below the rider. This wheel would be made to spin somehow and act as a gyroscope to help the bike stay upright when stopped. This seems to suggest that my plan would never work. If gyroscopes don't stabilize, then why are they used on monorail trains etc?
- joshrice 13y ago> If gyroscopes don't stabilize, then why are they used on monorail trains etc? They do, it's just the bicycle's wheels aren't heavy enough to provide enough force to really make that much of a difference.
- e3pi 13y ago...and, like a horse, I still can't get on these newfangled things from the starboard side.