6 ms·
Generally, the people doing brain simulations like to claim that they can use a massively reduced representation (little more than a graph model that pushes sig
by dekhn 13y ago
Generally, the people doing brain simulations like to claim that they can use a massively reduced representation (little more than a graph model that pushes signals around with some constants) and yet, somehow, the simulation is inherently capable of reproducing something complex about thought. I'm not sure how they get to this conclusion, but it's a massive reductionism. It would be nice if it were true- it would mean that for a reasonable expenditure, we could build a machine that, basically, "thought" and had a "mind" and we could convince ourselves that it was "living" much like we think of other humans.
To date nobody has come up with a really compelling disproof that they are more or less correct- thought and mind seem to be best explained as "emergent behavior of a complex system".
Now, whether can we bootstrap a thinking mind by running complex simulations on computers remains to be seen. I'd like to believe there is some interesting physics going on in brains we can't simulate with straightforward physical models, but there really isn't any good evidence for that.
- smosher 13y ago> something complex about thought Can you elaborate on this class of 'something'? There are intelligent behaviours that can be reproduced this way, so without more specifics I feel like you're making the same mistake you're condemning.
- jonmrodriguez 13y agoFor example, the glial cells are now believed to be vital to the brain's processing, but most "brain simulations" are still modeling neurons only, not glia. http://shahamlab.rockefeller.edu/pdf/CTDB_69_C_69003.pdf http://shahamlab.rockefeller.edu/pdf/CTDB_69_C_69003.pdf
- smosher 13y agoNot helpful. My question demands an answer from the person making the claim, unless you happen to know what they're thinking. Besides, this sounds nothing like what they're talking about. Worse, I don't think you're prepared to prove that a mostly pure-neuron simulation is incapable of giving rise to that certain complex quality apparently far removed from the level of the simulation.
- coldtea 13y ago>Not helpful. My question demands an answer from the person making the claim, unless you happen to know what they're thinking. No, questions can be answered by anyone, if they provide a relevant answer. What the person making the claim thought is irrelavent. The parent gave you a valid reply.
- smosher 13y agoI was literally asking someone what they were talking about. Instead I got an answer from someone else about something else. It's just some asshole who has one little nugget of information they want to spout at someone.
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe answer wasn't quite relevant to your question, but the specific person that answers doesn't matter unless you're asking for their expertise. So, basically, you're the only one being an 'asshole' here.
- JamesArgo 13y agoWhen did reductionism become a dirty word?
- sgentle 13y agoI've noticed this too. I blame a combination of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance and not knowing what the word actually means. From my observation, it appears people assume "reductionist" means "simplistic" as opposed to "representing a complex system as no more than the sum of its components". To be honest, I think it's just an etymological problem: "reduction" sounds bad, so "reductionism" sounds bad. The grandparent here follows this pattern. Using the actual meaning, it would be paradoxical for an approximation to be reductionist. In fact, it's quite the opposite. A reductionist would hold that the most accurate high-level model of a brain would be the most low-level model of a brain. If we could model each atom precisely then we would, necessarily, model the whole brain precisely. The whole thing is pretty amusing when you take into account that anyone who manipulates software or systems in any serious way needs to engage in reductionism to be able to work. It's not as if "first, we write module A, then module B, then a system magically appears from the ether" is a viable architecture. At least, not since we stopped taking neural nets seriously.
- bbgm 13y agoReductionism is fundamental to science. There are places where it shows it limits, but I've always equated being reductionist with being clever, with taking a complex question and re-casting it in terms that can be measured/studied using the current state of the art.
- Shorel 13y agoSome parts of the mind are emergent, but I'm sure some parts or features of the mind are a consequence of the particular organization of the neurons itself, and they won't 'emerge' without careful tuning. Otherwise Sperm Whales would simply be much smarter than us. About conscience itself, my guess is as good as yours.