7 ms·
It's weird to me that people need all these amazing tools to just write stuff. I typically write things in emacs text mode buffers because I'm writing words and
by jgrahamc 13y ago
It's weird to me that people need all these amazing tools to just write stuff. I typically write things in emacs text mode buffers because I'm writing words and don't need any bells and whistles.
Almost all of The Geek Atlas was written like that and then pasted into whatever thing O'Reilly wanted me to create XML with.
- joshdance 13y agoSome people might say it's weird that people write in emacs. :) To each his own.
- jgrahamc 13y agoSure, but an emacs text buffer is pretty stripped down; that was my real point.
- eshvk 13y agoI dunno. I personally like writing on vim or on paper. However, there is a reason I feel more expressive. It is the very nature of these specific tools. I really like vim as much as I really like writing on moleskine. So I understand when people say the medium in which they portray stuff is important for them.
- rickyc091 13y agoWell, I think it's also partly about being part of the medium network and having your writing surface for others to see.
- rhizome 13y agoAnd people denigrate portals...
- antitrust 13y agoI think his point was that the writing was fine, but control over the web publishing portion was not. As far as writing goes, I think a lot of us work in text editors. They're more responsive and stable than word processors.
- mbesto 13y agoIt's a syndrome of "blaming the tool". Writing is hard. Not because it's actually hard to physically write words, but because it's hard to stop yourself from thinking your writing is bad. So, naturally we blame our tools when we get frustrated with our writing. This is the same for website templates, IDEs, to-do lists, etc. I wrote about this awhile back: http://www.techdisruptive.com/2012/06/29/the-cyclical-nature-of-the-hammer-industry/ http://www.techdisruptive.com/2012/06/29/the-cyclical-nature...
- sillysaurus 13y agoThis seems like a good opportunity for me to solicit some advice, if I may: My writing is bad. Do you have any recommendations for how I could improve? Better question: Would you mind describing what your own path was like going from "I'm a bad writer" to "Hey, I'm fairly good"? My lack of writing skill has bothered me quite a lot over the last year or so. I've sent emails to various HNers asking that question, "What did your path from beginner to master look like?" but no one responds. (... Perhaps I didn't write the email very well...) :) I have a lot I'd like to write about, but expressing myself well turns out to be the hard part for me. If I can figure out how to do that, then I think people will find the topics interesting. But I'm finding it very difficult because I'm a complete beginner. I've never written any long articles/essays/books before. Thank you for your time! EDIT: Here's something specific: I'd like to get better at using metaphor. I'm finding that even though I've been writing a lot, I seem to have reached a "plateau" of quality. It's.. well, it's just dull. I don't use many metaphors, and I know my writing comes off as very dry. So I'd like to get better at whatever skill or mindset that lets me spice up my writing, rather than my writing plodding dutifully along its lackluster course without any flair in presentation. Has anyone else found themselves in a similar situation? How'd you overcome it? EDIT2: Thank you for the great responses!
- x0x0 13y agotwo things: 1 - I think (though perhaps I'm putting words in his mouth) jgrahamc's point is that dicking around with sites and tools and blah blah blah is, well, just dicking around and not actually writing; 2 - lots of authors I respect have basically said that the way to get good at writing is to write a lot, revise a lot, and be prepared for early writing to suck. I wish there where a shortcut.
- reinhardt 13y agoDid you read the post? His problem was not "writing words", in fact he actually recommends medium if that's all you want: "Medium really is a great platform if you just want to write. Unfortunately, for me, that just wasn’t my problem."
- larrys 13y ago"It's weird to me that people need all these amazing tools to just write stuff." Agree but have to say that when Pagemaker 1.0 came out on the Mac (might have been 512k) some people that I worked with talked about the creativity that just flowed. I think it was a mania induced by having the ability to see on the page the final product and what it looked like as opposed to just the words which someone else would typeset. (In other words to repeat the "high" created added to the creativity). Was hooked up to a Linotronic for camera ready copy.
- gms 13y agoDid you add all the XML tags after the text was written, or during?
- jgrahamc 13y agoAfter. There wasn't much to add just some indication that "this is a header" etc.
- themodelplumber 13y agoI visited the site; it's really nice but four <br>s between paragraphs in the summary looks pretty strange. Seems like it might be their system because when I click "Continue," the awkward spacing goes away. Anyway, looking forward to reading more.
- msutherl 13y agoI really like the idea of writing in a text editor, and have tried to do so many times in Vim, but for some reason it's very important for me to see the result as it will appear to the reader as I'm writing. I don't know why this is, it just happens. When I'm in a WYSIWYG word processor with the typography mostly figured out, everything goes smoothly. Likewise, when I write a post on web forums, Facebook, HN, etc., I need to publish it first before I can properly edit. Seeing the post in context is somehow important.
- philsnow 13y agoYou can very likely wire that up, if you've got a bee in your bonnet to do so. When I was editing latex files regularly, I had an environment something like $ make output.pdf $ xpdf -remote projectname output.pdf & while inotifywait -e modify **/* ; do make output.pdf; xpdf -remote projectname -reload; done Then any time I changed a figure or a tex file or an embedded screenshot or whatever (any transitive dependency of output.pdf), make would rebuild it and display the result. xpdf nicely does not change the scroll position (even a little bit), so this gave me a rather nice nearly-real-time WYSIWYG view. My $EDITOR at the time was vim and it never entered my head to try to contrive automatic saving every time I paused typing or something like that, but that seems like a fun idea.
- msutherl 13y agoWell, there are a lot of things like that, e.g.: http://socrates.io http://socrates.io, but it doesn't do it for me. I like to be actually manipulating the end result.
- praptak 13y agoI am the total opposite. Seeing the result as I write feels just annoyingly distracting. The unpredictability of the jump to the next line is what I dislike the most. Obviously I do look at the final formatting and possibly tweak it, just not at the same time I edit the text. Obvious disclaimer: I do not think that this is "better", I'm just providing a different data point.