9 ms·
Bill Gates’ nuclear company explores molten salt reactors, thorium
- andyl 13y agoI want a thorium-powered car. http://www.geekosystem.com/thorium-powered-car/ http://www.geekosystem.com/thorium-powered-car/
- InclinedPlane 13y agoNo you don't. Thorium reactors are actually breeder reactors which run off of U-233, one of the byproducts of breeding U-233 is U-232, which emits gamma rays like nobody's business. The only way to stop gamma rays is with lots of shielding made out of high-Z materials, like lead, which is inevitably super heavy. So you'll either get a multi-ton car that crawls or a light-weight car that gives you cancer or a lethal dose of radiation if you drive it more than a few hours.
- gus_massa 13y agoThe "thorium-powered-cars" were discussed previously. They are based in a totally different "unproved" technology. The main point about "thorium-powered-cars": * It's not a nuclear reactor, it doesn't produce fission. * It says that the thorium has a lot of potential energy, but it's not clear how to extract it. (A similar weight of potatoes has the same energy and at least it's easy to extract a part of it.) * It mixes lasers and radioactive material. A lot of buzzwords but the explanation of the details is unintelligible. I gave more details and direct quotes for the project in a previous comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2879955 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2879955
- acchow 13y agoWhy is it so obvious to the internet and no one else that thorium is the future of power? What do they (the experts) know that we don't?
- zxcdw 13y agoThe other party benefits from status quo and we don't, that's why. :) ...maybe
- ekianjo 13y agoThorium is cleaner than Uranium, and does not produce radiaoactive elements that can be used for weapons proliferation (it does not produce plutonium).
- tehabe 13y agoBecause Thorium isn't the answer. What I don't get, that people who care about technology and about freedom prefer a centralised technology like fission power over a decentralised technology like solar or wind, in combination with electricity storage. So far nobody has developed a reactor design which is really better or cleaner than what it is currently available. No "new" design could deliver what it has promised. Not even nuclear power was able to deliver what it has promised to begin with. Well, I guess, we both don't get the other side.
- dragonshed 13y agoWind and solar aren't the answer either, or you wouldn't be having this discussion because it would already have been deployed. The economics of all intermittent power sources make it unfeasible; Installing the necessary transmission lines to all those decentralized sites, the energy lost during transmission to and from storage, the costs of storing that much power, and the other inefficiencies of generating the power, make what you propose very unrealistic. Nuclear power is millions of times more energy dense than solar, wind, and fossil fuels. Though the current generation of nuclear reactors have some significant drawbacks, not the least of which is the inefficient use of fuels leading to nuclear wastes, they still generate much cleaner power than the alternatives. Liquid Salt reactor designs based on Thorium take aim specifically at the nuclear fuel and waste problems. Rather than using 1% of the solid fuel like today's reactors, it's possible for liquid salt reactors to use up nearly 99% of the fuel, reducing the waste problem by many orders of magnitude, and would not contain the transuranics that take 10s of thousands of years to decay. It's a good thing that serious people are looking into radically different forms of nuclear power. The current conventional reactors were based off of designs for producing materials for weapons, and it's high time we set that garbage aside and consider other options.
- btilly 13y agoThey say Bill Gates because he's famous. This is a spinoff of Nathan Myhrvold's Intellectual Ventures - which is a patent trolling company. They may talk about plans to produce actual nuclear power, but I'll believe it when I see it. However it is guaranteed to create a lot of patents. Personally, even if it does succeed, I would have a bad taste in my mouth for anything and everything involved because I do not like Nathan Myhrvold.
- DaniFong 13y agoDo you know him? Honesty I don't have a huge amount of information about his other dealings, but I think there is a genuine case for what he is trying to do with IV, even if you disagree with with methods. With me and my company, he has been a man of tremendous character and generosity. I daresay you and most others are prejudging the situation. In error. Keep in mind, I am no fan of the patent system either. http://daniellefong.com/2010/02/11/how-law-shapes-the-business-landscape-and-a-patent-puzzle/ http://daniellefong.com/2010/02/11/how-law-shapes-the-busine...
- cabalamat 13y ago> Do you know him? I didn't know Adolf Hitler, but I know enough of him to know that he wasn't a nice person. Patent trolling is a legal form of extortion. It is evil. Myhrvold is an evil man.
- anigbrowl 13y agoCalling Myhrvold 'evil' and putting himself in the same context as Hitler is absurd. One is a businessman whose tactics you disapprove of and consider to be unethical, the other instigated the murder of millions of people, over and above the casualties of the numerous wars that he started.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoI agree the Hitler comparison is absurd, but I think the whole "I'm gonna patent this obvious concept, not do anything with it, and then sue everyone who comes up with the idea independently while actually making an attempt to solve the problem in practice" is sort of evil.
- haekuh 13y agoMy god it is about time that someone started looking into this technology. I understand the tech hurdles and the even cleaner tech etc. but think about how much safer LFTRs are. Even just to replace all the running reactors if not build more. http://www.ted.com/talks/kirk_sorensen_thorium_an_alternative_nuclear_fuel.html http://www.ted.com/talks/kirk_sorensen_thorium_an_alternativ...
- joshuaellinger 13y agoNathan Myhrvold He did this cool TED talk about shooting mosquitos out of the air with lasers salvaged from commodity electronics. Since that was years ago, it appears that it is doesn't work in the real world. Par for the course with TED. A prominent malaria expert tore into him for exploiting a real crisis that kills millions to make his company actually does something good for the world. Going all hi-tech hero when what is really needed in low-tech nets. So I'll go with evil for $500. Nice cuddly evil but evil nonetheless.
- psbp 13y agoWe don't need solutions. We need big corporations to accrue patents and public approval so that they can steamroll the rest of the industry many years down the line. It's called charity™
- joezydeco 13y agoHey but now when someone does get the bugLaser working, he can be there with prior art AND a patent to collect upon.
- jingo 13y agoThe title has now been changed to remove the reference to Intellectual Ventures. A well-known philanthropist has taken its place. Maybe it's not true that "all publicity is good publicity". At least not for Intellectual Ventures.
- zmic2 13y agoWhen the traditional nuclear plants were built, scientists and engineers said that they were perfectly safe. Now they want to sell thorium reactors, because they are more safe. What do you mean? More safe than perfectly safe?
- jbverschoor 13y agoToo bad that kirk sorensen is never mentioned, as he and his company flibe energy are a big advocate of all this
- rbanffy 13y agoHe'll probably get sued by IV in the near future.
- ahaefner 13y agoTo everyone bashing Intellectual Ventures, the key here is that TerraPower is a spinoff. They are becoming independent of IV precisely because they don't want to be a patent troll. Also one LOL of having Bill Gates fund your nuclear company is you end up with the biggest Windows cluster for simulations. Source: I'm a PhD student in nuclear engineering with friends working at TerraPower.
- Roboprog 13y agoAnd we get some idea of the power requirements for Windows 10??? :-)