9 ms·
Here’s what’s holding back 3D printing, the technology that’s supposed to revolutionize manufacturing and countless other industries: patents. There's somethin
by ilamont 13y ago
Here’s what’s holding back 3D printing, the technology that’s supposed to revolutionize manufacturing and countless other industries: patents.
There's something else that's holding back 3D printing: Demand.
For all of the hype about 3D printing around how empowering it is, how cheap it's getting, and how it's going to revolutionize the world, where's the evidence that people are going to rush out to buy these, even if prices fall off a cliff?
- khawkins 13y agoWhenever I see new 3D printers released or promoted, the main thing you see them model are functionally useless figurines and toys. I don't see a lot of people talking about practical applications. Although I can see its uses in rapid prototyping, which I do a fair bit of myself, I don't see a massive market on the horizon.
- tptacek 13y agoThis comment makes me want to come up with a 3D printing startup; you've practically distilled it to the koan of the "next important technology". I felt the same way (meaning, as you do about 3D printing) about MP3s. The big problem I see with 3D printer products for the home is that they're very slow. Pushing aside the fact that they won't always be slow (because swinging too early for the market is no better than swinging too late; both result in strikes), this is problem that can be solved at a consumer level by retail, the same way we don't have offset printers and copy machines in our houses but all know where to find a Kinkos. Bear in mind that most people will never design a 3D model; most people can't even draw, and 3D modeling is harder. But that doesn't matter, of course, because some people can't help but 3D model things and will publish those models to places like Thingiverse.
- goldfeld 13y agoI think 3D printing will really take off when startups develop ways to make them useful, not faster. People just don't have a good use case for them today, if they had, they'd simply wait for the machines to slowly churn out what they need. For instance, when people can print out custom handset chassis and form factors to go with easily swappable electronic internals. Custom input devices. The printable stuff will have to integrate with electronics (or print them anew) as to make it useful in order for it to outgrow the current market of prototyping enthusiasts. I'd really like though to be able to print a paperback for reading and then tear it down in the machine when I'm done so the material can be fully reused. That's the ebook revolution for me. Actually, I agree with you. When 3D gets fast to the point of instantaneous and cheap and with fully reusable material, we could have really interesting things. Imagine a 'physical' computer. I issue some command in bash, and a little physical representation of a file pops out from my workstation, and it has built in sensors and input so I can interact back with my workstation by interacting with it. I could have actual printed pseudo-ebook-readers tied up as tabs in my web browser.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ISL 13y agoI'd really like though to be able to print a paperback for reading and then tear it down in the machine when I'm done so the material can be fully reused. That's the ebook revolution for me. You can do that right now. Buy recycled paper, print a book, read it, and put it into the recycle bin. Just think of paper in the same way you think of ink.
- iamwil 13y agoI think you were thinking as you were typing, since you reversed your position a bit, but faster 3D printers will make them MORE useful. There are many things that are impractical to print as a result of how slow 3D printers currently are. But if they were faster, then you can make things as you need it, you can make things where you don't know what you need to pack beforehand, and you can make disposable things on demand. Same with computers. Many of the software we use regularly now were considered impractical with much slower computers with smaller storage (spam filters, any 3D graphics game). By making them faster, a larger class of things were available to be made more useful. In the far far future (say 30-40 years), if 3D printers were fast enough with good enough materials, some startup can make a physical dropbox. Never use storage again. Digitize what you want to store, and recycle the object. When you need it again, print it out.
- PeterisP 13y agoMy personal opinion is that any mass consumer adoption will come some time after mass SME adoption: there are craftsmen and small businesses who have more frequent needs and can justify the investments more. They are currently used in prototyping labs or for niche hobbies, but not in most businesses who could use them. I wouldn't expect consumer adoption soon if I don't yet see, say, small household electronics repair shops using a 3d printer to make spare plastic parts on the spot instead of keeping inventory or long waits for deliveries; or tacky accessory/imitation jewelry stores printing rings/whatever out of metallic substrates with custom sizes and coloring right after order, or stores that sell handheld items (any, from computer mice to firearms) offering to print custom grips to match your hand exactly. If I'd want to do business with 3d printing, then I'd start with such B2B usecases; or wait for the "right time to swing" at consumer market after this professional market is already full. By the way, "designing a 3d model" is out of pretty much any of these usecases, the model is either premade by others or generated by specific software from some scans/measurements; and there could be a lot of money in making this software or models for the many businesses that want to sell stuff, not design it. On the other hand, building stuff "on order" is speed sensitive as if you can do it with a waiting time comparable to, say, Starbucks, then you open up much more business models than if customers need to wait an hour for the printing.
- scoofy 13y agoI have a lot of practical stuff i've made. The fact is that 3d modeling with any precision is time consuming. The learning curve is STEEP, and open source modeling software is rarely intuitive, e.g. blender is absurdly complex. That is the thing holding back buyers. Modeling stuff is sketchup is great, but getting the measurements as you go requires lots of redundant measuring. Give me an intuitive, free solid-works clone and there will be an audience.
- rogerbinns 13y agoThere is a difference between "we can't think of functional uses now" and "nobody will ever be able to". Toys R Us are to a first approximation a store full of functionally useless figurines and toys ($14bn in sales per year). Increasingly kids will grow up limited by their imaginations, and not what is carried there. My fridge is full of containers, all of which could be differently shaped and sized to better suit me. It is awkward sending people things in the mail that aren't boxy due to standardised mailing containers - again being able to print the perfect one would be great. My garden could do with some innovative shapes such as a structure I can put half above ground, half below and put various plants in various orifices, have water flow and be stored in useful ways that reduce maintenance etc. Child safety seats could match the children exactly as they grow. Edible printing could throw open all sorts of creativity. Furniture could be made to fit spaces exactly. Printed items don't have to be rigid, which opens up possibilities in clothing - non-functional trinkets at first, but later on perfectly form fitting clothing for the occasion. The real question is what will never be technically possible, with a mild mixture of what will never be economically feasible.
- kansface 13y agoI disagree that 3D printers are the new 2D printers and everyone will eventually have one. Lets think about 3d printing in the context of the rise of 2d printers. Was the thing that held back personal printers the lack of things to print- at one point, likely. Did a massive influx of 3rd party things to print solve this problem? No. 2D printers were popularized because people had shit they needed to print- text documents to start with and later photos. They made these things themselves. Thingiverse was not the solution for 2d and won't be the solution for 3d. The only reason Thingiverse gets mentioned is that its damn near impossible for anyone who isn't a specialist in the field to design anything printable. The software is too complex and physical items must be durable. This say we solved the software problem. We still have the enormous problem that the vast majority of people are incapable of making cogent 3D designs. IE, customization isn't buying you anything other than the ability to emboss your name or make a slightly different iphone case. Really, name one item that the average Joe can customize that isn't kitsch. Here's my list: glasses and jewelery (and only the later with quite a bit of hand holding). You may name a few more, but they problem have integrated circuits or other components that are not printable (lenses, diamonds, etc). Maybe 3D printers will one day be valuable for printing out replacement parts; perhaps this is true. You'll take your broken whatsit to get 3D scanned and replaced. But of course, this business model may never come into existence due to copyright/patent laws. Even here, you will most likely get this done at your local kinkos because they will do it better, faster, and cheaper. I don't foresee personal 3d printers becoming a thing, if ever. Perhaps in 20 years I'll look back on this statement in the same way that I think about "why would anyone ever want a personal computer". We'll see.
- Flenser 13y agoI think there's lots of 6 year olds that would think printing figurines and toys were a practical application for a 3D printer. Toy companies will be giving printers away so they can advertise downloadable plans for action figures after saturday morning cartoons so kids can re-enact todays episode with todays costume/pose/accessories.
- 31reasons 13y agoPeople don't see much demand in 3D printing is because we are accustomed to mass manufacturing as the way of life for consuming goods. Just like the Web created the "long tail" demand for goods and services, customized manufacturing will open the doors for highly personalized goods. Imagine printing a helmet exactly for your head or printing very comfortable Car seat for your body shape. There will not be the shortage of demand but because the technology is so new there is definitely a shortage in imagination for its potential uses.
- deelowe 13y agoCan you provide an example of anything like that being 3d printed and actually used? The only use case I currently see for 3d printing is prototyping and very, very simple fixes(e.g. clips for chip bags). Sure there's various types out there used in one off manufacturing scenarios, but what home user needs anything like that? Traditional manufacturing processes produce higher quality parts and are more cost effective for most things you'd use a general purpose 3d printer for.
- angersock 13y agoOkay, I'll bite. One in obvious production would be dental fixtures and fillings--there are already CNC devices available. Another would be sex toys, or for auto shops.
- sliverstorm 13y agoOf course, the follow-up question; in what way is 3D printing superior to CNC dental fixture machines that already exist? Said CNC machines are already fast and small enough to fit into any dental practice.
- deelowe 13y agoActually the biomedical field is one of those areas where I think 3d printing makes a lot of sense. It's one field where basically every part is ideally a customized one-off. Though, I doubt anyone would buy a home 3d printer for this use-case.
- sien 13y agoGreat point. It would be interesting to see a Hacker News Poll on how much people have and use 2D printers now even, let alone 3D. It would be great to have access to a good 3D printer at a low price that was convenient at, say a Kinkos or something. 3D printers could well be more like good quality photo printers - something that is better used by lots of people at a shared facility.
- SupremumLimit 13y agoI don't think there's any correlation between the use of 2D and 3D printers - they don't have much in common other than the name. I expect the use of 2D printers to be declining as more and more things are done online, but custom fabrication of objects is another matter altogether.
- nickpinkston 13y agoWell they both are things you might just order instead or buying the machine. I don't own a 2D or 3D printer, but I use services for both.
- iamwil 13y agoSupremumLimit is right. 2D and 3D printers are fundamentally different things. The analogies you can draw are pretty shallow. As someone that has a 3D printer, I feel this way, but at this moment, I can't quite put my finger on why, other than the things you print out with a 3D printers can be used to solve your problems, whereas pages printed on a 2D printer is used to transfer or hold information.
- nickpinkston 13y agoI think you just love your 3D printer - which is totally cool, but I actually think the comparison is quite apt. There's a lot of people who love printing photos, flyers, etc. at the click of the mouse. We shouldn't demean that - there's a lot of real uses for 2D printing. The own/rent/outsource question is a big part of the future of digital fabrication. See my article in MAKE: http://makezine.com/2013/06/24/what-is-the-new-industrial-revolution/ http://makezine.com/2013/06/24/what-is-the-new-industrial-re...
- NoPiece 13y agoI would ask this question. What do people buy today that could instead be 3d printed? Probably not that much. But if the question was what do people buy today that could be printed by a higher quality easier to use larger scale printer of the future, then there is an exciting opportunity. And because that is exciting, it is worth paying attention today.
- hyperbovine 13y agoThe best use case I have dreamt up so far is replacing this annoying plastic guide that broke off my shower door. I have looked everywhere but cannot find a replacement. In short, I see your point.
- bigiain 13y agoI met a guy who bought a 3D Systems Cube - justifying it to himself (and his wife) saying he was going to use it to make toys for his kids for Xmas. It worked out great for that - then he realized that the broken part on the $250k+ printing press that was keeping it out of commission at work, and was unavailable because the manufacturer was in receivership, could also be easily enough modeled and printed out on his "toy". So he did, and it worked fine.
- Zecc 13y agoThis printing press at work, was it a commercial 3D printer? That would have been quite ironic. (under some definition of "ironic")
- bigiain 13y agoNope - it was some fairly specialized printer that printed onto thick corrugated cardboard to label packing boxes. 3D printers that print 3D printer parts are pretty much the whole idea behind RepRap - arguably one of the very first consumer/hobbyist 3D printer projects…
- bigiain 13y ago
- savrajsingh 13y agoAgreed. Though times are different now, here's a great video about revolutionary 3D printers, from 1989: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpRDuJ5YgoQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NpRDuJ5YgoQ
- stormbrew 13y agoI bet you could find a video about cell phones from 1975 or so that people in 1989 were laughing at (or would have been if youtube were around then). There's a cycle to these things.
- jfb 13y agoYeah, it's going nowhere until there's something that people actually want to print. When somebody figures this out, though, it is potentially truly disruptive, not in the Clay Christensen sense but in the "whoa Nelly there go the assumptions we've based a good part of our entire industrial economy on" sense.