5 ms·
I saw this on a miniature scale when I created a new subreddit (http://reddit.com/r/LSAT http://reddit.com/r/LSAT) I spent about two weeks creating quality art
by graeme 13y ago
I saw this on a miniature scale when I created a new subreddit (http://reddit.com/r/LSAT http://reddit.com/r/LSAT)
I spent about two weeks creating quality articles for the sidebar, personally replying to every submission/comment, manually recruiting anyone who mentioned the LSAT, and reaching out to moderators of related subreddits for links.
Mercifully, a subreddit is a small thing to launch, and after two weeks the place became self-sustaining and grew to 1500 subscribers.
I'm seeing the same thing again with a website I just launched (http://lsathacks.com http://lsathacks.com), which has free LSAT explanations.
Very positive initial comments, but just letting people know about it hasn't resulted in a surge of traffic. Instead, I'm going to have to manually recruit people. Only then will I know if it's worthwhile.
My point is that this doesn't apply just to high growth startups. Almost anything new requires initial unscaleable effort.
Edit: The LSAT is the Law School Admission Test, a logic test required for admission to North American law schools.
- vidar 13y agoThats a great way to practice user acquisition.
- rlu 13y agoYep. Reminds me a lot of when it was fairly common to start your own forum back in the early/mid 2000s. (phpbb, vBulletin, IPB, etc.)
- graeme 13y agoFor anyone interested in using a subreddit to practice acquiring users: Metareddit lets you track all mentions of keywords or phrases across Reddit. It let me find literally everyone who commented about the LSAT. http://metareddit.com http://metareddit.com
- rfnslyr 13y agoFantastic marketing tool.
- babs474 13y agoYou should give http://www.commentfindder.com http://www.commentfindder.com a try. I believe it has a more extensive index than metareddit which I'm pretty sure is based on google search. I'd love any feedback.
- seltzered_ 13y agoI just spent some time on it - I like the concept! The one thing I noticed is that I noticed less comment-worthy opportunities on here compared to just doing a search on twitter (for my work, I just search for "photoshop shortcut" or "illustrator shortcut"). There might be some more worthy places to also incorporate search in (quora comes to mind)
- graeme 13y agoSome quick notes. Mostly negative, only because I haven't used it long enough to notice advantages. Overall, it looks like a good site. Hope these are helpful: * I couldn't block subreddits from the feed. In my case, LSAT is also a weapon in some popular videos games. On Metareddit, I was able to block the most common gaming subreddits so those results never came up. * Metareddit produced an actual feed I could check once a day for new comments. This is more of a search engine. * I have to hover over the link to see the subreddit. That's often very relevant Apart from that, looks good. And obviously, these criticism depend on your use case. I used metareddit specifically for monitoring.
- babs474 13y agoThanks for the thoughts. I think the monitoring use case is a very natural next step. Basically "saved" searches. On commentfindder you can exclude specific subreddits with "-subreddit:askreddit" syntax or target subreddits by removing the minus. Of course, I should make this more obvious, right now its kind of a cheat code.
- JayNeely 13y agoI wish there were an RSS option for the search results sorted by recency. Would love to be able to see when there are new mentions for a term without having to come back and search frequently.
- aw3c2 13y agoBoth links say LSAT everywhere but I could not find any mention of what the acronym means! I had to check Wikipedia.
- graeme 13y agoOh yeah. Everyone in the target market knows what it is, otherwise it's pretty obscure. It's a logic test required for admission to law school in North America, highly competitive.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoMost Americans with college degrees have heard of it, even if we never go near law school. Same for the GMAT and MCAT.
- graeme 13y agoHow old are you? I'm 27. I find everyone in my target market (23 and under) knows about it, people my age don't always know about it, and people older than me often don't know about it.
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago38.
- anywherenotes 13y agoI'm 36, and when I saw LSAT I confused it with PSAT. So I thought I knew what it was, but was very much mistaking.
- DrPheltRight 13y agoI'm 23, didn't know.
- hkmurakami 13y agofor those of us who aren't familiar, GMAT is for business school and MCAT is for medical school.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoInterestingly from questions on their Meta sites StackExchange found that this sort of "priming the pump" didn't really work for them when it came to building on-line communities. Their attitude (having tried it) is now if the community doesn't build itself it won't sustain itself. If you've got a working community then you can promote it but this sort of work won't work to build a community that's not already there. Not saying that what PG says isn't true for start-ups which are obviously different, but it may be relevant in your case.
- damarquis 13y agoI love some of the SO sites but they have a lot of communities that have been lingering in beta limbo for ages. I would be interested in more detail on how they reached the conclusion that pump priming is not useful. Do you have a link?
- graeme 13y agoThat's an interesting result. Do you have a link where they explain how they came to their conclusion? Because I did build a community entirely by priming the pump. There was no community there. So it absolutely worked in my case. However, Reddit was an easy place to build a community, as I just had to tell existing Redditors who studied for the LSAT that there was now a subreddit for that. It was an easy sell.