15 ms·
Don't Even Think of Using Encryption Software to Escape NSA Scrutiny
- mtgx 13y agoGreat, so the choice is between using everything in the open, unencrypted, and then maybe they won't look at it, or encrypt it and then there's a very high chance they'll look at it. It seems to chill speech either way. This is why the wholesale spying must stop.
- drKarl 13y agoI´m pretty sure the unencrypted communications will be automatically parsed and processed to look for certain patterns or keyword, and if not found, ignored, but after processing nonetheless. They can attack an encrypted communication and probably decrypt it, but they just want you to be afraid of encrypting with fear of being targeted so that they have it easier to process your information. But that´s a fallacy and a puny tactic to make the general public afraid of being under scrutiny because of the very reason of using encryption. They might be able to decypher encrypted communications if they are the minority, but even with their big supercomputers and billions of dollars, I doubt they would be able to process people´s communication if encryption was the majority of communications. And these articles work towards the NSA´s goals and agenda misleading the public in thinking that it´s better not to use any encryption at all. If the public was educated on this subject and everyone used encryption, I guess they would have a really hard time processing all this information...
- jeffreyg 13y ago'a puny tactic to make the general public afraid' This 'tactic' was classified until leaked, so I don't think its purpose is to scare the public. My guess is that they just want tons of ciphertext samples to use in future cryptanalysis work.
- klez 13y agoOr maybe it's just masked as a leak when it's actually a controlled release.
- cinquemb 13y agoAre you suggesting this could be a limited hangout[0]? [0]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_hangout http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_hangout
- LoganCale 13y agoIt came from Snowden, so it's unlikely unless he's part of a broad conspiracy to release exactly what the NSA wants him to.
- jessaustin 13y agoSince he's apparently now deep in debriefment with the Ruskies, this would have been a brilliant counter-intel maneuver, leveraging the prejudices of all of us chattering morons to fake out everybody in the world. That it would have been brilliant, is how I know that General Surveillance and his minions didn't do it.
- LoganCale 13y agoThere's absolutely no evidence that's true. People are just speculating that the Russians might want to do that. As far as anyone knows, Snowden is still sitting in the transit area of the Moscow airport and has never left that location so far.
- jessaustin 13y agoPresumably they allow smartphones in the transit area? I feel like we would have seen something by now.
- davedx 13y ago> They can attack an encrypted communication and probably decrypt it Surely this is massively dependent on the kind of encryption being used?
- rgbrenner 13y ago"They can attack an encrypted communication and probably decrypt it" Why this assumption? The NSA has NO super-human abilities. And one of their jobs is to protect gov secrets. Which is why they participated in the AES standard. If you really believe they can decrypt AES, then you believe they chose an algo that is insecure, than would allow China, Russia and others with similar abilities to read any of our nation's secrets. Not to mention, that there are currently no known attacks that would allow them to decrypt AES in any reasonable amount of time, even if they had every single computer in the world. If you really believe the NSA can decrypt anything, then you're out in conspiracy-theory land, with magical yet-to-be-invented computers, and humans with super-math abilities.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rgbrenner 13y agoAES is approved for use in a type-1 system.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> The NSA has NO super-human abilities. No, but they do have a larger hardware budget than you. And a larger budget for crypto research.
- DennisP 13y agoA larger research budget than the entire open cryptographic community? Maybe. But it's not just about budget. A lot of the smartest cryptographers don't work for the NSA anymore, because they like to publish their research, and/or because industry pays better. If you haven't broken the algorithm, a "larger hardware budget" really isn't helpful at all. Key sizes are big enough that the laws of physics prevent you from brute-forcing them. From Bruce Schneier: "If we built a Dyson sphere around the sun and captured all its energy for 32 years, without any loss, we could power a computer to count up to 2^192. Of course, it wouldn't have the energy left over to perform any useful calculations with this counter." http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2009/09/the_doghouse_cr.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2009/09/the_doghouse_c... If they've made a huge breakthrough on quantum computers, they could break the popular public-key algorithms, but could only halve the effective key size of symmetric algorithms.
- nathan_long 13y ago>> They can attack an encrypted communication and probably decrypt it No. If you do it right, nobody on earth can decrypt it. From Bruce Schneier: >> In fact, we cannot even imagine a world where 256-bit brute force searches are possible. It requires some fundamental breakthroughs in physics and our understanding of the universe. For public-key cryptography, 2048-bit keys have same sort of property; longer is meaningless. and >> These numbers have nothing to do with the technology of the devices; they are the maximums that thermodynamics will allow. And they strongly imply that brute-force attacks against 256-bit keys will be infeasible until computers are built from something other than matter and occupy something other than space. http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2009/09/the_doghouse_cr.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2009/09/the_doghouse_c... Also, from Bitcoin Talk: >> But what about very well funded entities such as the US National Security Agency (NSA)? Could they build a machine to crack a 256 bit key? Assume they could build a theoretical nanocomputer that executes 10^13 instructions per second (approximate rate of atomic vibrations) in a space of a cube with a side that is 5.43nm across (This is the approximate size of a silicon lattice10 atoms wide, or a crystal containing 1000 silicon atoms). Assume that it could calculate an attempt in 10 cycles. Such a computer the size of the earth would take more than 10^13 years (roughly 58 times the estimated age of the earth) to attack a 256 bit algorithm via brute force. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=360.15;wap2 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=360.15;wap2
- leephillips 13y agoSnowden himself said it in a recent interview: the NSA can not decrypt your messages if you use a reasonable encryption method. They rely on endpoint security.
- MasterScrat 13y agoHow hard would it be to make an encryption system that produces a normal-looking text, which can only be decrypted with a specific key?
- drKarl 13y agoYou´re probably better of using steganography and hiding your message on images or videos.
- jvanenk 13y agoWhat your parent comment described is steganography. It's not strictly limited to images or videos. (1,2) (3,4) (10,7) (11,1) (12, 2)
- Intermernet 13y agoHEYLO ?
- a3_nm 13y agoIt would perhaps be possible to adapt text watermarking tools like <http://seclists.org/fulldisclosure/2002/Sep/68> http://seclists.org/fulldisclosure/2002/Sep/68> to function as steganography tools.
- DanBC 13y agoSteganography is hard. You need a large amount of cover text to hide the plain text. Many steganography systems use images or video or sound, but are 'proof of concept' - toys for learning - rather than serious tools. This, unfortunately, includes many of the steganography systems described as serious tools. One of the problems of hiding text in text is persuading people not to re-use the cover text.
- quchen 13y agoThey can't look at "it" when it's encrypted. They can look at data that is indistinguishable from random noise, and in case it can be decrypted in the future they will finally be able to do what they're doing with unencrypted data right now, probably still with considerable effort.
- a3_nm 13y ago> the choice is between using everything in the open, unencrypted, and then maybe they won't look at it, or encrypt it and then there's a very high chance they'll look at it ... but then it's encrypted. I'm not willing to take chances with the argument that if I send everything in the clear and take steps to act non-suspiciously then they won't intrude on my privacy. What I send in the clear I assume will be looked at; as for what is encrypted, they are welcome to store it and look at it as much as they like. (Yes, maybe they can break OpenPGP-grade encryption, but if this is the case then we're screwed anyway.)
- bornhuetter 13y agoMaybe we need the "Herd immunity" of a large number of people using encryption software. If a sufficient number of people are using encryption, then targeting those users becomes less worthwhile.
- antocv 13y agoIn a world were most people would use encryption, NSA and other agencies would just backdoor consumer hardware or libraries such as OpenSSL and pretend to cry over their sudden loss of power. Technology is not the solution to this problem, it is society and it can be solved by rule of law, accountability, revolution and such old forgotten concepts.
- Karunamon 13y agoOpenSSL? You mean the open source software with a million eyes on it? Technology is not the solution to this problem, it is A solution, among others.
- antocv 13y agoReally, a million eyes on it? Okay, lets go with that, to compile OpenSSl you need a compiler and an entire toolchain, an operatingsystem, microcode and hardware. In any layer it is possible for an organization such as NSA to do its dirty deeds. They dont fabricate their own chips/hardware for fun. Well, maybe for fun too, but not only for fun.
- jessaustin 13y agoSure we can't go around trusting trust. OTOH most of the compilers in general use see a number of eyeballs. Ditto for the operating systems. I could even see this becoming the case for hardware eventually. An evil system must model the system that relies on it in order to attack that relying system, while remaining functional in general. The longer you make the chain that inserts your nasty code into higher-layer objects, the more complicated, fragile, and discoverable the attack becomes.
- pvaldes 13y agounless everybody else does...
- binarymax 13y agoIf you are using Tor correctly, they can't target 'you' because they don't know who 'you' are. Also, have fun storing indefinitely all of my banal communications until forever.
- lscritch 13y ago>If you are using Tor correctly How can you be sure "they" are not running the exit node?
- vinceguidry 13y agoControlling the exit node does not inherently compromise anonymity, only allows access to the plaintext message. If using end-to-end encryption on top of Tor, you should be able to maintain both anonymity and protection from tampering and snooping.
- delinka 13y agoThey still don't know the source of the communication. Running an exit node means they can see where traffic is headed as it emerges from Tor, not that they can magically determine from whence it came. The problem here is that the destination can identify you. You, after all, are the one paying for that VM instance at that IP address within AWS. Who else would be connecting via SSH?
- gambiting 13y agoControlling the exit node does not help with Tor <-> Tor traffic.
- greyman 13y agoBut is it also true if they can monitor the whole Internet traffic?
- lgeek 13y agoAs far as I know, Tor is theoretically vulnerable to a correlation attack by an entity capable of monitoring the entry and exit nodes. Personally, I thought having this capability, plus actually implementing the attack was a bit far-fetched for most cases. However, reading about what the NSA might or might not be be doing, plus the fact that GCHQ is tapping the transatlantic cables and knowing that the US and western European intelligence agencies tend to cooperate, I'm not so sure anymore. I think at this point we can assume that other countries have similar capabilities as well. Knowing that the infrastructure for this kind of attacks is in place, I think the cost is a lot lower than I would have expected a few months ago.
- PurplePanda 13y agoSince I am not a citizen of that country I am quite happy to "not be treated as a United States person". And from the other point of view, Americans and American companies are surely aware of organisations other than local ones that they might want to keep secrets from, so I'm not sure that this information should change anyones behaviour.
- weland 13y agoI have a small conspiracy theory going, that they are using this sort of articles to discourage people from using encryption. I suggest that we all create a handful of large files from /dev/random, make torrents out of them, and seed them until their servers bleed out.
- drKarl 13y agoFor me it´s not a theory, thats what I said in my comment and I´m pretty sure they ARE actually using these articles to discourage people from using encryption. Your idea of seeding some /dev/random or attaching some /dev/random to emails sounds like a great idea, and also funny, to me. We should definitely do that!
- sigkill 13y agoIs 1 gigabyte fine?
- darxius 13y agoMake a quick website (hosted on Github or whatever), with a bunch of torrent links to a bunch of huge encrypted files. Then spread the word and give them something to spy on.
- drKarl 13y agoWouldn´t they probably find that github and just discard those torrents from their cryptanalysis?
- kernel_sanders 13y agoWhat if some percentage of the torrents there were used to transmit secret information?
- darxius 13y ago
- danbruc 13y agoI'd rather prefer they store my encrypted data forever over storing my unencrypted data for five years. Yes, they might be able to break the used cipher during my lifetime but there is at least a (good) chance that they will never see my data in plain. Therefore I have to completely disagree with the headline.
- quchen 13y agoI agree with this, especially if you keep in mind that there will probably be a large gap between being able to decrypt today's data in individual cases and being able to crunch it on a large scale.
- Swizec 13y agoXKCD once had a very salient comic on this point: https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/ The idea being, you think they can't break your encryption, but they can just break your fingers one by one until you tell them the password.
- shiven 13y agoHTTPS with perfect forward secrecy is passwordless :P Right?
- danbruc 13y agoTrue, but that only applies to data in flight. For everything you want to store and look at again you better have a key - otherwise you could just delete everything and arrive at essentially the same result.
- rgbrenner 13y agoSo you're saying: don't force the NSA to get a court order and force you to reveal the unencrypted data, just hand it over to them now so they can look at it any time they want?
- Svip 13y ago
- davidjohnstone 13y agoAs a non-American, apparently I'm already fair game, so there's no harm in using encryption.
- greyman 13y agoBut, for example, if they would run a query "select everyone who uses email encryption", and then analyze this subset of people further, then you might have placed yourself under radar, and they can have a closer look at your other non-encrypted traffic. Basically, you revealed that you "have something to hide". Anyway, I have found that if some article claims that you should or should not do something to protect yourself against NSA, it is almost always written by an amateur. The real experts know that we currently don't know which capabilities NSA has and what exactly they do, so it is almost impossible to assess if something will help or not help or hurt. My "amateur gut feeling" tells me that if you really want to send something secretly, you should at minimum setup a separate hardware+software with no connection point to your real identity. But this is not advice against NSA, just an opinion.
- cinquemb 13y agoFrom what the CIA officer who was operating out of the US embassy in moscow had on him when he was caught by russian authorities recently, that makes sense.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- noarchy 13y agoWhat is quite telling (at least within US media coverage) is that it is apparently only controversial that the NSA is spying on those in the US. The complete disregard for everyone else in the world seems almost casual, as if it isn't an issue at all. But indeed, let's keep using encryption. It is, after all, the US government that has a long history(1) of trying to keep encryption out of our non-American hands. (1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_in_the_U...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pyvek 13y agoEven if you don't encrypt your communications, can you be sure that NSA will not store your data indefinitely? Sure, they can pass the raw unencrypted data through their system, parse out the important bits, save them in a database with a unique key for you and then throw away the raw data. Are you OK with that? They have lied in the past and might even keep that raw data as well. How will you know? IMO, best bet is to keep it all encrypted. It sounds like an attempt to scare people into leaving their stuff open.
- orthecreedence 13y agoExactly. We're operating on the assumption that they are telling the truth. I think that's a pretty stupid assumption. This is just a scare tactic to get people to not use encryption, but it's also dimwitted because they could get a lot more mileage by saying "we can break all forms of encryption" and the American public would probably believe it (even with Snowden/a vocal minority calling out the NSA on the lie). The media would most likely propagate the lie because they don't seem to care about the rights/freedom of the people in the US more than creating a scare frenzy. In summation, the NSA are liars and will keep your data regardless, so encrypt everything, don't put anything sensitive on Google, Skype, Dropbox (you'd have to be really stupid to do this anyway), and call your senator.
- LoganCale 13y agoIt's possible they're pushing the story now as a scare tactic, but the source of this information is a document from the DoJ authorizing the NSA to collect and store U.S. data in certain cases, leaked by Snowden.
- muyuu 13y agohttp://www.garykessler.net/library/steganography.html http://www.garykessler.net/library/steganography.html
- decasteve 13y agoThe NSA's resources are finite. The more people that use encryption the more resources needed to store and attempt to crack it. Not to mention a push for users to continually adopt stronger encryption.
- cn2c 13y agoplease, ssh insecure? don't use encryption? wtf!
- jwr 13y agoActually, if I go to the trouble of encrypting my data, I have nothing against someone storing it indefinitely. That's the whole point of encryption — it no longer matters who has the data, it only matters who has the key.
- Ma8ee 13y agoThe problem with that is that what might be considered safe today might not be it tomorrow, whether it is some undetected flaw in the encryption implementation or even in the algorithm you are using, or if someone builds an effective quantum computer. edit: That was odd downvotes. Anyone care to explain?
- 77887 13y ago>>That was odd downvotes. Anyone care to explain? There seem to be a bunch of people that will down-vote every little thing. Unfortunately it has become quite sizable now. Just watch them down-vote this comment. They really are Re..tards.
- Dirlewanger 13y agoThose prime numbers aren't staying unsolved forever. Then again, with quantum computing still a ways off, I think we're good.
- bad_user 13y agoNot all public key cyphers are based on the difficulty of factorizing huge primes. Quantum computing only solves a small subset of problems we have, but it doesn't solve NP. AES-256 takes 2^256 guesses to break by brute force and by using Grover's quantum algorithm that's only improved to 2^128. It is something, but I can bet that AES-256 will at some point become insufficient due to Moore's law, not due to quantum computing - a theory that has originated in the 1980-1981 and that has yet to yield actual machines that we can use. And of course, Moore's law also works in our favour, since with more power and specialized chips, we'll be able to use bigger keys that aren't likely to be breakable by Moore's law or Quantum computing in the next century or even millennium. As long as we cannot reduce NP problems to P, then virtually unbreakable cryptography is possible. Also, cryptography as a (mathematical) field is pretty new.
- msy 13y agoAnd this is why we all need to start encrypting everything. Every HTTP request, every email. There's strength in numbers and privacy in a crowd. They may have massive resources but they're not limitless, we have the technology available to render tools like PRISM unfeasible for the foreseeable future, the choice is ours.
- danbruc 13y agoThe problem is that we are not enough - you have to get the other 95 % not really caring on the bandwagon...and this without causing the slightest bit of additional inconvenience.
- greyman 13y agoOr it is rather 99.995? ;-)
- danbruc 13y agoTrue. 316 million US citizens and 117 thousands of them signing the Snowden petition yields a first approximation of 99.96 %.
- eru 13y ago95% would be nice, but a few percent should be good enough, if there's enough traffic overall. (And even 100% would not be enough if there's almost no traffic, like in the beginning of the internet.) Absolute numbers matter more than shares, here.
- buro9 13y agoWe own websites... make them SSL. We affect the 95%.
- malloc2x 13y agoYou must assume that the NSA already has master keys for all domestic CA root certificates, and given how many were hacked recently, foreign ones too. In which case SSL traffic is effectively the same as plaintext to them. The solution could be a distributed CA system like http://convergence.io/ http://convergence.io/
- Buzaga 13y agowhat an awesome country you have there, eh? here's the rationale: if we don't have total awareness and snooping power over this guy private stuff, he must be doing secret stuff and we can't know if it's bad, therefore we have reason to believe he must be a TERRORIST(are you still using this one or have you admitted to yourself that the objective is just `total information awareness`?) also, cannot stop LOVING that non-americans basically have no fucking rights whatsoever.
- orthecreedence 13y agoAs an American, it's pretty sad. As if the rest of the world wasn't getting sick of us already. Let's stick our noses into everyone else's business all the time, start a bunch of wars for the obvious benefit of our corporations, crash the world economy (btw we're doing more derivatives trading again so expect another crash lolol), and now spying on every person in the world, US citizen or not. On top of it, instead of our media telling us "WAKE THE FUCK UP AND LOOK AT WHAT YOUR GOVERNMENT IS DOING!!" they are saying "Gee, where will Snowden go next lol?!?! Ohh he's in Moscow now, neat!!!!" I think the endorphin rush people get from receiving a Facebook message on their portable distraction device outweighs the negative feelings of the government spying on every aspect of our lives. People don't know what's happening two feet away from them, much less in their government or the world (besides what big media tells them). We're sliding fast down a slippery slope while chuckling and playing Farmville on the way down.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoThis article is idiotic, should I stop using HTTPS too? Telnet in to work?
- zeteo 13y agoThis doesn't follow. The article makes two points: 1. The NSA is allowed to store and analyze encrypted data longer than unencrypted 2. US citizens' encrypted data will be treated the same as non-citizens' It still seems you have a much better expectation of privacy by encrypting your data and trusting to mathematical proofs that it would take thousands of years to break it; rather than leaving it in the clear, and trusting to five year storage limits and the supposed privileges of American citizenship.
- quux 13y agoKeep in mind that as a rule of thumb, its useful to assume that the NSA is about 20 years ahead of the public in crypto research. Even if systems like HTTPS and Tor appear secure today, the NSA may already have knowledge of weaknesses that we don't.
- gulbrandr 13y agoCould you please provide sources to what you are mentioning?
- quux 13y agosee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5939782 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5939782
- drstrangevibes 13y agoblowfish ftw
- pja 13y agoTor is already vulnerable to anyone that can watch a large enough portion of global network traffic. Thanks to the NSA taps on US internet use & the (recently revealed) taps that GCHQ puts on EU internet traffic travelling through the UK it seems likely that the NSA can track Tor users in the US and most of Europe in real time if they choose to. (It's fairly likely that the US has covertly tapped undersea cables elsewhere in the world as well.)
- PavlovsCat 13y agoPersonally I thought encrypting stuff was just a temporary middle finger, and denazification the long term solution? After all, you don't get safety by complying with commands from your predators, that just gives them ideas. So how about simply ignoring all that. Think of vampires; they can't get in without your permission, and sunlight kills them real fucking quick, so quick you will doubt they ever existed. Sure they can be dangerous, but their main tools are lies, and foolishness of their victims. As Assange pointed out, censorship betrays fear. These people have nothing but a huge house of cards. Even if they ruled forever, they have nothing inside; they are a clenched fist around nothing, around a bluff, around fear. So they already lost anything humans can loose, they already went the way of the dinosaur, at "best" they can take us all with them. They have my pity, and those who are still able to get out I wish the best, but the rest should simply learn to know their place already. Regards, a deluded narcissist, writing from the fortress of his mind, unimpressed by noob stuff such as death.
- furyg3 13y agoUS Persons are protected from surveillance without a warrant. This is a right guaranteed to them by the Constitution. The burden of establishing if someone is a US Person should fall on the government agency performing surveillance. If they cannot establish if a US Person is party to the conversation, they should assume one is and remove the potential of violating this constitutionally guaranteed right. This could be due to a failure of the service provider (Google, Verizon) to collect this information (they don't), or the fact that the communications are anonymous or encrypted, etc. Proving a negative can be tough, but that burden is the government's to bear. Of course there is also a moral component… I'm pretty shocked that as patriotic as we are about the sacred rights of the constitution, we somehow feel that it is morally ok to not afford these protections when dealing with foreigners. The Declaration of Independence says: We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. With the rights to be enshrined more specifically later in the Constitution. How can anyone passionately agree with these words and not believe that the just treatment afforded to US citizens should somehow not be afforded to non-citizens, or citizens who choose to use a particular software program?
- superuser2 13y agoLawyers on HN and elsewhere have been pretty unequivocal in stating that the 4th amendment protects possessions, not communications.
- vilya 13y agoIf only we could get spammers to encrypt everything they send...
- lucian1900 13y agoIf only encrypted email was accepted, precisely that would happen :)
- INTPenis 13y agoTo whomever came up with that title; Never, Ever tell people not to encrypt things!
- bsenftner 13y agoIsn't every https page load and form submit an "encrypted communication"? This article seems to imply that any secure online surfing or shopping would trigger this "capture the encrypted communication" stuff. Thisvdoesbnot make sense.
- drstrangevibes 13y agoWhen encryption is encountered, however, the gloves can come off, with analysts being allowed to retain "communications that are enciphered or reasonably believed to contain secret meaning" for any period of time. --They are doing this anyway I'm sure Since the NSA guidelines say that a person "will not be treated as a United States person" without a positive identification based on name, address, electronic communication addresses or geographic location, encryption users may because classified -- at least temporarily -- as non-U.S. residents by NSA analysts. -- non sequituer fallacy, of course the encryption user cant be assumed to be a citizen if they dont know who the encryption user is. It doesnt mean you cease to be a citizen it means the unidentified entity cannot be assumed to have that privilege, point is as long as the entity is unidentified there is no connection with YOU. Presumably if they break the encryption (n.b. google recently invested in a quantum computer) they would be able to ID the encryption user and all the assumptions about citizenship would be re-applied.
- bjf 13y agoIs using a service like privnote a plausible way to communicate privately? According to the privacy policy, at no time is any note held in any readable format state on their servers. Also each message 'self destructs' after being opened one time.
- DanBC 13y agoAlways assume "No" unless you have a bunch of established crypto researchers who've looked at the system and who are prepared to use it themselves. People might say that "there are no posted attacks for privnote", but that just means the bad guys haven't told you they can crack your encryption. Since bad guys will never tell you that they can crack your encryption you must not assume lack of evidence of cracks is the same as lack of cracks. (http://pablohoffman.com/how-privnote-really-works http://pablohoffman.com/how-privnote-really-works) There's some stuff that is vaguely worrying about privnote. Really, learn GPG / PGP. Help other people learn it. Fix the UI. Fix the documentation. Sign everything. Encrypt everything.
- gasull 13y agoIsn't this giving in and doing exactly what they want, always using unencrypted communications? The question is, how much do you want an unchecked organization with no oversight to know about you? Do you trust the NSA to know everything about you and never do anything wrong with it, 10, 15 or 20 years from now?
- gasull 13y agoAlso, Snowden himself said that encryption works: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/17/edward-snowden-nsa-files-whistleblower#block-51bf3588e4b082a2ed2f5fc5 http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/17/edward-snowden-n...
- Nano2rad 13y agoIf you are considered a foreigner they have to break the encryption. If you are US citizen, constitutional restrictions have to be overcome. Nothing lost when encryption is used.
- dbg31415 13y agoI wish things weren't the way they are.
- sigkill 13y agoAlong with the headline, the layout of the header picture (with the man holding the flag) gives me the creepy 1984-ish vibes.
- gwgarry 13y agoScare tactics. They know they can't break encryption so they are threatening you with this. Encrypt away, it's better than not. They are going to keep the data forever anyway.
- hamoid 13y agoWhat if we all start attaching files with random content to our e-mails? An extension could do this automatically. Can the output of "dd if=/dev/urandom of=unicorns.pgp bs=1 count=1024" be easily distinguished from a real pgp file? No one could ever decrypt these files.
- edwintorok 13y agoAttaching random content to emails reminds me of Emacs's 'M-x spook' command (and I'm not even an Emacs user). As for distinguishing random data from PGP that is very easy: PGP messages (even binary ones) have some headers that determine who the recipient is, what encryption is used, etc. See here for the format of PGP messages: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4880 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4880 What you could do is to generate a public/private PGP keypair, then destroy the private key, and encrypt your /dev/urandom data using that public key.
- hamoid 13y agoIn that case one could create an extension that creates a PGP keypair _for the recipient_, attaches encrypted crap to the e-mail, and deletes the private key. Is that what you mean? The idea is to add by default an encrypted message to all e-mails that contain nothing useful, to make it indistinguishable from e-mails that do contain useful encrypted stuff. Is that possible? Does it make any sense?
- zby 13y agoWhatever - I am not a USA citizen - so they keep my communications anyway.
- anologwintermut 13y agoThis is a distraction. If you don't trust the NSA's oversight, then you should assume they keep everything for ever and taking issue with them being able to eavesdrop so easily. If you do trust the oversite, it makes sense that they keep encrypted data around since they have no easy way of knowing if its from a US person or not. Once they decrypt it and find out it is a US person, thats where you should focus. It should be as if they collected US Person data originally and should count it as collected when they actually got it, not decrypted it. As to the argument that the NSA could count anything as encrypted. Yep, they could. See point one.
- lawl 13y agoDoesn't matter, you should still encrypt anything. If they manage to break it, cool. If they use it against you it will become public knowledge what ciphers have been broken by the 404-Agency. Then just switch to a different cipher or up the bits.
- marc0 13y agoI always wondered why there are no mainstream mail clients which use encryption by default. With "by default" I do not mean that it's an option that may be turned on or not. Rather, as soon as an e-mail address is entered when composing a mail the client should search the key servers for available public keys, import them and encrypt the message. Likewise, it shouldn't even be possible to launch a mail client without having generated a key pair for your address. I see of course that there is this movement towards webmail, and this makes things more complicated. Wouldn't it be possible to write an online version of an encryption-friendly mail client? I mean, a web service which polls your mails via POP/IMAP from any server, and where the encryption is done client side in javascript. If that doesn't exist, maybe we should write one.
- 1337biz 13y agoRandom question: Is there some way to troll NSA by 42 zip exploits, i.e. a zip file that includes always bigger and bigger emptied zip files, only this time with relatively easy to crack passwords. Would be fun giving these some suspicious sounding names and sending them around in circles.
- kamjam 13y agoI starting to get the feeling that the best way to "encrypt" my data and stay safe from the watchful eyes of all the various agencies around the world is to just to go back to good old fashioned mail that physically gets posted in a box!
- graycat 13y agoBut, but, but we know for certain that there's nothing to worry about, nothing wrong, no violation of the Fourth Amendment. How do we know? Because the FISA court, all bow down, assume an appropriately servile, submissive, obsequious, respectful posture, told us so! And we all know that the FISA court is infallible, the great Wizard ("pay no attention to the man behind the curtain"), deserving of all our trust, right? Thank you; thank you; thank you, oh wonderful, all knowing, all seeing, all wise, all powerful, wonderful FISA court watching over us and taking such good care of us!! FISA court, I don't know who you are, where you are, what you do, or how to contact you or review your work, but I know that you are now watching over all of us. What a new day! For 200+ years we've had the restrictive Constitution from those skeptical founding fathers and suffered under such paranoia as "The price of liberty is eternal vigilance" when all we needed was the wonderful Father FISA court! Why didn't the founding fathers think of this???? I can believe that Hitler, Stalin, Mao, and even Pol Pot thought of this -- why not our founding fathers? At a secure, undisclosed location in the private chambers of the FISA court: "Darn, why can't we keep those ink pads for our rubber stamps in stock? Oh, well, the rest of the day is shot. Back to watching those SnapChat intercepts from Sweden!".
- alexqgb 13y agoI'm routinely hostile to people who use the "If you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear" apology. Few positions encapsulate a more dangerous concept of proper relations between the state and its citizens. And yet, when I think about how I actually live my life, my basic assumption is "I'm not doing anything wrong, I'm okay." The difference between how I think and how I behave is pretty glaring. Yeah, yeah, three felonies a day. I know. But there are a third of a billion people in the US. Given a billion felonies a day (more or less), it's easy to find comfort in statistics and probability. Honestly, I've got bigger and more likely problems to worry about than getting sucked into some Kafkaesque nightmare (though, like an attack by shark or bear, it's not impossible). No, what really concerns me is the emergence of a belief that the government is an impervious citadel, fortified against any democratic control or correction. When stuff like the spying scandal, or the crime spree on Wall Street, goes unchecked (let alone unpunished) it saps political will in general, and that leads to a social environment that really is intolerable. A tiny portion of the population resorting to encryption doesn't do anything to change that. The truly appropriate response is a political one, and one that goes well beyond the mass surveillance issue in particular. Specifically, we (the people) need to recover control of our own Congress. The mushrooming scandal with spying fits a broader pattern of regulatory capture, adding to the constellation of toxic effects that result. But at the heart of all this corruption, there's a relatively vulnerable target. That's because the mechanics of capturing legislators rest of four key pieces: private campaign finance, closed primaries, gerrymandered districts, and the revolving door between public and private offices. Before the apathy goes to deep, we need people to coalesce around a set of conditions for winning office. Specifically, no legislator gets past the voters if they haven't committed themselves to changes that make them exclusively beholden to the voters (i.e. open primaries, non-partisan redistricting, public election finance, and a lifetime hell-ban on going to work for the industries you once "regulated"). If someone promises to do all this, but balks once elected, throw them out systematically. Keep doing this until there is a critical mass of legislators who can push through reform that makes legislators dependent on the people alone. Not their financial backers, not their future employers, not their political parties, and not the voters they hand-pick. Lots of folks aren't worried about the NSA at all. There's a fairly disturbing number who actually think mass surveillance a good and necessary thing. But regardless of where you are on the political spectrum, there's a good chance that something about crony capitalism bothers the daylights out of you. Different people will have different reasons for insisting on the basic "you-work-for-us-alone" condition for winning office. That's fine. As long as people will hold legislators to it, the restoration of government of, by, and for the people can happen. But aside from this - from the sustained and forcible assertion of exclusive control over legislators - I don't see how the spying problem, or really any major problem, will resolve itself satisfactorily.
- 205guy 13y agoSounds like US citizens should have an unencrypted email signature saying: My name is XXX, I am a US citizen. My address is YYY. By the rights guaranteed by the US Constitution and supported by federal courts, the contents of this email are encrypted, private, and require a valid warrant to be intercepted, stored, or accessed by the US government.
- IceyEC 13y agothe statement "communications that are enciphered or reasonably believed to contain secret meaning" tells me that it doesn't even have to use Tor or be encrypted in any way. Double entendres, for example, contain 'secret meaning' and thus would also be included just as easily as encrypted communication!