11 ms·
"At it's heart, web design should be about words." No. The web is not just a place for text / words, that is not its heart and soul, and therefore neither is
by adventured 13y ago
"At it's heart, web design should be about words."
No.
The web is not just a place for text / words, that is not its heart and soul, and therefore neither is that the case for web design. It really never has been. I see no great argument in favor of words being the core over any other form of expression. Today's bandwidth more than allows for beautiful video, animation, high quality graphics and photos, etc. Or low key graphics, subtle interactivity, and so on. It's absurd to argue that such a rich medium should always be focused on words.
Text does not have to be the focus. It depends on what the purpose to be achieved is.
- weixiyen 13y agochange "words" to "content".
- adventured 13y agoI don't think so. That isn't what the person said. Their entire post was built around stripping down web design to the words. In fact, the author was very precise in the usage of the term "words." This for example: "But the most powerful tool on the web is still words." That blatantly is not the case in my opinion. Photos are vastly more powerful than words on today's web. That's why 3/4 of all the posts on Reddit's home page are links to imgur. That's why a gazillion photos are uploaded to and shared on Facebook every day. That's why you can read about protests in Brazil all day long, and until you see the photos, the sheer power of the protest will not ring anywhere near as loudly. This has been true so long as photography has existed. Whether we're talking about the Holocaust and WW2, an atomic bomb going off, or a photo of a kitten or puppy, you name it and photos win 9 times out of 10 over words. What would walking on the moon be like without photos (and video) to go with it? Would reading the transcripts have amazed the world like the imagery did? I say not even remotely. Imagine reading about a man standing in front of tanks in Tiananmen Square, versus seeing it. Another side note to all of this: there are almost a billion illiterate people still, sadly. And another billion that are only partially literate. Nearly every one of them can understand imagery. Imagery also crosses languages, you don't have to understand Mandarin to grasp the Tiananmen Square protest.
- weixiyen 13y agoHe was taking a stab at visual design / aesthetics being prioritized over content when building a product. Words are used simply here to better communicate his point. Nowhere did he say that words are more important than photos or video. You say "No" to him, but yet you know he would not disagree with what you have said regarding photos and video. I find the whole response to his original post borderline strawman.
- adventured 13y agoNowhere did the author actually say that. I would argue the evidence for focus on "words" is overwhelming, and that you're attempting to change the meaning of the piece. The author did say this however: "At it's heart, web design should be about words. Words don't come after the design is done. Words are the beginning, the core, the focus." The title is "Words" The author uses "writing" and "reading" and "words" over and over again. The word "content" isn't used once, nor anything like it (except as a negative, against content management systems). And the author says: "If you're a web designer, or a client who is working with one, I'd like to challenge you to think about words first. Instead of starting with a style guide or a Photoshop mockup, start with words on a page." Again, the author is intentionally guiding toward a very precise thing: words. There is no confusion on the focus, it's blatant.
- kragen 13y agoI have never seen a still image that conveyed the horror of the Holocaust to me in the way that Elie Wiesel's Night did. I have seen a movie that did: Schindler's List, which was fiction, made with actors; and which was made at enormous expense because of the things people had said and written. Beyond that, though, while images and movies are highly effective, if very expensive, ways of influencing people's feelings, they work just as well in the service of falsehood as in the service of truth. As such, they primarily work to amplify the influence of the powerful. Language allows you to share your thoughts instead of your feelings, and text in particular provides a much better way to gradually explore our way toward the truth. With language and text, mere power stands helpless before reason.
- 13y ago
- jkestner 13y agoRight. The majority of images on webpages are the design elements, not the photos. His point would still stand if he included a relevant image inline. Focus goes to the content, not the chrome.
- alex_hitchins 13y agoA good example - http://stallman.org/ http://stallman.org/ Horrendous on the eye but gives everything you need. And more.
- mixedbit 13y agoOn the other hand, yesterday there was a discussion on HN of Steve Jobs remark that his legacy won't survive long, because technology quickly becomes obsolete: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5906202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5906202 Words have much better chance of survival than other elements of web design. What was considered a decent design 10+ years ago, is today often laughable.
- adventured 13y agoThis opens a question on what exactly elements of web design are of course. Some would claim content isn't an element of design, others would claim the opposite. I would just remark that photos and video have the same survival aspect to them that text does. Particularly as our present and future is clearly one stored digitally. It's all bytes. I would also point out for fun, that duration of survival doesn't inherently equate to greater value or beauty. There are some ugly and boring things that last a very long time (rocks vs flowers; I think I can say that people tend to think certain flowers (roses) are inherently more beautiful than your average gray rock).
- koshak 13y agonot technology but tool. apple // was tool. It is obsolete. Netscape was a tool. Obsolete. Is TCP/IP obsolete? The trend of today is sticky headers. Tomorrow it will look rediculuous. Is it tech? No. It's the matter of fashion.
- derleth 13y agoTechnology is tools.
- lmm 13y agoSites made ten years ago with a design that focuses on the text still look good. Sites with a more "visual" design, even one that was very well regarded at the time, look far more dated.
- daenz 13y agoAgreed. The author is assuming our capacity for communication is/should be text based. We're visual beings as well, and aesthetics is a lubricant for effective communication.
- mijustin 13y agoAbsolutely. I clearly should have posted this on Instagram. ;)
- morsch 13y agoI think his point is that it's a communication system that facilitates communication amongst everyone. And everyone can communicate in words, typed out[0]. And not everyone can produce or effectively communicate using beautiful video, high quality graphics and, I guess, responsive design. [1] It's interesting to wonder what the next-common "wide area" communication mode is -- photos are widely shared, but is there a lot truly communicated with them? I guess it depends on whether you think those picture's typically say more than a thousand words. Videos, too. They serve as a topic of discussion amongst peers, not as a mode of discussion themselves. In fact the deeper point remains even if I conceded your argument: there are always those who excel in the creation of art and in presentation, regardless of medium. What makes the Internet different is that it facilitates peer to peer communication, that quality powered for the most part by the universality of written text. I guess that's why it if often compared to the invention of the printing press, another time such a fundamental shift in human communication took place (facilitating many to everyone, but not everyone to everyone). Those who excel in arts and communication -- and, to an unusual degree! engineering -- are still the magic wizards/grey eminences of the medium, prominently shaping something that wouldn't exist without them. [0] Words, typed out: A manner that's arguably truly more efficient and useful than what it's originated to represent, speech. Imagine consuming all the text content you read everyday on the web (such as this!) delivered by speech. [1] Leaving out the fact, that of course, not everyone has the ability to participate in words, typed out. While I do think it has served to interconnect everyone in terms of exchanging thoughts, it also serves as a means of separation between those who can and those who can't: lacking access or straight up capability to use this mode. Edit: added some more thoughts.
- adventured 13y agoEveryone can communicate in words? That isn't true, unfortunately. I don't see why you even said that, only to negate it at the bottom. More people can digest a photo than can read a specific language, by a radical margin.
- epo 13y agoAll of your contributions seem to denote someone who doesn't really have anything worthwhile to convey in writing. Try to communicate "Hire me, I'm experienced." in a photo. Share that on Facebook.
- kragen 13y agoIt's unfortunate that the article doesn't try to actually make the case for the primacy of linguistic communication, and I'm not going to take the time to do it here either. I'll just say that while I agree with you that a diversity of media is better than just one medium, I spent my childhood, before the Web was built, reading books instead of watching TV on purpose, not by accident. Books without pictures. And it's not an accident that I'm answering you in text instead of using my webcam. I have occasionally seen beautiful video on the web. I have much more frequently seen video whose author had deluded himself into thinking it was beautiful. http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2013-June/000979.html http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2013-June/00... talks some about the relative usefulness of different kinds of digital media.
- pnathan 13y agoDo you have a good citation for the primacy of linguistic communication? I have become profoundly convinced over the last 15 years that words (& to an extent, text), is the generally best mode of communication of meaning, beating out things such as video, images, smells, etc. But I've been generally unable to articulate that idea cleanly and persuasively.
- lelandbatey 13y agoI feel that words are the best way to communicate because words are born purely out of us; they are literally our thoughts in physical form. Videos, music, pictures, are all representations of physical things in the world around us; words are representations of the worlds inside us.
- williamcotton 13y agoI sometimes have a hard time putting certain thoughts or feelings in to words, in which case I either draw a picture, play a melody, or use one of the other myriad forms of expression available to me to communicate with others. I in no way feel like I am translating these thoughts from words to these other forms of expression. I have a much easier time singing a melody than transcribing it. I have to force the music to comply with written forms.
- sucramb 13y agoI think the authors point is that good content is more important than form and not that graphics and media should be forbidden. It just happens that HN is an excellent example for that - people come here for the content and not for fancy design, graphics and media. A friend of mine has a special weakness for Venice (Italy) because it is one of the few place without any billboards, i.e. graphics everywhere. It is not black and white but good food for thought.
- zanny 13y agoIn defense of words, hypertext markup language has a lot of tags for words (more than I could count on two hands) vs two hands worth for images, pictures, video, etc combined. Throw in CSS (which makes words pretty) and you have a lot of stuff to do with words, and not that much to do with arrays of pixels or sine waves.
- adventured 13y agoOk, but I'm not sure how the quantity of tags determines the value of the content contained. I can vary a graphic element or photo a near infinite number of ways prior to inserting it via one tag. I wouldn't say that argues in favor of imagery over text, or vice versa, however.
- zanny 13y agoI'm not arguing the value of the content, just the original intent. HTML was just meant to be a markup document language to display rich text over http.
- adventured 13y agoI definitely get you on that. Does that original intent say anything of whether words should be the heart and soul of web design however? Should black and white photography be the heart and soul of photography just because limitations (or costs) of technology started us there? I'm guessing you wouldn't argue that original intent should define future value, but these are all interesting points to discuss.
- pdpi 13y ago> I see no great argument in favour of words being the core over any other form of expression. I think the article zooms in on text for "shock value", if you will, but there's a deeper point. I trust you're not on Hacker News because of the aesthetically pleasing orange bar at the top of the page, you're here for the news, and the discussion. And that's what the article is getting at. We get so wrapped up in the tech stack powering our websites, and oh so elaborate presentation layers, that we sometimes forget that what truly, really matters is the content encased in all that.
- adventured 13y agoRight, and there's a very strong argument to be made for a text focus on Hacker News. As I said, it depends on what the purpose of a site / web page / etc. is. The point was that words are not the heart and soul of web design. There's nothing that argues in favor of an inherent bias to words over other forms of expression. That's my position.
- anu_gupta 13y agoOf course words are more important. Imagine the web without images. Maybe Boring, but largely functional. Now imagine the web without words.
- simpsond 13y agoAgreed. At it's heart, web design should be about conveying information effectively.
- Spearchucker 13y agoYour post reminds me of http://www.ftrain.com/wwic.html http://www.ftrain.com/wwic.html.
- mapgrep 13y ago>The web is not just a place for text/words, that is not its heart and soul... It really never has been. I am thinking back when they named the protocol the HyperText Transport Protocol and the primary format the HyperText Markup Language, text was indeed the heart and soul of the medium. At one point, images weren't even displayed inline but via a helper app. This is why Mosaic was a big deal.
- wmeredith 13y agoYeah, that's all fine and dandy, but what if we measure "what the web is for" in bandwidth? What do most people use the web "for"? Netflix and YouTube, I'd wager.
- strickjb9 13y agoNo, you are thinking of TCP. This is an article about HTTP. (in terms of bandwidth, HTTP ⊆ TCP)
- MichaelGG 13y agoPretty sure YouTube is transported over HTTP. Not sure about Netflix but I wouldn't be surprised. HTTP has become a generic TCP wrapper for the common request->response pattern.
- vacri 13y agoWireshark doesn't think so: 9792 42.750939000 74.125.109.232 10.1.1.21 TCP 1506 [TCP segment of a reassembled PDU]
- MichaelGG 13y agoDunno, I tried loading a YouTube page and capturing packets. Only ports in use were 443 and 80, even to the cdn-like hostnames (bla.c.youtube.com). First packet shows "GET /videoplayback?...."
- euxneks 13y agoAgreed. The internet is essentially about information. Words are a subset of information transmission. What we can take away from this page though, is that information should not be obstructed by cruft. I agree with that.
- bitwize 13y agoThe web is not just a place for text / words, that is not its heart and soul, and therefore neither is that the case for web design. I'd say that text is not only the heart and soul of the web, but also of motherfucking civilization. Animation and video are nice, and great adjuncts to text. But language is still the most common and easy way to store and share information intended to be consumed by humans, and since that's what the Web is all about, it's not only natural that the Web should be language-focused, but also unnatural that it be anything else.
- vorporeal 13y agoDrawings are the heart and soul of civilization. For one, they originated ~37 thousand years before the first written language. Second, understanding text requires knowing how the information it contains is encoded (what language it is written in). Drawings are far more universal.
- sramsay 13y agoPerhaps, but Classical Greek civilization remains startlingly intelligible to us after 2500 years. We stare up at the paintings on the caves at Lascaux having only the vaguest idea what they mean (and that's hardly the most recent example). One might also imagine how our understanding of, say, the Italian Renaissance might be affected were every painting to disappear, and then to reconsider the same scenario with every bit of writing erased. Both would be devastating, but as a student of human culture, I'd far prefer the former.
- scotchmi_st 13y agoThe fact that images pre-date anything vaguely similar to what we call civilisation shows that the two are not causally linked. Words /are/ causally linked with civilisation.
- drcube 13y agoAnd I read picture books before I graduated to books with text and chapters.
- 1123581321 13y ago
- sageikosa 13y ago>>"At it's heart, web design should be about words." >No. There's some strange dissonance going on in my head reading this on a site with practically no images at all. Once images went inline, the web's focus moved from content to presentation, much to its detriment (in my humble opinion). We progressively became more at the mercy of the page designer rather than the copy editor.
- BHSPitMonkey 13y agoI don't think posting a comment counts as "web design". Nobody said "writing comments shouldn't be about words".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sageikosa 13y agoThere is a "design" to this page. It just doesn't include pictures, videos, hover bars, animated banners, nor advertisements for weird tricks to lose weight. This site is about the flow of textual information. I like a usable application interface as much as the next guy, and am quite happy to see native interfaces (even if they aren't my beloved WPF ;-) rise back into prominence so that the hyper-text transfer protocol can get back to carrying hyper-text.
- BHSPitMonkey 13y agoThe people who built HN did the web design you speak of; Web design is not what users posting comments are doing.
- sageikosa 13y agoYes (except I am not speaking, I'm whispering). I never implied that posters and commentators were doing web design while using this site; I started with a comment on the dissonance of reading a statement refuting the web as a textual medium on a site that is effectively only a textual medium.
- tracker1 13y agoExactly.. without the graphics, audio, plugins, etc... it may as well be gopher, which most browsers don't even support anymore.
- tracker1 13y agoI don't get why the above post is so inflamatory to some... I used to use gopher, don't recall the ui all that well, but it was useful. Most browsers early on supported gopher as a protocol, and most do not today. And without the support of richer media (from images, to audio, scripting, even plugins) the web would not have been nearly as successful.
- CodeMage 13y agoAnd yet you chose to present your ideas using words. At the heart of the Web is the communication between humans. At the heart of that communication are words. You can argue that we can communicate using images, but that communication is limited when compared to words. You can argue that we can communicate using sounds, but unless those sounds are words, the communication is limited in the same way as when using pure images. You can argue that the Web is not only about communication between humans (e.g. we can do shopping online), but the communication is indispensable for all those other services. You can argue that the Web is not only about communication between humans, but all that machine-to-machine communication is ultimately there to connect humans. Web design is there to help you achieve whatever you're trying to do on the Web in a way that's more appealing and easier to interact with. I think that Justin's assertion is that words are at the heart of whatever you're trying to do on the Web. And I think he's dead on.
- adriand 13y ago> You can argue that we can communicate using images, but that communication is limited when compared to words. Like so many other things, it depends. When people are online looking to book a bed and breakfast, buy a pair of shoes or find a date, they tend to find images very valuable indeed. In fact, in the absence of images, many of the web's transactions would simply not happen. It's not for nothing that we often say, 'a picture is worth a thousand words'.
- pseut 13y ago"It's not for nothing that we often say, 'a picture is worth a thousand words'." This sentence can support either side of the argument. I love it. Draw that sentence.
- ErrantX 13y agoIt's funny but this is not really true. We've just finished a massive UI test involving a choice our users have to make during sign up. Various graphical images illustrating the choice caused more confusion than a short sentence for each. We also found replacing text links with icons increased support requests from new users by a noticeable margin. AND when keeping the icons and restoring the text it was still above baseline My view is that for length and complex ideas images or video can be illustrative. But for 90% of interactions text is always clearer.
- mwcampbell 13y agoWords delivered as electronic text are a great equalizer, for both the writer and the reader. Words impose no accessibility barriers for people with sensory disabilities. Words require minimal bandwidth. Even for readers with no significant disability or bandwidth limitation, words are great because the reader can read them in whatever way he or she sees fit (computer screen, e-ink display, printed page, text-to-speech). Written words allow a writer to communicate without being hindered or prejudged by things beyond his or her control, such as accent, rate of speech, sound of voice, or poor acoustics. A writer can rewrite and edit his or her words to say exactly what he or she wants, far more easily than one can edit a video or audio recording. Electronic text is more amenable to analysis and manipulation (e.g. translation) by machine than any other human communication medium. I'm not so sure about this, but written words might favor reason over emotion, especially if one can disable presentation hints. For these reasons and more, the Web should be primarily about written words delivered as electronic text.
- sillysaurus 13y agoI see no great argument in favor of words being the core of any other form of expression. Except the novel, the poem, the play, the scientific paper, the biography, the corporate operating agreement, the rule of law...
- scotchmi_st 13y agoThis argument really irritates me. Apart from all of the excellent reasons that other commenters have given as to why this is false, the fact that programs such as Instagram are as popular as they are, /that do nothing other than remove everything but the text from a page/, shows this is false.
- mijustin 13y agoIt's funny... there haven't been many photo responses in this HN thread. ;)
- Anonymous238 13y agoAgreed. If you want static text pages, go back to the 90s. We didn't feel very connected then, and there wasn't a big sense of community. It was mostly people publishing static pages for others to consume. Not much fun. Things have changed for a reason, and the internet has become a much more powerful place. This article is absolutely pointless. Great, you didn't use a CMS, your content is now harder to manage. Users can't register or comment, so where do they discuss your article? Wait, they have to go to another site to do that, one that isn't completely dated.
- bargl 13y agoI think that if you replace "words" with "story" then he hit the nail on the head. The web is about a story (not just words) and those can be told through a variety of mediums, but in this case, the author used words.
- e3pi 13y ago"At it's heart, web design should be about words." Yes. I corrupt too many hours concerned with flash, and dressing words in garish nonsense. Minimalist HN is an excellent model to excise and distain word flash dreck, and images or whatever kind of vid snippet. Look at HN's traffic, others agree. With the myriad digressions of image, js, and html5 magic, it's difficult for me not to be seduced by other's new eye candy. But the best pages I like to find, are simplest original tty, possibly with a word centric CGI engine dynamically serving up what I want, or what I didn't know I want. Most often then not, these plain forged dynamic/static pages, I bookmark. Some site's landing page ar so busy loading, to read what I want I drag-copy or 'print' if that's an option. If not, forget it, it's just too much painful nonsense spam or Las Vegas sequins headache to tolerate. I'd also prefer a text browser, but gave up as none seem to keep up with required js, certificates-ssl, etc. I'm no longer an infant, or a girl believing in fuschia unicorns, let's lose those brain-numbing colors too.
- dthunt 13y agoI honestly believe that we could fix HTML by stripping javascript out, or narrowing its scope such that it was incapable of asking anything about the presentation of content and interface devices. Why should anyone care whether a web-page is being read by a human using a cell-phone, from a terminal, by a blind person with a braile reader, an elderly man with essential tremor (hint: fiddly pop-up-and-disappear menus are really hard for some people), someone using JAWS or other screen reading technology, whether someone is actually not a someone at all, but a rather a computer program Jim wrote to alert him of news stories he might want to read. Why should we care if someone uses a mouse with or without a scroll-wheel, or if he has an 24-bit display? It's frightening to think that the peak of web-accessibility may have been in the past, and that the web is getting harder, rather than easy to 'design for', as people slowly but surely continue to try and gobble up the browser's job of presenting content, so that they can get it to do display according to their own arbitrary sensibilities instead of expressing basic intent.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dk8996 13y agoI agree. I think the old way was about content now it's about a apps. One of those, if good, solves a problem.
- sidcool 13y agoWhile your argument seems persuading at first read, a second glance makes it clear that it's a refute just for the sake of it.
- alex_hitchins 13y agoShow me a good, informative webpage without words.