10 ms·
So is the 4th amendment, and look how much that one is abused. In the end the Constitution really is "just a piece of paper", if not the government, not the jud
by mtgx 13y ago
So is the 4th amendment, and look how much that one is abused. In the end the Constitution really is "just a piece of paper", if not the government, not the judges, not the media, and ultimately not even the people respect it, live by it, and try to protect it as soon as it's endangered by people trying to accumulate too much power. Where are all the street protests?!
I also fail to understand people who so viciously defend the 2nd amendment "because of potential tyranny", but don't try to defend the 1st and 4th amendments with the same aggressiveness, when in fact those amendments are the first line of defense against that encroaching tyranny, and if they fail, it's the first clue the country is slipping into tyranny. Would you rather wait until the very last moment, until people can't take it anymore but to rise up against the government with violence and starting a massacre, all just to remove the government? Or would you try to fix things while you still can do it peacefully, by protecting the 1st and 4th amendments, so it doesn't have to come to "using the 2nd amendment right to defend against the government with guns"?
Or maybe it all comes down to who has more money to raise the awareness about it. NRA is a powerful lobby. ACLU and EFF less so.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWhere are all the street protests?! The people who went to the streets protesting in 2011 got arrested. You're looking at the maturation of a tyrannical, authoritarian neoliberal regime.
- criley 13y agoI like you said "got arrested" instead of "got thrown into jail indefinitely". Are any Occupiers in prison without having committed crimes worthy of the sentence? Or are you just being extremely hyperbolic?
- talmand 13y agoThere were groups who have protested who had no serious arrests to report. There were some groups that had a heavy amount of arrests. If one were to look at all the groups protesting recently with an objective eye I'm sure examples can be found that show why one group had such results.
- rbanffy 13y agoCould you clarify that?
- talmand 13y agoI wish I could but it would likely turn into an argument over partisan politics and name-calling. I'd rather not to do that. What I would suggest is look into major political protests over the past few years and draw your own conclusions from their outcomes.
- malandrew 13y agoIf I were to bet on the most significant predictor of arrests during a protest, my money would be on size. The fewer people present in a protest, the more likely that it will be left alone and no arrests will be made. The more people there are, the more likely that those in charge will try to "contain it" through actions that lead to altercations and arrests. I'd say that it's pretty much impossible to have a Tiananmen Square size protest in the US (or any other country with sufficiently advanced surveillance systems for that matter)
- talmand 13y agoThat may be in the case in some situations, but I can recall several major, i.e. large, protests that resulted in very few arrests or problems with the police. In fact, some of them were a quite pleasant crowd if the reports were to be believed. Sadly, you just generally don't hear much of them in the news.
- marcosdumay 13y ago> tyrannical, authoritarian neoliberal One of those adjectives has an almost oposite meaning to the other two. Please, don't just throw "bad" words in a setence if you are trying to make a point. Understand what you are saying, and if you don't completely grasp the meaning of a word, either look it up, or not use it. The way you wrote it, you sound like a South America neofacist (and yes, I just made up a label). And I'm quite sure you are not proposing creating a facist government hidden behind populist policiy, thus you should not speack like one.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIt only sounds contradictory. In actual fact, neoliberal regimes everywhere have been "libertarian" only in their business laws, and authoritarian in nearly everything else. The US is becoming rather like Pinochet's Chile: money can do what it wants, everyone else has orders to follow.
- DamnYuppie 13y agoI don't disagree with you on the importance of the 1st and 4th amendments. I think the ACLU and EFF will indeed become stronger. I don't know of any 2nd amendment supporters who are also not strong 1st and 4th supporters, the issue comes down to how their voice is heard. Also I don't know any of them who who wouldn't rather change things peacefully, it is a much better solution.
- skaevola 13y agoI don't think this is true. There are many on the right who detest the ACLU as liberals trying to undermine the country.
- mindcrime 13y agoNo doubt. That reminds me of the old joke "If you get stuff in the mail from the ACLU and the NRA, you're probably a libertarian". As somebody who is an NRA member and who has donated to the ACLU, that rings true to me. :-)
- DamnYuppie 13y agoMany as in raw # or as in percentage? To be honest I haven't met many of those, all the ones I know are more libertarians then conservatives so they don't take strong issue with the ACLU or EFF.
- skaevola 13y agoI just did some searching to try to find what percentage of the Republican Party identifies as libertarian as opposed to conservative, and I didn't have much luck. But, considering the party's platforms on gay marriage and immigration, I think the percentage of libertarians is small.
- fpgeek 13y ago> I don't know of any 2nd amendment supporters who are also not strong 1st and 4th supporters Are you sure? For instance, on cultural grounds, I'd guess that there are plenty of 2nd amendment supporters who would be happy to ban flag-burning...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pekk 13y agoThreatening to take up arms is a way to pressure for political concessions as an end-run around representative democracy, when you aren't getting what you want (for example, when the populace elects the 'wrong' President).
- talmand 13y agoI would suppose it's possible for the populace to threaten to take up arms when the representative democracy isn't so representative anymore. An opposing viewpoint doesn't always fit so cleanly within a partisan view.
- invalidOrTaken 13y agoYou have the order wrong. Voting is an end run around war. An election is a civilized war, meant to get the same outcome as war without bloodshed.
- rayiner 13y agoThe 4th amendment is strong as it has ever been, and the 1st is much stronger.[1] Are police knocking down your door without a warrant? If not that's the 4th amendment working as intended. What we have here is a system: 1) Clearly designed to pass a 4th amendment analysis; 2) Enabled to to pass such scrutiny be the unprecedented access Americans give corporations to the details of their private lives. For what its worth I think the NSA programs are bad ideas, in an administration that has had a lot of them.[2] But not every bad idea is unconstitutional, that is to say not every bad idea can be fixed in court rather than in Congress. [1] In light of this story, who is still mad at the Supreme Court for holding that Congress couldn't shut down the speech of corporations (like the ACLU?) [2] Menacing over the Supreme Court justices during the state of the union probably being the worst.
- anon1385 13y ago>The 4th amendment is strong as it has ever been […] Are police knocking down your door without a warrant? Yes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kentucky_v._King https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kentucky_v._King Justice Ginsburg , dissenting. The Court today arms the police with a way routinely to dishonor the Fourth Amendment ’s warrant requirement in drug cases. In lieu of presenting their evidence to a neutral magistrate, police officers may now knock, listen, then break the door down, nevermind that they had ample time to obtain a warrant. I dissent from the Court’s reduction of the Fourth Amendment ’s force. http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/09-1272.ZD.html http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/09-1272.ZD.html
- rayiner 13y agoYou're haggling over the definition of "reasonable", probably based on your views of the drug laws. Do you think that in 1800, the framers would have considered it an unreasonable search to enter a home they could hear being burglarized? No. That's why the 4th uses the wiggle word "unreasonable." I'd bet the reason you think Kentucky is different is that you think drugs are a non crime. I do too, but lots of people do. I grew up in "just say no" suburbia. My mom and lots like her (see the reddit meme: scumbag suburban mom) thinks drugs are the worst thing ever. In any case, Kentucky is an affirmation of the very simple principle that a warrant is not required. For better or worse, the framers did not give us a 4th amendment that admitted no compromises. They gave us one that asked us to analyze whether a search was "reasonable", asking us to reach compromises.
- jebblue 13y ago>> I also fail to understand people who so viciously defend the 2nd amendment The definition of "viciously" at: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/viciously http://www.thefreedictionary.com/viciously "Having the nature of vice; evil, immoral, or depraved." What was vicious about newbie12's comment which was a direct quote from an American President? http://www.monticello.org/site/jefferson/when-government-fears-people-there-libertyquotation http://www.monticello.org/site/jefferson/when-government-fea...
- rdl 13y agoHe was clearly using sense 6, meaning "forcefully"
- munificent 13y ago> Where are all the street protests?! I'm going to interpret that question literally. A key thing you have to keep in mind is that in almost all of the US outside of a few very large cities, the "street" is not a useful public place. People don't gather and interact on streets in the US. They are merely channels for cars. Protesting on the streets would be as useful in most cities in the US as wandering around next to a shipping lane on the open ocean. The only people "there" are driving vehicles at full speed. That of course raises the question of where Americans do congregate together. Churches are the answer for many, although I believe those are dwindling. Some go to bars. Neither of those is a particularly good venue for dissent. One unfortunate consequence of the US being so car-centric is that we've destroyed public space, and consequently made public assembly much harder.
- Abundnce10 13y agoYou bring up a good point. Maybe the best form of protest these days is not to take to the streets but rather take to the highways. Blocking a interstate highway going into/out of a large city might get more attention.
- kbenson 13y agoThis would be remarkably effective at getting attention, but I'm not sure how beneficial to a cause it would be. If the purpose is to disrupt travel or commerce, it would most likely achieve it's goal almost immediately. If the purpose is to bring attention to some other issue and the disruption of the highway system is unrelated (or only tangentially related), then the attention would have to be weighed against the negative impression it creates for the many affected. I don't have the relevant experience in this area to know under what circumstances protests that negatively impact average people succeed in their goals.
- mahmud 13y agoThis would be a bad idea, tacically and economically. In a protest, at least in the U.S., you can take measures to protect your identity and not carry any documentation, along with the ability to flee on foot in any direction. You also have no tangible assets on you that the government can seize. In a vehicle protest you forfeit anonymity (lincense plates), ability to split since road-blocks can easily stop you, and most importantly your vehicle might be impounded.
- mindcrime 13y agoWhere are all the street protests?! Over the digital privacy / 4A issue specifically? I don't know. But protests in general are still quite alive, here in North Carolina.[1][2][3] [1]: http://www.newsobserver.com/2013/05/13/2890544/nc-moral-monday-demonstrations.html http://www.newsobserver.com/2013/05/13/2890544/nc-moral-mond... [2]: http://www.wral.com/-mega-moral-monday-protests-heat-up-outside-legislature/12511141/ http://www.wral.com/-mega-moral-monday-protests-heat-up-outs... [3]: http://www.thenation.com/article/174679/protesters-shake-north-carolina-legislature-moral-monday-demonstrations http://www.thenation.com/article/174679/protesters-shake-nor...
- tsotha 13y agoIt takes awhile for a protest movement to actually mobilize, particularly if you're trying to bring in more than the professional protest group everyone ignores without a second thought. We won't know for a month or two whether this has legs or not.