6 ms·
What's the big mystery here? There have been published articles on the ease of hacking car remotes (and even the onboard electronics) going back at least a cou
by mindcrime 13y ago
What's the big mystery here? There have been published articles on the ease of hacking car remotes (and even the onboard electronics) going back at least a couple of years. For example:
http://content.usatoday.com/communities/driveon/post/2011/01/car-theives-can-eaisly-hack-remote-keyless-systems-swiss-research-discovers/1#.Ua9oK-lMY7w http://content.usatoday.com/communities/driveon/post/2011/01...
http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/07/hacking_bmws_re.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2012/07/hacking_bmws_r...
http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13746_7-20085131-48/remote-unlock-and-start-for-cars-hacked/ http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13746_7-20085131-48/remote-unlo...
http://news.consumerreports.org/cars/2011/03/researchers-cars-electronics-can-be-hacked-remotely.html http://news.consumerreports.org/cars/2011/03/researchers-car...
Here's a video (with no commentary, unfortunately) that shows someone who has apparently decoded the signals from a car remote and is using the remote and an arduino, to toggle some LEDs:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=doELL4g4cS0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=doELL4g4cS0
I have little doubt that there are hackers out there who can easily build a device to remotely unlock / start cars that use keyless entry. In fact, I'd be far more surprised if there weren't.
Edit: to elaborate... when I say "What's the big mystery" I'm referring to a notion, which I interpreted from the article (rightly or wrongly), that people are totally unaware that this kind of thing is even conceptually possible. I don't claim to know the exact exploit or mechanism being used here! Just pointing out that this general class of attacks isn't something totally foreign and unknown.
- jrochkind1 13y agoOh, but according to SOMEONE (source for this claim is not given) "That code is encrypted and constantly changing — and should be hackproof." American media at it's best!
- jcampbell1 13y agoHow would you describe a challenge based authentication system that uses 128-bit AES? I find the reporter's description reasonable.
- mindcrime 13y agoYour comment piqued my interest, as I wasn't sure if car manufacturers were really using 128-bit AES or not. That led me to this page: http://ir.atmel.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=665225 http://ir.atmel.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=665225 Where Atmel announced a new transponder chip & microcontroller, which do, indeed, use 128-bit AES. This is from 2012 though, so I'm not sure how widely adopted this particular chip is, or if other, older chips are in widespread use that are 128-bit AES. But even if everybody is using 128-bit AES, all that means is that the actual encryption itself is probably essentially unbreakable. But, as well all know, cryptographic systems are more than just the raw crypto algorithm. All sorts of systems which use crypto are eventually found to be insecure, so this whole thing should still come as little surprise (well, to people like us anyway. To the average cop, maybe this all sounds like black magic).
- jcampbell1 13y agoTo me this looks like a Honda/Acura specific exploit to unlock the passenger side door. It doesn't look like a replay attack, nor do these guys have the ability to start and steal the car, which uses separate encryption keys from the locks. I agree with you that this crypto system failure, not an algorithm exploit.
- Zimahl 13y agoOr they are just really smart thieves. Better to get caught with petty theft than grand theft auto. Also, maybe keeping the crime as just theft is keeping it under the radar - the cops aren't going to throw up any road blocks for that level of crime.
- DanBC 13y agoEnclosed, but not encrypted (http://www.h-online.com/security/features/Enclosed-but-not-encrypted-746199.html http://www.h-online.com/security/features/Enclosed-but-not-e...) A make of USB drive enclosure that claimed to be using AES 128 bit encryption, but it turns out that wasn't for the data.
- 13y ago
- adventured 13y agoWhat does it have to do with American media in general? Or were you just randomly bashing? Versus the amazing quality of Chinese or Russian media? Brazilian media? Romanian media? Or maybe it's the French that have outstanding journalistic integrity and never make mistakes!
- piqufoh 13y ago"What's the big mystery here?" That California PD haven't googled this yet...
- Glyptodon 13y agoIf they were using key reprogramming/hacking there's no reason to 'always use' the passenger side front door as claimed in the video. So I don't think it's clear that these thieves are using any of those techniques. I imagine it might be stupider, like maybe there's a way to induce the unlock button or motor to trigger via induction or something. Though I'm pretty poorly informed about that kind of thing scientifically and am likely completely wrong.
- mindcrime 13y agoIf they were using key reprogramming/hacking there's no reason to 'always use' the passenger side front door as claimed in the video. It's a fair point, but I don't know that I'd take that at face value. That could have just been a subjective assessment that got repeated as fact. Without us having access to the actual videos or the raw numbers, it's hard to say. So I don't think it's clear that these thieves are using any of those techniques. Sure, and I'm not saying it's 100% certain that this is exactly how the thieves are operating.. just pointing out that it's well known that modern cars are vulnerable... if there are additional, as yet unreported vulnerabilities, would anybody be surprised? I imagine it might be stupider, like maybe there's a way to induce the unlock button to trigger via induction or something. That actually strikes me as semi-reasonable, without having research the matter in any depth. Where were you on the night of January 12th, when a black Suburban was stolen ...
- michael_h 13y agoI would assume that they use the passenger side front door because that is where the storage compartment is located.
- adammil 13y agoThey use the passenger side door because its the one facing the sidewalk.
- PaulMcCartney 13y agoNot in the video posted. Both cars look like they are on a driveway.
- corresation 13y agoYou ask what the big mystery is, and then link to a lot of unrelated hacks/exploits. Yes, the article is that someone hacked/exploited the remote door open specifically, apparently on seemingly random cars. It is a mystery how they are doing it, though it is painfully obvious that they are exploiting something.
- mindcrime 13y agoYou ask what the big mystery is, and then link to a lot of unrelated hacks/exploits. I don't see how you can say that is "unrelated". Even if our "mystery" thieves aren't using those exact exploits, there is NO "mystery" that hackers have demonstrated the ability to break car remote systems. But the article and the quotes from the police make it sound like the police are just staring at the wall, drooling and going "duuuhhh huhhh huhhhh... how'd they do that.. duhhuhhhh huhhhhh." Now that's probably not literally the case, but the article makes it sound like nobody has even the slightest clue that this stuff is possible, or how it's done. And that's just not true.
- corresation 13y agoThe article makes it sound exactly like what it seems to be -- that the thieves are using an exploit that they don't know, and thus they want to know. One of the guys quoted makes a profession out of this and he doesn't know what they're doing. But apparently lots of people on HN do.
- mindcrime 13y agoNobody here has claimed to know exactly what exploit the thieves are using. But a lot of people are claiming (rightly) that general knowledge that these car systems have vulnerabilities is widespread. And that point is what seemed, to me, to be missing from TFA. If TFA had given some more context, and said "exploits which would allow this type of access were shown at a recent hacker conference, and some cars have known exploitable vulnerabilities... but we don't know if this crop of thieves are using that or a newer, unpublished exploit" then it would, IMO, have been a better article. Instead, it leaves people with the idea that this whole concept (hacking cars) is something brand new, unknown, and unexpected. And it's not.
- iblaine 13y ago>What's the big mystery here? The method that the thieves are using is unknown. While those links to may be useful to shed light on this type of crime, they do little to confirm the method that these thieves are employing. Hence, there is mystery.
- mindcrime 13y agoAgreed, there is a mystery about the exact details. I read TFA as suggesting that the fundamental concept of "car hacking" is unknown. I was responding more to the generalization that I felt like I observed, than to the question of exactly how this specific set of thieves is working. I should have been more clear on that point.
- inafield 13y agoI'd be willing to bet that someone has stolen some universal unlock codes for a variety of manufacturers and it is now in the wild. Of course, no car company wants to admit this.
- nutjob123 13y agoI would also put money on something like this. Honda/Acura was the only brand mentioned in the video so I can even guess who lost them.