8 ms·
Florida shortened yellow lights to increase red light camera revenue [video]
- jluxenberg 14y agoPredictable consequence of red light cameras. Most of the revenue (over 50% in Kissimmee, FL [1]) goes to the vendor! [1] http://www.kissimmee.org/index.aspx?page=636 http://www.kissimmee.org/index.aspx?page=636
- harold 14y agoI haven't timed it yet, but I'm pretty sure this is happening in my town here on the central calif. coast.
- rhizome 14y agoVery common: http://www.shortyellowlights.com/ http://www.shortyellowlights.com/
- bryanlarsen 14y agoIf they increased the "all-red" time to match, then good for Florida. They've increased their revenues, their roads are safer, and those who are running yellows are getting what they deserve. Running yellows is illegal and far too common. If they didn't increase the all-red time they are making the roads more dangerous. People get accustomed to the length of the yellow & all-red time. But if the total doesn't change, only the relative proportions it shouldn't have an impact on safety.
- codex 14y agoHow goes giving someone less time to stop before someone else goes not decrease safety? Why not shorten the yellow time to zero?
- bryanlarsen 14y agoIf they decrease the yellow time and increase the all-red time the same amount, people have exactly the same amount of time to stop.
- tolmasky 14y agoJust so I understand, you are under the impression that 0 seconds is the appropriate time required to stop, which would obviously be the case if your car was moving legally at the speed limit at the edge of the road when the green light immediately changed to a red light.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoYellow means "stop if safe". Red means "stop", but when driving "if safe" is always implied. I've driven through red lights to let emergency vehicles through, and a judge would likely throw out a ticket given for such a reason. Yellow lights increase safety by avoiding the "slam on the brakes" effect you've described. They've replaced this with a very common "floor the accelarator" reaction which also decreases safety. How do you get one without the other? Red light cameras combined with a short yellow seem the best approach to me.
- jlgreco 14y agoReducing the amount of time that drivers have to react will never make roads safer. The data supports this.
- mistercow 14y ago>Yellow lights increase safety by avoiding the "slam on the brakes" effect you've described. They've replaced this with a very common "floor the accelarator" reaction which also decreases safety. In a typical car, flooring the gas pedal is conservatively going to be about 9ft/s² in the same direction as you're already moving. Slamming on the brakes is going to accelerate you at about 15ft/s² in the opposite direction as you're already moving. The effects these two actions have on safety are not comparable >Red light cameras combined with a short yellow seem the best approach to me. Except that that approach has been conclusively demonstrated to increase both accidents and fatalities, while lengthening yellow lights has been shown to reduce both accidents and fatalities.
- abduhl 14y agoThere is a portion of time where all of the lights at the intersection are red. The person you are responding to notes that as long as this portion of time is increased such that the total time that the intersection has for someone to clear it (i.e. - time that the light is yellow plus time that the lights are all red) stays the same then safety inside the intersection should not be impacted. This says nothing about safety leading up to the intersection (e.g. - people slamming on their brakes).
- codex 14y agoYou make an excellent point. I am worried about the case where the driver, distracted, looks away from the intersection for a second. Returning their gaze to the light, they see it red. They never observed it yellow, and thus they have no idea how long it has been red and whether or not it is safe to run the light. Perhaps this is why we have yellow to begin with--as an redundant means of clocking the time until the opposing light turns green.
- jzworkman 14y agoIf the "all-red" time is increased to compensate, then the time before someone else goes does not decrease. However, if they are just decreasing the yellow time, and keeping the all-red the same(making the total time from yellow to opposite direction green shorter) then I agree that safety has been lowered to increase profits, and this would be super un-ethical.
- jlgreco 14y agoEven if you increase the all-red time, shorter yellows are still more dangerous. For example if you drop the yellow time too low for the legal speed limit of the road then you will create a situation where people have to start emergency braking in order to avoid running the red. This situation is unsafe for obvious reasons.
- rdtsc 14y agoAs someone pointed out it doesn't if the total red+yellow time is still the same (i.e. red time is replaced with yellow). The counter-argument is well it increases chance of rear end collision when people stop suddenly. And that is true. The counter-argument to the above is well they should be driving with enough assured distance between vehicles and below the speed limit. To "maximize" revenue they could be making the legally correct assumption that everyone is keeping a good enough distance and driving below the speed limit, and they'd actually have a legally defensible position as much as I hate to admit it. (It is also hard to argue informally that they don't know what they are doing, they know perfectly well, as others pointed out, if this was a start up maximizing revenue we should be cheering, right, right...?)
- pasquinelli 14y agoactually, i wonder if there wouldn't be fewer rear end collisions if there were no yellow lights. people might be more cautious when approaching an intersection and less likely to ride someone's ass.
- Goronmon 14y agoDriving through a yellow light is not illegal. Also, is shortening yellows actually making the roads safer or is it just a way to increase revenues? Seems like one likely cause of shorter yellow lights is that more people make harder stops at intersections, result in more rear-end collisions.
- alexmchale 14y agoMore rear-end collisions also leads to more tickets and more revenue...
- mikey_p 14y agoIn many places, such as where I grew up in Ohio, the language regarding yellow lights is to "clear the intersection", and that if you are able to stop, you must not enter an intersection when presented with a yellow light. In other words, treat it like a red light, unless you absolutely cannot stop. Of course in practice most folks will go for it if they think they can clear the intersection in time. Some may even accelerate, and having excessively long yellow lights may encourage that behavior even more, despite it being illegal.
- mistercow 14y ago>Some may even accelerate, and having excessively long yellow lights may encourage that behavior even more, despite it being illegal. If you are in doubt about whether you can safely stop when the light turns yellow (and you have very little time to make that judgment), it's much safer to err on the side of running it. The longer the yellow light is, the more likely you are to be able to correctly judge whether you can stop on time. The shorter yellow lights are in your area, the more likely you are to to slam on the brakes to avoid running the red light. Slamming on the brakes is far more dangerous than running a freshly changed red light, to say nothing of running a yellow.
- chrisro 14y agoI live somewhere with long yellows and it does encourage people to run the lights. It's a problem, but we are also a very bike-friendly city and long yellows give cyclists time to clear the intersection. Also, there is a delay after the red before the next right-of-way gets their green and this seems to prevent accidents (because the late-yellow/red light runners are clear before the next green). Nevertheless, we do have some red light cameras here. One day I was stuck at an intersection with a camera, and I was waiting to turn left. I had a red left turn signal, and it suddenly stopped cycling. It was rush hour, and after three cycles with no green arrow, I called the non-emergency dispatch and told them the problem and asked the cop what I should do. She told me to take the safest course of action I thought I could. I told her that was running the red light during a break from oncoming traffic, but that I would be given a ticket for this. She said she couldn't invite me to break the law, but just do the safest thing. The legal move would have been to change lanes to the right and go straight through the intersection on a green, but this was also the most dangerous choice because of the heavy traffic flow. Thankfully the light cycle following my conversation with the cop, I got my green arrow, but it sucked to feel so helpless--knowing the safest and correct action (running the red once oncoming traffic allowed it) and knowing I would be penalized for it.
- kstenerud 14y agoLengthening the yellow light duration reduces the number of red light violations: http://www.motorists.org/red-light-cameras/timing-myths http://www.motorists.org/red-light-cameras/timing-myths Even worse: Red light cameras make intersections LESS safe by INCREASING accident rates: http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/18/1835.asp http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/18/1835.asp http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2012/11/red-light_cameras_lead_to_more.html http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2012/11/red-light_cameras_l... This only makes sense since you're removing decision power from the person most qualified to make the decision (whether it's safe to stop or not).
- abduhl 14y agoYour first link is a red herring. We are trying to increase safety, not reduce red light violations. Your other two links make a common mistake in traffic safety debates by assuming that an increase in accident rates is a decrease in safety. Look at the types of accidents that are increased or reduced by red light cameras and you'll see that they generally do make intersections safer by reducing high speed, side impact collisions. This comes at the cost of increased low speed collisions, namely people running into someone's bumper as they slam on their brakes to avoid the red light ticket which is a psychological (risk aversion) problem, not a problem with the technology itself.
- joshuamerrill 14y agoThere's an inherent conflict of interest when cities, counties, and states rely on traffic tickets as a source of revenue. The all-too-tempting incentive is to maximize that revenue, either by abusing civil rights or, in this case, by endangering public safety.
- doki_pen 14y agoIt won't necessarily endanger the public if they add more delay between one light turning red and the other turning green.
- mistercow 14y agoIf you do that, you'll still cause more people to slam on their brakes to avoid running the red. Slamming on the brakes increases the risk of losing control of the vehicle, and of being rear-ended.
- benmccann 14y agoIt can if you're used to the lights being yellow for longer, it suddenly turns red, and you slam on your brakes and get rear-ended.
- flogic 14y agoIf people stop harder, they're more likely to get in an accident doing so. If you don't have ABS, stopping harder increases the odds that you'll skid. Also you're more likely to get rear ended if the person behind you isn't paying attention.
- rhizome 14y agoYou're not responding coherently, but it's indeed a fact that delayed green lights create safer intersections. Here's a news story from 35 years ago on the topic: http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1913&dat=19780310&id=CD4pAAAAIBAJ&sjid=BWYFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2853,1363262 http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1913&dat=19780310&...
- maratd 14y ago> It won't necessarily endanger the public if they add more delay between one light turning red and the other turning green. This is usually referred to as a delayed green light. They are absolutely terrible for public safety. There are drivers who look at the opposite light to get a cue as to when they should go. It also pisses regular drivers off, because it looks like absolutely nothing is happening for everyone and they have to sit there and wait for no good reason. A yellow light, even a long one, at least shows some sort of activity and progress.
- adnam 14y agoIf you extract too much honey from the hive, the colony might not survive the winter.
- aresant 14y agoThis is a terrible abuse that pisses me off. But it still struck me as funny how many of us HN's (self included) jumped to the defense of Weebly for "optimizing revenue" in the "When a Startup Sends a Passive-Aggressive Email Every Day " story that was trending earlier today (1) If Florida's red-light system was my start-up I'd be pretty damned pleased with myself for figuring out how to drive more revenue with "no cost". (1) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5704860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5704860
- jlgreco 14y agoSlight difference, of many: Spams aren't causing traffic accidents.
- rhizome 14y agoNeither are yellow lights. Cross streets don't turn green until the yellow is gone.
- jlgreco 14y agoYellow lights don't cause more traffic accidents... shorter yellow lights do. How do you think that "Cross streets don't turn green until the yellow is gone" indicates that should not be the case?
- sp332 14y agoIf the purpose of a government was to make money, this might be more acceptable.
- georgemcbay 14y agoI work close to a fairly rare "no right on red" (in California right on red is legal unless signs prohibit it) intersection. Without fail, near the end of the month there will be a cop car sitting under the bridge overlooking the turn for hours just waiting for someone to make the turn. Shamelessly sitting there, in the dark and under a bridge, blocking half the rightmost lane of a busy street, causing a far greater safety concern than would be caused by anyone taking a normal right-on-red at that corner.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoSo you sympathize with people who can't be bothered to observe posted traffic regulations?
- georgemcbay 14y agoNo, I don't really sympathize with people who get caught there very much nor did I say I did. But I sympathize far less with the cop who is doing way more to endanger my safety than the other drivers are, all in the name of scoring some easy stops to meet an obvious quota. For visual reference, this is the intersection: http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&ll=32.917322,-117.235688&spn=0.566608,1.056747&sll=32.934589,-117.235794&sspn=0.002213,0.004128&t=m&z=11&layer=c&cbll=32.917322,-117.235688&panoid=vBKCzKxH9ESD51CHaW-KyA&cbp=12,55.15,,0,-7.69 http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&ll=32.917322,-117.2356... The people getting popped for right hand turns are the ones to the left in this image. The cop sits under that bridge in the shadow area without any lights on, taking up over half of the rightmost (leftmost from this view) lane. The difference in brightness between daylight and under that short overpass bridge is very high.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- talmand 14y agoHe's not sympathizing with those people, he's pointing out the police officer that can't be bothered to observe posted traffic regulations.
- itg 14y agoI can't wait for self-driving cars to become commonplace. Wonder how much of a hit these departments that rely so much on red light camera and speeding tickets will take.
- danpat 14y agoIt's not only that. A good buddy of mine is a criminal defence lawyer. He says that a goodly portion of his drug-related cases begin with traffic stops. By goodly portion, I mean 50+%. We've talked about it at length. There would be major changes in law enforcement practices if automated cars obviated trivial traffic law enforcement stops.
- talmand 14y agoNah, they'll just start pulling cars over to check the firmware on your car to make sure it's up to date.
- quackerhacker 14y agoI'd really love to see how a Google street car (those autonomous vehicles) would handle a yellow...in my book, yellow still means speed up lol.
- troebr 14y agoThe same thing happened in New Jersey, but the state took the matters in hand, and effectively suspended the cameras last summer (http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2012/06/is_your_local_red_light_camera.html http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2012/06/is_your_local_red_l...). I was flashed in Newark, after a very short yellow light on a 55mph road where normally yellow lights are long enough so that you do not have to dangerously slam the brakes. According to another article I read, it is supposed to be 4 seconds for 40mph roads. I was flashed after what looked like at most 2 seconds of yellow light. I never received anything, and I found out about the yellow light abuses.
- roboneal 14y agoAn appropriate partial quote of Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged: “Did you really think we want those laws observed?" said Dr. Ferris. "We want them to be broken." <snipped> "But just pass the kind of laws that can neither be observed nor enforced or objectively interpreted – and you create a nation of law-breakers – and then you cash in on guilt."
- thrownaway2424 14y agoAfter you turn 14 you'll realize there is actually never an appropriate moment for an Ayn Rand quote.
- chm 14y agoI have never read Ayn Rand, but I have heard of her before. Why are such quotes inappropriate?
- jlgreco 14y agoPeople object to Ayn Rand quotes because they believe her politics to be naive, or her fiction to be heavy-handed. I cannot speak to either of those things one way or the other. Even giving these things, these are of course no reason to never quote her. Hell, there is a time and a place for quoting even Himmler.
- 300bps 14y agoI believe that many left-leaning political types strongly dislike and attempt to discredit Ayn Rand because they vehemently disagree with her political philosophy. A common criticism is that her philosophy sounds good when you are a child, but when you grow up you realize it doesn't work in the real world. For myself, I'm a 40 year old that leans Libertarian so I tend to agree with some of her political philosophy. I even tried reading Atlas Shrugged but it was so boring I put it down after about 100 pages.
- sageikosa 14y agoThey make some people's head 'splode, others generate kneejerk responses. For an otherwise obscure writer, that that she is so well known to have detractors everywhere is itself telling, but you'd have to judge for yourself what it is telling about.
- ianstallings 14y agoSurprise surprise, the King wants to squeeze thew peasantry again with another tax.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoFor those of you who didn't bother reading the article, which I assume will be all of you since this topic normally drags up the least-able critical thinkers on this site, I'll summarize it for you: the Florida DOT lowered yellow duration to a level appropriate for the speed limit on the road. The duration might not be long enough for speeding cars to stop. So in addition to being colossal asshats, people who are speeding might also be getting more tickets from red light cameras. And in conclusion, drivers are the most self-entitled scofflaws in the world.
- pasquinelli 14y agohear hear!
- aasarava 14y agoWas anyone else pleasantly surprised to find that this is a well-researched, plainly-told article -- the kind you rarely expect from local news? This should be an example on how to investigate and report impactful news.
- Mz 14y agoThe emperor still has no clothes and the god's are still crazy. (I mostly walk, thankfully. And don't live in Florida.)
- kunai 14y agoThis is unsafe for pedestrians. The yellow light means "Clear the intersection," not "Slow down." The purpose is to give time to people crossing the sidewalks to finish walking over to the other side. Shortening them is a safety hazard for pedestrians like me who don't own a vehicle. I don't live in Florida, but this is shameful and disgusting.
- talmand 14y agoFor some reason, that has never occurred to me. That is an excellent point that reducing the yellow not only increases the likelihood of traffic accidents but of problems for pedestrians as well.
- steve-howard 14y agoI'm pretty sure the flashing-hand signal is what gives pedestrians time to clear the intersection (often with a counter!).
- JensenDied 14y agoI've seen enough crosswalks that go from solid red hand to a flashing red hand immediately, that I now ignore the flashing red hand until the street light turns yellow. Shortening it makes it dangerous for a lot of parties.
- enf 14y agoPlease complain to your local traffic engineers. The MUTCD requires at least a 4-second walk signal and specifies 7 seconds as the normal minimum. http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/htm/2009/part4/fig4e_02_longdesc.htm http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/htm/2009/part4/fig4e_02_longdesc.h...
- abduhl 14y agoThis is absolutely incorrect. Traffic lights are for vehicles. Pedestrians should be obeying the pedestrian signals and your cue to "clear the intersection" is the blinking red hand. Traffic lights do not switch to yellow until after the pedestrian signals are solid red hands. This obviously only applies where pedestrian signage exists.
- sehugg 14y agoI think short yellows are dangerous, especially with loaded vehicles. US DOT should set standards for minimum yellow light times. Here is one such proposal: http://www.shortyellowlights.com/standards/ http://www.shortyellowlights.com/standards/ EDIT: Linked to proposed standard and equation
- Anechoic 14y agoUS DOT should set standards for minimum yellow light times. They do, through the MUTCD: http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/knowledge/faqs/faq_part4.htm#q32 http://mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov/knowledge/faqs/faq_part4.htm#q32
- sehugg 14y agoI meant actual times, the MUTCD only says you must use "engineering practices" in determining the interval. The ITE equation was included in my link -- however it optimizes for reduced red-light violations, so it's no wonder it's not used in these cases.
- simmons 14y agoHuh, it's interesting that there's actually an engineering standard for yellow light times that local governments don't seem to acknowledge. I've always been annoyed at the dangerously short yellow lights around here (Denver), compared to the rest of the country. (I think they were short even before we had red light cameras.) When I'm traveling in other states, I often find myself automatically hitting the brakes when I see yellow, only to sit at the yellow light for a few seconds. :/
- doki_pen 14y agoI wonder how it would be if we eliminated yellow lights altogether and instead had a countdown on the green light. At the very least it might save gas, as you could see that the green light ahead will turn red long before you could hope to hit the intersection, so you could coast in. Of course, you'd need to have an adequate "all-red" time for it to not be dangerous.
- gtz57 14y agoYou can kind of do this by looking at the clock on the pedestrian sign. I would think it would help more with traffic flow than saving on gas.
- walid 14y agoI keep hearing this a lot but if I was "embroiled" in all of this, I would sue the state for entrapment. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment Excerpt: Two competing tests exist for determining whether entrapment has taken place, known as the "subjective" and "objective" tests. The "subjective" test looks at the defendant's state of mind; entrapment can be claimed if the defendant had no "predisposition" to commit the crime. The "objective" test looks instead at the government's conduct; entrapment occurs when the actions of government officers would have caused a normally law-abiding person to commit a crime.
- MrSourz 14y agoI find the news article rather sensationalist, because the reductions on the yellow light timing are now based off the limit rather than the greater of the limit or average speed. While this does increase the number of ticketed incidents it It seems reasonable to ticket those who would be impacted by this, for if the forumla is correct it should just impact speeders. I agree with the sentiment shared by others that the all stop time should stay the same to protect drivers from the speeders.
- mos2 14y agoI know this has been done in Sacramento for years. Yellow Lights at large higher speed (40mph) intersections (like Fair Oaks and Howe) have the yellow light set at the CalTrans minimum safe approach speed, which is often 25 mph. This is on a double lane left turn with traffic at or above the posted speed limit. Good luck fighting that ticket, well within the California State law. Too bad they don't have to set the yellow light timing consistantly. That probally wouldn't give you the 2x increase in citations.
- scragg 14y agoI despise these traffic cameras. They are popping up everywhere in the DFW area. So many people I know get rolling right on red tickets... it's absolute BS. It has nothing to do with safety and everything about money. There are so many instances where you can check if it's safe to make a right without having to make your wheels completely stop. I can't imagine many accidents being caused by a vehicle moving <2mph while making sure they were clear as opposed to coming to a complete stop. These photo enforced lights make me nervous as all hell, as I approach, first sign of yellow and I find myself slamming on the brakes. https://plus.google.com/115905827925711420560/posts/LauLtrvS6mb https://plus.google.com/115905827925711420560/posts/LauLtrvS... Example of a right turned that ended in a photo enforced ticket. Edit: fixed the link.
- Strilanc 14y agoThis is a perfect example of mismatched incentives. When a deterrent is working, you get very few violations. Rewarding the detection of violations is incentivizing exactly the wrong thing. You're rewarding for making things worse! I don't know what incentives would work, in the case of red light cameras. - Accuracy on unmarked test cars going through the intersection? (testing is expensive) - Clamping the income from fines below some threshold? (the threshold might be manipulated) - Rewarding low accident rates relative to other intersections? (probably too unstable)
- scarmig 14y agoAll fines from traffic incidents go into a separate piggy bank that's refunded equally to taxpayers at the end of the year and can't be drawn on for departmental or government funds. How we get from here to there, I don't know.
- will_brown 14y agoThe actual video from these camera should not be admitted as they violate the rules of evidence. Out of 1,000 cases this attorney from the Ticket Clinic claims to have won all 1,000 on this argument alone. I have yet to take one to court, but I imagine I will, as an FL attorney not a violator. http://www.wftv.com/news/news/local/learn-secret-how-you-can-fight-red-light-camera-ti/nTm8d/ http://www.wftv.com/news/news/local/learn-secret-how-you-can...
- ender89 14y agoThe problem with red light cameras is that they encourage blind obedience to rigid traffic laws, and not driving safely as dictated by the road conditions. There are plenty of legal situations where a driver might "run" a red without having done anything "illegal" or dangerous, such as getting caught in the middle of an intersection. I'm in favor of ripping them all down, as their only real function is to suck money out of the taxpayers pockets.
- mindstab 14y agoSo below the federal recommendation and worse, not uniformly but more often on lights with cameras leading to non standard light behaviour. Because we really want unpredictable behaviour from our traffic system... that can only lead to safer roads... like variable length steps on a stair case. These people should be charged with public endangerment. edit: Also as someone pointed out, less warning to pedestrians to clear the cross walk and less time to do so. Very safety conscious.
- scarmig 14y agoIt might be surprising, actually: having significant uncertainty can be much safer than (false) certainty. There was a town that took down all stop signs and traffic lights, and it significantly decreased traffic accidents and injuries.
- jimktrains2 14y agoAren't Yellow Light times determined by engineering and it becomes a public safety issue if they are shortened?
- vlasev 14y agoI am a canadian and I've driven in cities like Vancouver and Calgary. The yellow lights in Calgary hold so much longer (maybe even double the time?). I found it much more comfortable to drive there than in Vancouver. That said, I've been thinking for quite some time now that it might be best to just add a count-down number on the lights to show you how many seconds are left until the green light turns yellow. If you are going to beat the light, might as well speed up a bit from afar than by a lot near the intersection.
- sehugg 14y agoAlso: 6 Cities That Were Caught Shortening Yellow Light Times For Profit (2008) http://blog.motorists.org/6-cities-that-were-caught-shortening-yellow-light-times-for-profit/ http://blog.motorists.org/6-cities-that-were-caught-shorteni...
- t0mas88 14y agoIf you think this is a way to collect money, try driving in the Netherlands. Our normal speedlimit is 130 km/h, but we have limits of 100 km/h on wide and empty 5 lane highways in the middle of nowhere enforced by average-speedcameras (so 100% chance of getting caught even if speeding by as little as 2 mph) Oh and the fine of 10 mph (16km/h) over the limit is 174 USD... but really, this is about safety, not about the money :X
- greg5green 14y ago$174 USD isn't unreasonable for a 10mph over ticket in the states. I'd expect that plus court fees here.