13 ms·
Children of parents classified as “tiger” have worse grades, are more depressed
- jjtheblunt 14y agoIt's almost like kids benefit from running around outside with other kids, rather than being forced to be mini adults. Or something.
- rayiner 14y agoOn the contrary, the chart in the article shows that "permissive" parenting produced lower achievement than "authoritative" parenting. The distinction in the article isn't about letting kids "be kids" but whether parents are responsive/warm versus cold.
- sebcat 14y agoNo, it showed higher achievement and lower rate of depression among the "permissive" group.
- nostrademons 14y agoYou're confusing "authoritative" and "authoritarian". Authoritative > permissive > authoritarian.
- jlgreco 14y agoThen so is rayiner, as far as I can tell. Not allowing your children to run around with other children outside is authoritarian, not authoritative.
- rayiner 14y agoI wasn't talking about the "running around" I was talking about the "being kids" rather than "mini adults." As used in the article, the distinction between "authoritarian" and "authoritative" is a cold versus warm distinction, not a "directed" versus "undirected" distinction.
- jlgreco 14y agoIsn't not allowing your children to run around with other kids a specific case of not allowing your children to "be kids" but rather requiring them to be "mini adults"?
- rayiner 14y agoSo what you said is that if you don't let your kids run around, that's authoritarian parenting, not authoritative parenting. Which I'll concede is true. I will also concede as true that not letting your kids run around is a specific case of not letting them "be kids" but requiring them to be "mini adults." However, that does not mean that requiring your kids to be "mini adults" is a sign of authoritarian parenting rather than authoritative parenting, for the obvious reason that you can require your children to generally act like "mini adults" while also letting them play once in awhile.
- taeric 14y agoI think the point was that that was still below the middle line.
- nostrademons 14y ago"Authoritative" parenting means letting kids explore the world and their own interests while still setting strict limits that are necessary for the health & well-being of the kid. An authoritative parent wouldn't prevent their kid from running around outside with other kids, they'd let the kid run around outside "but stay away from the railroad tracks, and don't get drunk or do drugs, and be home by 11".
- rayiner 14y agoThat's not really how it's defined in the article. It's more "this is what you're going to do, but I'm willing to negotiate the details."
- nostrademons 14y agoThere's a bunch of background in the psych literature beyond just this article. Here's one summary of authoritative parenting: http://psychology.about.com/od/childcare/f/authoritative-parenting.htm http://psychology.about.com/od/childcare/f/authoritative-par... If you've ever had a good boss, there's a good analogy there. A good boss doesn't micro-manage or tell you what to do: she lets you arrange your time as necessary to accomplish your objectives and exercise a lot of discretion about your day-to-day work. However, she doesn't let you just spin your wheels and not accomplish anything either. She provides just enough guidance to ensure that you're still moving forwards without dictating how you move forwards. A good parent is very similar. He provides structure and direction, but lets the child discover his/her own interests and pursue them. It's only when the kid is at risk of stepping seriously off the rails that the parent steps in.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- TheLegace 14y agoDefinitely agree. But I wonder what happens when your parent(s) do both those things but in different ways for different things? Kinda what I could say happened to me, my father being extremely authoritative(making me work at very young age for his business), but at the same time not being around to not set very much boundaries.
- rdtsc 14y agoYes. And I think those are rather orthogonal concepts. One can be permissive and cold. Permissive and warm. Authoritative and cold and authoritative and warm. Authoritative and warm sounds odd, but it think I kind of describes my parents. Some issues like respecting elders, saying thank you, making sure to help friends in needs, sharing were non-negotiable, others like what major to choose, or how late early and when to do homework or what extra curricular activities to take or not take was up to me. Otherwise I never lacked loved, attention or time spent with any of my parents. One of them even quit a much better paying job just to make spend more time with me after school and in the evening.
- wvenable 14y agoNobody treats adults that way. I think kids benefit from really being treated like adults.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoThis only works if kids are also given adult responsibilities along with their consequences. Giving kids the choice to choose their own path doesn't work when they know that they are not truly responsible for their actions. Contrast kids today with kids decades ago when it was typical for a kid of 13 to get a job to support the family. If you want to treat kids like adults you can't half-ass it.
- cafard 14y agoWithin the last half century in the US, kids were not contributing to the household support with whatever jobs they had, unless their families were squarely at the bottom of the economy, migrant farm workers for example. Minimum wage x 40 hours x 10 weeks went surprisingly far toward state college tuition, but not toward the expenses of a middle class household. Forty plus years ago, high school friends of mine were busing tables before 16, and we mostly held down summer jobs once 16. I don't know that we were that much different from kids today.
- mtowle 14y agoI never know what to make of these kinds of studies. The author has full license to decide what "categories" will be part of their spectrum and what their definitions will be, and then further to interpret every data point by themselves. The former you can review and question, the latter you cannot. So let's question the former: >Kim decided that for her study, she would both parse further the different dimensions of the Eurocentric profiles and create new ones that better fit the styles of the East Asian families. Oof. Two biases don't make a right. >The responsiveness that’s considered an aspect of “authoritative” parenting, for example, was broadened to include both positive and negative attributes: warmth and hostility. Control, she would write, has “multiple facets … positive control is measured by parental monitoring and democratic parenting; negative control is measured by psychological control and punitive parenting.” The Stasi were a form of positive control, apparently. Just kidding -- kind of. Suffice it to say none of the above are so mutually exclusive that they should be put in categories called "positive" and "negative."
- WalterSear 14y agoGo read the actual study then rather than the article, and find out how she justified her decisions. Most likely, she based them on definitions that were defined and validated by multiple previous studies before her, or presents research demonstrating validity of her claims. From my time in academia, I can assure you spend most of your time and writing justifying your decisions, and a whole load of very critical people have to agree with your judgement before something gets published.
- mtowle 14y ago>Go read the actual study then rather than the article, and find out how she justified her decisions. If you've got $11.95 to spare, I'll take you up on that. Unfortunately all that's available is the abstract. But if you want me to analyze that, I will. 232 words, not counting the copyright. 122 unique. 'Tiger' occurs 7 times -- 4th behind 'parenting' (15), 'the' (12), and 'and' (9). My analysis concludes that Kim doesn't just have something she wants to say, she has something she wants the public to hear. I.e., right or wrong, Kim has an agenda. >Most likely, she based them on definitions that were defined and validated by multiple previous studies before her I don't see how; she openly states in the quoted section of the parent comment that her delineation of categories was aimed at challenging the standard in the field. >a whole load of very critical people have to agree with your judgement before something gets published. In this case, it was the fine people over at the AAJP. The Asian American Journal of Psychology. Most def not a journal oriented toward "their version" of the truth, I'm sure.
- bitwize 14y agoIn Japan there is the concept of "amae". The feeling of being loved and "taken care of" is recognized as a valid need, and it is as much the job of the parents to make their children feel safe and supported as it is the job of the children to make their parents proud through high achievement. I don't know what Chinese parents are like back on the mainland, but I suspect that they have similar ideas, as Japanese concepts of loyalty are largely borrowed from Confucius. Not that amae-based relationships can't be pathological, but they are less one-sidedly authoritarian. So not only does it not work, I have grave doubts as to whether "tiger parenting" is normal among Chinese, or Asians in general. If anything it's a pathological development among certain first-generation Asian immigrants, who felt the need to produce exceptional children in order to compensate for perceived cultural disadvantages.
- doctorstupid 14y agoThat's a good point, that this may be more of something arising from the dynamics of cultural mixing, rather than being purely Chinese/Asian culture. Cultural traits, when taken out of their home culture with its natural checks and balances, can become unhinged and overpowered, like when introducing species into a new habitat.
- olivier1664 14y agoOn the mainland, the main influence is the one-child policy. So there is four grand parents and two parents for one children. The Children became the family treasure. Another influence is the "Chines Imperial examination" where the social success is done by being the best at school (that may come from Confucius).
- eric-hu 14y ago> If anything it's a pathological development among certain first-generation Asian immigrants I was thinking this throughout your comment. I've also observed that it's a trait much stronger among first generation families or those closer to them (second generation instead of fifth, for instance). I grew up as the children of Chinese immigrants and spent a year in college studying abroad in Beijing. I expected to see a city of 20 million high-achievers. I was in for quite a surprise. The people I met there were more like the non-Asians I knew in America than the Asians I knew. I have no idea what specifically about immigration causes this behavior, or if it's just correlation. It could simply be the case that people prone to extreme "life optimization" are more okay with the emotional upheaval of moving to another country.
- rayiner 14y agoThis is mostly due to the study's redefinition of the term "tiger" to include "unsupportive."
- chockablock 14y agoNot according to the fine article. The 'Tiger' category emerged from a clustering analysis of parenting styles, and was defined by high scores on both positive ("Warmth, reasoning, monitoring, and democratic parenting") and negative ("hostility, psychological control, shaming, and punitive measures") dimensions. The claim is that even when they show lots of warmth and positive parenting, parents who are also hostile and shaming, have kids who do just as poorly as the kids of very harsh, unsupportive parents.
- rayiner 14y agoRight. The article defined the "tiger" category to include hostility, the opposite of "supportive."
- MichaelSalib 14y agoHuman beings aren't computers and human interactions aren't binary. It is perfectly possible for a parent to be both supportive of their children (i.e., have genuine warmth) and be hostile (i.e., lots of shaming). There is no contradiction here.
- pchivers 14y agoI was under the impression that Amy Chua (the woman who wrote "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother") gave up the "tiger mom" strategy after one of her children had a breakdown: "What brings the situation to an end is two horrifying incidents. First, Lulu hacks off her hair with a pair of scissors; then, on a family holiday to Moscow, she and Chua get into a public argument that culminates in Lulu smashing a glass in a cafe, screaming, "I'm not what you want – I'm not Chinese! I don't want to be Chinese. Why can't you get that through your head? I hate the violin. I hate my life. I hate you, and I hate this family!" Her relationship with Lulu in crisis, Chua, finally, thankfully, raises the white flag." http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2011/jan/15/amy-chua-tiger-mother-interview http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2011/jan/15/amy-chua-...
- fatjokes 14y agoI'm not a fan of the Tiger Mother method of parenting, but the description of the incident hardly sounds like a breakdown. It describes Lulu when she was 4 years old, so it's more of a child's temper tantrum than a breakdown.
- dubfan 14y agoI think you're misreading the article. The first paragraph describes an incident involving a four-year-old Lulu. It's not very clear when the quoted incident occurred, but either way the language used in the outburst would almost certainly not be used by a four-year-old in a tantrum and is much more characteristic of an early teen.
- prostoalex 14y agoHer daughter is on very good terms with her, and points out a lot of sentences in her mother's book were intended as dry sarcasm http://www.nypost.com/p/entertainment/why_love_my_strict_chinese_mom_uUvfmLcA5eteY0u2KXt7hM http://www.nypost.com/p/entertainment/why_love_my_strict_chi...
- Klinky 14y ago
- tokenadult 14y agoAs I commented when I shared the link kindly posted here among my Facebook friends, "Like most studies of child-rearing of this nature, it is correlational rather than experimental, subject to argument about definitions, and not yet replicated, but this is food for thought." So if we think about what this means, yes, parents should be affectionate toward their children rather than reserved. Parents should also be open to children pursuing THEIR OWN interests rather than the profile of interests reputedly best for getting into a famous college. Indeed, parents should be open to the possibility that a career in private industry in an occupation in which job applicants show what they can do through work-sample tests and being a "smart and gets things done" worker can be better for a young person than piling on lots of higher education degrees. That said, letting Junior play video games all day (as contrasted with WRITING a few video games) is not good for Junior either. Maybe Junior won't report being depressed in that case until reaching his twenties and finding out he is unemployable at a living wage that allows independence from Mom and Dad. Maybe Junior, while growing up and having limited life experience, might benefit from some actual adult leadership and guidance. It is possible to do too little as well as too much in parenting. (Basis of knowledge: I am the father in a "half-Asian" family, although oddly I am probably the "tiger-like" parent as a native-born American, while my Taiwanese wife is more easy-going. We have one child who has grown into independent adult life as a hacker and three younger children still living at home.)
- vishaldpatel 14y agoYou know, unless Junior wants to go pro.
- tokenadult 14y agoYou know, unless Junior wants to go pro. Are you talking about the video games? I have local friends who have more children than I have, and two of the boys in that family traveled overseas to try out the professional gaming circuit in one of the countries with serious gaming pros. (That family is very supportive of children trying out their interests, to its credit.) After the boys made the trip, they came back here, and if the last report I heard about their activities is still current information, they are buckling down in their studies and pursuing other careers.
- macey 14y agoI feel like this was always obviously the case in the United States. Nothing about US culture complements tiger parenting. Go ask Chinese kids in China how they feel about it. (hint: their culture fully supports and _expects_ this parenting style)
- ceras 14y agoI'm not sure I understand your hint. When I studied in Beijing, most Chinese college kids I talked to just lamented about how hard they worked throughout their childhood and how overly stressed out they always were. Nobody spoke positively about this.
- cafard 14y ago"he vast majority of parents were foreign-born in Hong Kong or southern China, with relatively low educational attainment and a median income of between $30,001 and $45,000 in each of the study’s three phases, spaced out equally over eight years." Wait. Amy Chua is US born, no, and of at least the educational attainment needed to teach at Yale Law--which I assume is paying her & her husband rather more than $45K between them. So how do she and her daughters relate to this, except as a hook to grab our attention.
- robryan 14y agoThey popularized the idea and the term used to refer it. Obviously their anecdotes don't prove anything.
- defen 14y agoYeah, and her father is a EE professor at Berkeley who predicted the existence of the memristor...not exactly a family of "low educational attainment".
- illuminate 14y agoWe do not possess a media with any skeptical abilities, regurgitation of press releases and narratives is all we have.
- dbg31415 14y agoCurious, why no mention of parenting that leads to high-achieving and high-depressive kids.
- jere 14y agoI think the implication is that those are incompatible.
- dbg31415 14y agoWell... there are a lot of Jews out there who tend to disagree. Ha.
- laurentoget 14y agoUnless you include every jewish male character in a woody allen movie or a philip roth novel, which can be read as a case study on highly depressed high achievers.
- sliverstorm 14y agoHardly. Not a new phenomenon in the least. Off the top of my head, we can look to 1897: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Cory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Cory It is of course a poem, not a historical figure, but it was written all the same.
- sliverstorm 14y agoMuch trickier subject. Unsuccessful and depressive go together quite easily. Successful and depressive is a stranger beast, probably requiring more than a rudimentary understanding of psychology to wrangle.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jere 14y agoI'm reading this as: Asian students perform better than other groups even with ineffective parenting. Am I missing something? >“Whenever scholars compare European-American and Asian-American families,” she said, parents among the latter “almost always score higher on controlling and lower on warmth, which means they’re more likely to be classified as authoritarian.” Yet, their kids were outperforming whites in school. This gave rise to the “achievement/adjustment paradox”: kids doing well by external measures while feeling torn apart inside.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- scott_karana 14y agoMany immigrant tiger moms have lower means, have the same reasoning as Chua, and could use her book as justification. This seemed cautionary to me.
- sliverstorm 14y agoAm I missing something? One thing that comes to mind; at least in the Bay Area, asian students often grow up in whole communities made up of other asians, so even if their parents are mucking things up a bit, they are still fully immersed in the culture of extreme focus on academics and achievement.
- illuminate 14y ago"Am I missing something?" Class. All the "tiger moms" are of high economic condition. Lower-classed Asian immigrants do not follow the model.
- aclevernickname 14y agoThis "Tiger Parent" situation is a bit of a conundrum: we as society are unable to tolerate this form of child abuse, but are equally unable to say something about it, for fear of being considered "racist" by someone hiding behind the shield of "Chinese Tradition".
- ddoolin 14y agoBecause it's not child abuse. Just because a group of people don't agree with it does it make it "child abuse."
- aclevernickname 14y agoKeep telling yourself that. I'm sure that will help you sleep at night. Meanwhile, this "successful" woman will keep verbally/mentally/emotionally abusing her children, and nice people like you will look the other way.
- alexholehouse 14y agoIf tiger moms organize and control their kid's lives, do the kids ever learn skills relating to decision making and time management, two absolutely crucial skills for 'real world' survival?
- RYUUSEiiSTAR 14y agoNot even just those two skills, but anything to do with the 'real world'. I struggle to talk to people and have constant shivers even when I know I'm in a non-threatening environment. I just can't make conversation easily. Even something as simple as when I took the train for the first time by myself going to uni. I was petrified I would miss my stop or something equally stupid, when the solution would be to just get off and hop onto a train that would take me back. Again, I don't think I have a tiger mum, but she's awfully close.
- ikailan 14y agoAnecdote alert. I have a wannabe tiger mom. Unfortunately, she had to work full time+++, so full on tiger-ness could not manifest. Just as children of many non-tiger moms DON'T learn decision making and time management skills: some do, and some do not. There are other factors at play. At a certain age, it's near impossible for a tiger mom to control 100% of someone's life.
- swampthing 14y agoFrom the article: "Tiger parenting doesn't produce superior outcomes in kids" Not to point out the obvious, but correlation doesn't equal causation. It could very well be that the worse grades a child gets, the more reason the parents have to become "tiger".
- dmishe 14y agoI had to google what is tiger mom, and found this: "never allowed: - attend a sleepover - have a playdate - be in a school play - complain about not being in a school play - watch TV or play computer games - choose their own extracurricular activities - get any grade less than an “A” - not be the No. 1 student in every subject except gym and drama - play any instrument other than the piano or violin - not play the piano or violin.” Well, fuck.
- gradstudent 14y agoThere's a few things on the list I disagree with (games, sleepovers, school play) but otherwise? Spot on. Kids lack sufficient perspective to understand which activities are important and why.
- eatitraw 14y ago> Spot on. Kids lack sufficient perspective to understand which activities are important and why. Important to whom? I am pretty sure kids know what is important to them and why. Sure, this may be different to what their parents think(e.g. their parents may find games, sleepovers and other stuff "unimportant"). BTW, you can use the very same logic as justification for controlling adults. [And frankly speaking, this logic is used by (almost?) all politicians]
- gradstudent 14y agoKids don't know jack. If a kid isn't good at maths, and their friends aren't good at maths, they conclude that maths is stupid and not worth doing. Adults know better which is why they need to push kids toward productive activities and away from unproductive ones. Which isn't to say they shouldn't be allowed leisure time to be kids. Simply that a guiding hand, and sometimes a forceful hand, is necessary.
- jiggy2011 14y agoBut is it necessary to micromanage to that level? I mean , it's certainly preferable for your kid to study music than to do drugs but do you need to dictate the exact instrument they will play? Or perhaps they aren't so interested in music and would prefer to use the time for some other constructive activity (say programming).
- beachstartup 14y agoi'm asian american and grew up in california, i knew lots of asian kids growing up. all the kids that had super-strict parents were screwed up in some way by the age of 25. dropouts, burnouts, social maladjusts, booksmart losers, drug addicts, delinquents, criminals, etc. not all asian parents are like that, but a LOT are, i'd say probably 4-5x the rate you'd find in the general population. /anecdata
- candybar 14y agoWhat's clear to me from these articles and studies is that there's no silver bullet - if you want to raise your child well, you have to spend a lot of energy understanding your child and guide him, but from his perspective, not your own. Be firm, for his own sake, but without injecting yourself too much. It's wrong to forcefully impose your own goals and expectation borne out of your own insecurities on your children at a stage when children can make decisions on their own, but it's also wrong to be secretive, manipulative and passive-aggressive about your expectations or pretend to yourself that they don't exist. Instead be gradually open about your own feelings and expectations and why you have them and allow them to make decisions that incorporate, but aren't forced by your own desires. All of this is a hard balancing act that demands a lot of mental effort and emotional maturity, not something we can follow out of a book. The more we try to follow someone else's rules for raising a child, the less effort we spend understanding own child and/or look inside ourselves to understand what we truly need to do.
- abalone 14y agoIt sounds like the study reduced the definition of "tiger parenting" to simple authoritarian attitudes. I went to a high-achievement school with a lot of kids of tiger parent types, including an elite music school. That's not the whole picture. Maybe these kids ended up depressed (who knows), but worse grades? I don't think so. The study notes "the vast majority" of parents it looked at had "relatively low educational attainment and a median income of between $30,001 and $45,000". Oddly it claims it also "controlled for socioeconomic status", but that seems suspect when the vast majority of the sample is in one particular income range. So the study mostly looked at poorer households with low-educated parents. This is quite different from Chua, a Yale law professor, on the high end of both income and education. There's a big difference between just yelling at someone and yelling at someone while putting them in elite schools, music lessons, explaining derivatives to them, critiquing their essays, etc. I don't doubt for a SECOND the psychological impacts of authoritarianism, high stress and poor socialization. For me the argument against tiger parenting is more than it's not worth the psychological damage it inflicts and that it kills creativity, both of which are really important in life, beyond just being a finely honed academic machine. But poorer grades, no way. This study is just using its own simplistic definition of the term.
- eeemmmccc123 14y agoBoth of Amy Chua's children are, in a sense, positive outcomes. One was "good enough" for her mother's standards, and another rebelled. But sometimes, different outcomes happen: http://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/28/magazine/who-was-responsible-for-elizabeth-shin.html http://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/28/magazine/who-was-responsib...
- gwern 14y agoI jailbroke the paper for you guys: http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/85192141/2013-kim.pdf http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/85192141/2013-kim.pdf
- losethos 14y agoYeah, God says, "I'll make your enemies footstools," but it's just sweet nothing love from a parent. He does, actually, do stuff like punish you, sometimes. Not so much punish enemies. He's just like a parent. God says... 16:35 Wherefore, O harlot, hear the word of the LORD: 16:36 Thus saith the Lord GOD; Because thy filthiness was poured out, and thy nakedness discovered through thy whoredoms with thy lovers, and with all the idols of thy abominations, and by the blood of thy children, which thou didst give unto them; 16:37 Behold, therefore I will gather all thy lovers, with whom thou hast taken pleasure, and all them that thou hast loved, with all them that thou hast hated; I will even gather them round about against thee, and will discover thy nakedness unto them, that they may see all thy nakedness. 16:38 And I will judge thee, as women that break wedlock and shed blood are judged; and I will give thee blood in fury and jealousy. 16:39 And I will also give thee into their hand, and they shall throw down thine eminent place, and shall break down thy high places: they shall strip thee also of thy clothes, and shall take thy fair jewels, and leave thee naked and bare. ---- I'm not sure, but might be God humour. God says... minister eight-and-twentieth quicken labour stumble prophet venture neither goads whale self-confidence evaporates even unfailing prince witness calf contemn cogito Russia pen vagrant unworthy lashes idol pleasantly chill pole harass less Saint joke angels attuned supplies groan reins dispersion recalled Madagascar otherwhere ecclesiastical charges overcame burden reputed Nepal sluggish AUGUSTINE let concerned judgest extinguish ensuing victorious pick_me_pick_me wise ears warring fillest back lighteth forsakest
- epo 14y agoThere is the old saying that "talent skips a generation". It is much an observation on parenting styles as anything. This "tiger" moniker just refers to extremely pushy (read "abusive") parents. Their reward will be producing children who grow up hating them.