11 ms·
Aaron Greenspan sues Facebook, Sequoia, Andreesen, YC, others
- Jd 14y agoEven though I'm not a huge Greenspan fan (are there any?), I find this money transmitter stuff incredibly fascinating. I haven't reviewed the relevant legal code, but I strongly suspect that Greenspan is right in that: (1) there are lots of little annoying laws related to money transmitters that makes it very difficult to get new payment stuff off the ground (2) If you have deep pockets and good lawyers you can pretty much ignore these laws I strongly suspect that the correct solution is to change the laws, but that this is also an even greater pain in the ass than protecting yourself with highly paid lawyers, esp. since relevant laws vary significantly from state to state. What exactly Greenspan is attempting to prove here is beyond me, but I'm still quite curious as to the results.
- igravious 14y agoAhh, is this why all these tech giants use a non-money credit system for their stores and networks: Sony, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon(?), ... there must be many more.
- jonny_eh 14y agoI'm pretty sure all of those companies also take $'s for digital goods. Microsoft is the most famous for having a credit system, but you can still buy retail download games using $'s. AFAIK, the only reason these companies would use a credit system is so that people need to buy credits in bulk, reducing the hit received from processing credit card transactions.
- danielkan 14y agoI think most larger companies use non-money credit systems because it gets more lock-in and is slightly harder for many people to parse how much they are truly spending.
- georgeecollins 14y agoThe reason why companies use points instead of $ is: 1) Easy to keep the price consistent world wide 2) There is a casino chip theory that you spend more money when it is abstracted. People spend more when they use their credit cards as opposed to cash, etc. 3) You can sell point cards at retailers to the unbanked. In the Xbox case this is important because a lot of your audience is kids.
- bobsoap 14y ago2) is on the spot. As soon as you introduce an abstract that is one step removed from money, people are more willing to gamble with that abstract. This is true for everything from credits to casino chips and from stock/shares to options and derivatives. Also, the word "willing", in this context, is actually an intended pun, since this happens on a subconscious level. There is a lot of literature on the topic; some pieces even establish a tie between that notion and the most recent banking crises and scandals. For example, stock options are not just one step removed from currency, but at least two or more. Interesting stuff indeed.
- caf 14y agoI suspect that even applies to foreign hard currency that you're not familiar with.
- kalleboo 14y agoAs for 3, Apple sell currency-denominated cards for the iTunes store without any problems.
- dangrossman 14y agoMoney transmission means moving money from one person to another. If you could use your Xbox to send money to a friend who also has an Xbox, then Microsoft would need a money transmitter license. Selling products, services, or "credits" for products or services, is not money transmission and doesn't require any kind of financial license.
- cinquemb 14y agoSo in the case of AirBnb, their service is helping people find places to stay?
- dangrossman 14y agoIs all the money you pay to Airbnb for the service of helping you find a place to stay? Or is most of it being transmitted to the property owner after the end of your stay? Yes, it is; they are acting as a money transmitter. Money transmitters typically take some of the money; they're licensed businesses, not charities.
- gburt 14y agoHow is being a "money transmitter" any different than buying the "inventory" and reselling it? Airbnb could have an "expense" paying their providers. This seems crazy.
- cinquemb 14y agoIf Airbnb says that they are being paid for the service they provide, and part of that contract with their customer is to pay a property owner (like an Travel Agent), does that change things? Would a Travel Agent be called a money transmitter? As someone asking someone else who seems to know more about this than I, does this lawsuit have legs to stand on? [Edit: seemed to be answered here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5677731 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5677731]
- dangrossman 14y ago
- gluegeorge 14y agois the idea that the defendants pursued unfair and illegal business practices, promoting their services, while a law abiding service got swept behind? anyone know what the precedent is for this sort of thing?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- glurgh 14y agoI think it's reasonable to assume, by this point, that anything he does should fall under the rubrik of http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/christ-what-an-asshole http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/christ-what-an-asshole Except, unfortunately, without notably increasing the humor value, so far.
- neurotech1 14y agoIANAL.. but at the very least, I'd say its poor strategy because the people he's suing (esp. VC funds) are well connected in Silicon Valley. It looks like he's equating "pass through" transactions with being a (unlicensed) Money Transfer Agent. Hypothetically, If I was going to start a PayPal alternative, I would figure out a way to stay somewhat compliant. If that fails, seek a declarative judgement against XYZ agency to get legal clarification, without dragging all the VCs, Angels and unrelated companies into the case.
- larrys 14y ago"What exactly Greenspan is attempting to prove here is beyond me" Not seeing that this has been date stamped by the court...yet. Typically you scribd the stamped copy so you know it has been filed.
- kevingadd 14y agoIt seems strange to file one suit against a ton of defendants, making it more likely that they will pool resources for defense. Or is that not possible in this context because of the nature of the complaint?
- dangrossman 14y agoI don't think Greenspan actually cares about winning anything. This is about making everyone play by the same rules -- bringing attention to the fact that California makes it near-impossible for a startup to get licensed as an MTA, essentially shut down his company for trying to get licensed, while all these other startups just ignore the problem and operate illegally.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- masonhensley 14y agoI don't have time to read much of the lawsuit, but is Think Computer suing for some sort of injunction to require all the companies listed to use Face Cash as only it has a California Money Transfer Act license? And for those double taking at the name, Aaron Greenspan is the CEO of Think Computer. http://www.thinkcomputer.com/ http://www.thinkcomputer.com/
- kevingadd 14y agoFrom reading the complaint, it seems more likely that the expected result here is something like: * State is forced to fairly enforce the rules that caused Think Computer so much trouble (re money transmitter regulations) * Fairly enforcing the rules causes incredible amounts of grief & overhead for companies large enough to comply, and drives smaller companies out of business * The grief drives those larger companies (and investors into the smaller companies) to push for these laws to actually get fixed I could see there also being an interest here in having investors be penalized for knowingly investing in companies that were violating the law (having a board seat seems like it would give you enough access to realize that a portfolio company is a money transmitter and be able to ask them whether they're licensed).
- hollerith 14y ago>The grief drives those larger companies (and investors into the smaller companies) to push for these laws to actually get fixed Huh? The law just got rid of many of their competitors, and they're going to push to change the law?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hollerith 14y ago>The grief drives those larger companies (and investors into the smaller companies) to push for these laws to actually get fixed Huh? They're going to push to change a law that prevents smaller companies from competing with them?
- jluxenberg 14y agoSome context: (1) Think Computer Corporation built FaceCash (https://www.facecash.com/ https://www.facecash.com/) a mobile payment solution (2) Aaron Greenspan is Think's President and CEO Maybe he's trying to get these companies to lobby against "money transmitter" regulation.
- Moto7451 14y agoSome additional context about past litigation: http://abovethelaw.com/2012/06/facebook-litigation-continues-a-closer-look-at-aaron-greenspan/#more-167565 http://abovethelaw.com/2012/06/facebook-litigation-continues...
- prostoalex 14y agoFor fuller context don't forget Aaron Greenspan vs Google, Inc. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/aaron-greenspan/why-i-sued-google-and-won_b_172403.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/aaron-greenspan/why-i-sued-goo...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- shaddyz 14y agoCan someone please translate this lawsuit into common language. It looks pretty interesting, but I'm not familiar with the laws on money transmission. Thanks!
- RyJones 14y agoThis group of people knowingly broke the law and profited from it. I chose to obey the law and forgo profits. I would like some profits, hopefully conveyed by legal means, to make me whole.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- soup10 14y agolol 78. Defendant Yishan Wong, in response to an article authored by Plaintiff on the website Quora, wrote the following comments (among others) indicating his knowledge of payments-related laws and regulations on June 15, 2011: “Yeah, I am constantly amazed at how people haven’t yet learned that the paymentsindustry is really hard to get into. It was okay for first-wave companies like PayPal to besurprised by it, but anyone who does their due diligence before starting a paymentsstartup should know everyone – literally everyone, including regulators and thegovernment – is going to be working against you. If you can’t take the heat, get out of the kitchen and go start a photosharing startup.” “Payment startups face a far more adversarial environment, including utter and totalhostility. It was okay for PayPal to whine about this (though they didn’t), because itwasn't known. But now it’s known. If you run a payments startup, you are fightingagainst thugs, actual criminals – both real ones and government ones. It is not normalbusiness. It is like trying to start a business in an actual warzone. Complaining aboutthis is just whining. There is no actual solution than to win. Anything else is, in fact, justwhining.” Presumably with the hope of “winning,” Defendant Wong proceeded to invest his own personalfunds in Unlicensed MSB Defendant Balanced (part of a $3.4 million seed financing round)
- wisty 14y agoTrying to create political pressure against these "thugs" isn't necessarily a bad move. Let's say you want to start a company which bypasses Taxi medallions. It's in your interest to create a PR storm over the unfairness of the medallion system. It's not OK to be surprised when the entrenched powers try to bite you (though it may not hurt to act surprised). Of course, if you don't have the stomach for it, you shouldn't be getting into the space.
- EarthLaunch 14y agoSince title changes are being done anyway, this one should be changed to "Aaron Greenspan". There's only one famous Greenspan, and it's not this one.
- Asparagirl 14y agoThat's not strictly true, but actor Jason Alexander isn't usually known by his birth surname.
- obviouslygreen 14y agoWow, yeah, I was very confused until I read this comment. Guess that's what I get for paying too much attention to the comments before reading the article.
- buro9 14y agoMy first thought was why Alan Greenspan would do this and what his incentive would be.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoYa, I thought Alan Greenspan was retired.
- iguana 14y agoI too was shocked that Alan Greenspan was suing people. "The Fed has gone too far!!!"
- jdmaresco 14y agoAgreed. Had the same thought.
- pbreit 14y agoSorry, guys. Fixed.
- stfu 14y agoProbably should add the first name to the title. That family name is usually associated with somebody else...
- ryanhuff 14y agoYes. For some reason, I assumed it was Alan Greenspan.
- yabbadabbadoo 14y agoReason for including YC in this nonsense: The YCFunds share common management and are venture capital funds invested in a number of unlicensed money transmitters. Can that really hold up? Can an investor be held liable for the decisions of a company they invested in? By that logic, what's to stop someone from suing Facebook shareholders?
- kevingadd 14y agoPresumably if individual Facebook shareholders had real influence over Facebook's actions you could sue them. I would guess the justification here is that YC's partners/etc have a real, tangible influence on the companies they invest in so they do bear some share of the responsibility.
- jacoblyles 14y agoIt's regulated by criminal law, not civil code. The complaint quotes the law: "Whoever knowingly conducts,controls, manages, supervises, directs, or owns all or part of an unlicensed money transmitting business, shall be fined in accordance with this title or imprisoned not more than 5 years, or both."
- wmf 14y agoThe whole reason for this mess is that VCs refused to invest in his "legal" startup (didn't want to waste money on compliance costs?) and invested in a bunch of "illegal" competing companies instead.
- Atropos 14y agoPretty weird. On the one hand, there clearly went some effort into this. On the other hand, they are not represented by counsel (p.36), which makes the likelihood of the case being thrown out for procedural reasons regardless of the merits around 99%. All in all I'm leaning more towards publicity stunt...
- bzalasky 14y agoDoes this have anything to do with this patent (listing Greenspan as the inventor), which has a publication date of March this year? http://www.google.com/patents/US8396808 http://www.google.com/patents/US8396808
- rdl 14y agoSomehow I suspect suing everyone, including those who would otherwise be your friends/allies, isn't in the Dale Carnegie book...
- Alex3917 14y agoTo be fair, you'd be surprised by some of the stuff that's in the original version.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoAaron so far hasn't had any friends or allies in this. Nobody else (as far as I know) has committed to dealing with this law.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rdl 14y agoI wonder if HN user thinkcomp (i.e. Aaron Greenspan) is willing/able to comment here. It would be interesting to know his motivations for doing this.
- SurfScore 14y agoProbably legal reasons why he won't. Most companies make it a policy not to comment on ongoing litigation. Usually nothing good comes of it. Although there are exceptions...
- darkarmani 14y ago> Most companies make it a policy not to comment on ongoing litigation. Usually nothing good comes of it. Although there are exceptions... This might be the only case where the only good that could possibly come of it would be to comment.
- aidenn0 14y agoHe's unlikely to comment now that it's in progress, but here's a comment on the topic from the past: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5308013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5308013
- wmf 14y ago"Fake it till you make it" as unfair competition? Interesting theory, but it seems like it would cause a lot of damage in the startup world.
- jacoblyles 14y agoThe law would do a lot of damage to the startup world if it were enforced as written.
- teej 14y agoInterestingly enough, Stripe and WePay are not named while Balanced and Square are. Can anyone comment on why?
- neurotech1 14y agoIANAL: They are Payment Processors, technically serviced by banks, and not a Money Services Business. The difference between them and say AirBnBs transactional payment service is a technicality, but I'm not a lawyer.
- zackzackzack 14y ago1. They might actually know what they are doing or 2. they aren't doing payments of the sort that needs this sort of license.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gsibble 14y agoWell, that's one way to get blacklisted by everyone in SV.
- stevenwei 14y agoIt seems really odd to me that AirBnb is being included in this list. 57. Defendant Airbnb, Inc. allows its customers to rent the homes of other customers for varying durations, in lieu of a hotel. To process each transaction it holds onto the customer’s funds, and remits those funds to the property owner at the conclusion of the stay, minus its fee. Well, okay, but wouldn't this apply to every company that acts as a marketplace between buyers and sellers? Is the point of this to show the absurdity of the scope of the Money Transmission Act?
- dangrossman 14y agoIn most marketplaces, the buyer pays the seller. In this marketplace, the buyer pays the marketplace and the marketplace pays the seller. Any business that engages in the transfer of funds between people is a money transmitter and needs a license. Escrow service has always been regulated.
- ISL 14y agoPerhaps I'm new here, but any chance the title might get 's/Greenspan/Aaron Greenspan/'? I got real confused as to why Alan Greenspan might be suing tech companies...
- chm 14y agoI had the same reflex.
- pedalpete 14y agoI agree, it isn't a person suing corporations, it's a corporation suing corporations. Can we have the title changed to "Think Corp"?
- gojomo 14y agoBut, Aaron Greenspan is synonymous with Think Corporation, which he himself emphasizes in his request to press this claim, as a non-lawyer individual, without the usual (by rule) corporate counsel. Greenspan is the 100% owner, the author of this complaint, and the origin of its offbeat legal reasoning. To leave him and his personality out of the headline, and name the artificial corporate persona instead, would hide the real story.
- pbreit 14y agoDone.
- ISL 14y agoThanks! (though the unexpected karma flood has ended :) )
- eridius 14y agoUnfortunately this change didn't help. I thought it said "Alan Greenspan" until I started reading the lawsuit, saw "Think Corp", and went back to re-read the HN headline. I agree with pedalpete, the headline really should just say "Think Corp".
- jarrett 14y agoDid anyone read the part where he explains that he is not being represented by a lawyer? ("REQUEST FOR CIVIL LOCAL RULE 3-9(b) EXEMPTION AND RETIREMENT.") That seems a very unusual decision indeed. Does anyone have any idea why he would do it that way? Is it probably a money issue?
- dangrossman 14y agoIf the PR (making the tech community aware of the problems with CA's MTA laws, getting the VCs to stop ignoring it, and perhaps getting the legislature to reconsider how they treat startups that try to get licensed) is more important than the result of the suit, you wouldn't want to bankrupt yourself over the suit.
- jarrett 14y agoYeah, that's kind of what I thought--a money issue. I have no idea whether Aaron Greenspan has money to burn on something like this. The fact that he was bringing suit on behalf of his computer company made me immediately imagine a monied plaintiff. But that could be a false assumption. I agree that the PR could be beneficial to the industry as a whole. Let's hope this doesn't mess up a bunch of legitimate businesses in the process.
- wpietri 14y agoFunny! After reading the first few pages, I said, "What lawyer is willing to put his name on this garbage?" and paged around in the document. Only to find no lawyer's name at the bottom, just his own. And now you confirm it. Is there some way that this isn't idiotic? I have seen a federal judge in full-on "this case is a waste of my time" mode, and it is fearsome. I would never file a document with a federal court without having a very experienced lawyer involved. Of course, I also wouldn't step to all of those rich and powerful people without a clear and sensible plan of action. If Greenspan has one, I can't extract it from this document. Is he a total loon?
- pjg 14y agoHave you looked at Aaron Greenspan's legal credentials ? He is (or atleast claims) a fellow of Stanford Law School. Has build a site for searching legal articles and in general spent considerable time researching this issue
- tomrod 14y agoWho is Aaron Greenspan?
- staunch 14y agohouseSYSTEM failed -> Sue Facebook FaceCash failed -> Sue Facebook + everyone Aaron got rich by filing a frivolous lawsuit against Zuck, might as well try it again, huh? This time with even more victims. Building successful companies is hard, let's go lawyering.
- yekko 14y agoWhy not, it seem to be a great business model, that's what America is all about lately.
- gammarator 14y agoDon't forget the self-published screed about the houseSYSTEM/Facebook saga: http://www.aarongreenspan.com/authoritas.html http://www.aarongreenspan.com/authoritas.html
- larrys 14y agoOn the list USV, a dwolla investor is missing.
- debergalis 14y agoI'm one of the parties to this: I founded ActBlue back in Cambridge before coming to SF and building Meteor. The funny thing is it came to my house yesterday as a single cover sheet plus a CD-ROM full of files, and I literally don't have a way to read a CD-ROM anymore.
- anonyfuss 14y ago> The funny thing is it came to my house yesterday as a single cover sheet plus a CD-ROM full of files, and I literally don't have a way to read a CD-ROM anymore. This doesn't seem very funny.
- gridscomputing 14y agoIf you don't have a way to read a CD-ROM, how do you know that it is "full of files"? Couldn't it be an audio CD?
- dangrossman 14y agoProbably from the cover sheet attached to the CD. It's a safe assumption he hasn't been served with a mix tape.
- gojomo 14y agoOn page 35, in order to represent his own company as a non-lawyer, Greenspan appeals for an exception to the rule that his corporation, as the plaintiff, must retain legal counsel. He bases this request on (among other reasoning) the Citizens United decision. Like Greenspan, IANAL, but I suspect his complaint will die quickly on that basis alone.
- apaprocki 14y agoThe court replied on 5/8 that he has until 5/22 to retain qualified counsel or it will be dismissed without prejudice.
- nostromo 14y agoThere is something to be said about how in the US it's often best not to contact regulators at all, and to simply fly under the radar for as long as possible. That said, this guy is seriously toxic. Just by responding to his emails in a friendly manner can get you named in a lawsuit... and to blame competitors instead of regulators... Seems like someone to be avoided at all costs.
- ricardobeat 14y agoBear in mind this guy has spent a fortune and has been severely screwed over by regulators, while dozens of startups operate in the clear with similar services. He could probably get over the hurdles with funding, but who's going to put his feet into this mess? I'd be freaking out too. Makes me wonder, if had he operated under the radar for a while, and gradually complied with newly imposed regulations, things would be ok. Even if he got a massive fine, that'd be good publicity, and he must be spending a ton on lawyers anyway.
- nemothekid 14y agoApparently that was first avenue of action. He says here : https://www.facecash.com/legal/brown.html https://www.facecash.com/legal/brown.html that he applied, but they required his company to raise 80 million dollars before he could pay $5,000 fee. Strangely enough however, he also claims to have built facebook (although the language keeps it vague enough that you aren't aware of his contribution)
- ricardobeat 14y agoNot strange at all. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Facebook#Aaron_Greenspan_and_houseSYSTEM http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Facebook#Aaron_Gre... For some perspective, Stripe has only raised $40M to date.
- cabinguy 14y agohttp://newsroom.fb.com/News/198/Facebook-and-Think-Computer-Corporation-Resolve-Trademark-Dispute http://newsroom.fb.com/News/198/Facebook-and-Think-Computer-...
- rdl 14y agoI wonder if the smaller companies named in that should just do the absolute minimum and free ride on the HNW and big company/funds who will fight this without being hurt as much by the legal expenses. I know Coinbase raised $5mm, but they shouldn't burn even $250k on this suit. All the individuals are pretty high net worth, at least.
- tzs 14y agoI'd give my initial opinion based on a first light reading of the complaint, but I'm afraid Greenspan might find a way to construe that as money transmission and add me to the suit.
- apaprocki 14y agohttp://ia801700.us.archive.org/20/items/gov.uscourts.cand.265908/gov.uscourts.cand.265908.docket.html http://ia801700.us.archive.org/20/items/gov.uscourts.cand.26... "2013-05-08 Order to Show Cause ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE. If, by 5/22/2013, an attorney qualified to practice in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California does not appear in this action to represent Plaintiff, the court will dismiss the action without prejudice. No hearing will be held on the order to show cause unless otherwise ordered by the court. Signed by Judge Edward J. Davila on 5/8/2013. (ejdlc1, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 5/8/2013) (Additional attachment(s) added on 5/8/2013: # (1) Certificate of Service) (ecg, COURT STAFF)."
- dangrossman 14y agoHe has to hire a lawyer or the case won't move forward, because you can't represent yourself when filing as a corporation. We'll find out within 14 days if Greenspan actually intended to take this case to court, or if it's just about the awareness/PR it creates.
- X-Istence 14y agoHe asked the court to waive that requirement ...
- dangrossman 14y agoWhat you're reading above my comment is the response to that request. He has until the 22nd to retain a qualified attorney or the case will be dismissed.
- grellas 14y agoThe key to understanding this lawsuit lies in a technical point having nothing to do with the merits of the claims and which appears at pages 35 through 37 of the complaint. In that section, the plaintiff, Think Computer Corporation, "respectfully requests that Civil Local Rule 3-9(b) be retired, or that Plaintiff be exempted from the Rule given its particular ownership [i.e., owned 100% by one individual] and tax structure [i.e., status as a Sub S corporation]." The Civil Local Rules are the rules used by the federal court in the Northern District of California to regulate its proceedings procedurally, specifying who needs to do what in connection with the filing and prosecution of lawsuits in this court. These rules have the force of law and litigants who ignore them do so at their peril. Rule 3-9(b), which the plaintiff asks be "retired," states that a "corporation . . . or other such entity may appear only through a member of the bar of this Court." In other words, a corporation cannot represent itself in a lawsuit of this type and Think Computer Corporation has filed this action without an attorney representing it while purporting to represent itself in obvious violation of this rule. A few comments about what I think this signifies: 1. The plaintiff's principal is a spirited individual who has very definite ideas about the money transmission laws and who feels highly aggrieved by the impact that California's 2010 law has had on his company. 2. Those ideas about these laws are, in my view, quirky ones that take significant liberties in interpreting how laws work. In other words, without detailing particulars, I believe that Mr. Greenspan's views of these laws will likely not hold up when tested formally in a court of law. 3. Point 2 above, coupled with the complaint's wild swinging out at multiple parties on dubious theories of liability, is the most probable explanation of why there is no lawyer representing the plaintiff in this action. 4. To sue investors basically for having chosen to fund high-profile startups that the plaintiff deems "unlicensed money service businesses" is flaky and will never hold up. If the action is not bounced for violation of Rule 3-9(b), it will be out the gate as to these defendants on grounds that it does not state a cognizable claim for legal relief. 5. To sue the startups themselves for allegedly providing unlicensed money services is also quite dubious. The money transmitter laws are basically laws that give state governments the authority to require that bonds be provided, that minimum capitalization requirements be met, and that other precautions taken, to ensure that whoever handles escrowed monies takes prudent steps to protect those whose funds are entrusted to them. If these laws are violated, the state authorities have the power to take legal actions to enforce them. Nowhere is there any express private right of action that gives any private citizen the right to file suit complaining about alleged violations of these laws. Therefore, it is a stretch for any private party such as Think Computer to seek damages, injunctive relief, or any other form of legal remedy owing to alleged violations of the money transmitter laws. 6. There are conceivably some legal remedies that might work if the facts support them, one of them being for false advertising claims under the Lanham Act (which is one of the claims asserted here). One competitor can indeed sue another competitor for private damages and other relief if the other competitor is gaining an unfair competitive advantage by falsely advertising that its products or services do something that is material to the customer's decision to use that product or service. Here, the result would turn on the ability to show that the parties sued are in fact engaged in false or deceptive advertising. Even here, however, the case is likely sketchy, in my view, from a quick review of the allegations made. All in all, this is a most unusual case filed by an unrepresented party that cannot legally represent itself in the forum chosen and resting on legal theories that are a real stretch in most cases. I believe Mr. Greenspan is both sincere and passionate about what he believes but what he asserts is really a case to be made to the legislative policy-makers, not to the courts. There may indeed be incredible unfairness in the way in which these laws are framed and applied. But that does not mean a private party should be able to indiscriminately sue anyone around who happens to be offering services that involve some form of money handling, or their investors, for the results of the existing system. That in itself in not only a stretch but an abuse. Wrong parties, wrong framing. The action should therefore be dismissed forthwith by the plaintiff as having been ill-considered. If it is not, it will be dismissed by the court in fairly short order.
- gnuvince 14y agoWho?
- jstalin 14y agoCalifornia's money transmission business statute is quite broad: 2030. (a) A person shall not engage in the business of money transmission in this state, or advertise, solicit, or hold itself out as providing money transmission in this state, unless the person is licensed or exempt from licensure under this division or is an agent of a person licensed or exempt from licensure under this division. . . . (m) "Monetary value" means a medium of exchange, whether or not redeemable in money. (n) "Money" means a medium of exchange that is authorized or adopted by the United States or a foreign government. The term includes a monetary unit of account established by an intergovernmental organization or by agreement between two or more governments. (o) "Money transmission" means any of the following: (1) Selling or issuing payment instruments. (2) Selling or issuing stored value. (3) Receiving money for transmission. . . . (v) "Stored value" means monetary value representing a claim against the issuer that is stored on an electronic or digital medium and evidenced by an electronic or digital record, and that is intended and accepted for use as a means of redemption for money or monetary value or payment for goods or services. The term does not include a credit card voucher, letter of credit, or any stored value that is only redeemable by the issuer for goods or services provided by the issuer or its affiliate, except to the extent required by applicable law to be redeemable in cash for its cash value. ------- This appears broad enough to include Facebook Credits, bitcoins, etc.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI can't speak on the legal merits of the case, but this does seem like a direct hit (that, it sounds like, won't work) on VC-istan. They should start giving him EIR offers. He's earned it several times over. That might be the best way to make everyone happy.
- kkowalczyk 14y agoHe earned what "several times over"? What logic compels you to conclude that if you get viciously and frivolously sued by someone and publicly badmouthed by him (on his weblog) you should give him a lucrative and prestigious employment (i.e. the Entrepreneur In Residence)? Do you think a sane SV VC should employ a toxic person that publicly calls Zuckerberg a psychopat? So far he filed a bunch of frivolous lawsuits against anyone who came into contact with him and looked at him funny. He always represents himself, so there's no cost for him but it hurts the defendants because they have to hire and pay for real lawyers. His previous lawsuit has been dismissed by the judge http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716057 http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716057 His other lawsuit (http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716056 http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716056) is in shambles on procedural grounds because his California lawyer wants to withdraw from the case which would leave Greenspan as the only lawyer and, just like in this case, he sues on behalf of his company and a company can't represent itself, so his has to have an outside counsel to proceed.
- michaelochurch 14y agoWhat logic compels you to conclude that if you get viciously and frivolously sued by someone and publicly badmouthed by him (on his weblog) you should give him a lucrative and prestigious employment (i.e. the Entrepreneur In Residence)? Let's start with the fact that his startup (lawsuit) actually does more good for society than 95% of these VC-istan social media companies (that are just excuses to waste young peoples' careers). If nothing else, he's drawing attention to the "we'll fund your competitors if you don't play our way" aspect of VC-istan, pointing out the problems with a law, and one could argue that he's (indirectly) shining light on the VC-istan collusion problem. I'm not saying that Greenspan deserves to be a billionaire, but he's way past having earned EIR-- if VC-istan were the meritocracy it claims to be. That's an obvious fact at this point. Do you think a sane SV VC should employ a toxic person that publicly calls Zuckerberg a psychopat? Wait, so having a disagreement with one powerful person means that someone deserves to be completely blacklisted? Isn't this the kind of antiquated corporate conformity that people went to California (back when it was great; before conformist corporate asshats got in) to escape? I've been called worse and I, frankly, don't think a person deserves not to have a career just because he says something nasty, about me or anyone. That's just a ridiculous and mean-spirited idea. His other lawsuit (http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716056 http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/case.html?id=716056) is in shambles on procedural grounds because his California lawyer wants to withdraw from the case which would leave Greenspan as the only lawyer and, just like in this case, he sues on behalf of his company and a company can't represent itself, so his has to have an outside counsel to proceed. The courage alone that Greenspan has shown proves him to have superior courage to 95+ percent of the VC-istan cool kids, most of whom are useless, morally redundant, corporate shills. If nothing else, Greenspan has established that he's intelligent. That alone confers merit in a world where it can't be assumed.
- bitteralmond 14y agoThis doesn't seem as much like an actual attempt to gain compensation as it does to simply get a law changed.
- mdlevinson 14y agoI believe you're absolutely correct. It seems rather obvious that he has no standing here, and was not injured by the defendants' actions. But he is extremely knowledgable about these regulations and has a very valid set of complaints regarding the lack of clarity of the law and the lack of predictability in how it is enforced.
- sjg007 14y agoIt is better to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission. It is easier to get a money transmitters license after you IPO than before. Taxi medallions, asinine sublet and renter laws are all examples of this. Legal gray areas make great businesses. The CA law he references was sponsored by the big financial companies to favor protectionism and so if enforced will raise hell and probably be overturned by the Feds and currency/interstate commerce laws.
- saltyknuckles 14y agoWell all of those companies are welcome to come move to Miami. Lots of office buildings and land for sale.
- rantee 14y agoLike others predict, I think this will get booted because of lack of standing. Interesting that Greenspan makes the broad First Amendment argument about being able to represent his corporation as legal counsel based on political speech rights found in Citizens United.. but that case is not on point and won't help here. The court is unlikely to explain why and probably will dismiss it for reasons Grellas notes in the first comment too. The complaint isn't as long as it looks for non-lawyers - just skim over the parts where he lists all the defendants. After page 37 it's just copies of the laws, regulations and screenshots. Assuming he hired a lawyer to file his other case claiming arbitrary enforcement of the CA law against his company (discussed in paragraph 4 of the complaint linked to above), that one seems much more likely to go somewhere although relief at this point is pretty unclear. Also the first time I've noticed someone use "pivot" in the Lean Startup sense in a legal complaint (fn. 3).
- L0j1k 14y agoI sincerely hope this guy kicks the door in at the heart of this financial industry in-crowd fortress.