4 ms·
If you just start paying people money no matter if they work or not, what is their incentive to improve in life. Frankly, this smells of people trying to sneak
by tomjen3 14y ago
If you just start paying people money no matter if they work or not, what is their incentive to improve in life.
Frankly, this smells of people trying to sneak communism in through the backdoor.
And what do you do when they blow all their money on drugs (this will happen with some of them).
- hayksaakian 14y agoIn theory, those who lead destructive lives (drugs) will die sooner (if the anti-drug claims are true) therefore removing themselves from the system. I'd imagine the payments in this case are only enough for food and shelter. Spending $ on drugs makes it harder to obtain the other two. Communism would be conditional income ("to each according to his means, etc."). What the article describes is unconditional.
- mathieuh 14y agoSocialism would be conditional income, Full Communism would be unconditional.
- enraged_camel 14y agoSo basically, you don't know what communism is.
- jjoonathan 14y agoTo elaborate, communism aims for the abolition of private property and the elimination of class distinctions. BI aims for neither.
- funkaster 14y agodid you even read the article? My impression is that you did not read it, or did not even understood it. Also, you seem to have no idea what communism is about.
- sfmcjgkbrbm 14y agoIn communism there is no private property. You can't run business or be employed in any. Minimum income is completely unrelated. It only means giving a few dollars for the poor so they don't starve or freeze to death. It's already done in developed countries (welfare) but in unreliable way. Minimum income doesn't interfere with free market and accumulation of capital.
- Dylan16807 14y agoBecause the money given is not enough to comfortably live on by itself, and definitely not enough to be wasteful. In communism the incentives aren't there because you can't get more money by working harder. With this plan you have all the time in the world to get money by working harder/at all. If someone blows all their money on drugs they need a rehab facility.
- Peaker 14y agoTheir incentive is getting even more money, so they can buy more than food and shelter. Also, self fulfillment. Throwing around words like "Communism" is not productive. It would be better if you only mentioned specific negative aspects.
- gizmo686 14y agoWe have a certain amount of work that needs to be done, this work takes a certain number of people to do it, call this number X. We have Y people who are willing to do the work. At the moment, Y>X. If we give a small BI, then Y would decrease. This is not a problem, as Y>X. The question then becomes how how the BI should be. Given our current unemployment rate, the answer is greater than 0.
- philwelch 14y agoIf only it were that easy. The fact is that X >> Y, but not all parts of Y are useful to satisfy X.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThat is a religious belief. In most developed countries there are more unemployed people than job openings, period. If you waved a magic wand that solves all skill and mismatch problems, forever, and filled every standing job opening, there would still be large portions of the population unemployed and unemployable.
- philwelch 14y agoIf you think of it in terms of job openings, sure, but that's myopic. I'm thinking of it in terms of the number of people who could be profitably utilized to improve the material well-being of humanity. My notion of the "work that needs to be done" is in no way limited to what current job openings exist. In fact, there's likely an infinite amount of work that needs to be done. The limiting factor is the number of people capable of doing it. For instance, what if we multiplied by one hundred the number of researchers working on major problems like fusion power or eradicating disease? There isn't anywhere close that number of people qualified to be physicists or medical researchers, though, so it simply isn't considered. There are probably enough unsolved problems in materials science alone to profitably employ twice the number of currently unemployed people for a lifetime, except all those unemployed people are almost certainly incapable of becoming materials scientists. My job, and likely yours, filled a "job opening" that only existed because someone else did the basic work of building the technology and the infrastructure to enable the creation of that job. The more people you have doing that work, the more job openings pop into existence. Don't think of it in the sense of Google or Amazon having only so many job openings, and once those are filled, that's that. Think of it in the sense of Tim Berners-Lee building something that enabled every single job at Google or Amazon to exist in the first place. It doesn't even have to be that radical. A healthy, growing company expands at a rate that's eventually limited by the number of people it can hire. Once it hires those people, it expands its operations until it needs more. So even on the most basic level, simply counting job openings misses all the job openings that would be created once the first batch was filled, and so on recursively.
- EliRivers 14y ago"what is their incentive to improve in life" Is that a serious question? What do you think their incentive to improve in life is? Here are some ideas for you: To be healthier. To live longer. To have a nicer house and better living conditions. To improve the lot of their family. To travel and have new experiences. Do you think that people want to live short lives of misery? "what is their incentive to improve in life"? Really?