5 ms·
I think Gruber is in denial over the weakening fortunes of Apple. The writing over Apple hasn't gotten crazier in my opinion, just more negative (and I think it
by adventured 14y ago
I think Gruber is in denial over the weakening fortunes of Apple. The writing over Apple hasn't gotten crazier in my opinion, just more negative (and I think it's appropriate).
They were the world's most valuable company and they run it like a black box. They do a terrible job of communicating with shareholders. I think that has been responsible for some of the $300 billion in value Apple is missing these days (and the 9 pe ratio).
The market wants to know: what is Apple going to really do about competing with Android / Samsung / Kindle Fire / very low cost, high value smart phones and tablets.
Can Apple retain a healthy ecosystem (apps, music, media) with 5% of the global market? 10%?
Android has become a near monopoly in smart phones, squeezing Apple into an increasingly smaller corner of the market. The same thing is going to happen in tablets, if only due to price / selection alone. Eventually this compression will begin stealing value from the company and not just slowing down their growth rate. Most forecasts are pegging them to declining profits and drastically slowing sales. Is that crazy writing? No, it's a negative view on the company's prospects.
- mwfunk 14y ago"Most forecasts are pegging them to declining profits and drastically slowing sales." Citation needed, and sensationalist analysts don't count.
- adventured 14y agoHow about the entire industry, does that count? "The average earnings estimate among the pros this quarter is $10.01 per share, 19% below last year's $12.30. The indies are looking for $10.55 (down 14% year over year). The median EPS: $10.10 (down 18%)." http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2013/04/21/apple-earnings-revenue-forecast/ http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2013/04/21/apple-earnings-revenu...
- moakleaf 14y agoAndroid is not becoming a monopoly... Android's market share is larger than the iPhone, but iPhone's market share is still growing(!), and it is still quite significant. I think a lot of the negative sentiment comes from the fact that people think that the iPhone (as a platform) was number one at one point, and is now number two in market share. At the same time people think Android is one phone. Neither of these statements are true. The best selling phones are still iPhones. Android is not a single device or company but a highly competitive market by itself. It is really really hard to compete on that market, because you need something to stand out of the crowd. It is also really really hard to be innovative, because everyone has access to the latest version of Android OS, and in today's market, pretty much everybody has access to the underlying hardware. The only thing that matters is if you can squeeze your supply chain enough to get a large enough profit. This is where both Samsung and Apple have reputations of being very strong -- For different reasons. In reality, most customers don't really care that much about megapixel count, number of CPU cores, memory, etc. So as an Android phone-maker, the only place to really distinguish yourself is by custom "home-screens" and exterior design. Exterior design is difficult. A couple of months ago Samsung was the only company profiting from Android phones. Apple still takes the majority (more than half) of the smartphone profit. I don't know if either of that has changed in the last quarter (we'll see). But Android is not a monopoly it is a lot of different manufacturers fighting over around 50-70% of the market share with very similar products. Samsung has the majority of that market. The currently only major alternative to Android, iPhone, on the other hand is made by one company.
- adventured 14y agoAndroid is becoming a monopoly in the same respect that Windows ever was. It's no different for Android running on multiple hardware vendors, ala Dell / HP / Compaq / Gateway / etc etc back in the day. It's the market consolidating around a standard. Android is going to take 85%+ of the global smart phone market. There's absolutely nothing that can or will stop that from happening at this point. It's going to be the obnoxious standard that everybody is going to complain about for the next decade. The iPhone's market share will stop growing this year. Android and the iPhone have squeezed out most of the serious competition, and now their market share lines are going to run head to head. Android will win that battle, and begin pushing the iPhone's market share backwards within four quarters. Apple's approach was always going to guarantee it got boxed into a corner. It's a +/- to their approach that they can start new markets, and then lose them fairly quickly. That's my opinion.
- sneak 14y agoI don't know about 85%+. Sure, a majority, but the big differentiator these days (vs MacOS/Win32) is HTML5/JS. Lots of things don't need to be native apps, and aren't/won't be. There isn't as much downside to picking the minority OS anymore. This is further strengthened by the fact that Apple's hardware is expensive, and people targeting spenders will still (and, imho, always will) do iOS first (and sometimes only). Fred Wilson's famous android-first-because-it-has-the-most-marketshare advice only makes sense if you're a Facebook or a WhatsApp and raw triple-digit millions of users matter to you. If you're e.g. Uber, you don't give two fucks about four fucks for the people buying the inevitable $39 Android tablets of the future. _Which_ users matter a lot more to the vast majority of app devs than _how many_ users. That said, I think Apple will eventually be found to retain _at least_ 25% of the final size of the market— and the top 25% at that.
- adventured 14y agoMost of the estimates I've seen peg current global Android market share at 68% to 73%, with iOS at 20%x. I would argue that Apple will lose upwards of half that position in the next two years. China alone will hammer them on market share, as Android will completely dominate the domestic Chinese market via cheap smart phones (particularly as the Chinese are heavily promoting their own vendors). I think it'll be 80% to 85% Android, 8% to 12% iOS, with most of the remaining going to Windows and Blackberry (if Blackberry survives). The history of technology markets consolidating toward a single standard (usually in the 65% to 85% market share range), leads me to believe that given the scale + momentum + competitive advantages that Android has, it's likely to creep toward that 80% quasi-monopoly line, and very soon.
- LekkoscPiwa 14y agoYou said:"The market wants to know: what is Apple going to really do about competing with Android / Samsung / Kindle Fire / very low cost, high value smart phones and tablets." Somehow, the answer is obvious to me. Continue making superior products. Apple creates expensive better desktops and laptops than Win/Linux/Lenovo/Samsung that do it at very low cost. That's how it won that market. That's how it's going to win smartphones/tablets. I switched from iPhone4s to Galaxt S3. Can't wait to switch back. If I can compare the experience to anything it would have to be akin to switching from Mac OS X back to Windows Vista/7/8/whatever. After 4 years of using iPhone I wanted a change. Now I just want a smartphone that doesn't suck. And it's not only me. People will keep buying BMWs even though there are cheap/better alternatives like Toyota. Once you got spoiled by BMW handling or iPhone user interface, you won't simply go back. Unless you're tired of buying product from the same brand all the time, so you will switch, get disappointed (like me!) and then switch back again. Look at S4 sales and reviews. People just wanted the change and Samsung did a great job with marketing S3 and got lucky with timing too. At that point last year people were just tired of iPhone, they wanted something new. They got it. They discovered it sucks. And big news for you - they will go back to Apple. There is now way in the world I'm going to purchase an Android device in the near future. And there is no way I'm going back to Toyota.
- adventured 14y agoI believe Apple can absolutely hold onto some market share with their model, assuming they keep making great products. But how much market is that? 5% won't facilitate the network scale they need to encourage developers to focus on their app ecosystem. And as the iPod sales continue to evaporate, Apple will lose its music dominance to the smart phone market (which would remove another key moat in their overall ecosystem). The question in my opinion is, how much of the smart phone market can Apple retain. If it's 5%, they're screwed. If it's 15%, I think that would work.
- rimantas 14y agoYou are conveniently ignoring iPad.
- 14y ago
- sinnerswing 14y agoAndroid is the new Blackberry/Nokia. Lots of "worthless" market share. Apple earns more revenue selling accessories than Google earns with Android. "Google-Oracle trial: Android revenues revealed" http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/apr/26/google-documents-search-revenue http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/apr/26/google-docu... "..after the costs of sales, marketing, engineering, product management and legal expenses were taken into account, the overall Android division was not expected to become profitable until 2011, by which time it was forecast to generate nearly $500m in adverts." "Apple's iTunes & accessory sales now greater than every other phone vendor but Samsung" http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/02/11/apples-itunes-accessory-sales-now-greater-than-every-other-phone-vendor-but-samsung http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/02/11/apples-itunes-acce... http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/01/28/apple-now-collecting-twice-as-much-from-itunes-software-services-as-from-ipod-sales http://appleinsider.com/articles/13/01/28/apple-now-collecti... "...For all of fiscal 2011, Apple is now noting that it actually collected...$4.47 billion from accessory sales. "
- adventured 14y agoI would wager that within two years Samsung will be making more money on smart phones than Apple. Apple's profits are going backwards now, while Samsung is growing very quickly. I believe that's a trend that will continue. Microsoft earns a lot more selling Windows and Windows server and surrounding products than all of the Linux vendors make supporting Linux combined (Redhat makes a mere $100m a year in profit for example). Does that inherently imply anything about Linux? No. What you're talking about is today (regarding Apple's profits). What I'm interested in is the trend of Android taking most of the market and what that'll mean in five years for Apple and the Android vendors. What it'll mean is: much like PC sales, Android sales will be dominated by 2 or 3 primary companies, with dozens of other vendors attempting to compete. My opinion is that Apple is about to get hammered as the iPhone's market share collides with Android and loses. I believe within eight quarters their profit will fall from $40x billion to $25 billion annually, and they'll lose 1/3 of their existing market share while margins also keep falling.
- ashishgandhi 14y ago
- cscurmudgeon 14y agoAs a business, Apple is in a neat spot. http://techland.time.com/2013/04/16/ios-vs-android/ http://techland.time.com/2013/04/16/ios-vs-android/ The Time says it best. So who is winning — iOS or Android? Android if you’re talking about market share; iOS if you mean financial success. So far, this is a strikingly different market than the PC business back in the 1990s, when market share translated directly into financial success. Repeating myself again. Don't compare the smart phone market with the PC market. The PC market is completely different... any analogy here does not rest on sound financial first principles. Market share by number of units has not translated to market share by profit. The former is useless.
- adventured 14y agoThat's today. And I believe it's a false sense of context because markets are momentum driven and the reading is all going by what Apple made in the last 4 to 8 quarters (rather than what's about to happen in the next few years). Does the profit machine hold so well if you have a declining market share? (in which case there are dramatic follow-on consequences in pricing power with suppliers, margins in dealing with carriers, in app ecosystems, you name it). I don't think it will hold up. I believe there's very likely a market share line in the sand, that if Apple gets pushed below it, there will be terrible profit consequences.
- cscurmudgeon 14y agoYou are just shooting from the hip again. Apple can probably be a great company with just 20% of the international market and 40% of the US market (also, they are gaining % in the US which is sort of an indicator for how the world would behave in the near future). Does the profit machine hold so well if you have a declining market share? Yes. All that matters directly is $ not how many units you sell. As a business it all comes down to $ and whether you can keep it flowing. They have kept it flowing with a reduced market share by units. Also, shouldn't the system have collapsed long ago when Android overtook iOS quite a while back? Care to explain why it will fall? As a developer, I will always develop apps for the platform with the most number of paying customers who appreciate quality. Consumers with $ will always go towards the best product. The hackers will go towards the best platform. *I don't think it will hold up. I believe there's very likely a market share line in the sand, that if Apple gets pushed below it, there will be terrible profit consequences.( Instead of giving poetic descriptions, please give us solid reasoning from financial first principles. I am convinced that you just want to see Apple fail and have no solid argument. I would be interested in one if you have it. It is not all flowery for Apple, but claiming "terrible profit consequences" is just FUDish IMHO.