6 ms·
It's easy to calculate a number for the waste of Bitcoin, but it's not easy to calculate a number for the waste of the awful, archaic systems it could replace.
by modeless 14y ago
It's easy to calculate a number for the waste of Bitcoin, but it's not easy to calculate a number for the waste of the awful, archaic systems it could replace. Transferring money is done today with mainframes, paper forms, and middlemen galore. If Bitcoin replaced all that there's no doubt in my mind we'd all be better off.
- anigbrowl 14y agoIf you're expecting technology to just eliminate rent-seeking, you're in for an unpleasant surprise.
- codeulike 14y agoYeah, my understanding is that miners are not just mining, they're also powering the distributed transaction engine of bitcoin. Is that correct? In which case the power consumption needs to be compared to (per $ or whatever) consumption for Bacs, swift, visa etc
- jacquesm 14y agoThe proper measure would be Joules/transaction.
- sigil 14y agoCorrect. It's quite ingenious actually. "By convention, the first transaction in a block is a special transaction that starts a new coin owned by the creator of the block. This adds an incentive for nodes to support the network, and provides a way to initially distribute coins into circulation, since there is no central authority to issue them." http://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf http://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- codeulike 14y agoBut how does that work when the generation of new coins tails off, but the generation of new blocks does not?
- sigil 14y agoGood question. Longer transaction blocks maybe? Would love to hear this answered.
- codeulike 14y agoFrom whats said here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5548503 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5548503 miners grant themselves a fraction of a bitcoin for each block, and that fraction is what decreases over time.
- sehugg 14y agoEach block also awards the miner a variable fee for every transaction included in that block, so there will always be an incentive to mine: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#If_no_more_coins_are_going_to_be_generated.2C_will_more_blocks_be_created.3F https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ#If_no_more_coins_are_going_to...
- paulhodge 14y agoThey are doing a make-work exercise which only needs to be time consuming, in order to prevent cheaters. It's mostly throw-away work. The actual computation that needs to happen is pretty trivial. I think it would be possible to fix Bitcoin so that "proof of work" is something that doesn't consume all that electricity, but I'm not sure what it would be.
- mayank 14y agoIf it doesn't consume electricity at a high rate, it's not proof of work, ie there's nothing to "fix".
- wmf 14y agoSince it's memory-intensive, scrypt might be a more energy-efficient form of proof of work than SHA.
- Freaky 14y agoAlready being used: http://litecoin.org/ http://litecoin.org/ Only more efficient in that nobody's throwing lots of chunky GPUs at it.
- wmf 14y agoDoes a GPU use less power while mining Litecoin? It seems like the cores would be 99% idle.
- corysama 14y agoNope. The GPUs get plenty hot. The difference is that with Litecoin, your CPU gets hot too! I have not dug into the technical details, but at a glance it looks as if Litecoin motivated research that fairly successfully overcame the GPU-unfriendliness of Scrypt. If anyone here can confirm or deny this, I'd love to hear it.
- Andrew_Quentin 14y agoWouldn't - if bitcoins was to become mainstream - wouldn't there be a need for bitcoin debit or credit cards though and atms and banks. So realistically we are only limited to comparing it to actual transaction costs.
- gdubs 14y agoI was trying to find stats on the energy/environmental impact involved in producing a single penny. What I did find was that at times a penny costs nearly double its worth to produce [1]. 1:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_(United_States_coin)#Metal_content_and_manufacturing_costs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_(United_States_coin)#Meta...
- alanctgardner2 14y agoA penny isn't really a fair comparison: - many countries have eliminated pennies - mining will have to continue even after "coins" aren't produced, to verify transactions. It's more apt to measure power per transaction, against a traditional bank (or a handful of cash, amortized over it's life.) There was a good explain xkcd about the cost of carrying around physical money in your car.
- wwwtyro 14y ago> mining will have to continue even after "coins" aren't produced, to verify transactions. That doesn't sound right - do you have a reference for that?
- samolang 14y agoAnd it costs more than 11 cents to produce a nickel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel_(United_States_coin) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel_(United_States_coin).
- epistasis 14y agoThis is a faith-based assertion, when data is needed. I am heartily skeptical that, were Bitcoin economy as big as the US dollar economy, that it could ever be as efficient as our system of middle-men, paper forms, etc. US Dollars extract transaction-based fees, whereas Bitcoin extracts continuous make-work in order to maintain consistent value. Say credit cards take a 1% fee on a transaction. At $150,000 per day, and a $2 billion market cap, the overhead is a little over 2.5% per year for Bitcoin. (Not that I think these numbers are completely solid, I'm just going off the best estimates available right now. Also, I'm not an economist, I'm just throwing together a napkin-calculation. Critique away!) Some things are very amenable to solving with technology. Other things are more amenable to solving with people. Only data will tell for sure.
- rictic 14y agoI'll also admit ignorance here, but it doesn't seem valid to compare overhead as percent of transaction vs overhead as percent of market cap. Current estimated USD Transaction Volume is ~$70 Million per day[1], so the transaction fees needed to sustain the $150k per day electricity overhead would be ~0.2%. All of the parameters in this calculation are in high flux of course (and we're not including total cost to mine here, just electricity), but when I've run this same calculation in the past at various times I've gotten similar results. Note also that mining is profitable enough due to new coin creation that transaction fees in practice are much smaller than this for now (average ~0.01%), but coin creation will gradually taper off over the years. 1] http://blockchain.info/charts/estimated-transaction-volume-usd?daysAverageString=7 http://blockchain.info/charts/estimated-transaction-volume-u...
- sigil 14y agoInterestingly, the original Bitcoin paper opened by addressing exactly these concerns: the origin of transaction costs in current payment systems consisting of middle-men (central trusted parties, in more charitable terms), paper forms, etc. While the system works well enough for most transactions, it still suffers from the inherent weaknesses of the trust based model. Completely non-reversible transactions are not really possible, since financial institutions cannot avoid mediating disputes. The cost of mediation increases transaction costs, limiting the minimum practical transaction size and cutting off the possibility for small casual transactions, and there is a broader cost in the loss of ability to make non reversible payments for nonreversible services. With the possibility of reversal, the need for trust spreads. Merchants must be wary of their customers, hassling them for more information than they would otherwise need. A certain percentage of fraud is accepted as unavoidable. http://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf http://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- coin 14y agoIt's not necessarily waste. My home is heated using an electric furnace. The heat given off by GPU mining offsets the furnace. It's essentially "free" electricity while mining during winter months.
- wmf 14y agoNote that resistive heating is generally less efficient than a heat pump or gas.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoSince you mentioned it - note that heat pumps are like 5 times more effective than gas or resistive heating. Really, given that they tend to have 400% - 500% efficiency, everything else is a waste. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump#Efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump#Efficiency
- coin 14y agoMy home is heated with resistive heating (heating elements in furnace + a few baseboard heaters).