3 ms·
>Teachers, who don’t receive outlandish wages or pensions, didn’t cause this problem, and the good news for them is that they will get their pensions because th
by hkmurakami 14y ago
>Teachers, who don’t receive outlandish wages or pensions, didn’t cause this problem, and the good news for them is that they will get their pensions because the state is legally required to back up school districts if they can’t meet their commitments.
How can teachers be completely absolved of responsibility for the current situation, considering that teacher's unions were at least partly responsible for negotiating the pension contents? Obviously the individual teachers or administrators never wanted a bankrupt system, but when you hand off representation to your union without taking responsibility for long term sustainability, stuff like this happens. Look at the Automobile Unions; basically the same sort of setup.
- gojomo 14y agoIn California, the union didn't just negotiate the contracts from one side of the table. The California Teacher's Association (CTA) is, by amount spent, the most powerful entity in state politics (to say nothing of volunteer 'ground troops'). Thus they control both sides of the negotiating table, and also usually get what they want via the initiative process, as with 1988's Prop 98 (guaranteeing school funding by formula) or 2012's Prop 30 (as noted by this article, bailing out teachers' underfunded pensions). Here's a nice exegesis of their role over the last 40 years: http://www.city-journal.org/2012/22_2_california-teachers-association.html http://www.city-journal.org/2012/22_2_california-teachers-as... If it's part of school finance or operations in California, and it's broken, it's because the CTA made it that way.
- rdl 14y agoI don't get how there is so much spending, but such crappy schools. There's a reasonable argument over how much should be spent on education (assuming returns are relatively proportional to spending), but CA seems to spend money for no return.
- barry-cotter 14y agoNo real quality control from outside (How many administrators aren't former teachers?) and really, really high switching costs. If you want to switch schools you can move house or pay for the government schools through taxes and private school in fees. Not that I think the evidence suggests there's much easy improvement in teaching quality but parochial/charter schools suggest you can do it for a lot cheaper.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoParochial schools are cheap in California?
- adventured 14y agoCalifornia decoupled the return on investment factor from its spending, with predictable results. It doesn't help that half the political spectrum has been arguing for decades non-stop to just spend more and more and more on education, without any concern for improving the low return on investment we currently have on education dollars.
- jellicle 14y ago> It doesn't help that half the political spectrum has been arguing for decades non-stop to just spend more and more and more on education, without any concern for improving the low return on investment we currently have on education dollars. Can you name even one person who has been arguing that?
- rdl 14y agoI think he means anyone arguing for more money without also wanting metrics. I think there are a lot of people against metrics, for two main reasons: they distrust the metrics for accuracy (or think they measure the wrongs things), or personal fear of change. A bottom-30-percent teacher probably knows he or she is in the bottom half, at least, and is rightly afraid of metrics.
- wildgift 14y agoYou don't get it because your premise that all schools are crappy is incorrect. There are good schools, and there are crappy ones, at least by their scores. The big spending happens on the poorest student populations, and the results aren't that good. Why? Well, I'm going to say something unpopular, but it is often because the parents lack education, or are crappy parents, or don't prioritize education. Maybe they think work or family are more important than education. Or there are no parents.
- rdl 14y agoIt's not that all public schools are crappy in California (Palo Alto, Hillsborough are great counterexamples), but a lot of them are.
- gojomo 14y agoOf course there are good public schools. The problem is, they're mainly where the kids would get a good education even if public schools didn't exist. Those parents would find a way. And by forcing those active-and-mobile parents to cluster together geographically, to get their money's worth from the public system, the abandoned isolation of the other students gets worse.
- greedo 14y agoReturns aren't proportional to spending. Most of the studies have shown that increasing spending has little to no impact on student outcomes, nor does decreasing class size. Of course, there's a minimum level of spending required, but that's been reached a long time ago.
- fusiongyro 14y agoWhat are you talking about? The schools actually are doing a fantastic job at their twin goals, which are: 1) being a place to send your children during the day so you can work, and 2) creating excellent standardized test takers. I have great faith that we are producing a generation of the very best and most talented standardized American test takers. No other nation in the world is producing kids who are as good at taking and succeeding at our standardized tests, and they're no help at all with babysitting.
- justin66 14y agoIn both cases, the union sits across the table from management/government. The union asks for money, the specifics of how the money is going to be raised are just not their problem.
- Ntrails 14y agoFinal salary pensions are outlandish˜. Utterly so. Using a realistic (inflation + 5%) investment return and 40 years of service, such a pension funded through DC would be ~30% of your salary contributed every year. The fact that they might be based on a relatively modest salary doesn't change the value of them as a benefit. ˜I am assuming based on article language this is what they have, it is also consistent with the civil service in the UK.
- _delirium 14y agoThey were pretty common until recently, in both the private and public sectors; it's not a particularly unusual arrangement only for these employees. My father was a non-unionized employee at a Fortune 500 firm and retired on a variant of a final-salary pension in the 2000s (variant because "final salary" was defined as an average of the final 3 years). Presumably his company is not going to decide to retroactively decide they don't feel like paying it, either, since it was the agreed remuneration. edit: As one concrete example, it looks like IBM had a final-salary plan until 2009, when it was (non-retroactively) phased out, http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/07/07/ibm_final_salary_pension_killed/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/07/07/ibm_final_salary_pen...
- Ntrails 14y agoYes, the issue is that when they were introduced you had government bond yields of well over 10%. Equities were expected to return even more. Pension promises seemed like a cheap benefit to offer, and one that was mutually beneficial. Couple this with mortality rates falling (expected lifetime increasing) and you have a bunc of completely unaffordable promises. There is a very very good reason that final (and even career average) salary schemes are being phased out. Companies have finally discovered just how expensive their promises are, and they are closing schemes as fast as they can get away with it. The government, meanwhile, buries it's head in the sand because the taxpayer cannot go insolvent. And even small changes to pension terms result in strikes. The mathematics is pretty trivial for this rough estimate, but 30% of salary is low ballpark of the contributions required to meet obligations with a 95% probability over 40 years. Admittedly I'm using an internal asset model which is relatively prudent, with long term derisking, and merely using todays retirement age, and mortality tables. It's probably a lot worse than that (but could be better, I mean this recession malarky can't go on forever right?).