11 ms·
SimCity’s first post-release DLC is a Nissan ad
- Fizzadar 14y agoWouldn't expect anything less from EA!
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI thought it was a pretty sad commentary. The sad part is that the thing doesn't even pretend to be part of the city, no power requirement etc. Ah well, I was waiting to buy a copy once the bugs had been worked out, apparently I can skip it entirely.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y ago> no power requirement It is solar powered. It is identical to parks in terms of how it functions.
- iuguy 14y ago> It is solar powered. Oh that's good that it sounds authentic, because cities all across the world must get enough solar power to charge electric cars without pulling from the power grid all day long, right?
- kalleboo 14y agohttp://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-09-25/tesla-fires-up-solar-powered-charging-stations http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-09-25/tesla-fires-...
- jeltz 14y agoThose are connected to the grid though and will send excess power to the grid, and I assume when there is on solar power they will get their power from the grid. Having them connected to the grid makes way more sense since then you can sell excess power and use the grid to fuel the few cars arriving at night.
- jeltz 14y agoAnd either there is excellent power storage or there is no charging at night.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThere is very little traffic at night.
- jeltz 14y agoNot in the winters in Stockholm where I am from. But then again such solar powered stations would be pretty much useless in the winters here anyway.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoI meant in the game...
- jeltz 14y agoThe topic was if it was "authentic" or not so how it is in the game should not matter much.
- vor_ 14y agoIts positive effects are so lopsided that you're practically obligated to accept the advertising in your city.
- gertef 14y agosounds like real life.
- unoti 14y agoIs it just me, or has EA gone completely off the rails? How does this happen? Do all organizations lose their ability to care about their customers at some point along their growth?
- pokpokpok 14y agothe key factor here is how a corporation works. by definition, they can't do anything besides pursue short term profits
- slapshot 14y agoThis is an oft-repeated line that is entirely false. Ben & Jerry's ice cream spent decades turning down good business deals to stay true to their ideals. The Chicago Cubs notoriously refused to play night baseball games at home for decades after it became popular, and were even sued by shareholders to try to force them to install lights at Wrigley. The Court ruled that management of the Cubs could choose to ignore short-term profits from night baseball if it thought that the franchise was best served by keeping the traditional purity of the game.[1] (Of course, the Cubs ultimately relented, but maybe that's why they haven't won the World Series). Craiglist, to the extreme consternation of its investors, has prioritized a certain long-term vision of the service over lots of short-term profits. Even publicly-traded companies can choose to pursue long-term goals over short-term profit. Autodesk is rumored to be setting up a subsidiary that blends profit and non-profit motives, and plenty of companies have done other acts that are not in their short-term interests. [1] Shlensky v. Wrigley, 95 Ill. App. 2d 173 (1968).
- marshray 14y ago> Ben & Jerry's ice cream spent decades turning down good business deals to stay true to their ideals If, instead of succeeding, Ben & Jerry's had joined the ranks of the many other failed food retailers wouldn't the corporate officers have faced the potential of shareholder lawsuits for having blatantly "turning down good business deals" along the way?
- kalisurfer 14y ago
- Tiktaalik 14y agoMy main issue with this is that the special building doesn't actually play by the rules of the game. It's a charging station that somehow doesn't draw power from your grid. Bizarre and stupid (like so many decisions EA made when developing this game).
- Osiris 14y agoDidn't you notice the solar panels on the top? Of course those panels generate enough electricity to power all give charging ports at the same time. However, I agree with the promoted comment on the site, they are pushed advertising over fixing serious issues with the game, or at least that's how it appears.
- uptown 14y agoI'm just surprised they found a company willing to associate themselves with the SimCity brand given the past month of turmoil. Presumably there was already a contract in-place for this deal - but still, you've got a bunch of pissed off fans for a game that still sits with a massive 1-star rating on Amazon, and that's scheduled to have a new wave of Mac users come on-board putting additional stress on their infrastructure. Plus how many people are going to rush out and buy a Leaf because they saw it in SimCity?
- rhizome 14y agoA month, when the Nissan deal has probably been in the works (at least) for a year and will go on for years (unless EA claws back IAPs at some point). To them the "turmoil" is a momentary bit of nerd rage leading to some copy.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y ago> My main issue with this is that the special building doesn't actually play by the rules of the game. It is literally a park. Do parks not play by the rules?
- 14y ago
- seanalltogether 14y agoSim city 4 has a lot of user made mods that replicate real life buildings, like mcdonalds as an example. So while this may seem like a cynical advertising ploy, the fans themselves set the precedent that this is a desirable feature.
- mmanfrin 14y agoI think intention has a lot to do with acceptability. User-made mods to add realism are much different in intent than an ad that, while functionally the same thing, is meant simply to sell ad space.
- danso 14y agoI think there's a profound difference between a user-mod to add real-life objects to the game world, and a paid-for game object that has magical qualities that only reflect favorably to the marketing client. For example, a user-mod to add a set of real-world Cold War era firearms to Counter-Strike is different than Bushmaster paying to have a prototype rifle that has zero recoil, automatic firing, and instagib armor-piercing ammo.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoSimCity's first free and optional DLC is a Nissan sponsored recharging station. Is it DLC? Yes. Is it a sponsored piece of DLC? Yes. Does it 1:1 replace a small park? Yes (in terms of in-game cost, and all other functionality). Basically it is an in-game park re-skinned as a Nissan Leaf re-charging station. Given away for free to those who purposely go and download it from EA's web-site, and then purposely build it in their city. Oh the horror? Plus SimCity is one of those games that broadly speaking benefits from real establishments and real brands appearing in the game. It is much more fun to see McDonalds on your little digital street than it is to see "Generic Burger House 10101." This whole article and the people that whining about this are just looking for any reason to beat up EA/Maxis. This is not a valid reason. There are tons of valid reasons: The broken game, the small city sizes, their misleading remarks (e.g. always on DRM), amongst other things. People are misfiring here.
- skwirl 14y agoThe charging station seems more compelling than a small park if homeless people can't live in the charging station like they can at the park, which (unless it is bugged like everything else) supposedly decreases the impact of the park.
- marshray 14y ago> It is much more fun to see McDonalds on your little digital street than it is to see "Generic Burger House 10101." I beg to differ. I loved SC2000. I would have purchased this SimCity right away had it not required DRM or constant online connection. But after seeing the first McDonalds or other licensed or paid-placement crap show up in the game I would have never played it again.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y ago> But after seeing the first McDonalds or other licensed or paid-placement crap show up in the game I would have never played it again. You mean the optional "paid-placement crap" that you have to purposely go download and then purposely build within your city? That isn't at all rational. Tons of games have had sponsored promotional items, World of Warcraft's Mountain Dew thing for one very large scale example. But just like WoW's Mountain Dew thing this too is entirely optional.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoB.E.S.U.R.E.T.O.D.R.I.N.K.Y.O.U.R.O.V.A.L.T.I.N.E.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dboat 14y agoI dislike this not for what it is by itself, but for the door I fear it opens in the industry. When Activision thinly disguised their DRM by calling Diablo 3 an MMO, it was a notable and large step for the industry in the direction of removing value rather than adding it in order to accomplish an objective. If anything, I wish the backlash was much harsher, enough to convince EA not to do the same thing with SimCity. It may be disproportionate to the case at hand, real brands may be actually appropriate in a game of this type. I prefer that door remain firmly closed, rather than opened with some cause and later reopened with none at all. EA has a very bad track record. Having brands in SimCity would only add to the immersion of the experience if they were all over place, which EA couldn't do if they wanted to.
- ijk 14y agoThe huge problem here is not just that there's a blatant ad in a SimCity game. Product placements and tie-ins are actually pretty common in Facebook games. Advergames date back to the '80s. The deeper problem is that SimCity is being presented as a relatively serious simulation. The mechanics of the game are intended to represent an approximation of the real world. People will learn about how the world works through playing the game--I know that I learned about zoning and traffic engineering and a whole host of urban problems through the original SimCity. And so did a lot of other people. In fact, a lot of people recognized early on that SimCity had the potential to educate and influence a lot of people. It's even been criticized on the ground that it limits the ways that the various problems can be approached, for example disallowing alternate methods of taxation to completely replace property tax. (Ian Bogost has argued that the best way to deal with this is procedural literacy, that is, learning to critically read a game system like we would a book or a film.) Introducing a magic electric car recharging station isn't just a tasteless ad. It's deliberate propaganda. Even if you support the cause (more electric cars) the way the system works subverts the basic mechanics of the game. This isn't like Maxis adding the recycling centers to SimCity 3000, or the way that nuclear power has always been risky since the first SimCity. Don't forget, this isn't just any electric car, this is a "Nissan LEAF(R)". Players who play the game with this DLC will be subjected to the continual message that adding a Nissan(TM) charging station to their city makes everything better, with no downsides. That may be an agreeable message if it gets us more electric cars, but it subverts the basic urban simulation model in service of propaganda. Imagine if it was, say, Shell or BP doing this with a regular filling station. Or McDonalds. And you'll note that Tesla doesn't have a SimCity recharging station... Even players who see through the transparent propaganda will be influenced by it, in the same way that advertizing always influences our behavior, even when we realize that it is having an effect on us. And for the subset of the player who might be skeptical about electric cars, this building also won't help. Because the building has no downsides, what happens when the player learns more about the real world and realizes that there are, in fact, problems that such a building would create (like drawing down a lot more power than just the solar panels can provide). Disillusionment is bad for advocacy. The resulting cynicism won't just sour them on Nissan, it'll sour them on electric cars in general. If they had created a more balanced building (or even a whole system of electric cars and public transportation) supported by Nissan as an in-game ad it would be less disturbing, because it would fit with the system and be a less transparent cash-in. (On the other hand, there's something to be said for the blatant transparency, since at least it's blindingly obvious propaganda.)
- mccolin 14y agoI found it funny that below this article about in-game advertising creep, the first comment is a "promoted comment," pinned to the top of the list and praising the ad effort.