11 ms·
The dissent on this bothers me as a lawyer. It basically says the whole thing is a sham to use a perceived "loophole in the law". IE By complying with the exac
by DannyBee 14y ago
The dissent on this bothers me as a lawyer.
It basically says the whole thing is a sham to use a perceived "loophole in the law".
IE By complying with the exact requirements of the law, they are committing a sham.
It's a policy argument, not a legal one.
A sham is doing something like "i'll sell my brother my house for $1". That's a sham. You are doing something to try to trivially comply with contracts law (which requires adequate consideration), but the $1 you are giving is really trying to cover up the fact that it's really a gift.
But that's not the argument the dissent makes, the argument it makes is "i don't like this behavior, so i will villify it" and act like it's a sham. The law imposes plenty of technical barriers to doing things.
I could make an amazing wireless system if i could use whatever transmitter power i liked, but the law prevents me.
The fact that they could use one large antenna is exactly right, but it changes nothing, because the law appears to prevents them from doing so.
Following the technical requirements of FCC law is not a sham, it's "what the law requires you do".
Following the technical requirements of copyright law is not a sham, it's "what the law requires you do".
- jes5199 14y agocan you explain what the legal mechanism is that makes a $1 house sale illegal? I don't understand how it's different.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoIts not illegal, its a "sham" (which is to say the house is worth much more than $1 and the sale has an ulterior motive). Similarly car sales where the car costs $1 but the "handling" charge is $15,000. The sham is that you pay sales tax on the sale price (that was fixed by paying sales tax on the blue book price but I digress).
- rorrr 14y agoSham isn't illegal. I don't understand your complaint. So they used the law in a creative way. Good for them.
- danielweber 14y agoPerhaps not "illegal," but it would nearly always be done in an attempt to bypass taxes. "I sold it to Joe for $1, I have no income tax to report, ha ha!"
- guan 14y agoIn fact, if the seller paid more than $1 for the house, he can take a nice deduction for the “loss.” In this example, in the US, it will be obvious to the IRS that the transaction is not arms-length, and they might levy gift tax on the fair market value of the house. They already thought of this loophole. There are, in fact, situations where the law is written to look more at intent than technicalities, for example in many areas of US immigration law, or generally in tax law when determining where a person’s residence is. That’s not always a good idea either because it leaves a lot of discretion for government officials and creates uncertainty about what the law is. An uncynical observer of the political system would say that the legislature has already thought of this: they’ve made the law very technical in areas where they want it to be, and less so in other areas.
- joonix 14y agoYou're mixing up contract law and IRS regulations. The $1 sale is a valid contract, but somebody will likely pay taxes on it, probably the recipient since he received a house at below fair value, which can be considered income.
- DannyBee 14y agoThe $1 sale may not be a valid contract, actually, it depends on the state, and whether they are still completely common law or not. Basically, under the restatement views, nominal consideration = no consideration under common law views, nominal consideration = consideration.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoI think its useful as an exercise to point out the challenges in Copyright law. Using 22nm MEMs technology I could imagine that I can get 1,000,000 antennas on a die which are clearly articulated when viewed in an electron microscope. Then I can sell these chips for $10,000 each to companies that want to use this "loophole".
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoWell, maybe, but not if the antennas need to be functional. To be functional there are physical laws that must be obeyed.
- rayiner 14y agoAs a lawyer, it was the majority's approach that bothered me. Simply, this hyper-technical approach makes for bad law. The court would've been better served here just saying it was fair use because the ads were preserved and the streams contained content that could be watched for free over the air anyway. Throw in the additional public consideration in this case, which is that the content owners are taking advantage of public airwaves to air this content in the first place, and the need to perpetuate this bizarre loophole disappears. The problem here is: what does "public performance" mean in the context of internet broadcasts? Cablevision just covers that consideration with mud. The answer is probably: the distinction of "public performance" is completely meaningless when talking about internet streams.
- jackalope 14y ago"...it was fair use because the ads were preserved..." Since when does fair use require the preservation of ads or any specific portion of the content? Your argument dilutes the meaning and intent of fair use. Even the matter of being free or not has no bearing. The majority wisely avoided this area and fundamentally upheld the fair use rights of the users. The dissenting opinion confuses the issue by discussing licensing agreements, even going so far as to suggest fair use is somehow illegal.
- DannyBee 14y ago"Since when does fair use require the preservation of ads or any specific portion of the content? " When "the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work." became a factor that must be considered in fair use? While the 4 factors were not meant to be all-inclusive, there's a great law review article that shows that something like 99% of court decisions only ever consider those factors
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kyllo 14y agoWe're going to have bad law that treats bits as physical objects, hyper-technical workarounds and loopholes until we, as voters, confront the reality that content providers are now "charging for smells," and force Congress to do something about it. http://www.paulgraham.com/property.html http://www.paulgraham.com/property.html
- joonix 14y agoContract law doesn't require adequate consideration.
- tokenadult 14y agoContract law DOES require "consideration" to form a contract, but consideration indicates dickering (negotiation) more than it indicates a set amount of money. (Yes, I am a lawyer too.) The dollar amount needed to distinguish a real estate conveyance that is a bona fide sale from one that is a gift is a separate issue from contract law, so I empathize with your disagreement with the grandparent comment.
- DannyBee 14y ago"The dollar amount needed to distinguish a real estate conveyance that is a bona fide sale from one that is a gift is a separate issue from contract law" I'm not sure why you think i'm talking about a non-contract law issue There are many issues with gifts, some in real estate, some in torts, and some in contract law. Plenty of jurisdictions allow disguised gifts (the classic example being nominal consideration, such as $1 for property) to be looked behind, and because they classify the consideration as a gift rather than anything real, do not form a valid contract. That does not mean it occurs in all cases, or that there aren't jurisdictions where i can have a legally binding agreement to buy a house for a dollar (there are plenty) However, if you don't believe this is a valid issue in the theory of contract formation, i'm not sure what to tell you. Maybe this helps? Restatement (second) of contracts §71. REQUIREMENT OF EXCHANGE; TYPES OF EXCHANGE ... b. "Bargained for." ... Moreover, a mere pretense of bargain does not suffice, as where there is a false recital of consideration or where the purported consideration is merely nominal. In such cases there is no consideration and the promise is enforced, if at all, as a promise binding without consideration under §§82- 94 There are plenty of jurisdictions that follow the restatement view. Would it make you feel better if I changed the example to sell ing a car to a relative for $1? Or do you think this is also a legally enforceable contract in all jurisdictions? (It's not, it would be enforceable in the 'still completely common law' jurisdictions, but not in the 'we take the restatement view' jurisdictions) I do agree there are separate issues as to whether it is specifically legal to convey real estate in certain situations, but this is completely separate from the general theory of whether you can form a valid contract this way. Even that is different than the question of whether you could get anything, even if the contract was unenforceable (IE some kind of quasi-contract recovery). However, this is all pretty useless pedantry (though i'm happy to argue about it, since lawyering is fun). I used an example that is legally correct in plenty of jurisdictions to make a point, and the complaint seems to be not about the point I made (that it's not a sham), but about the specific example, and in this case, like everything else, it depends on the jurisdiction. I could have written a completely legally accurate comment (at least for the US) by adding another few sentences that describe the possible outcomes in all jurisdictions, but it would not be very effective writing :)
- snowwrestler 14y agoI think it's a bit hasty to call this stuff the "exact requirements of the law." It's not like they are following a precise recipe laid out in the Federal Register. They are attempting to apply a precedent in a novel way. It's obviously not exactly settled, or the court would not be hearing the case. The whole point of the appellate ruling is to decide whether in fact they are adequately complying with the law. As a non-lawyer, my smell test is violated by how needlessly complicated the technical approach is, to produce a fairly simple result. It would be like saying there's an exception to "no trespassing" if you do a very particular, complex dance before entering the property.
- 205guy 14y agoBoth you and the dissenting judge seem to take issue with the complexity of the technical approach. That does not seem like a legal argument. I understand that if someone goes to great lengths to do something illegal, say hide their transactions and funds with multiple offshore accounts to avoid paying taxes, it can be a legal argument (it's proof of knowing and evading). But in this case, the goal is something legal: a consumer setting up a private antenna, connecting it to a private DVR and watching it over the internet. Aereo figured there would be a market demand, so they figured out a way to do it economically for a lot of people at the same time. [In fact, I wonder if Aereo is patenting their antenna array and general setup. It's clearly a highly complex innovation.] Actually, there is an exception to tresspassing: the complex dance involves getting certified as a pilot and using an airplane--and staying a certain level above ground. Here's another exception: some jurisdictions allow native populations access to land regardless of private ownership (though ancestry is less generalizable). Medical marijuana might be more similar: it's generally illegal, except for certain illness, so all of a sudden, a lot of people are getting diagnosed (with certain doctors and dispensaries gaining). My point is, all these models of interaction (real property, media copyright, and consumer rights) have loopholes of various degrees, or rather overlaps in what is allowed and what is gained (access vs. property rights, entertainment vs. commercials). Essentially, the market is still maturing. The model of over-the-air TV with commercials is not the end-all-be-all of consumer entertainment. Other models are being developed at its expense, reshaping the legal and economical landscape as they go, and of course the established players user their clout to hang on as long as possible. Actually, HBO is evolving. It was already cable-only in response to the shifting of these winds decades ago. Now it is releasing series (Game of Thrones) on its own terms. You see people who say "take my money, just let me download it." But having avoided the gray areas such as over-the-air broadcasting, it is in a position of power. It knows people want the series, that desire creates value, and it is in a position to reap that value. Sure there is torrenting, but from a copyright position, violaters are defintely in the wrong. As a result, I wonder if this ruling will eventually lead to the end of over-the-air TV transmission. And in the short term, it wouldn't surprise me if Aereo's facility suddenly had very poor reception due to some antenna misalignments at their local transmitter.
- noonespecial 14y agoAs a non-lawyer the whole affair just makes me completely lose respect for the law and want to fire up bittorrent. If you will: "No offence guys, go right ahead and argue about how many angels can dance on that particular pin-head, I'll be over here watching Game of Thrones on "AllMyVideos.net". It feels like they're making game out of it instead of rationally addressing the issue.
- GHFigs 14y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but Game of Thrones isn't broadcast over the air.
- rayiner 14y agoHe just likes getting shit for free.
- noonespecial 14y agoIts hyperbole. Game of Thrones is an HBO show and is not free, or broadcast outside private cable. The point is, if it doesn't matter, then people are just going to do whatever. The "over the air" stuff is ostensibly free, but if "the powers" are going to dick around with "free" like this even though its perfectly clear to everyman its silly, then why take any of it seriously? That's what I mean when I say people will lose respect. If free was free and pay was pay and it was clear what was what, people might get behind it. This nonsense is just going to make people bittorrent and push meaningful solutions that much further down the road.
- Dylan16807 14y agoIf all you care about is price hook up your own antenna and don't purchase aereo's service.