3 ms·
Comparing USA Average (the middle number), the prices actually don't seem bad at all considering that the USA has by far the best medicine in the world and a ho
by pbreit 14y ago
Comparing USA Average (the middle number), the prices actually don't seem bad at all considering that the USA has by far the best medicine in the world and a host of reasons why it runs high (legal, cost of education, free markets, high rate of elective procedures, center of advancements, etc).
- btilly 14y ago...the USA has by far the best medicine in the world... Citation needed. The statistics that I've seen usually place the USA near the bottom of the industrialized world on things like life expectancy, child mortality, survival rate after open heart surgery, etc.
- pbreit 14y agoCitation needed. Either way, some/many of the things you cite have to do with access to care, diet, smoking (yes, more than europeans), etc, not quality. Things like heart surgery mortality rates are tough to compare since the USA is well-known for performing more procedurs at the end of life. Not my favorite source but little reason to think it's way off: http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2013/01/15/facts-about-americas-health-care-quality-that-world-doesnt-know/ http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2013/01/15/facts-about-americ...
- kalleboo 14y agoI find all these debates so difficult because it's so hard to interpret all the numbers. For instance, your article's numbers all seem to be based on outcomes for people who are seeing doctors. Maybe there's something about people who don't see doctors in the US which would cause the outcomes to be worse. Or maybe not. It's just impossible to trust anything, since everything can be interpreted in 10 different ways.
- adventured 14y agoNear the bottom of the industrialized world? That's a pretty fantastic claim for data that involves so much fraud. For example, Japan's life expectancy is 83, right? Errr, nope not so much. You're no doubt aware of the vast fraud involved in Japanese welfare programs involving dead elderly. The US is within a small margin of difference with many of the other major industrialized countries when you adjust for fake reporting. The US happens to have one of the best data accuracy rates when it comes to reporting death - or did you think Bosnia and Russia really have a 50% lower infant mortality rate than the US (the same Russia whose men live to 60)? The US life expectancy is 78.5, that compares to 79.3 for South Korea, easily within a +/- margin of difference. The UK is 80, ditto Germany, again, it's trivially easy to skew these numbers artificially higher with fraud, but even in that case the difference isn't exactly dramatic. You're going to toast the US over a year variance on data that is not very accurate or proven? Yeah ok. And if you really want to get into the data: the US is the best country on earth when it comes to the top 85%, because the real problem with the US is poverty and diet among the bottom 15%. THAT is our real problem. If you compare the top 85% in each country, the US comes out at the top. But you're not interested in that discussion I'm sure.
- richardjordan 14y agoBy what measure? Not outcomes. I suggest you check your sources as the US falls behind most of the developed world on outcomes - which really should be what you measure for healthcare stats.