12 ms·
Ask HN: Does anyone know what's going on at Coinbase?
Maybe a Coinbase engineer can anonymously tell us what's going on over there, because nobody trying to trade with Coinbase can get a public answer.
Money is going missing. Transactions have been delayed for days and, in some cases, over a week. Even amounts already in BTC aren't leaving the system.
Coinbase claimed the other day this was all due to a database migration[1], but they're offline once again.
[1]: http://support.coinbase.com/customer/portal/articles/1051063-pending-transactions
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI'm rooting for them, but they definitely need to communicate more.
- merinid 14y agoAm rooting for them too - they are in beta folks, that's quite an honest communication on its own.
- joezydeco 14y agoSure, that's an honest communication, but apparently not completely honest because their systems are still down. Prior to that message, this was the only tweet from @Coinbase for the entire day: https://twitter.com/coinbase/status/314942700854071296 https://twitter.com/coinbase/status/314942700854071296 Not exactly confidence-inspiring.
- dabeeeenster 14y agoThis is ridiculous. If they are trading real money, they are not "in beta".
- bdcravens 14y ago"Beta": why didn't AIG think of that?
- niggler 14y agoThis is absolutely an issue that needs to be handled immediately. When there is real money involved, trust/faith is by far the most important factor. If there is any concern about missing money, people will lose faith in the service and usually stop using it. To give an analogy, consider what is going on in the minds of the Cypriots while their accounts are in limbo.
- bayesianhorse 14y agoIf anyone was thinking his transactions with a bitcoin exchange or their bitcoin account with some website was remotely as safe as a bank in Cyprus, we can't really call him a fiscally responsible adult...
- kragen 14y agoThis week we've been looking at threats that Cypriot banks would never reopen again, and at a minimum large depositors will lose a quarter of their savings. It seems like you have it backwards!
- ebbv 14y agoJust because Cypress is going to shit doesn't mean that moving your money into BTC is an awesome idea.
- kragen 14y agoIf your money is in Cypriot banks it's already too late, but it turns out in retrospect that it would have been an awesome idea a couple of weeks ago. Arguably nobody could have known that.
- justincormack 14y agoIt was fairly clear months ago that there would be depositor losses. The small amount of capital flight was surprising.
- smallegan 14y agoNot sure if my story syncs up with what everyone else is seeing: -I purchased 10 coins on the 14th. -Money came out of my account on the 18th. -They said they were available to me on the 20th via e-mail -Have tried multiple times to send money to external wallets with no success -My account balance went from 10 to 0 to 10 -Support has been horrible
- tpsreport 14y ago> -My account balance went from 10 to 0 to 10 That could potentially indicate a database infrastructure problem. Eventually consistent databases can issue responses that appear to travel backwards in time. And [1] says this: Coinbase uses MongoDB for their primary datastore for their web app, api requests, etc. Coinbase is a decentralized, digital currency that is changing the world of payments. [1] http://www.mongodb.org/about/production-deployments/ http://www.mongodb.org/about/production-deployments/
- wheaties 14y agoAs much as I love MongoDB it has way too many issues to use it as a primary data store for financial transactions. I hope they backed up and tested their backup recovery. Something tells me they're dealing with a data corruption/loss which wiped out their master and slaves without a backup. Perhaps if they've got decent logging they can piece it together with logs.
- Xorlev 14y agoI barely trust MongoDB with my personal projects. It's shot me in the foot enough given they're not a very stable vendor (case in point, see the 2.4.0 replication bug -- we didn't get hit by that thankfully). We've had issues where databases can get on divergent paths, then MongoDB will keep up to 300mb of the stuff it can't match in a directory and after that you're hosed.
- stuffihavemade 14y agoIt's absolutely insane if they are using Mongo as their source of truth (and not say some kind of caching layer). If there is one thing that should be ACID, it's financial transactions.
- ashray 14y agoI hope they figure this out soon. This is the kind of thing that scares me and the primary reason that I decided against speculating in bitcoins. For someone like me who can't really afford to lose a lot of money, I need to trade in historically stable stuff (even if they are as rigged as they are..). I don't really understand bitcoin very well, that is reason #2. I hope the Coinbase folks though have a solid grasp of it and can fix this otherwise this is going to look very bad.
- wting 14y agoIf you can't afford to lose your investment, you shouldn't be investing at all. Scared money is essentially lost money if you can't make rational decisions without being influenced by fear. As for #2, that can be solved through self education. Why use an investment vehicle that you don't understand?
- jessaustin 14y agoIf you can't afford to lose your investment, you shouldn't be investing at all. I doubt they would have let Madoff use this excuse. I'm not saying these dudes are anything like that jackhole, but rather that there is a difference between the risks inherent in the security or commodity (in this case bitcoin) and the counter-party risk of your broker screwing up the bookkeeping. Coinbase have made the latter risk appear significant.
- wting 14y agoMadoff is a straw man; he committed fraud.
- jessaustin 14y agoIf you said this was a poor example, I would at least understand what you're trying to say, but how on earth is Madoff a straw man in this instance? Try to to separate your [legitimately] dim view of Madoff from the fashion in which his example illustrates the phenomenon of counter-party risk.
- yarou 14y agoStrange indeed...I've never used Coinbase, but I had heard good things about them before. Hopefully they can resolve this issue in a timely manner.
- famulus 14y agoThis makes it pretty worthless: "Sorry, the maximum number of purchases on Coinbase has been reached for today"
- cobrabyte 14y agoSounds like they got outside of their reserves in the BTC run-up this month.
- taylorhou 14y agoI tried to exchange for 10 coins a while back and they said somehow my bank didn't approve of the ACH... that was when it was like $21 to 1 btcn.
- wilfra 14y agoThey are actively hiring for customer support if anybody wants to tackle the job of improving this situation: https://coinbase.com/jobs https://coinbase.com/jobs I know it's real money and people flip out but try to be understanding of their situation. Their business is exploding and they're moving 1,000 miles an hour in an industry that is literally being invented as we speak. Hiccups should be expected.
- metaverse 14y agoIt's possible that they've been undercharging for their service, and as a result have simply run out of cash. With the recent price growth, their buy price sometimes fails to catch up with the current exchanges rates, resulting in losses for them that their fee of 1% does not cover for. My friends trying Coinbase have raised concerns about the long delays as well, and I have a bitcoin transfer to my personal wallet that's been pending for multiple days. This needs to be resolved quickly to keep Coinbase and Bitcoins reputation.
- jmharvey 14y agoSeems unlikely. From their blog yesterday: This is probably as good a time as any to mention that if you are in SF and are an awesome software engineer, we’re hiring: https://coinbase.com/jobs Companies that are running out of cash tend not to hang big, "we're hiring" signs in the window.
- niggler 14y agoCompanies that want to give the impression that they are thriving also hang "we're hiring" signs.
- jessaustin 14y agoThis will affect the response they get from "awesome software engineers in SF", even if they are actually thriving.
- jessaustin 14y ago...their buy price sometimes fails to catch up with the current exchanges rates... This is an existential flaw in their business. Why don't they just reject transactions at expired prices? (If they wanted to be slightly more evil, they could do this in one direction only.)
- metaverse 14y agoOr just raise more money hoping that the price of a bitcoin will stabilize in the near future. Their current system is very convenient for users.
- djengineerllc 14y agoI've had a pending payment transaction to a couple places for about a week now. :( Still waiting....
- mrcoining 14y agoI wouldn't be surprised if they have accidentally and temporarily turned into a kind of Ponzi and don't currently have enough BTC to fulfill orders, and are waiting for new cash to come in so they can, or waiting for people on Coinbase to sell, they can match it up with someone that bought and has been waiting. The "technical" explanation to the situation does not add up because otherwise everything would be fine now for everybody. It looks more like the situation is related to finances.
- jonpaul 14y agoI'm a Coinbase customer, and as an additional data point, their customer service has been wonderful. Now granted, this was about a month ago. I did send them an email on Thursday and haven't heard back from them, but my request wasn't urgent, so I haven't thought much of it. Overall, I'm rooting for them, and being YC backed, I'm confident that they'll figure out their issues. I do hope sooner rather than later, as I can't wait to use their API.
- joezydeco 14y agoSure, we're all rooting for them. But a mod just deleted the "YC ('12)" off the headline. What should I think about that?
- jmharvey 14y ago(YC XX) is generally only used on HN for launch and funding announcements.
- joezydeco 14y agoMy mistake. Thanks for the correction. (And my apologies, pg)
- niggler 14y agoCoinbase (YC S12) hires first engineer http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5011361 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5011361 Is that a launch or funding announcement?
- subsystem 14y agoNope. https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/submissions&q=S10+or+W10+or+S11+or+W11+or+S12+or+W12+&start=0 https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/submissions&q=S1...
- pbreit 14y agoThose are all launch-like announcements. Is that what you were trying to show.
- mef 14y agoPerhaps they were running the client that got rolled back and got screwed on a big double spend. Pure speculation but that did happen recently.
- im3w1l 14y agoI thought the transactions were migrated over successfully?
- FredEE 14y agoFred from Coinbase here. There are still a few lingering issues, which we've been working hard to fix and will be looking at again today. To those affected, I'm very sorry for the wait. Funds are safe, it's just a question of opening the pipes properly to let them flow normally.
- PommeDeTerre 14y agoCan you please describe the implementation of this system, and the problems encountered recently, in more detail? Which database systems are involved in the "database migration" described in the support center article? Please list at least the product names and versions. What was the nature of the "refactor"? What programming languages and implementations were involved, for instance? What exactly happened during the "database migration"? Was there any data loss? What sort of backup infrastructure is in place?
- jmharvey 14y agoIm a Coinbase customer. I'm waiting for my pending transaction to go through, and for USD to hit my bank account. And I'd rather have Fred and the rest of Coinbase working on solving that problem than explaining what, exactly, the glitch is, and while they're at it, what their entire infrastructure looks like. There will be time for explanations later.
- jany 14y agoYeah no wonder they fail so hard, they use Macs.
- jany 14y agoDo not trust them with a single coin.
- jany 14y agoYeah no wonder they fail so hard, they use Macs. Do not trust them with a single coin.
- jany 14y agoYeah no wonder they fail so hard, they use Macs. Do not trust them with a single coin. Idiots will be parted of their coins sooner or later.
- jany 14y agoThey are not an exchange. Perhaps a broker, lousy one.
- jboggan 14y agoThat's too bad, I had actually set aside today to learn their API and integrate it into a project . . . nevermind. On a related note, check out the insane price action on the exchange rate overnight.
- newnewnew 14y agoI would give them six months to migrate off of mongodb first.
- michaelochurch 14y agoWait a minute. Y Combinator funded a fucking BitCoin startup? f is Fonz/YCombinator, w* is water, and S is a fucking vicious shark. Frame 1 (before funding a BitCoin startup): f wwwwwwwwwwwwww S Frame 2 (decision to fund a BitCoin startup): f wwwwwwwwwwwwww S Frame 3 (after funding a BitCoin startup): f wwwwwwwwwwwwww S
- tptacek 14y agoHow does that attempt at snark even make sense? In frame 1, before YC funds a Bitcoin startup, the Fonz is already on a trajectory that requires him to jump over a shark. Try harder next time, nascent evil 'edw519.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI'm cynical, not evil. I like what Paul Graham is trying to do, and I don't actually think one obvious bad call constitutes "jumping the shark". If terrible, stupid decisions constitute shark-jumping, then I shouldn't have any limbs left. However, I strongly dislike Bitcoin (obvious scam) and don't know why YC would gamble its reputation in such a degenerate way as to associate with it. Also, I felt the world could use some crude ASCII art.
- tptacek 14y agoWait, what? Is the Fonz heading towards the shark or not, Michael? I and many others demand to know. I don't like that YC blessed a Bitcoin startup either, but I like fatuous snark even less.
- michaelochurch 14y agoI like YC. VC-istan would be far more degenerate without the influence of Paul Graham. However, they're not infallible. Ridicule (what you called "fatuous snark") is a social immune system that sees degeneracy (e.g. funding Bitcoin) and says, "Stop doing that". It has a function.
- rdl 14y agoIIRC, Coinbase has a founder and an engineer, which doesn't excuse non-responsiveness, but is probably the reason. They're probably hard at work trying to deal with this problem, and haven't prioritized support or notification of affected customers. That might have been a good choice if the fix only took a few hours, but as it's dragging on a bit, it's probably better to take some time out from fixing it and communicate with customers.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- phormula 14y agoI wonder if part of the current price drop is lack of transactions from coinbase
- jensenbox 14y agoTheir lack of transparency is not a new problem. I had a problem with their API and it took days for them to even acknowledge that I had even emailed them about it. I doubt they will be around for much longer. When it comes to money, customer service must be the first priority even if it is to say "sorry".