30 ms·
Unfit for work
- FD3SA 14y agoMeans-tested social assistance is now a vestigial remnant of an economy strictly dependent upon labor as its primary input for growth. As the share of economic inputs tips increasingly in favor of capital (via automation), most laborers will steadily become unemployable at a subsistence-level minimum wage. As a result, we will see dependence and abuses of means-tested social welfare by these laborers who can no longer participate in the market. The only long term solution is a basic income system, which rewards consumption and allows the market to continuously reward innovation and efficiency. Without a redistribution mechanism to fuel consumption, the market collapses entirely as wealth is further concentrated. Further reading: 1. http://www.naturalfinance.net/2013/02/nearly-all-of-us-support-slavery.html http://www.naturalfinance.net/2013/02/nearly-all-of-us-suppo... 2. http://amzn.com/B005WTR4ZI http://amzn.com/B005WTR4ZI 3. http://amzn.com/B002S0NITU http://amzn.com/B002S0NITU
- purplelobster 14y agoThat is becoming increasingly clear. When I drive through small to medium sized towns I can't help myself thinking "what do all of these people DO for a living?". They have to import everything they need and many of these places don't produce anything of value. Add into the mix that if they do have any fast food or services, more likely than not they're global franchises sucking even more money out of the town. How is this sustainable? It seems to me that the more globalized, specialized and efficient the world becomes, a few hubs will produce pretty much everything. If in the past every town within a 100 mile radius had it's own carpenters making furniture, today there's one big Ikea in the middle of them all taking all that business away.
- ams6110 14y agoThere is a lot more to a local economy than factories and fast food. Small towns likely have an agricultural component, and most all will have trades (plumbers, electricians, HVAC, carpenters), mechanics, general handymen, other services, doctors, optometrists, lawyers, other professionals. It may not be New York or San Francisco but there's enough work to do to get by.
- tgrass 14y agoPay off your $60K house by the time your 30 (perhaps from commuting to some distant town) - and entertain yourself with television and playing cards, and you don't need much annual income.
- icebraining 14y agoTV and cards don't need much income, but the health care certainly does.
- bilbo0s 14y agoIt's more complicated than that. Just to give you an example, everything you mentioned is a service that would, ideally, be consumed locally. Consider where the money to pay the plumber comes from. Will hundreds of people from other towns call on that plumber? Or on their own plumbers? What I'm trying to say is that at some point, someone, not necessarily the plumber, but someone has to bring money into the town.
- bcoates 14y agoIt's quite common for people to reach child-raising or retirement age and move to such places, or even leave their families there and continue to work in the big city. These cities also tend to have a lot of cottage-industry scale businesses: the average small American town is probably the worldwide capital of some incredibly obscure product or service. A town needs hard-currency inflow to pay for their imports but not a terribly large amount of it.
- davidroberts 14y agoMore like each country had its own furniture making factories, but your point still stands. The ideal would be a society in which quality locally produced goods would be valued over trashy throwaway goods like those sold at Ikea, but this requires a complete rethinking of what's valuable in life by individuals and the society as a whole. Past experience has shown that attempts to manipulate this bureaucratically through tariffs, fixed pricing, closed guilds or the like just cause market distortions that bring about new problems without solving the old ones. In the meantime, though it's far from ideal, at least there is a way that hardworking people with no market for their labor can avoid starvation, although at a personal loss of dignity and a societal loss of that person's potential contribution.
- bollockitis 14y agoBut you're missing an important point. "Quality locally produced goods" are very expensive. I can get a "trashy" piece of furniture from IKEA for just a few hundred bucks. That same piece of furniture, produced by a local artisan, would cost me thousands. Most people don't buy cheap furniture because they choose to, they do it because I have to. As the population grows, more people buy more stuff. Local woodworkers and cabinet makers cannot possibly fulfill demand using locally sourced materials and hand tools. If everyone is to get chairs and tables and cabinets, production must be automated. Once automated, production can scale, which usually reduces both quality and cost. Instead of local wood, wood is imported and turned into particle board because its dimensions make automation easier. But now a nightstand can be turned out in less than an hour, where a traditional artisan might spend a week or more, driving up labor costs. In other words, it isn't that people need to "rethink" what's valuable. They have already done the thinking, and they value more affordable, lower quality goods over limited, expensive ones. And I don't blame them.
- jordan0day 14y agoBut what happens when Ikea sells goods of the same, or superior quality, than those "quality locally produced goods"? In fact, for many of the goods we buy, a lot of the "quality" we perceive from "locally-produced" is a figment of our imagination, or at least biased by taste. Sure, the coffee table you paid $30 for at Wal-Mart is almost certainly inferior in every way but one (price!) to something you'd find yourself paying $400 (or $4000) for at [locally-produced furniture company]. But you could probably spend $200 and get something made in China or Vietnam that is just as good as anything you could buy locally-produced.
- protomyth 14y ago"Weird, I look at cities and wonder what the heck you all produce since you've closed your factories (they smell) and don't farm, ranch, mine, fish, or log." Economics is subtle and much more complicated than what you describe. We are not heading to Mega City 1.
- purplelobster 14y agoYou're right, I mean there has to be something there or the people couldn't survive (unless they're all on disability). I would say though that 90% of these places don't have much except maybe farming. Maybe that's enough to sustain these places, but given how automated farming has become I'd doubt it. And farming is also concentrated the same way Ikea is. Modern farming tend to be much bigger scale (thus fewer players).
- protomyth 14y agoYou probably should do some research on what farming actually means in this day and age. Farms are not self sustaining, they buy seed, equipment, fuel, and supplies. Those people buy other things. A farm is a huge input to an economy and money changes multiple hands.
- vacri 14y agoMy mother has lived in a couple of different up-in-the-mountains hamlets and I've met the people in nearby houses. Like you say, there's farming support work. There are also people like scriptwriters, professional wine tasters, hoteliers/B&Bers, architects, software engineers, government consultants ('what kind of consulting?' => 'consulting'...) and officials, retirees, successful artists, landlords living off rent from elsewhere, so on and so forth. There are heaps of people with 'portable' jobs that can bring money into a town, and plenty of those like the small town or hamlet life. You can't tell that a town doesn't have a well-off scriptwriter living in a back street simply by driving through it.
- mogrim 14y ago> We are not heading to Mega City 1. Gutted, I need a Chopper style surf board!
- dhughes 14y agoI've thought the same thing, I live in a small town and when I travel out to the country and see small houses actually shacks (their pickup truck is bigger) my mind spins. Agriculture sounds innocent enough but living in such an environment I know it's not that simple. It's seasonal which is at the moment a huge problem the Canadian government has with seasonal workers in isolated areas. People get government assistance aka employment insurance or "EI" in Canadian-ese but the government has closed down the offices people go to apply and made it web based, baffling non-techy 60 year-olds. Now "EI cops" are making unannounced visits to these rural areas to make sure they people on EI are looking for work...but where?! Anyway it's an age-old situation, the people make our food live in the middle of nowhere get pennies per ton and when they need money the government and city dwellers sneer at them.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoAdmittedly, at the same time Big Farming are just the same kind of bastards as any other large manufacturing or resource-extraction capitalist titans, and are often receiving very nice breaks from the government.
- maxerickson 14y agoTake a look at the ownership breakdowns here: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/agriculture/farms_and_farmland.html http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/agriculture/farm... 826, "Farms by Size and Type of Organization" is probably the more interesting report. There is some room at the top for your cartoon owners there, but the typical farm, by acreage and number, is a medium sized place (still hundreds of acres) that is closely held by a family.
- dhughes 14y agoThe USA calls subsidies a different name but they're still subsidies especially sugar and corn crops. It's do as I say not as I do even if the rules are broken, but it's no shock coming from the US. NAFTA supposedly has wording about subsidies but the US often denies it I am just going by what I hear since living in an agricultural region you hear this stuff since birth even if you're not a farmer or fisherman.
- Florin_Andrei 14y agoReminds me of the movie "Cars" by Pixar.
- crusso 14y agoYou see communities surviving, perhaps thriving in their own way and you don't understand how. Instead of thinking, "I must not know something", you think "these places don't produce anything of value". Your comment said very little about economics and a great deal about you.
- gregpilling 14y agoI think with an increase in telecommuting jobs (except Yahoo!) there may be growth in these small towns in the future. Small towns are nice to raise children in, have lower costs of living - which can be offset by high pay, high skill work telecommuted into the office from small town home. And then the extra cash will turn into custom furniture because all the neighbors have IKEA and they want to be different.
- kevinskii 14y agoAs others have noted on HN, what you're describing is called the "Lump of Labor" Fallacy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy
- michaelochurch 14y ago"Lump of labor" is fallacious, but there's a demand curve at any given time, and demand for most of the stuff that being have been doing for decades is softening and will continue to do so. The long-term, progressive solution is to train people up. Give them the resources and autonomy to learn the skills they need to rise to a higher level of work. If this is done, then we break out of the zero-sum labor regime, people graduate to more creative, high-yield work, and we can all be happy. But... someone has to pay for these people to survive while they learn, which takes far away from our original-sin (work, or don't eat) economy and closer to the basic income concept.
- mkr-hn 14y agoThis is one of the big criticisms of unpaid internships. It favors people who already have the ability to work for something other than subsistence. There may be more room for paid internships than companies are willing to admit, and encouraging them to pay might be a useful stopgap until we come up with something better.
- michaelochurch 14y agoUnpaid internships exist for exploratory purposes (try people out, discard most) in industries that, while "cool", are effectively marginal (and headed toward obsolescence). The unpaid internship phenomenon is not there to skirt minimum wage laws, but to avoid an uncanny valley. The actual economic worth of a publishing intern is nonzero (and probably above the minimum) but unsavory. No middle-class college-educated person will work for $9.50 an hour-- it's a pride thing-- so the wage is reduced to a flat zero and the job type is redefined as a "learning experience". To be fair, it's not totally dishonest bullshit. If the pay is zero, the power dynamic is different. So it is a different kind of experience (I'm just not sure how much of one it really is). I actually think that a basic income is good insofar as it removes the need for the minimum wage. Minimum wage is essentially a clumsy minimum-income program where the bill is paid by low-end employers, who respond by cutting low-end jobs, creating unemployment. In theory, without a minimum wage, we'd have zero unemployment (except for the beneficial, intrinsic kind). Add that to basic income, and the (theoretical) result still holds: full employment. Most capable people would work, for economic reasons, but the option not to work would give employees more leverage and be better, on the whole, for society. As much or more work would be getting done, since it's unambiguously bad for people to be economically disenfranchised (1930s proved that fucker true).
- dia80 14y agoI often discuss this with friends. It often comes down to: Big technology disruptions have happened before. The market adjusted and something new came along for people to do. I like to argue: There were about one million working horses in the UK in 1900 but only 20k by 1914. No one found new jobs for those horses... [1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_horse_in_Britain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_horse_in_Britain
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoExcept when a horse became a cost instead of providing income, it would likely have been slaughtered. I don't think that's the path we want to take with people.
- mbetter 14y agoBased on the glee that a significant proportion of Americans seem to derive from cutting social safety nets, that appears to be exactly the path we seem to be heading down.
- pc86 14y agoYeah those stupid Americans sure do hate poor people, don't they? /s
- niels_olson 14y agoPerhaps you haven't been to the South? Even the poor people hate the poor people. And they have the most poor people. Figure that.
- mncolinlee 14y agoThis is too true. Here in Minnesota, we had a state representative equate food stamp recipients to animals in two separate speeches. In her rural district, almost twenty percent are on welfare programs and most residents are under the poverty line and qualify for food stamps. They still vote for her in spite of statewide coverage of her statements. The attitude that everyone else is lazy and abusing the system seems most common in poor rural regions that depend the most on benefits. It usually has racial, anti-urban overtones that imply "we're only suffering because of THOSE people who don't look like us." It's a form of scapegoating.
- Domenic_S 14y ago> The only long term solution is a basic income system We already have basic income (guaranteed income/'living wage'/whatever buzzword you want to use) in the US, it's called... welfare and disability.
- tjic 14y agoThis is the point made by blogger The Last Psychiatrist.
- michaelochurch 14y agoThat's closer to a minimum income program, in any case. The difference is that a basic income means that X amount is paid to everyone. There's no "welfare valley" (or plateau). Every $1 earned on the market is $1 (less taxes) earned.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jchrisa 14y agoThere are BIG problems with welfare that are solved by giving it to Bill Gates also. For starters, right now the income you get when you transition off of welfare is taxed at greater than 100% - why work when you can get paid more to do nothing and get paid more?
- yebyen 14y agoIs that really true? Explain Are you saying that welfare income is not taxed, but when you earn the minimum amount required in order to be denied welfare, it's less than the welfare check / also taxed? I am not sure that's the same as 'taxed greater than 100%' -- that would mean that you've earned $10, so pay $13 in taxes. The math might work if you had actually been earning welfare; if you mean something else than what I'm saying, please explain.
- scarmig 14y agoWell, we're talking about effective marginal rates, not the listed amounts. The next dollar would be taxed at 20% or whatever the listed rate is. However, if you also lose a dollar of welfare, the tax rate is actually 120%, at least in terms of how incentives influence someone's marginal decisions.
- obviouslygreen 14y agoWhile this is interesting, it breaks down -- suggested logical fallacy notwithstanding -- at "the only long term solution is [x]." Applying enough reasoning to see and understand our larger problems is a necessary first step, but to find one potential solution and stop there, as though further consideration could not possibly find alternatives, is extremely baffling.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoOf course, it's a moot point at this point in history. Lots of productive professionals are probably willing to pay $8-10/hour to have their homes cleaned, meals cooked, and errands run. I certainly am. The robots don't do that stuff yet. Yet there are millions of people who claim they can't find work. Something doesn't add up.
- bilbo0s 14y agoThe union of the set of people you would be willing to have in your home and the set of people comprising the millions who claim they can't find work is, I suspect, small relative to the size of the US. ie - The people we are talking about... you probably wouldn't hire.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoHmmm.... extremely true. Even when we're not talking about the criminal underclass, I wouldn't hire an unemployed frat-boy type to take care of my apartment (too much nerdery about the place) or cook my meals (what's he going to know about kashrut or how to make curry?).
- bluehat 14y agoWhile cleaning your home for a few hours a day is not hard physical labor, cleaning houses all day would probably not be a great job for somebody with back pain. It is certainly more physically strenuous than your average job at McDonalds, which they already have available to them.
- prodigal_erik 14y agoMany of them may not. I remember news covering a McDonalds "national hiring day" where they hired 62,000 out of a million applicants. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-04-28/mcdonald-s-hires-62-000-during-national-event-24-more-than-planned.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-04-28/mcdonald-s-hires-62...
- brigade 14y ago
- DennisP 14y agoLet's assume you're right that we should have a basic income system, where every citizen receives a fixed amount. The money for that can partly come from cutting existing welfare systems, but we'll likely also need new revenue for it. Coincidentally, the "fee-and-dividend" plan proposed by James Hansen calls for taxing carbon emissions by the ton, and distributing all the money to citizens, equal amount per capita. That sounds a lot like basic income. Maybe we can kill two birds with one stone here.
- joelmichael 14y agoThe basic income might sound like a far-left idea to some, but it is supported by some ardent capitalists including Milton Friedman. He specifically supported its implementation in the form of a "negative income tax" which would replace the current welfare system. The reason for his support was that it was a more efficient redistributive system, as it avoided the perverse incentives of means-based welfare.
- RandallBrown 14y agoI like the idea of a negative income tax. I'm imagining it as a system where if you make below a certain amount of money, you aren't taxed, you're actually given money. If you make above that amount, you're taxed. As long as it's implemented in a way that there is still an incentive to make more money, I think it could be a decent solution to our problems.
- scotty79 14y agoThere's always incentive to earn money as as long as there are things to buy that your neighbor won't be able to buy with basic income an you, with your earned money will be able. Earners are driven by envy and competition.
- nitrogen 14y agoRight now there's a disincentive to make more money because you lose some types of benefits when you get a job, even if that job pays less than the benefits.
- mjn 14y agoThe EITC is somewhat like that, though it's mainly targeted at families (the amounts for households without children are extremely low, with a max benefit in 2013 of $487/yr).
- TomatoTomato 14y agoThe best example of this is the FairTax. The prebate is currently based on making sure those at the poverty line pay 0% federal taxes. But, if you change this to be 2x the poverty line or something, you effectively achieve a floor "basic income" https://fairtaxer.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/prebate-chart-married3.jpg https://fairtaxer.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/prebate-chart-...
- lukifer 14y agoI agree wholeheartedly, including on basic income, with one more detail: as long as people are being paid, why not pay them for "unprofitable" work? Firstly, pay people to go to school. Any subject, useful or not, for as long as they like. The education and mental fitness of the populace is a deep reservoir of Real Wealth. Secondly, pay (more) people to do community service work: visiting the elderly, cleaning up parks, tutoring kids, etc. And last, those people still work in the few remaining market jobs: have them work fewer hours! There will always be those who want 40+ hour weeks, but for everybody else, distribute up the same workload over a larger number of people with 20-32 hour work weeks. More people employed, who are less stressed, and a healthier society due to more time to self-improve and spend with family. Income is only one part of the sociological phenomenon called "jobs". People also want to feel useful.
- iskander 14y ago> as long as people are being paid, why not pay them for "unprofitable" work? What you're describing is very similar to the "full employment" of Soviet bloc countries.
- lukifer 14y agoSo what? A thousands other details of politics, culture, and economic structure are vastly different. Soviets also had police and military and schools: should we automatically not do those things either?
- john_b 14y agoRegarding your last point, it basically ignores everything about the "mythical man month" concept. Work and productivity are usually not evenly divisible into discrete chunks. When we had an economy dominated by factory work, where workers attached Widget A to Bracket B, you could divide things fairly evenly between workers. But today most jobs that aren't just physical labor benefit from having employees around more often. They stay up to date more easily, they can communicate what they learn more quickly, they can code for hours straight without the interruption of leaving at 2pm (not to mention all the interruptions due to meetings that would have to be compressed into shorter workdays to keep them up to date). There are also economic benefits of longer work days. A smaller fraction of a person's time is spent commuting (in aggreggate, cleaning up the roads and reducing carbon emissions due to fewer workers per company). And in the US, where we have decided to couple a person's insurance and benefits with his or her employer, the non-salary costs associated with an employee are a very significant component of the total cost of that employee, companies have a big disincentive to hire a large number of people, even when the work can be evenly divided into small chunks.
- jchrisa 14y agoWhat's Wrong with a Free Lunch is another great one, and short. http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0807047139/ http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0807047139/
- nathan_long 14y ago>> The only long term solution is a basic income system, which rewards consumption What do you mean by "rewards consumption"? Consumption is the reward for labor.
- olefoo 14y agoNo. Consumption is in fact a form of labor. One that in some manifestations is employed in support of natural hedonism; but often has little or no relation other than that hedonism is used to propagandize the consumption. In the United States this is particularly and sometimes painfully obvious, when people who do not wish participate in certain forms of consumption are sanctioned in various forms. This sanctioning can be overt "You'll need to wear a suit and tie if you're you want this job." or covert, "That guy rides a bike to work, wonder if he got a DUII?" Keeping up with the Joneses is the job you have when you aren't at work. One of the surprising things about social status in America is how often certain forms of consumption are effectively mandatory to signal ones class membership. Go looking for a CEO of a publicly traded company who chooses not to own a car for instance. Or a partner at a major law firm who does not have more than one residence. Those are only gross examples, one that is more familiar is the prevalence of electronic gadgets, especially those by Apple as symbols of membership in the digital worker class. The truth is that our choices in those matters are socially constructed, and that social construction happens in response to needs that are historically contingent rather than deterministic in nature. True a certain amount of consumption, of food, shelter and medical care is biologically determined; the rest is cultural.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoOh, it gets worse than all that. Every so often you hear stories floating around about managers, in these sorts of signal-ridden workplaces, who threaten the jobs of employees who don't consume to the appropriate level. Why? It's really much more straightforward than only "class signalling": if the worker consumes too little, they'll get out of debt, and thus they'll be far less captive to one particular employer. Therefore, employees must be encouraged to be do things like purchasing new cars every so often, to keep the Golden Handcuffs tight.
- 14y ago
- aethertap 14y agoThis is an interesting concept, but I have two big objections to it (the same objections I actually have to other safety nets as they currently exist). First, I want to mention at the top that I'm not in favor of leaving people out in the cold. I love to help people, and I think anyone who wants help should get it. The problem I have is that money seems to be the default strategy for "help," when it often seems to be counterproductive. The two things I really don't like about the ultimate safety net are these: First, that type of mechanism actually seems to be oppressive (based solely on my own observations, which are limited, but I'll explain below). Second, having the safety net from on high actively discourages people in a community from helping each other directly. Instead, they turn to the authority, saying that the basic wage is good enough, so why should I bother? The observations I mentioned were over a period of about a year when I lived in a neighborhood that was almost entirely composed of people living on some form of assistance. They were not evil, bad, or leeches, and I'm not going to make that claim. However, as best I could determine, they had found a strategy that was "good enough" that they didn't feel the need to improve their standing in life. In other words, they had elected to live in near-poverty because it was effortless. I knew several of them to varying degrees, and they were intelligent, able people. The effect of the safety net on their lives was extremely negative (in my opinion), even though they would certainly say otherwise. They did not want to be in better circumstances, and given the opportunity to learn a skill that would immediately improve their lives (trade skills like welding, or gardening even), most would refuse. I don't think that is a natural state for people, and it was frustrating for me to see it (especially for the kids involved, who had subsistence living as their primary model). The other point, about passing off responsibility for helping neighbors, is something I've seen in two flavors. First, and by far the most common, is in the world of conflict resolution. It's typical for one neighbor to call the nuisance abatement or police on another rather than actually go knock on the door to solve a problem. This is because they can offload all of the discomfort of confrontation onto an authority figure. The unfortunate consequence is that it makes the neighbor hate them, and things get worse from there. The other flavor of this problem is when people who do work and pay taxes resent seeing people who don't work but could, who are living "on the dole." The feeling of resentment looking at someone who is, even to a tiny degree, living for free on the fruits of your labors gets in the way of actually wanting to help that person. It gets people thinking in terms of "Why should I help them? They already live for free on my back, and they're not trying to make any changes." So what would I propose? Like I said, I'm not a fan of the "survival of the fittest" approach, and while many people seem to advocate that I don't think they actually want to see others suffer either. My main objection is that I see money going to causes that I think are directly harmful to the people they're supposed to be helping. What I would like is a way to direct the resources I spend on social support to causes that I think are actually beneficial (free education, skills training, apprenticeships, etc., maybe even with stipends and whatnot). I realize that everybody likely has a different view of what "helpful" means, so what I'd like to see is decentralization of social support into various forms that cater to different people's concepts of what actually works. You can make paying into it compulsory or not, but to me the real problem is that I don't like to see my money going to what ultimately seems to be an oppressive form of "help."
- rohern 14y agoI appreciate the interesting reading. Thanks for the useful comment!
- guard-of-terra 14y agoHow does the basic income works against immigration (including illegal)? Because it seems that once you declared basic income and nobody wants to work anymore, you'll get a huge influx of immigrants from the third world (who would be like slaves but even more oppressed) plus they will be trying to get citisenship as hard as they can. Won't be pretty.
- scarmig 14y ago"Because it seems that once you declared basic income and nobody wants to work anymore" That's not in evidence: most programmers could work a month out of the year and have the amount of money provided by a basic income, but they choose to work much more than that. But I digress. Immigration is one of the more interesting challenges for a BI, but I think it's overstated. As alluded to above, there's still all the incentive in the world to work even while receiving a basic income: which is to say, more income. You would want to make sure that you don't have a huge immediate influx of immigrants, but that's pretty simple: limit the number of immigrants in to a manageable amount (whatever that is), and only give citizenship to an immigrant once they've lived here for X years. At that point they'd have been working aplenty, paying taxes, and building skills: on citizenship and receiving the income, they'd have the same skills and incentives to continue working.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoif a basic income is $10000 a year, i doubt that many people are going to be falling over themselves to stop working and try to scrape by on just that.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 14y agoThe rise in "back pain and other musculoskeletal" disability claims since the 1960s seems to track well with the rise in obesity during that same time. And I noticed that a fair number of the pictured subjects were obese.
- bluedino 14y agoNot to mention asthma. I know of a few people who are disabled because they have asthma, and they are obese.
- williadc 14y agoMy sister is a paramedic with asthma that sent her to the hospital regularly for much of her childhood, but has diminished as she's gotten older.
- robertfw 14y agoPerhaps also desk work?
- arbuge 14y agoIt seems that a large part of this is a problem with implementing and/or acting upon rudimentary analytics. If a particular doctor or judge is referring plenty of patients into the disability rolls, that doctor/judge should be singled out for special investigation.
- rthomas6 14y agoThis seems like what journalism should be. This is shocking to me. An entire generation of people have slipped through the cracks, and I had no idea this sort of disability-gaming was occurring. Is this common knowledge?
- michaelochurch 14y agoIt's not "disability gaming" for the most part. These people have legitimate, serious health problems and, in this economy, no employer wants to accommodate them. There are a lot of people who are capable of delivering economic value, but not on a typical employer's terms. The sad truth is that the demand for most labor is crashing. The truth is that disability is a spectrum from 0 (no economic function) to 1 (full health). In 1950, there was high demand for labor and people at 0.7 could get full-time jobs with access to middle-class labor. Now, the 0.8's are unwanted and the 0.9's are trapped in secondary labor, unless they're extremely intelligent and can swing as free agents.
- bradleyjg 14y agoHow is this not gaming? "Scott tried school for a while, but hated it. So he took the advice of the rogue staffer who told him to suck all the benefits he could out of the system. He had a heart attack after the mill closed and figured, "since I've had a bypass, maybe I can get on disability, and then I won't have worry about this stuff anymore." It worked; Scott is now on disability."
- michaelochurch 14y agoI don't know Scott's situation. Maybe there's a job for him that doesn't involve cardiac risk. Maybe there isn't. How the fuck am I going to know? Yes, some people abuse social welfare programs. In Williamsburg, there are goddamn middle-class hipsters who take food stamps and use their parents' money to buy drugs. It happens, but this idea that there's an epidemic of moochers or that most people on programs are degenerately gaming the system is off the mark.
- scott_meade 14y agoAnd so continues the attitude of "why should I take care to keep myself healthy when the federal government will give me checks to be unhealthy"? Nevermind that it's a sure path to continuing the cycle of poverty for one's family and their kids' families. Sigh.
- mkr-hn 14y agoDid you read the whole thing? The system pulls the rug out from under people the moment they start making progress. The scaling that exists is too abrupt.
- scott_meade 14y agoThe federal government disability program pulls the rug out from under people the moment they start making progress? I read the whole thing but missed that part of the reporting. Maybe I read it wrong. Where is it?
- mkr-hn 14y agoThe reforms were meant to encourage people to work their way out of welfare: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare-to-work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare-to-work This reflects that: "Jahleel's mom wants him to do well in school. That is absolutely clear. But her livelihood depends on Jahleel struggling in school. This tension only increases as kids get older. One mother told me her teenage son wanted to work, but she didn't want him to get a job because if he did, the family would lose its disability check."
- scott_meade 14y agoI see. It is unfortunate all around.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- altoz 14y agoSo the poor get disability and welfare. The rich get bailouts and subsidies. Guess who comes out behind?
- avenger123 14y agoNot you. Being poor is not fun. Period. Can you imagine living on $20K, $30K, $40K, a year? Depending on where you are in the US that might just cover your living costs. There is a large segment of the population that will not get degrees, not work in jobs that are considered "careers". In any demographic class there are people that abuse the system, but I wouldn't consider the poor in that category. These people are as or more hard working than the middle class. Also, the government giving disability and welfare doesn't mean they are bringing in $100K a year in benefits. The government provides enough to live on.
- qdog 14y agoThey article states it's $13k/year in cash. Not sure what the value of the medical benefits, but $13k/year would be pretty miserable on a family. I know someone who subsists basically on minimum wage and made just about $12k last year, he's still pretty young and healthy and is looking for a job that's better (has a degree), but he's spent a significant amount of time having to live with family/friends to get by. He's always on the lookout for $.99 taco night, but I think really at some point he'd like to get past that phase of life.
- genwin 14y agoFor a family or working person, sure. For an individual who no longer has to work or live in a city, $13K/yr is a windfall. One could live like a king, experiencing great nature with all the time freed up, and have money left over. For medical, it's a safe bet that many of those on disability go to the emergency room and never pay a dime.
- Femur 14y ago>Can you imagine living on $20K, $30K, $40K, a year? Yes, because I have done it every year for the past decade. Having lived in several large metropolitan areas, I don't consider myself poor or even struggling.
- mbetter 14y agoAbsolutely fantastic content and presentation.
- cdjk 14y agoWhile not related to the topic of this article, the UI around the pictures for the article is impressive. It's modern and clever, but not in a distracting way like a lot of attempts to do things that are clever. And it's still perfectly readable on my phone. Normally I don't like "clever" designs, but this one is pretty neat.
- guelo 14y agoOh no. Poor injured people might be getting money. Stop them!
- marknutter 14y agoI'm injured! I want money! Can I get some money?
- sliverstorm 14y agoIf he gets money, I could be injured too! I bashed up my leg when I slipped on ice last month. Can I get money for that?
- jareds 14y agoAs a blind individual in America I’m an example of someone on the disability bubble. What allowed me to avoid going on disability was college. By being blind I got some additional financial help to get through college. Even though I could have probably gotten full disability it made a lot more sense for me to get a degree and a programming job. I never considered going the disability rout since I easily make three times what I would have on disability and expect that gap to grow wider as I become more experience. If college hadn’t been an option for me I could easily see myself going on disability. I can’t think of a lot of jobs I could do that wouldn’t have required a college degree since most physical labor is not an option for me. Even with the help I got from the government with college I’ll still wind up being a plus on the governments balance sheet since I don’t receive any disability payments now that I work full time and pay taxes. Unfortunately from reading the story most people don’t have the opportunities I did, and even if they do some refuse to take advantage of them. While I think we should expand opportunities for education and job training there’s no way to force people to take advantage of them.
- rthomas6 14y agoI am curious: How does one program while blind? Obviously it's just as easy in your brain, but what is the process for reading and writing code?
- jareds 14y agohttp://stackoverflow.com/questions/118984/how-can-you-program-if-youre-blind http://stackoverflow.com/questions/118984/how-can-you-progra...
- chadmaughan 14y agoThe social safety net and creative destruction discussion is interesting. However, I'm interested from a design perspective. Does anyone know if this was built by the "apps team" at NPR? IMO, it's very well done. More from the NPR "apps team." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5279440 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5279440 http://blog.apps.npr.org/2013/02/14/app-template-redux.html http://blog.apps.npr.org/2013/02/14/app-template-redux.html
- azurelogic 14y agoI was actually wondering if this was posted here for content or design reasons
- maerF0x0 14y agoWith a guaranteed income defined not in dollars but in goods, the government could automate (much of) the welfare of these people. "You get 10 loaves of bread, 3 cheese, and 1 elective per month." for example. Then people wouldnt complain about the big screen tvs, etc. that they think the poor spend the welfare money on.
- squozzer 14y agoI think you've re-invented the Roman welfare system. Probably less vulnerable to abuse than currency-based welfare, but in the end it had sustainability problems.
- roc 14y agoWe had that. "Government cheese" was not always a metaphor. Neither were "food stamps". As it turns out: it's better to just give people cash and let them make their own determinations and let the free market and substitution do its thing, than maintain a huge parallel infrastructure just to avoid hurt feelings over the idea that someone somewhere may buy a non-necessity with welfare dollars. It costs the taxpayer less, people get better results, they have a better opportunity to learn and improve, etc. Some will abuse it, but some sold their government cheese and food stamps to buy non-essentials as well. People complaining about the big screen TVs are flat-out disingenuous. They're either outright ignorant of history and/or of the specifics at hand [1], or they're lying to effect a policy change they couldn't justify with the truth. [1] Studies have been done. The "welfare queen" and "strapping young bucks buying steak dinners" do not actually exist. Exceptions do, but they've never amounted to significant quantities of waste. And we already do search for, and ferret these people out.
- maerF0x0 14y agoThe only problem with the "free market" thing is that the current market isn't really all that free, and a totally free market is full of externalities and wrong incentives (incentives for A and B to collude to the detriment of C) .
- tomjen3 14y agoAs a convinced capitalist, I find myself agreeing with you (although you leave out things like toothpaste, shoes, etc). In economic terms giving anything but money is less efficient, but in practice it would save massive amounts of money, prevent starving people in the streets and give them an incentive to work themselfs up.
- snake_plissken 14y agoHow do they do that scrolling over the bus image? That's pretty cool.
- sprobertson 14y ago`background-attachment: fixed`
- seivan 14y agoADHD makes one very unfit for work, or not unfit. But it makes it harder.
- youngerdryas 14y ago"Charity degrades those who receive it and hardens those who dispense it.” Self reliance, while not always possible, is always better as it empowers the individual and the state. I have never met a disabled person who enjoyed being helped.
- sliverstorm 14y agoEvery month, 14 million people now get a disability check from the government. Holy cow. The working population in the USA is a little below 140 million; that's almost 10%.
- e40 14y agoIn the city where I live, I walk to work. On the way, I see an uncountable number of cars with handicap placards. They are especially dense near large office buildings. My wife once drove to my work to have lunch, but ended up going home without us having lunch--there were no free parking spaces she could find after 30 minutes circling. This has got to hurt business. I'm not saying there are a lot of disabled people in my city, but it shows the mentality. People want something for nothing and a lot more people that I would have thought don't mind pretending to be disabled. My favorite is watching people pull up next to Lake Merritt to park, but before they get out they put up the placard, then proceed to walk 3+ miles around the lake. My wife works in social services, and people are constantly trying to game the system by claiming disabilities. On the flip side, our social safety net in the US is horrible and unemployment is very high. I don't really blame people to trying to use any means they can to live. The bottom line is that if we had a real safety net that caught people slipping into poverty, there would be many fewer people claiming disabilities.
- dreamdu5t 14y agoWe need to accept that a byzantine bureaucracy isn't the way to achieve social welfare. Simply cutting everyone a check would be far cheaper and equitable.
- sliverstorm 14y agoThe layout reminds me of this story: http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall I like it. The snowfall article is fancier, but they share an aesthetic, and I hope we see more of it. Thinking about it, I'd be willing to pay for a regular stream of articles that are presented so nicely. (Well, assuming the content itself is also good). This is significant... I've never been willing to pay for news in my life.
- bluehat 14y agoThis article just reminded me to support what is probably one of the last worthwhile news programs on air. Here's a link for you if you want to too! http://www.npr.org/about/support/ http://www.npr.org/about/support/
- williadc 14y agoI lived in Aberdeen when they shut down the mill. I remember everyone saying how this was the end of the town. It's weird that the article didn't show a picture of downtown. It's just a bunch of run down buildings with boards over the windows. The Wal-Mart there is doing great though, one of the most profitable in all of Washington state, according to friends that work there.
- lotsofcows 14y agoWe're kidding ourselves if we believe that we can continue to find meaningful work for the uneducated. Given that education for the poor is appalling and getting worse, it seems that we are kidding ourselves. At some point we need to accept that an economy based around leisure is already here. The irony is that adapting people to that mindset is going to take education... The bigger irony is that only the (rapidly becoming extinct) upper classes really know how to entertain themselves.
- shawnee_ 14y agoPart of the rise in the number of people on disability is simply driven by the fact that the workforce is getting older, and older people tend to have more health problems. This is probably one of the key points the article could be making, but it's kinda glossed over. As the baby boom generation (the one born ~1946 –> ~1959) nears retirement, it makes a lot of sense. That generation - my parents' generation - really did a large portion of the work involved with building out the physical infrastructure that allows our economy to operate as it does today: buildings, roads, power lines, mining, machinery, warehouses, etc. Physical work tends to create more injuries and disabilities than sedentary work, and people who do that kind of work simply cannot do it for as long as people who do sedentary work. How can we forget there was an entire generation of people who turned the 1940's USA into the one of the 1970s? I know I've mentioned this on here before but it's relevant: my dad hung sheetrock for living. He stopped going to school after 6th grade. There was no way he could have made to age 64 -- people thought he was crazy to be doing it until age 53 -- which is when he died, almost 10 years ago. From a combination of issues related to what his work did to his body. But the sheer idiocy of the system which has rewarded and continues to reward neat-suit Realtors and loan officers and salesmen (those "educated" ones who tend to work the sedentary jobs) -- instead of the workers meant that he was left with no options for healthcare, retirement, or even being able to leave his children a dime. It's not like none of them have a work ethic. . . many of them have worked long and hard already; they're just "prematurely" tired and worn out. Not to mention the system keeps trying to move the dangling carrot of retirement further and further away from their grasp by attempting to increase retirement age. [edit -- apologies for the awry double pasted text in the original post]
- abbasaamer 14y agoBut the sheer idiocy of the system which has rewarded and continues to reward neat-suit Realtors and loan officers and salesmen (those "educated" ones who tend to work the sedentary jobs) -- instead of the workers meant that he was left with no options for healthcare, retirement, or even being able to leave his children a dime. I can understand the frustration you have and you make some thoughtful points, but I wonder how could you change "the system" to be any different? It's not as if these are government jobs. The prices are pretty much set by market forces so what can you do if the market doesn't deem the price high enough?
- nerdo 14y agoThe part about kids and SSI abuse is also cited as being the reason for the uptick in ADHD diagnoses (and not violent video games or high fructose corn syrup or gay marriage): http://www.boston.com/news/health/articles/2010/12/13/follow_up_process_lacking_in_ssi_disability_program/ http://www.boston.com/news/health/articles/2010/12/13/follow...
- up_and_up 14y ago> Jahleel's mom wants him to do well in school. That is absolutely clear. But her livelihood depends on Jahleel struggling in school. This tension only increases as kids get older. One mother told me her teenage son wanted to work, but she didn't want him to get a job because if he did, the family would lose its disability check. This system is completely messed up.
- scarmig 14y agoA thousand times, yes. But people hate the idea of giving people money when they "don't need it." So for each dollar someone makes that pushes them above bare sustenance, a dollar is taken away. In some perverse income ranges, more than a dollar is taken away. The only way around it really is to either give people nothing, or to provide a basic income. Most people hate the idea of both of those: if you give people nothing, you in a very real sense end up starving people. You can pick and choose who gets aid, but that immediately adds a bunch of administrative overhead and encourages gaming the system. A basic income, though, gives Bill Gates free money from the taxpayers, and is very, very expensive. All told, I prefer the BI, but that has a load of difficulties.
- pasbesoin 14y agoOk, I haven't read this. The title alone brings an immediate reaction. I live in the U.S. I've observed, first hand and individually, more instances than I can count of deliberately unsafe work conditions. Contractors having e.g. employees deal with lead paint without protection. Small businesses as well as large corporations having employees work regularly with unsafe chemicals. Landlords renovating "under the radar", spreading toxic contaminants throughout their properties. People take advantage of other people's ignorance. They "don't want to be hassled" and "hate the government" and want to "save money". I'm one person. And I can hardly go through a day in life without running across this. In part, perhaps, because I am at least semi-informed, and because I pay attention to my surroundings. It's no mystery to me that our population ends up with so many "unfit to work", disabled people. In addition to the above, add the stress of job insecurity, health care insecurity, bully bosses. A lot of people who have to live amidst this (and you, exhalted programmers and "high technology" wonks, are generally not -- in such roles -- among these; that is speaking generally, while I do recognize the individual experiences vary widely), eventually resign themselves that "this is the way the world works". The smart ones try to save and earn a retirement before their body gives out. And/or to move into some sort of management position where knowledge and experience keep them valuable and employed. In the U.S., at least, these circumstances continue to exist because we let them and because many people continue to take advantage of them. The next time you're looking for lower bids on your renovation project, keep this in mind. There are the formal rules -- OSHA and all that. Then, there is an entire culture of "on the side" and "under the table" and loyalty and betrayal, that changes and morphs somewhat but that remains, on a day to day basis, apparently largely untouched by all this. I'm sure it's worse, often far worse, in much of the rest of the world. But... the U.S. has more -- far more -- than a "few bad actors" that contribute to the problem, domestically. Lots of people make lots of money, in amounts both small and large, from taking advantage of this. And... this is anecdote. One guy, just looking around as he goes through day-to-day living. Another reason I am disgusted by the health care situation in this country (where the results of these problems ultimately end up). Another area where costs and benefits are not at all aligned and balanced, on an individual basis.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jnazario 14y agofascinating piece, i'll have a deeper look later. i came here to say it's gorgeous and presented beautifully and functionally. the designers should be proud.
- Maven911 14y agoHas anybody ever had a situation where someone left work for an extended period of time because of "stress" - and what did the employer do about it ?
- gklitt 14y agoWow, surprised that there's no comments here yet about the visual design of this page. I really enjoyed the long, scrollable page, with readable typography and just the right amount of flair with the headings. It's also a well implemented responsive design. This type of long, scrollable design seems to be growing in popularity these days -- e.g. the NYTimes Tunnel Creek article [1] or AirBnB's annual report [2], and I think it's a good trend. Even though this NPR page has less special effects than those other two examples, it's still a fantastic reading experience, and I'll take it over a standard paginated article any day. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall/#/?part=tunnel-creek http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2012/snow-fall/#/?part=tunne... [2] https://www.airbnb.com/annual/ https://www.airbnb.com/annual/
- IheartApplesDix 14y agoOn top of that, I'm blocking 100% of the scripts on the site and I'm not missing any content.
- rohern 14y agoAgreed. This a great article and great presentation.
- evo_9 14y agoYeah, I thought the whole point was the unique, impressive design. The story is good, too, but I think the real point is being missed by everyone.
- 205guy 14y agoI came to say the same thing. Also, nobody mentioned the "scrolling window" effect on the images behind the headings. One problem is that it doesn't show up with paging (Page keys or scroll wheel), only with smaller scrolling increments.
- Alexx 14y agoAgreed. This is a fantastic presentation of long-format text. The balance between readability, design, and imagery is very well done. I would love to see more journalistic publishers take a leaf from this book.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rabino 14y agoThat's a really nicely designed article!
- lucian303 14y agoWith the lack of affordable healthcare, a drugged out populace on drugs that cause depression (prozac and the like as well as many benzodiazepines used longer than 2 weeks) and insanity (alcohol being the biggest culprit), stressful work for little pay, and the national economic depression, how can this trend not be going up in a nation that has been at war, non-stop for over a dozen years? This is a surprise? I think not.
- ianb 14y agoEconTalk had an excellent interview about this: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/04/autor_on_disabi.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/04/autor_on_disabi.htm... This EconTalk is also interesting: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/12/mulligan_on_red.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/12/mulligan_on_red.htm... – the thing that really made me think is the observation that the marginal benefit of work is often negative for people on different assistance programs, and that comes up in the first interview too. To try to get ahead, to try to get off disability, will put you behind where you'd have otherwise been. I think it also offers something of a solution, to look at the entirety of the support systems and make sure that there's always a benefit to being more beneficial to society. I suspect that would largely mean increasing benefits for the not-quite-poor, or the almost-disabled, etc. But if a well managed slope of benefits is achieved, the incentives may lead to less total dependence. It's also something that, in theory, could be supported by Republicans and Democrats, as analysis is based on ideas that are appealing to both sides.
- wildgift 14y agoI agree about this - the fact is, there's a gradient of disability, and a gradient of employability, and a gradient on the ability of people to participate in the market. Having benefits pulled out doesn't work, particularly health insurance.
- fab13n 14y agoWe geeks are working at increasing the rest of the world's productivity. And we're doing great! This means that less people are needed to produce the same wealth, and that more and more people have nothing left to contribute, because we improve productivity faster than teachers improve education. It's not a bad thing: I'd rather have everyone being useful, but I'd rather pay someone for doing nothing than for doing an unnecessary job; at least in the latter case, we've got a honest view of the situation, we haven't broken the compass. A society where half the people are economically worthless and they don't even know it is doubly broken. Jobs serve two purposes in our modern Western world: they produce wealth, and they're our way to redistribute that produced wealth. The latter is a convention, not a necessity. Exchanging wealth for work proportionally is an effective motivator for those able to produce actual wealth, but for the increasing masses who simply can't, it's a cruel joke, a game they're forced to play and doomed to lose humiliatingly. So sure, they shouldn't get the same revenue as a heart surgeon; but if there's a robot which can flip burgers better than them, and thus make them economically worthless, I'd rather give them their minimum salary and let the robot do the flipping. My life is interesting enough that I don't need others to suffer in pointless jobs in order to endure mine.
- zanny 14y agoI think you touch on one of the greatest problems of the 21st century - coming to terms with the reality that maximizing for wealth creation rather than redistribution means very few people are doing things anyone can predictably assume is beneficiary - such as research, arts, etc. Almost every job lost in the last 50 years due to globalization and automation have been jobs very few people would want to do with their lives, and people always dodge that over some preconceived notion everyone should be putting in 9 - 5 hours. Though, I think the more acceptable solution is to just drastically cut the hours of the uneducated grunt work that still isn't automated (while spending the time to automate it, because we are at the threshold of eliminating traditional labor and that is a good thing) and just divvy up the available work to the many, maybe even as little as an hour a day, or an 8 hour shift a week. The problem is changing the entrenched century old agriculture / housing / trade industries to accept a lack of scarcity and dramatic price drops across the board. You want the income from that tiny work week to be the disposable income after providing food, warmth, shelter, and transportation, since it seems silly to even think of anyone living today unable to enjoy their life, when we have so much plenty.
- septerr 14y agoThe fact that more and more people do not have the skills to make it in America today is the most heart breaking. And with the costs of college education, the problem will only become worse with the offsprings of those affected today becoming the most likely to be affected in future. I think education is what should be provided free or subsidized. Not related to the topic.. The site is really well designed and kudos to NPR for a splendid coverage and presentation as usual.
- brisance 14y agoI noticed quite a few of the states on the top 10 are from the south. I'm curious how many of them were ex-military.
- at-fates-hands 14y agowondering why nobody has brought up the fact under Obama, unemployment assistance has been extended multiple times and it would seem obvious once your unemployment runs out, you would simply apply for disability. I wouldn't propose this if I didn't already know several people who have done this in order to continue supporting their family. Also, my best friend is on disability and wholeheartedly deserves it, so I'm kind of torn about how I see people use and abuse this program.
- saadazzz 14y agoBlame it on the a-a-a-a-a-a-a-alcohol
- dnr 14y agoRelevant: http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/11/the_terrible_awful_truth_about_1.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/11/the_terrible_awful_tr... He argues that the system is "broken" on purpose.
- alanh 14y agoDenying more people disability is not a fix. Solving the question of what to do in our partially-post-scarcity economy is the fix.
- jdietrich 14y agoWe have very similar problems in the UK. The number of people claiming Incapacity Benefit grew from 0.75m to 2.75m in less than thirty years. Two-thirds are claiming for reasons of mental health or back pain. In the most impoverished parts of the country, nearly 20% of the population is officially "too sick to work". The issue is currently the most contentious of many welfare benefit reforms, I suspect in large part because discussing the issues raised in this article are almost totally taboo. Everyone knows perfectly well why disability rates are 10x higher in the poorest parts of the country, but there's a political taboo that prevents anyone from saying "Incapacity Benefit was used for decades by governments of both parties as an accounting trick to keep down the official unemployment figures".
- alan_cx 14y agoIm entering evil mode here....... I cant help think that business would rather keep the, er, difficult to employ out of the employment market. Do employers really want to employ people with various disabilities and ailments? Do they really want the added grief, work, red tape, costs, etc? Then we have the long term unemployed, the , er, useless manky scum who cant wash, dress or string a sentence together. Drunk, illiterate and on drugs? Do employers really want these people over and above nice educated suited "normal" people? Who wants Frank Gallagher on reception, as a sales rep, or stinking out out nice Google offices? If the answer is yes, then hit the streets and employ a few. Go down where the "scum" are and offer them jobs and hope. Cheap, easy to find and plentiful. If the answer is no, then lets stop begrudging the meagre social security they get. Lets happily pay our taxes to keep such people alive, comfortable and out of "our" way, so that we can get on with our businesses and work, and improve our lives. Hows that for evil?
- citricsquid 14y agoI don't think it's a taboo to discuss it, it's not being discussed because it shows very clearly what a big problem we have (just like America) with waning job numbers and really awful support for the poorest. We're not in as deep is as America is (from my basic understanding of our benefits vs. American welfare) but if the government were to talk about the problems with Incapacity Benefit they would also have to address the problem of another 2 million unemployed people with no recent job history and no jobs for them even if they could work. Things are just about ticking over now, imagine the shit storm that would occur if every unemployed person was told they're now competing with another 2 million people, keeping this a "secret" is as much in the governments interest as it is every person that votes. No good would come of this issue being out in the open now, it needs to come out when there are jobs available or proper support for the unemployed, neither of which is true at the moment. I could be missing an important factor (due to aforementioned shallow understanding of benefits) so please correct me if I'm wrong and there is an advantage or proper way this can be addressed.
- d4vlx 14y ago"The company has an office in eastern Washington state that's basically a call center, full of headsetted women in cubicles who make calls all day long to potentially disabled Americans, trying to help them discover and document their disabilities" Why am I not surprised that getting people on disability has become an industry. I very much believe that governments should look after people who need help but there seems to be a significant lack of accountability when it comes to disability. Does anyone know the details American of politics of disability? Welfare, social security and health care are constantly in the political news but I do not recall seeing much about disability. As someone who regular consumer of political text I find this surprising. Especially given the size of the program.
- gwern 14y agoFurther reading: Charles Murray's _Coming Apart_.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ca98am79 14y agoNice job Rich Orris - I really loved the design
- tsotha 14y agoUnemployment benefits run out after a year (or whatever they changed it to), but disability benefits never run out. If you look at the chart the big increase from 1961 to 2011 is "back pain and other musculoskeletal problems", which, as every prospective medical marijuana patient knows, is impossible for a doctor to disprove. Of course disability claims are going up - the economy is bad and people are using disability as an unemployment benefit. The unfortunate result of all of this is going to be lots of extra paperwork (and potential rejections) for people who really are too disabled to work.
- marze 14y agoA simple fix would be to give each disabled person a "wage bonus" subsidy. For each hour they work, their employer gets x$. If they were more disabled, the number gets bigger.
- brownbat 14y agoIf disability is masking unemployment, we should expect anomalies in other labor statistics, like labor force participation rate, or per capita employment. Labor force participation has been declining the last few years, but at least some of that is aging population and massive recession. And despite the decline, the rate remains well within historical bounds. I'm glancing at Bureau of Labor Statistics charts, not seeing a massive hidden class of people that are somehow staying off all the books. On the other hand, there's an MIT economist that totally disagrees with me, claims that disability DOES explain trends in other labor statistics, like participation rate: http://economics.mit.edu/faculty/dautor/papers/disability http://economics.mit.edu/faculty/dautor/papers/disability Full disclosure: I am most definitely not nor have ever been "an MIT economist." His paper from 2006 depicts some interesting trends. (Wait, 2006? This guy has been forecasting disability armageddon for seven fucking years, when the real threat back then was the imminent housing bubble!? Now I'm skeptical again...) ==================== Data: UPDATE Neat labor data infographic: http://newyorkfed.org/employment/ http://newyorkfed.org/employment/ Scary labor force participation chart (with really narrow scale to heighten the effect): http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 A million Census charts: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/labor_force_employment_earnings/labor_force_status.html http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/cats/labor_force_empl... Employment status, 1970+: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0586.pdf http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0586.p... A long article on unemployment rate, participation rate, etc., with some brilliant charts: http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2012/02/graphs-unemployment-rate-participation.html http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2012/02/graphs-unemploymen... Autor and Duggan's 2006 piece I reference above: http://economics.mit.edu/files/597 http://economics.mit.edu/files/597 [PDF]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- thezach 14y agoI'm going to reply to this thread against my better judgement because I'm afraid of getting trolled. I am on SSI, I have Autism as well as severe longterm depression and PTSD. I get about $700 a month to live off from. In my area you can't find housing under $450. Then I have to pay someone to pay my bills for me at $39 a month because social security somehow deems I can't spend my own money. My point is after necessary things (electric, transportation, gas, water) I struggle for toilet paper at times. I have tried jobs before, got fired in a manufacturing job getting overwhelmed by the process - got fired in another job because i could not understand "shop talk". I don't like living off the system and one of the main reasons I'm really pursuing entrepreneurship is I see it as the only way I can get off the system.
- wildgift 14y agoMy sympathies. I know someone with a some similar mental health issue on SSI. It's tough out there. (And they have relied heavily on basically working at home online to have a little extra money. It's tough right now due to the recession and basically nothing comes in, but the process of doing that work is positive.) I can also understand being overwhelmed. I don't have autism, but have done the programmer thing, and have trouble interacting with people so might be on the spectrum a little bit. I swear, if it weren't for our mechanized society with machines to repair and computers to fix and program, I'd be a poor dirt farmer. I wish you the best of luck. If you'd like to brainstorm possible jobs or business maybe we can talk on this thread.
- unclebucknasty 14y agoWhat' s interesting is that this move to disability is just another manifestation of the unanswered question, "what do we do with all of these people for whom the economy no longer has use?" Between globalization, automation/technology, and "increased productivity" (aka working people like slaves), we just don't need as many U.S. workers. Yet the wealth is still flowing, corporations are realizing record profits, and more billionaires are being minted. We here on HN tend to feel immune, due to our skillsets. And, while it is true that the shift currently most affects those with high school educations and/or in other sectors (manufacturing), our time is coming. With continued outsourcing, gains in automation (software writing software), and other shifts, we will all experience this. While the software and technology we here produce are helping to facilitate the shift for others, some day the focus will be on us as too costly or ineffecient. So we will have wildly profitable corporations, an extremely wealthy investor/executive class, and an economy that produces all that the world needs while employing only a tiny fraction of the world's population. Either these entitlement programs will continue to bloat to unprecedented levels or we will require a fundamental restructuring of society.
- wildgift 14y agoThey can continue to bloat. Eventually, they will cause so much debt that the wealthy will have no choice but to pay for it.
- atsaloli 14y agoRedistribution of wealth is incompatible with liberty and the pursuit of happiness. It violates my liberty when my wealth is taken away by force. Wealth redistribution is morally hazardous to the recipients, getting something without earning it or doing anything in exchange.
- wildgift 14y agoI just heard the show on TAL, and while it was interesting, some aspects grated, particularly the one about learning disabilities. That part of the show is going to end up as a proxy for all kinds of mental disabilities, making it sound like these things not only don't exist, but when they exist, they don't matter. I know some people on disability who have mental issues. Some had developmental problems, and some had strokes, and some have mental illness, and there are other situations in between. They aren't employable, at least not easily and full time. The reason is that as the economy has shifted to a service economy, the service jobs, which used to be considered "kick back" or basically low stress, have become high stress. When the profits of the business depend on the service workers, the stress falls on the service workers. That stress is either around increasing production of mentally produced product (I'm sure programmers here know this), or of producing a positive psychological experience for someone else. For example, the people working in retail have to be nice. They can't be grouchy and talk shit to each other like people used to when they worked in factories. Maybe Joffe-Walt hasn't really thought about this, but within the class of sit-down jobs, the ones she has are not the common kind. There's variety in the work, and a huge need to "think outside the box". Even the stressors have some variety to them. Most service jobs are about forcing your mind into the box, and handling the same stressors over and over. These are easy on the muscles, but rough on the mind, and the mind, as we sometimes forget, is a manifestation of the brain, an organ in the body, subject to being overworked and injured.
- VigUi7vv8G2 14y ago> People don't seem to be faking this pain, but it gets confusing. I have back pain. My editor has a herniated disc, and he works harder than anyone I know. There must be millions of people with asthma and diabetes who go to work every day. Who gets to decide whether, say, back pain makes someone disabled? I dunno, maybe the difference is that you don't have a job where you have to STAND ALL DAY? If you're in a wheel chair you can still do a desk job. Does that mean you're not disabled?
- azernik 14y agoThe same reporter did a more human-interest variant of the story for This American Life (available at http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/490/trends-with-benefits http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/490/t...). It's an interesting perspective on the issue.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- CurtMonash 14y agoWhat large number of sit-down jobs do you expect to be available to dubiously-educated people that can't also be outsourced to poorer/cheaper countries? It's a problem if you believe the less educated should still have nice rich-country middle-class lives.
- prawn 14y agoWould it be somewhat fair in this situation of disability as described to say that disability is a bit like welfare with an excuse? "I'm not too lazy to work or study, my back hurts." Easier to say in front of peers/parents/etc.